Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Congratulations Egypt!!!

Posts

Congratulations Egypt!!!

#1

Lee Grindinger

Congratulations Egypt!!!

Lee Grindinger

Hosni Mubarak has resigned! He has handed power to a military council which is a good thing. The peaceful conduct of the Egyptian demonstrators has been awe inspiring.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#2

A few years from now, we will

Kelby

all look back at this as a huge disaster.

Mubarak is a problem, but there is not a better answer in Egypt. Those who will take control now will be far worse than Mubarak has been.

Time will tell.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#3

McKinneyMike

Re: A few years from now, we will

McKinneyMike

They may well be worse off, but at least there is change brought about thru peaceful means, which is no small feat in the Middle East it seems. I commend the people of Egypt for their handling of this situation too.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#5

Re: Interesting reply

paul in AZ

I'm afraid that what happens there WILL be relevant not only in the middle east but to us as part of the grander world stage. That is not to say that we should have any role in dictating how that evolves. Its their deal.

I am also not overly optimistic about any replacement politician being kinder, gentler or more able than Mubarak.

And I have NEVER EVER watched Fox news nor do I pay attention to the talk show hosts -right or left.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#6

Lee Grindinger

I don't understand

Lee Grindinger

I don't understand how a move from a corrupt, cruel and tyrannical regime to a democracy can be a bad thing.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#7

Re: I don't understand

paul in AZ

If thats what they get.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#8

Re: Interesting reply

Stuart Johnson

The people of Egypt have peacefully removed a ruthless leader whose regime is responsible for many, many, many human rights violations.

At what point are these no longer called peaceful? The news (not Fox or any cable) has been full of violent actions. When autos are burned, shops looted, people being clubbed and beat, shots fired and wounded being carried through the streets it is not peaceful. It makes no difference what leader is being tossed out or who is doing the tossing it is a violent overthrow. Whether it is good or bad depends on your political and economic views. History will tell if any change of any government was good for the local people and the stable health of the world.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#9

Granted, there are risks in any change...

John in NM

However they will never get a democracy without the change.

Regardless of the risks it baffles me that Americans can condemn anyone who simple wants freedoms similar to those we enjoy.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#10

Lee Grindinger

Stuart

Lee Grindinger

If your news sources have portrayed this revolution as violent they have done a disservice to you.

I have followed this revolution closely through Al Jazeera and many individuals in Cairo, Alexrandia and other Egyptian cities through Twitter. These people are reporters, citizens, Muslims, Christians Jews, men, women and youth as well as any other group you can think of. If you'd like an explanation of the violence you did see let me know, it will be lengthy. If you've made up your mind then I won't bother.

Lee

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#11

Re: Lee - I'm not arguing

Stuart Johnson

Lee, the news does not report it as being violent. They like you say it is a large peaceful uprising bringing about democracy. In comparison to many (Uganda) it is peaceful. I'm very certain the violent acts shown in the course of reporting are for the most part 'blood sells' type of reporting. In '92 or '93 there were some peaceful marches in Atlanta right up to gunfire from some business owners protecting their shops from looting.

My objection is to the term peaceful not the action or the cause. One last thing, at this point there is some discussion about this could be looked at as a military coup. A democracy has not yet been achieved and even if it does develop that does not automatically make it great for the rest of the world. The Egyptian people have an open ended opportunity but they can just as easily turn it into a never ending disaster.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#12

Don't like where this thread is heading...

John E in SC

I'm pretty sure political threads are off limits on Woodcentral, correct? This has certainly gotten political and is becoming contentious (although I applaud the fact that no one has resorted to name calling yet!) I've seen too many messageboards dissolve into nothing but one OT argument after another, and I really hope WC doesn't become that. I don't visit those other messageboards anymore.

I have no problem with the typical WC OT posts, but how about lets stay away from politics and keep it civil?

Thanks.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#13

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

Byron

Yes, amazing to witness the educated youth using social networks to organize and execute a peaceful demonstration toward a democratic process. Step 1 completed but now comes the very hard work: establishing a government that meets Egypt's needs.

I too have followed the last 18days on twitter, facebook and al jazeera -- it is heart-warming to watch, read and listen to people standing up against oppression in a peaceful manner. They sat down in front of the tanks -- they faced the secret police instigating violence -- very brave people who have much to be proud of.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#14

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

Thomas S Stockton

I see things like this happening and thinks it's great, but in the long run very few are successful and I think Pete Townsend of The Who has summed it up pretty well.

