Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT-Tool Rant

Posts

OT-Tool Rant

#1

OT-Tool Rant

Northwest29

Disposable America, I guess. I think I'm like most all woodworkers in that I try to get the most out of my tools. I buy them and use them until they are no longer useable (AKA thrifty, frugal, cheap). I have a battery Porter-Cable drill that I have had for 8 years or so and recently my second battery died. Now, over the years I have had to buy a couple of replacement batteries. As I recall they we about $50. And like most folks I like convenience and don't want to wait around while my only battery recharges. So, I started shopping for another battery and OUCH. So far the prices I have seen for a replacement is about $75 and that does not include shipping (probably the supply and demand thing). This morning I'm looking in the local paper and see a Dewalt 12V with 2 batteries, charger and bag for $160. So, I ask myself, should I go buy a new Dewalt and when the Porter-Cable battery dies throw away a perfectly good drill without battery?

Unless I find batteries for a reasonable price, In the end I won't have a choice, I guess (I haven't called Batteries-Plus yet).

Okay, rant over. Anyone else face this dilemma and what were your thoughts.

Ron in Oregon

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#2

Yes, exactly....

Barry Irby

I have a Makita 12 volt drill. The batteries died and I agonized as you did and ended up buying a new set with two batteries, charger, drill and Impact driver. Then I stumbled across a matching drill at HD (somebody stole the batteries) and I bought the drill for $20. The batteries died again and I sent them away and had them rebuilt. (Primecell, five years ago). Now they are dead again. It kills me to toss three drills and an impact driver because the batteries crapped out. I am thinking of either rebuilding them again (maybe two this time rather than all four). Look at Primecell and MTO.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#3

Re: OT-Tool Rant

Dave's Not Here

Consider having your existing batteries rebuilt or just buying some rebuilt batteries.

http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient&aq=0&oq=battery+rebuilders+porter+cable&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1T4ADRA_enUS427US428&q=battery+rebuilders+porter+cable

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#4

Re: OT-Tool Rant

paul in AZ

I faced this same thing last summer. A drill I'd used for a great many years wouldn't hold it's charge and a replacement battery was ridiculously expensive. I bought a new drill.

Equally silly was a cell phone that needed a battery. OEM batteries were almost $40 and aftermarket not available. I got a new phone, a newer model of the exact same phone, for $20. go figure.

Maddening for those of us who grew up repairing things instead of throwing them away.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Corded

Moses Yoder

I know it's a hassle to find an outlet and plug in a cord, but in reality it only takes about a minute extra, maybe 2 minutes to get the cord out and put it away. I will be installing a cabinet this afternoon, corded Makita drill and screw gun. My Dewalt batteries died some time ago, and I just haven't seen the need to replace them. If I was a full time professional, I would see the advantage of the cordless mobility, but for a hobbiest homeowner I use cords.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#6

Re: Corded

Jesse Cloud

Realistically, I think battery powered tools are just 'consumables.' The corded drills last forever, so if Black&Decker/Porter Cable/Delta/DeWalt is going to make money, its gotta be cordless.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#7

Re: OT-Tool Rant

Larry in NW Ohio

I have bought, rebuilt, and rebuilt more than I care to think about. I`m seriously thinking about going back to cords again. It makes me sick thinking about all the battery drills I bought over the years and really for what, a little convienience. BS a big B__S__ I don`t think it`s really worth it. The only thing I think I would keep is my new 12V P-C Li ion Drill-Driver. Larry

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#8

Re: OT-Tool Rant

Joseph Mulherin

Ron, I recently bought the 3drill from Rockwell manufacturing via the Woodcraft website.

It drills with a 3/8" chuck, and hammer drills too. Cost is around $180 but you get two lithium-ion batteries and a charger... recharging a battery only takes 30 minutes for full charge, and you can work with one battery while the other one is charging. You also get the warranty of full lifetime battery replacement.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#9

ditto....buy corded


Re: OT-Tool Rant

#10

Guaranteed for life batteries at Home Depot

Bill Tindall

Batteries have a life span. It depends on the details of how the battery is charged and discharged but eventually all batteries will die. Given that reality, the guaranteed for life battery powered tools from Home Depot are compelling. So far the guarantee has replaced the batteries in both my and my daughter's drill.

