Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Hand tool recommendations

Posts

Hand tool recommendations

#1

Hand tool recommendations

Ray

It looks like I may have found a good workbench. Now on to tools. Can someone recommend a brand of planes and chisels that a serious beginner should be considering. As with most things like this, I have found that the first purchases are those that will help me decide what I will buy as better replacements.

Thanks

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#2

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Phil Joines

In a lot of ways the pre WW2 stanley planes are better than the current production until you get up in price to Lee Valley or even higher to Lye Neilson, etc.

You might want to post your question on the Hand Tools board.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#3

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Joe Shelton

One very well-reasoned approach is Anthony Guiduice's, as stated in "The Seven Essentials of Woodworking". It does not entail buying the wrong stuff to begin.

His opinions often put people off, but he is clear and no-nonsense.

What bench have you settled on?

Joe

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#4

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Dave Paine

As another reply advised, try the Hand Tools section of Wood Central.

I concur with Lee Valley and Lie Nielsen as very good brands.

However, before you spend any money, I recommend you do some woodwork to find out which type of tool you need.

Some years ago I walked into a Woodworkers Warehouse store (since gone out of business) and stated that I want to purchase my first plane, and what the store could recommend.

The person was honest and advised he did not know hand planes. I was still eager to but and so purchased a Record Jack plane. I truly did not appreciate when this would be relevant to use.

I have since done a lot more woodwork, and now own 7 or 8 hand planes including this one. The others happen to mostly be Lee Valley, but the important detail is the intended use. One is a garage sale Stanley #4 circa pre WWII.

Only by using the planes do I begin to appreciate the intended use for a given design.

I still use the Record, although I did replace with a Hock blade, good decision.

My favourite hand plane is the Lee Valley medium shoulder plane. A joy to use, but the nature of the design is that it is relevant for cleaning out dado's, tenons or rabbits.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#5

And, if you haven't already, do your reading

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lots of books in most libraries on woodworking, some of which are about hand tools, some of which have hand tool chapters. Worth reading through them to understand different tools.

This can get really subtle - for instance, bench chisels - the most common size, about 10-12" long - are generally beveled. Good chisels are ground/forged so that the remaining flat on the side of the chisel is very narrow, allowing you to get into tighter spots.

My chisels are all garage sale chisels of various old makes; I've heard good things about Ashley Iles, Hirsch, Two Cherries, and Narex (middle to lower-middle class tools). In the upper middle, we have Lie-Nielsen, and then you get into the fancy stuff like Barr.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#6

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Ray

Thanks for the heads up on the book.

I am fairly certain that I will be buying a used Swiss made LaChappelle bench. I weighs about 250 lbs, is approximately 70' long and has a face and tail vise.

I am very new to this board and to woodworking. I really appreciate all the responses.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#7

Clint Searl

At 70', that has to be the mother of all benches.

Clint Searl

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#8

Clint Searl

Decide on a project first

Clint Searl

Then get just the tools necessary to make it. The brand doesn't matter; you'll learn just as much using Stanley's as with the most expensive. It ain't the tool; it's the hands holding the tool.

Clint

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#9

Re: At 70', that has to be the mother of all bench

Ray

The old eyes are not as good as they used to be when it comes to proofing my work.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#10

a poor craftsman blames his tools

Jerry Gibbs

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#11

Re: a poor craftsman blames his tools

Jesse Cloud

You shouldn't blame your tools for beginner level results, but, give yourself a break and start with a good tool just to get the feel of working with hand tools. The old yard sale Stanleys can be a good deal, but you have to know what you are doing and put in a lot of elbow grease to get them up to snuff. Once you build your basic skills, they may be the way to go for you.

The 'gateway' skill for hand tools is sharpening. Don't rush, spend the time to learn how to get that plane or chisel wicked sharp - then hand tool work is easy and fun.

My recommendation would be to start with a Lie-Nielsen 60 1/2 block plane (a little over $100, resellable for close to that) and a plate of glass with several grits of sandpaper (google scary sharp).