We'll be fighting in the streets

With our children at our feet

And the morals when they worship will be gone

And the men who spurred us on

Sit in judgement of all wrong

They decide and the shotgun sings the song

I'll tip my hat to the new constitution

Take a bow for the new revolution

Smile and grin at the change all around

Pick up my guitar and play

Just like yesterday

Then I'll get on my knees and pray

We don't get fooled again

The change, it had to come

We knew it all along

We were liberated from the foe, that's all

And the world looks just the same

And history ain't changed

'Cause the banners, they'd all flown in the last war

I'll tip my hat to the new constitution

Take a bow for the new revolution

Smile and grin at the change all around

Pick up my guitar and play

Just like yesterday

Then I'll get on my knees and pray

We don't get fooled again

No, no!

I'll move myself and my family aside

If we happen to be left half alive

I'll get all my papers and smile at the sky

For I know that the hypnotized never lie

Do ya?

Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

There's nothing in the street

Looks any different to me

And the slogans are out-phased, by-the-bye

And the parting on the left

Is now parting on the right

And their beards have all grown longer overnight

I'll tip my hat to the new constitution

Take a bow for the new revolution

Smile and grin at the change all around

Pick up my guitar and play

Just like yesterday

Then I'll get on my knees and pray

We don't get fooled again

Don't get fooled again

No, no!

Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!

Meet the new boss

Same as the old boss

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#15

Lee Grindinger

Yeah,

Lee Grindinger

It has been incredible to watch this unfold. The highs, the lows, the attempts to squelch the pro Democrat demonstrators and the press have been fascinating to watch. The new media, especially Twitter, has made so much possible and it's IMpossible to cut off news any longer. I've been following my own Twitter list as well as this one, http://twitter.com/#list/AntDeRosa/egypt

It's been inspirational.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#16

Lee Grindinger

Twitter joke

Lee Grindinger

As you know, the humor of the Egyptians didn't fail, this was one of the funniest tweets I read, "Hosni Mubarak has changed his Facebook relationship status with Egypt to 'It's complicated"

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#17

Saddam Hussein was democratically elected

Kelby

and, as I recall, the vote was unanimous for many years. ;)

There are real democracies, and then there are tyrants who use the illusion of democracy to sustain their power. Many of the Arab nations have all the tools in place for true democracy to work effectively. Others have had social structures that resulted in tyrants reigning under a sham democracy.

Looking at the social and political forces in Egypt, I anticipate that we will see something that looks democratic for a year or two, but there will soon be forces in power that are even less accountable to the people and more brutal than Mubarak ever was.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#18

Re: I don't understand

Earl

Take a look at Iran and tell me their change was GRAND. We'll see. Earl

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#19

yup. WAY worse !

steve mackay

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#20

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I agree , the peaceful process was something that was wonderful to see,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#21

Re: Interesting reply

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Golly Lee, Please explain to me in 10,000 words or more why Fox News channel is so bad if it is beating ithe cable news competition by factors 2 to 1 and in some cases 4 to 1. Please don't quote the rags on msnbc.

My 2 to1 numbers are available through Nielsen: http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/category/cable-news.

Inquiring minds want to know,

Ken

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#22

Lee Grindinger

How about one word

Lee Grindinger

Presentation

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#23

Re: Interesting reply

Alexander Grigoriev

The ruler is not there anymore, but people are still the same. Eventually they will elect themselves another dictator. As it has happened in Russia.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#24

Glad I got there before this started--

Joanne in Point Pleasant


I actually remembered to put on my WC hat before this picture was taken. I had the opportunity to visit Egypt (and Israel) last Spring with my mother and sister. For the most part, the Egyptian people were warm and friendly and very sweet. Of course, something like 80% of the income there is from tourism, so they sort of have to be nice to travelers.

Okay, Ellis, here's your sighting picture.

Re: Congratulations Egypt!!!

#25

Re: How about one word

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

I could give numerous examples of reporting and/or analysis where both sides of an issue are present for discussion. You are happy in your liberal world, I am happy in my conservative world. I will stick with Fox News, and you are welcome to stick with moveon.org, the daily cos, etc. I honor you right to your opinion, even though I disagree with it.

I am dropping the discussion at this point.

As Spock would say, live long and prosper,

Ken