Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Hand tool recommendations

Posts

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#26

Re: Where are you?

Ray

I am in a NW suburb of Minneapolis. It would be great to make contact with anyone in the area.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#27

Re: Where are you?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Just exactly which NW suburb? One of the top ten (maybe top five) great plane makers of the world lives in Elk River. I live in Hutchinson. Furthermore, there is a meeting of the Midwest Tool Collector's Association in Medina, MN, on Feb 12, where there will be nearly every hand tool you could ever hope to acquire. Mike Siemsen, of the Pine City Woodworking School would be pretty much straight east of you. He's one of the very best.

I'd be willing to make a road trip. Ping me.

Edited to add: the MN Woodworkers Guild meets in Richfield in two weeks. Their skill level will likely be what you're shooting for eventually, and the quality of work displayed is phenomenal. It's an inspiration, at the very least. I can hardly ever make it to their meetings because I'm invariably on evening shift when they meet.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#29

Re: Start off right . . .

Larry Williams

"...That said I can safely say I've NEVER bought a "new" tool that worked the way I wanted / needed it to work "off-the-shelf". NEVER..."

In general, I agree. There are exceptions. From my end, every forum thread I see on sharpening leaves me wanting to pound my forehead on my desk. I think there's a lot more noise out there than good information and it's the reason for a high percentage of "summer romances" with hand tool woodworking. There's a gimmick gadget for every edge tool ailment, unfortunately nearly all of them belong in the trash can. A little knowledge of what it takes to get a good edge and traditional sharpening technique would go a long way toward increasing the population of woodworkers using hand tools. It's just not that difficult to get a good durable edge where you want it and in almost any shape or configuration.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#30

The best sharpening method

Dan Donaldson

The best one is whichever one that you learn how to use and gives you a sharp edge. Basically any method is capable of sharpening a blade, you just need to bite the bullet and learn how to do whichever one you choose and not keep looking for the "silver bullet". (how is that for word echo;-))

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#31

One To Include

David Yoho

All of the advise you've received here is right on. However, I would add one hand tool that I didn't see mentioned but I believe is a "must-have", and that's a cabinet scraper. I tend to like the Stanley #80 and have two that I use on almost every project.

Where I find it most useful is in smoothing the joints of a glued-up panel. It's quicker than sanding and doesn't leave scooped out areas like a sander can. It is especially excellent at smoothing highly figured woods too. It works like a plane in one sense because it shaves the wood and produces fine curly shavings. It's dead easy to sharpen and create a hook on the blade that does all the work. They're also very affordable.

This is not to be confused with card scrapers or scraper planes. All have their place but the easiest to begin with is the cabinet scraper. Do enough woodworking and you'll get plenty of use from one.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#32

training wheels

Bill Tindall

My success with hand tools is recent in my woodworking "career" and it resulted from learning what "sharp" is and how to achieve it. If 3 years ago someone had said you must sharpen free-hand I would have quit, or you will be sharpening free-hand I would have laughed. Yet that is what I do exclusively now. But it took "training wheels" to get there on my own. I think with mentoring I could have skipped the training wheels, maybe.

In this case training wheels is a honing jig. The other requirement was an abrasive format that removed metal at something less than geological time. I never knew what sharp was because I never wore away at a tool with traditional abrasives long enough to get there.

A honing jig and abrasive sheets enabled inexperienced me to achieve sharp and hence success with hand tools. Once hooked I was motivated to then search for something quicker, resulting in a shelf of rejects accumulated along the way.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#33

question

Bill Tindall

I own one. Tried it and it chattered across the surface (without a doubt due to my lack of knowledge of how to use it or sharpen it). So it became a shelf decoration. I don't see this tool used much in shops so I never got to ask about its secrets. I can see where it would be a most valuable tool if it didn't chatter across a surface.

How is the blade prepared/sharpened?

If it chatters, what needs adjusting?

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#34

Re: question

David Yoho

Bill, I can tell you what I do, which is very elementary at best. I know I leave out some steps others will say need to be there but it works for me and it's quick.

I start by running the blade's bevel over a file. I have a Veritas� Jointer/Edger and mill file I use for this to keep the bevel right. Once it's sharp, I put the blade in a vise and use a burnisher to roll the burr over. Then I place the blade into the body in the correct orientation and almost just snug the two screws. I want the blade to move at this point but not be sloppy. I lay a dollar bill or piece of paper on top on my saw table and place the scraper blade and front part of the sole on it. The rear surface of the sole is not on the paper. At this point I tighten the two screws holding the blade in place.

Whenever I start out with a fresh edge, I don't need to turn the thumb screw against the blade much. After a few uses, I find tightening the thumb screw some helps it cut right. I'm not sure why you're getting the chatter you are. I only get it once in a blue moon. Maybe it's how you're holding it. All I do is grasp the two handles, and place my thumbs pressing down on the rear of the sole and push away. I get clean, smooth, chatter-free cuts that more times than not produce nice curly shavings.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#35

Re: question followup

Bill Tindall

"blade's bevel over a file."