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#12

two recommendations

Bill Tindall

I got laughed off the Hand Tool Forum for this one.......When we first became interested in raising sheep I went to an experienced sheep farmer and asked to buy some ewe lambs. After some discussion to determine my level of sheep raising expertise, the farmer suggest I buy some old ewes. His reasoning was that since I didn't know what I was doing, I should first buy some ewes that did.

I have the same view of hand tools. By some means, either buying a new quality tool or a used one from someone that would know one in working order, start with a tool known to work. I had a lot of hand tool failure trying to learn hand tool usage on stuff that wasn't working well. However, once I became experienced with hand tools the old Stanley planes etc. are my go-to tools and the new Lie Nielsens sit unused. You can rely on anything from Lee Valley in the hand tool line.

Second, you success with hand tools will depend on your ability to sharpen them properly and quickly. Some mentoring on these matters would be helpful. I had no idea what sharp meant till I started using hand tools. It will matter not if you have a $350 LN plane, if it is dull it won't work. Period!

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#13

Don't feel like the Lone Ranger

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Half of us are afflicted by it, the rest will be. :D

Seriously, two things.

Post on the hand tool side. There are many hand tool users over there who don't come here to read.

Start small with a single project in mind. Figure out what you need to do it, and then do it until you get that right or are satisfied with it. Besides, it's a lot easier to sneak one or two new tools past the finance committee than it is to acquire them all at one shot. You have to figure out what you want to do.

A little story. A friend went to a pre-retirement seminar and was exhorted to start developing a hobby before retirement. He picked woodworking, not because of any real interest but because he knew I'd advise him on tools and he knew what enjoyment I got from it. I wrote out a list and told him to get them along the way. Then I didn't hear from him for a few months. In the meantime he acquired an entire shop full of tools: table saw, band saw, scroll saw, drill press, orbital spindle sander, router, jig saw and a bunch of hand tools. I told him to take it slow, but that wasn't in his vocabulary. Then he discovered wood carving. Nearly all his tools are in the boxes in which they were delivered, 13 years ago. The drill press is still covered with cosmoline and plastic wrap.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#14

Where are you?

Randy Johnson

You might live close to someone on this board who would be able to let you test drive a few tools.

I'm in Connersville, IN.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#15

Re: two recommendations

John E in SC

I would agree with the recommendation to get some help in the beginning if using hand tools. I was a "machine" woodworker for years (decades? :\ ) before starting any significant use of hand tools, and only then after taking a class that tought me how to properly set up and sharpen a hand plane. Just about everything else I've learned from reading books and trial and error, but my attempts at using a hand plane were dismal failures until I had that class. There are so many different ways to sharpen tools in particular that reading about it and decididing what equipment to buy, much of it expensive, was somewhat overwhelming. The class I took was just a long weekend, and was well worth the cost for NOT having to waste money and time on the "trial and error" approach. The joy of making that 1st "see through" whole shaving was something I still remember. So, bottom line in my opinion, at least when it comes to hand tools, get some help.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#16

My firsts

Todd Nebel

I agree with much of the advice above. Here's what I started with and use on nearly all my flat projects:

Ashley Iles American Bench Chisels (1/8", 1/4", 3/8", 1/2", 3/4", 1")

Lie-Nielsen Mortise Chisels (1/4", 3/8", 1/2")

Lie-Nielsen Rabbet Block Plane

Veritas Medium Shoulder Plane

Norton Waterstone Starter Kit: 220/1000 grit stone, 4000/8000 grit stone, SiC flattening stone

I've added more over time, but this will get you going.

My hand tool skills are only as good as tuning up machined joints and glue-ups.