Alternatively, buy at tool where the battery is easy to rebuild. Either learn to rebuild your self or have it done at the Battery Plus shop.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#11

Battery Cost

Jerry Nicholson

Think of the cost of replacing the batteries in a Tesla Roadster when they go belly up!!!!

Jerry

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#12

Rebuild...

John in NM

If you don't want to buy a new battery, then have the old one rebuilt. Why buy a used drill, whose batteries may be no good either, or may only last a little while before you find yourself in the same situation.

Given how badly some cordless drills are engineered, I'm usually quite happy to have it last long enough to buy new batteries. It seems like a "deal" to buy the new drill every time your batteries go out, but it usually isn't. If the old drill lasts through several sets of batteries, you're typically ahead by the cost of a new drill if you make it last.

Say a you paid $150 for the original set of drill, charger and bats. When you go to buy new batteries (as I just did a couple months ago), a pair of them costs $150 and a whole new set is only $200. Save the $50, if your drill lasts through three sets, you've recouped the cost of the original drill set. I believe they price things this way for a good reason - every time you go to replace batteries, they either get an inflated price on those or a less inflated price on a whole new set. I bet the absolute profit is the same on either, their margin is just higher on the bats.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#14

Good Plug To Reach Accord!

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

:b

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#15

Totally agree!


Re: OT-Tool Rant

#16

You've got this pun stuff wired, Col.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's clearly a good outlet for your creativity; and you keep us all grounded with your hot humor. There's just no resisting a smile when you post.

Bill, not neutral on the subject of the Colonel's humor

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#17

Yeah, I get such a charge out of him!

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

He's got such and electric personality. With his wit, we can never accuse him of assault and battery with a pun.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#18

Oh, Joanne, my tummy hertz from laughing!


Re: OT-Tool Rant

#19

He seems to have you guys all amped up!


Re: OT-Tool Rant

#20

MTO - not just hand tools...

Terry Alexander

MTO (no affiliation....but they have served me for years) also sells rebuilt 12 volt batteries for my deer feeder and portable spotlight (NO.....I'm not spotlighting deer) :)

MTO will also TALK to you (yep....real people). I've had them tell me to NOT use their service on certain things because I would be better off new.

NEWay....just a dang good company with excellent service.

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#21

Had a similar issue with wheelbarrow tires

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

A few years ago I bought a 10 cu/ft dual wheel wheelbarrow on closeout for 89 bucks, (I wish I'd bought both the ones they had). Last week I got tired of flat tires, and I was looking for foam filled tires with the correct hub. Several sales people said just buy a new wheelbarrow. Well that just seem wrong. I spent 105 dollars for foam filled tires for a 90 dollar wheelbarrow but at least I won't have a flalt tire next time I went to use it and I didn't throw way rest of the wheelbarrow.

PS Ron what part of Oregon?

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#22

I solved my  wheelbarrow tire issues

Bill Tindall

I was always getting flats in the thin factory tires. Berry briars would puncture the tire. So........I used my saber saw to cut the rim off the "rim". Bought a trailer tire and bolted it to the remains of the wheelbarrow rim. It probably is nowhere near balanced but at 1 MPH who cares. Haven't added air in 16 years.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#23

Re: OT-Tool Rant

Northwest29

Greetings again everyone, and thanks for all the input. I do appreciate the sharing of your thoughts and experiences. I decided that I would buy some sub-c batteries and do the battery pack rebuild myself. It seems within my skill set to do so. I estimate the battery cost at $1.50 each, takes 10 for a battery pack. It may take more time, but it will save some money and seems like a reasonable approach. If you can wirre an electrical outlet you should be able to rebuild a pack. IMHO

Gary, I'm on the other side of the 'hill' in west Eugene.

Ron

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#24

Re: Had a similar issue with wheelbarrow tires

Joseph Mulherin

Years ago I bought a puncture-proof tire at Lowes garden center....no more flats.

Re: OT-Tool Rant

#25

Re: OT-Tool Rant

gary camp Bend, Oregon

Well if you ever come over to the Dry Side give me a shout.

glc