Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Congratulations Egypt!!!

Posts

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#26

Re: Democracy????

Howard Acheson

>>>> I don't understand how a move from a corrupt, cruel and tyrannical regime to a democracy can be a bad thing.

I think it is way too early to pin the label of democracy to the actions in Egypt. All that can be said with confidence is that the current regime has been ousted. The ousting was not a democratic process. What will replace it remains to be seen.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#27

I asked my son about this.....

Barry Irby

He is a Captain in the army and has spent two years closer to that part of the world than I have. While I don't think he has any inside info, he is a student of history.

His take is that this is not a truly popular uprising, but is being directed by someone form behind the scenes. The press, including both sides have gotten it wrong and are very shallow on this. The real power is the army and it was suited the army to allow the ousted regime to stay in place for 30 years, but now they have decided it is no longer acceptable.

If a democracy emerges, it is unlikely to anything that resembles what we think of as a democracy. As far as I know, no democracy survives anywhere in the world. We are a republic.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#28

Re: Glad I got there before this started--

Jennifer Indy.USA

Joanne what a great photo! A pleasant diversion in this thread that went a little off course from it's intent.

:)

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#29

Ellis Walentine

Great sighting, Joanne!

Ellis Walentine

Send me the larger image sometime, as I like to make our sightings at least 700 px wide whenever possible.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#30

Or...

Mark Nowicki

....they will do like Poland has done, combine the worst parts of socialism and capitalism.

Mark

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#31

Re: Great sighting, Joanne!

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Will do. I'll see what else I've got with the right hat or shirt, too.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#32

Lee, If there is a downside to this,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

It will only be that we shouldn't expect any new pyramids to be built in the near future. You know, without a good strong pharaoh, those things just don't happen.

%\],,,,,,,k

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#33

Yah, This has been great to watch! *LINK*

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

For the Egyptian Army to be there, but not turn on its own people should be an inspiration to the world.

Of course we all should have some trepidation of how this will all work out, but the best thing that we can do is stay out of the way, and let them chart their own course.

How can you not feel good about this when you watch the many thousands of people who participated in this vigil as they celebrate. I can not help but feel some of their optimism and joy, with the prospects of a better future.

Lee, like you, I have listened to a lot of sources giving differing takes, and there is no doubt that this is being used as a political football. I listened to NPR all morning and FOX all afternoon. I went to Rachel Maddow a little while ago, which did a great job of summing it up.

I have lots of liberal and conservative friends, and I love them all. But I do have trouble with a closed mind. Here was my favorite coverage for the weekend.


http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26315908/#41542564

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#34

Lee Grindinger

This was my favorite,

Lee Grindinger

Mona Eltahawy is an Egyptian columnist living in New York. She has been tirelssly appearing on news shows trying to describe these events to us. She has been incredibly active on Twitter and her passion is infectious.

This is her when it finally sinks in that Mubarak has left,

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFED8wBJXeU

I like Rachel Maddow but she spends entirely too much time trying to discredit Fox when she should be focussed on what her show is about.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#35

Lee Grindinger

Keith, I'll just add...,

Lee Grindinger

I'll just add that the American press was a very minor source for me. I tuned to American press for American reaction, not news from Egypt. To plant a lily white non-Arabic speaking talking TV head into the midst of demonstrators in Tahrir Square was ridiculous. America was very much behind the curve on this one.

My news came from Arab reporters, demonstrators themselves, and Al Jazeera. Andy Carvin did a decent job for NPR but it was the likes of Sultan Al Qassemi, Sharif Kouddous, Ayman Mohyeldin, Dima Khatib and Mona Eltahawy's relentless tweeting as well as the many demonstrators and bloggers themselves throughout Egypt that provided me with the news.

Oh, and Google Chrome has a translating bar so I often used Reuters Arabic translated as another source.

I found it exhilarating and my faith in humanity has been boosted.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#36

Re: I don't understand

Howard Norman

At this time there is absolutely no real idea what the government of Egypt will turn out to be after this event. It could be the most democratic government in the Middle East or it could turn out to be much worse than before. My personal guess, and that is all it is, is that it will not be the great democracy that some expect. It could also be the start of much unrest in the Middle East Arab world. If that happens the world will be much worse off than we were with Mubarak.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#37

Lee Grindinger

I see blue sky

Lee Grindinger

The Mideast has been ruled by tyrants one country to the next. The notion that these people don't have the means to govern themselves in democratic systems is absurd and perpetuated by those discouraging change.

The USA may lose clout. I'm happy for that. For too long we have interfered in these people's lives ostensibly supporting Democracy but actually propping up dictators willing to do our bidding and sell us oil and support Israel.

I believe the world is better served by free people..., by free and self actualized people able to grow and improve and develop into all those things we aspire to.