Todd

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#17

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Joanne in Point Pleasant

If you are just starting out, pick up a woodworking magazine or two, watch every woodworking-related tv show you can find, pick the brains of woodworkers you know and meet. Find a woodworking class to take somewhere. It doesn't have to be a semester-long kind of class; even a Saturday session at a Woodcraft of such place would help. Randy's suggestion to see if there is a WC person who lives near you is a good one. Hang out here and read or scan all 3 main boards; tons of wisdom to be found here. I also suggest going through the Shop Shots and Articles. Might give you an idea of a small project to start with. Have fun, tell us about your progress, and observe good shop safety procedures.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#18

A place to start

Bill Tindall

Presuming you will be building stuff, furniture and the like, and further making the assumption that you will be using hand tools and machines, each to their best advantage, I will make the following recommendation. If you plan to eschew machines altogether, then go get advice from the Hand Tool Forum.

The role of hand tools in a mixed machine-hand tool shop is to use hand tools for fitting parts. Hand tools excel in the task to remove precise small (thousandths of inch) increments of wood in a controlled way. Just what is needed for fitting a drawer or door, for example.

Every shop making stuff has a hand plane and chisels, and some means of sharpening. There seems to be a lot of personal preference as to whether a #4 or #5 sized hand plane is best. I started with a 4 and now prefer a 5. Chisels are even more personal. Either get a cheap set, like the blue handled Marples or buy one good 1/2" of some brand and a 3/4" of another and see what you prefer. The big decision is Japanese style, which excels at dovetailing and hinge mortising because of their shortness and lightness, or the longer and heavier western patterns.

The cheapest effective entry level means of sharpening is to use abrasive sheets stuck to a glass plate. I have an article in the Articles Section describing this approach. But to repeat, if you fail at developing a quick means of effective sharpening you are doomed to failure with hand tools.

Books and DVD's. It would seem that to get a book published one needs to present some novel way to do this or that. These novel approaches may not be the most efficient, reliable or easy to learn, or approaches that have stood the "test of time". Seeking advice from professionals (defined as people that have actually earned all their living for many years selling their woodworking), many of whom teach now days, can be effective. However, there are some things that professionals do in the name of efficiency, that are hard to learn for a beginner. I would put "pins first dovetails" in this category. So certainly seek advice, take classes(highly recommended), read, watch DVD's but keep in mind there are many means to a successful woodworking conclusion and you will eventually need to choose what is best for you.

As someone else said, an effective class can save you money by avoiding buying stuff you will never actually use. (I have a shelf full of these things)

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#19

Amen -  A place to start

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I want to echo Bill's comments.

I am a relative novice at hand tool work. My best experience has been with a Lee Valley shoulder plane that came sharp. WOW so that's how a sharp hand tool is supposed to work!

Sharpening is key. I'll add one tidbit of advice that I have read (and followed pretty much): pick ONE sharpening method and use it until you are competent. Don't just keep buying new stuff thinking that it will solve all your sharpening problems. Experience is the one aspect that you can't buy - and you need practice/experience to master any sharpening method. Some things may make they job easier and faster, but speed and reproducibility do come with practice.

Henry

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#20

Start off right . . .

steve mackay

Since you're talking about starting out I'll assume you're not in the market for high end stuff like LN or LV. That said I can safely say I've NEVER bought a "new" tool that worked the way I wanted / needed it to work "off-the-shelf". NEVER. I wound up frustrated and turned off by the whole hand tool idea. THEN I found a Stanley 5 1/4 in a dumpster and it followed me home. I had NO idea what to do with it. NONE. While trying to make it work I found Wood Central. Within a week I had it working well enough to see that this whole thing wasn't mystical or cosmic. HONEST ! Buy a $15 or $20 #4 on Ebay. PAY someone to sharpen the iron so you'll know what it supposed to look like AND feel. NOW you've got a starting point. You'll be doing work and not fighting a cheap tool. You'll get results that will please you and encourage you. I KNOW you want to go down, buy a tool and get right to work BUT . . .

Now, after only a couple years, I've collected more than a couple planes and chisels. They are a pleasure to use for their own sake. They all do their task better than any new tool on the market.

