Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Posts

Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#1

Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I know a guy who has an old DeWalt 16" Radial saw (with base). The saw is 5hp and 1ph. (I don't have 3ph power) Good working condition. It has a crosscut of 26".


I could probably get it for $1,200.

I often work with big boards...either thick or wide. I have thought it would be nice to have a big crosscut saw to process lumber.

Are saws like this really worthwhile to have? Downsides? Is this even a good price? Opinions or insight would be appreciated.

Tom

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#2

Alan Young

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Alan Young

Hi Tom,

I know you have approached Norm Capacity so this is just an Icing on cake acquisition :^) but for me if I had $1200 for a shop purchase this isn't on top of my list. For the number of times you are likely to cross cut wide boards I'd punt with a jig saw or circular saw. My 2cents

-Alan

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#3

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Joe Mohnike

Hi Tom

A RAS can do more than just saw. At one time you could get, various attachments, for joining, shapeing planeing etc. Some had dual shafts for other attachments. I have one, smaller 10", and would be lost with out it.

A 5hp may require you to run a seperate electric line with a 30-50 amp breaker, electricians are not cheap.

Most likley 95% of its use will be for someting that a 10" saw could handle.

For wide boards I have a jig that cuts 90 90 with a power hand saw and I have cut 6 1/2" with only a very small sandable ridge left when I finish the cut from the other side.

Just someting to consider.

Joe M.

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#4

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

We had one of these where I used to work. The motor could not be locally re-wound. It was available only from DW factory. Rebuilt motor was $750 in 2007 to a large industrial user! Be careful, bearings can be replaced, but motors are five HP in a three HP frame.

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I agree

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Alan,

I agree with you, even more than the cost of the saw is the foot print a saw like this would late up in a shop.

I use a clamp on straight edge and my circ saw, some times I even use my table saw with my dual runner cross cut sled.

I seldom use my chop saw any more either(seriously thinking of getting ride of it), I cut all my rough stock to length now with my half back saw, final sizing cuts again in my cross cut sled.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Clint Searl

In three words: not worth it. I have the Delta 10" RAS and a Hitachi 12" SCMS, augmented by a Bosch worm drive to handle any and all crosscutting. The RAS will accommodate wider stock than the SCMS and can take on thick stock by dropping the blade on successive passes. $1200 would finance a bottle of wonderfully rich '60s vintage single malt Scotch.

Clint

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#7

A Successful Intervention

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

This is exactly what I needed...an intervention. Thanks.

My tool budget is empty anyway. I think the snow must be getting to me. Thanks all for the good answers and a good old fashioned slap across the face to bring me to my senses.

Tom

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#8

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Larry in NW OHIO

Tom We also had one of these where I use to work, and when they shut down I think it went for something like $200 at the auction they had. Of course things were going very cheap. They had a CNC machine that they paid $250,000 for just 5 years before and came from ITALY and they only got $100,000 and it was almost like new. Boy the auctioneer was mad. Larry

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#9

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

FredD

A couple of thoughts Thomas, one , the saw is over priced ,unless it was a reconditioned one from Wolfe .

It is a model commonly used in lumber yards and Construction sites and like one poster said , it is a huge footprint in a shop.

For cutting really thick beam like wood ,which is far beyond the capacity of a ten inch saw , I use a Stihl chainsaw.

If you want dead on plumb cuts , there are jigs to hold the saw to the wood .

If you use a Chainsaw frequently , then you should have no problem getting a presentable cut free hand.

FredD

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#10

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Wait a Minute now

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

You think we're done?? :D

Come on Tommy, we're just getting started!! :b

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#11

same here

Bill Tindall

These saws used to be a common fixture in most every shop but I rarely see one now days for the reasons enumerated above. I would way more prefer to occupy the space with a drum sander, for example.

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#12

If I were you, I would consider this.  *LINK*

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Thomas, I have got a RA saw of about that vintage, only mine will cut 4" h x 32"w, that the table takes up about 20' along one wall. I don't think I would bother with one that wouldn't cut at least 24".

But then, I see a lot of panel saws going for less $ than your lust tool. Here is a recent link. The needed floor space would probably be about the same.


http://www.irsauctions.com/index_lots.asp?pg=details&id=14303&bp=183628

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#13

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

That price is a bit steep for a Dewalt. If it were a Unipoint would be worth it.

If you had a RAS maybe you would have been able to cut those curly walnut boards down to a reasonable size instead of getting stuck with making such a long table.

Robin

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#14

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Joanne in Point Pleasant

Wow, and I thought the 10" RAS I'm building a bench for was a big behemoth! It's a bit scary seeing so much of a 10" blade above the table coming at me; I don't think I'd care for a bigger one. If I didn't inherit the thing for free, I don't think I'd buy one. And I agree, $1200 sounds like a lot for such a saw.

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#15

Bob

Festool circular saw replaces this tool

Bob

I use my Festool circular saw for just about everything you could do with a radial arm saw and much more. The only thing it doesn't do is cut dados (not that you would really do that with a radial arm saw that size) but it takes almost no storage space and would cost less new than that big old used saw. I used it yesterday to cut some angled stretcher parts, just draw a line, lay the track in place and cut, so simple. I have also been using it to cut veneer and it works just as well for that. Paul Schurch has a utube video showing how he uses his to cut veneer. I find I can run the saw forward rather than backward like he does and the cut is still perfect.

Bob

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#16

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Ditto on the Festool circular saw 

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#17

Re: Festool circular saw replaces this tool

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

Okay, I have a smaller DeWalt, a 14" GA, and it does what it is supposed to do. I like being able to see the cut and the fact it will crosscut a 4x4 with one pass. Mine has a 3 hp motor, which has never bogged down and doesn't take as much juice to run. I got it probably 10 years ago for less than half what you think you would have to pay for the one you're talking about.

Moving on to more ponderable subjects, what is a 50 year old single malt like? i have never bought a bottle older than 15 years and wonder if I should be saving my money.

Roy Girolami

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#18

Re: Festool circular saw replaces this tool

frank ashmore

Have you thought about a sliding table for your t/s.I can cut a 45degree angle across a full 4x8 sheet of plywood.60" of travel. made by excalibur

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

#19

Re: Big DeWalt Radial Saw Dilemma

Barry

I have a little 9" Delta radial arm saw. It's probably from the 1950's or 60's. It's a neat little saw and is useful as a cutoff saw, but I don't use it for anything else. In fact, a good sliding arm miter saw would probably be way more useful and more accurate. I picked this one up years ago for almost nothing, painted and re-wired it and put on a new table. I wouldn't spend the money for a new one. In fact, I have considered replacing this old one with a miter saw. For the record, all of the many operations you supposedly can do with a radial arm saw either look dangerous to me or are just too hard to set up. I can't even bear to use one to rip a plank. It just seems way too awkward.