What is bevel angle?

How heavy a burr compared to card scraper which I can usually successfully prepare?

Thanks for help

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#36

Re: question followup

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a 45 degree angle on my #80 blade. The burr is fairly light.

I find it easier to get a more uniform job on a larger surface with the #80 than a card scraper alone. A few years ago I made a tool chest for my BIL that incorporated a piece of unbelievably gnarly grained locust he had given me. That wood was resistant to absolutely every blade in the shop, and there was only so much sanding that I wanted to do. The #80 handled it without a hitch.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#37

David Barnett

One of my most-used tools, too

David Barnett

I'm apt to reach for it over my #212 in most cases, for panels, veneering, luthiery, even bookbinding. I'm not too finicky about the bevel angle, although I try for 45�. Different burr angles and lengths, however, make it an incredibly versatile tool once you get the hang of it. I've found that slowly moving the burnisher with light to moderate pressure produces a finer and longer-lasting burr. Hit it with a mill file followed with a cheap 600-grit diamond file or paddle lap for really fine work. BTW, Hock makes a superb aftermarket blade but the stock blades are surprisingly adequate.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#38

What Bruce said.

David Yoho

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#39

Re: As you stated that you are new to

ray

Gary,

I really appreciate the advice. Not only does it make sense, but it prompted me to call a few friends. I found a very sturdy bench with a top constructed from 2x6s on end and 4x4 legs (free).

Thanks to your advice, I will have both types available in my shop.

I couldn't pass on the opportunity to buy the traditional bench. The price was too attactive.

Thanks again.

Ray

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#40

Re: Where are you?

ray

Thanks for the information. I live on the border between Plymouth and Maple Grove. I will definitely be at the event in Medina.

Where is the Pine City woodworking school? As part of my job I am at Pine Technical College approximately twice a month.

Ray

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#41

Re: Where are you?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Be aware that you need to join MWTCA to get in, but you can do that at the door:

http://mwtca.org look under meetings http://www.mwtca.org/tool-meets.html we're in area A. I'll be at the meeting in a green WoodCentral cap and maybe maroon WC sweatshirt, probably be getting there at around 8AM. Come up and introduce yourself. It's possible that Dean Jansa and Mike Siemsen might be there this year, as they were last year. Wayne Anderson from Elk River usually attends. He's one of the officers. There are more tools than you would imagine.

Mike Siemsen's school: http://www.schoolofwood.com/

Also take a look at the rest of the metro area schools and programs:

http://www.finewoodworking.com/SkillsAndTechniques/SkillsAndTechniquesArticle.aspx?id=28165


you'll need to cut and paste the links.

My offer to get together still stands.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#42

Re: Where are you?

Mike Siemsen

I am North of Minneapolis and have a woodworking school that does a lot with hand tools. Come to the Midwest tool collectors Meet in Medina, MN on Feb. 15th. I will be demonstrating and you can buy some tools from the vendors.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#43

Dale Lenz

I get chatter...

Dale Lenz

if the project piece is not anchored well. Example: my two side of a flag case is clamped in the vise and the bottom of the case is above the vise, I get scraper chatter. Once I sink the bottom of the flag case between the vise jaws, no chatter.

Good luck, the cabinet scraper is worth learning to use, beat the crap out of sanding, plane tears and such.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#44

Re: Decide on a project first

Ray

I am ready for my first project. I have been looking for plans to build a wall hung tool cabinet for storing chisels, marking and measuring instruments, a few planes, etc.

I have not been able to find any plans that inspire me. Can someone point me in the right direction? I need to find a perfect cabinet plan so I can go out and spend money on the first hand tools that I will need to build it!

Thanks to everyone that has responded to my original post. It took three of us to manhandle the top of my cabinet maker's bench into my soon-to-be woodworking shop in the basement.

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#45

Clint Searl

Wrong project!

Clint Searl

You won't need a tool cabinet, if ever, until you have some tools to put in it. The first law of woodworking says that the first project must be a coffee table. Top, apron, and four legs...of your design. Get to it.

Clint

Re: Hand tool recommendations

#46

maybe not

Bill Tindall

I was tempted to offer similar advice. But then, having hung out on the hand tool forum for a while, I came to the realization that every woodworker doesn't strive to build furniture for their house (still can't quite get my mind around this fact). Hence, what gets built are tool cabinets, benches, plane shavings and the like.

One should probably start woodworking when young and poor. Under these conditions anything built would be useful and appreciated, and at home in the home of the day. Ideally one's skills would develop as one's discrimination developed such that anything that got built would find a place in a home. An alternative might be to start building for kids that are poor and less discriminating. My early woodworking efforts have been handed down to children or hidden in the rec room.

A tool cabinet would develop some generally useful skills and not be subject to criticism by anyone. When I was learning to hand cut dovetails I made a roll around cabinet for my lathe stuff with a multitude of drawers. It was a good learning exercise and a useful product to boot. I made it out of lumber so junky that no one ever noticed the lack of dovetailing skill.