Above all, I want these people, and all like them, to have the freedom to pursue their own ideals and dreams..., something impossible under authoritarian regimes.

Egypt, and Tunisia are sparks..., each one larger than the last, and I hope a great blaze arises that burns these oppressive regimes to the ground.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#38

Lee Grindinger

Thank you all

Lee Grindinger

Some of you are cynical bastards, I'm a liberal fool. Thanks for the civil thread!

:D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#39

Re: Thank you all

GolfSteve in Calgary

I think I'm both.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#40

It is Iran's turn now

Byron

world wide web@irannewsnow.com/2011/02/live-blog-iran-25bahman-feb14-2011/

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#41

Lee Grindinger

Wouldn't that be amazing!

Lee Grindinger

I've been hearing of the unrest in Iran and hope it happens..., that would turn the west on it's ear!

Thanks for the link!

Here's a Twitter list for Iran, http://twitter.com/#!/theriverfed/iran

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#42

Re: It is Iran's turn now

Howard Norman

Almost any change would be an improvement in Iran. So more power to the protesters there.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#43

Re: Wouldn't that be amazing!

Mark

Would be interesting for sure, and God knows (any God) that Iran could use a change of direction and leadership for everyone in the Middle East and the West.

However, after reading many of these posts and from a historical perspective I think more then a serving of healthy cynicism, mixed with a dose of reality is well founded for Tunisia, Egypt, Iran,Yemen,Behrain, Algiers

I think the West see any revolts in the Middle East as some sort of moral victory and endorsement of Democracy, but it has not exactly so, and democracy as much as we like to celebrate it and make pronouncements about beleiving in it, is not the history of this region of the World.

Democracy is more foreign to them then it is familiar.

Two examples come to mind

After deposing the tyrant and dictator Saddam, the people didn't come running to the self professed Liberators embracing democracy ...they plunged into a civil war.

And let's not forget that the last up rising and revolution in Iran .... didn't exactly work out so well, and is a far cry from a Democracy.

Let's hope but be realistic.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#44

FOX "NEWS" is actually an entertainment BUSINESS

charlie belden

There was a time when the Network News was part of a social contract - YOU make money using the public airways - and in return you provide a civic service - at least an hour of broadcast news of events happening in the United States as well as in the rest of the world. The NEWS was not a money making thing - it was a public service. And the Edward R. Murrows and Walter Cronkites were not on the air to boost ratings - and profits. They were there to provide factual information - not to sell advertising time to soap makers.

FOX "News" - and The Factor & Glen Beck - exists to fulfill it's primary objective - to get people to watch - so they can sell ads. And, as the former World Wrestling Federation, now World Wrestling ENTERTAINMENT, realized - giving people Big Mean Nasty Bad Guys and Strong Right Thinking Heroes - with a Good vs Evil Theme - sells tickets. And the bigger and badder the villians, the more tickets you sell.

So ratings have little to do with the quality of the content of a "news" program. That FOX can sell ads for soap at a higher price than competitors has nothing to do with the quality or accuracy of the info the use to get ratings.

As for the violence of the Egyptian revolution - the facts appear to point to the Mubarek supporters as the source of the violence and loooting - a very old tactic of repressive regimes.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#45

Re: Wouldn't that be amazing!

Larry in NW OHIO

Mark I don`t want this to get into an argument, just a discussion. Of course I don`t fully agree with your statments because most of the people you speek of listen to the "so called religous" leaders to much. They strap on bombs on themselves or let their children do it and go out and murder people in the name of religon. In my opinon that is no religon. I`ve said enough. Larry

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#46

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Clearly, those are commentary shows.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There are plenty of other 1- to 2-hour segments during the day that are far more dedicated to the news than the host's viewpoints. And just because a host conducts a seemingly heated interview doesn't mean that they take the opposing view of the subject at hand.

Surveys taken at "the other networks" indicate a an overwhelming tendency to vote a certain way among the reporters--to the tune of roughly 90%. You don't think that could POSSIBLY lead to bias, do you?

Jason

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#47

Re: This was my favorite,

Barry Irby

I have a friend that thinks Rachel Maddow is the end all and be all. I tried to watch. I also tried to watch Fox, Glenn Beck and O'Riley et al. It appeared to em that Beck was talking about the founding fathers and O'Riley talks his stuff and Maddow talks about them. Her time would be better spent on original topics.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#48

Moses Yoder

Re: Clearly, those are commentary shows.

Moses Yoder

I could say what I think about it, but this is now clearly a political thread so I am keeping my mouth shut in deference to those who don't see it my way. I saw a wooden sarcophagus once that was made in Egypt several thousand years ago. It was really cool. Now we are back to woodworking ;)

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#49

(swish !)

steve mackay

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#50

Didn't the Ancient Egyptians use hide glue?

John in NM

I wonder what their preferred sharpening method was? :D