Now I love every tool that I rescue. They are more "mine" than anything I could ever get "new". And probably work better.

I won't comment on the "slippery slope" of hand tools. For it IS the Abyss. You'll be peeking into it soon enough ! It is dark but with distinguished company.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#21

Re: Start off right . . .

Jesse Cloud

Good advice above. I'm embarrassed every time I look up at the shelf of sharpening gadgets I have fell for. Pick a method - sandpaper or stones - and practice until you are proficient.

Take a class, find a local woodworking club, find a mentor - all good ideas.

I'm a little wary of the garage sale Stanley's. Lots of things can be wrong with them, not just dull blades. A woodworking club, class, or mentor can, however, help you find a good one and tune it up if that's the path you want to take.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#22

No offense meant . . .

steve mackay

I was out in the shop and thought of my response. I meant no offense about sharpening. Its a skill I'm still working on. And getting better at. "In the Begining" I just had no idea what a properly sharpened iron even looked like. Or felt like. Kinda one of those "I SEE !" moments.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#23

As you stated that you are new to

Gary Smyth

Woodworking, and if I'm not too late, allow me to voice an opinion that a woodworking bench, while pretty, will not serve you to the purpose you believe it is to serve. If you are new, the vises will certainly be handy (essential), but I think you need an assembly table/bench far sooner than a traditional bench. As a newer woodworker you will find that a traditional bench , with or without a tool trough is too narrow in width and in addition, you will beat the crap out of a traditional bench. Not too soon after, when you get better at woodworking, you will hate yourself for the dings, paint, glue, jig damage you did to it early on. I suggest you find an alternative until you feel as if you cannot do the work without a traditional bench. Maybe never! With fewer dollars and just a little help you can build a bench (with vises and cubbys) that will save you money, be movable, have a replacable top, AND do a better job for you while building up your skills and shop. I'd apply funds first to the work you are working on and if it entails the purchase of quality power tools or hand tools or both so be it. It mostly depends on the work you do, of course, but my experience is that a traditional work bench might be a better later purchase.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#24

Re: Hand tool recommendations

Tony - Memphis

Hi Ray. COngrats on the bench and the entry into the wonderful world of woodworking. I can't add much to all o fthe advice already given, but I would add that used tools are a rally good way to start. There are several reputable dealers that you can work with. The good ones will sell you soemthing that you can count as being a good tool. I bought a #4 Stanley smoother first. I think I paid $75 for it. It is a wonderful tool. A lot of it depends on the work you will do. I like 18th century stuff, so a Stanley 151 spokeshave was another early purchase. A nice block plane is very handy. I have an LN that was a birthday gift many years ago (they aren't that expensive for an LN plane). As for chisels, I don't really have a favored brand. I like the old Stanleys and the Witherby's, but those often command a higher price than a new chisel. Lee Valley offers a whole line of planes that are a better value than some of the others. Also, send an email to some of the dealers out there and explain your situation. I've gotten advice and offers of good "user" tools for very reasonable prices.

The other thing I would suggest is to educate yourself. There are tons of youtube videos (LN has a bunch out there) that show how planes work and how to work with them. There are lots of DVD's to be had as well. Subscribe to the online woodworking magazine databases (like FWW) and read al the articles about tuning planes and sharpening and such.

Now, I have been at it a while and I got an LN 62 (I think) - the low angle Jack for Christmas last year - wow! m What a plane! I love this thing. It does evrything and does it well. Plus, it's beautiful to hold and look at. Chris Schwarz (or Schwartz?)at Popular Woodworking put out a book on planes last year I think that has lots of good info in it. I think it is a reasonably priced book too.

Anyway, I could keep babbling! Good luck with it. Oh, and don't get frustrated. When I first tried using hand tools, it was awful. I'm not great with them, but at least now I trust that when there is a problem, its me (or tha its time to sharpen). That's the other thing - learn to sharpen. Makes all the difference.

Tony

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#25

Fully Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA