Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

***New Messageboard Format***

Posts

***New Messageboard Format***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***New Messageboard Format***

Ellis Walentine

>Hi folks,

As you have seen by now, we've changed the way the messageboards look and feel. I won't go into all the reasons why we've made these changes; I just want you to getused to them and see if you agree that they are for the better.

The most evident thing you will see is that there are no frames anywhere on the 'boards anymore. Everyone gets to see the navigation (which itself has been restyled and made more efficient), and nobody has the horizontal frames anymore. The Sightings image is on the splash page where you enter the messageboards, so everyone can now see the sightings as well.

Another change we've made is to switch the default viewing mode to UBB Sort order. This is a feature we didn't use in the past because of bandwidth and responsiveness issues, as it is a bit more processor intensive when loading the index page. Now, it is so close to the other orders we decided to go for it. The advantage is that anytime somebody posts a reply to an old post, even if it has scrolled off the board, the whole thread comes back to the top of the list. This should serve to keep valuable discussions alive longer.

To navigate the new messageboards, I suggest you use the back button on your mouse (or, if you don't have one, the back button on your browser) to go back to the message index after reading a message. It is instantaneous that way -- no waiting for the message index to reload.

I'm going to be away from my computer on and off for the next several days, but I will check back to read your reactions and suggestions. This change is expected to be permanent, pending an even more up-to-date change in the board structure itself, but we are open to any and all suggestions. You can still use the "Set Preferences" link to go back to the Mixed Threaded Single Message display that we had until today.

Also, note that the three main boards have their archive links right in their message index page. All the boards have spam patrol and FAQ links in their gray navigation bars at the top of the page.

There may well be broken links and other unexpected fallout from this very complicated, wholesale change, but we will deal with such issues as they occur. Thanks for your patience. I hope you like the changes.

Best,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#2

Wow I thought it was some thing

Dustmaker Mike

>I drank.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#3

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>Different, but good.

I suggest right-clicking on messages and selecting "Open in a new Tab" as a quicker way than using back to get back to the main list. This assumes a modern browser with tabbing of course. Then just follow the threads in the various tabs and kill them when done.

Jay

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#4

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Howard Norman

>Thanks for the update Ellis. When I opened WC a few minutes ago and found that the frames were not there my immediate response was to go to preferences and redo them, but I will try the new format for awhile and see how it goes.

Howard

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#5

May I suggest...

Dan Mitchell

>I generally would prefer to use the "Posted since your last visit began" setting. One confusion with this occurs when someone posts a reply and changes the subject line. Say someone starts a thread asking "What's the best table saw?", then there are 3 replies under this heading. Now a 4th reply is posted where the writer has changed the subject line to "Well, in my opinion...", or "Avoid Brand X like the plague!!!". When this post appears under the "Posted since your last visit began" setting, you can't tell what discussion it is part of, since the subject is no longer "What's the best table saw?". If there are any replies for a given thread which fit the "Posted since your last visit began" criterion, is there any way to have the thread's initial subject line appear as a header above them? This way you could tell if the reply is part of a thread you have been following without having to open it.

Just a thought.

Dan

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#6

I like it

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I like the new format, but it seems slower loading up the first message page.

Lee

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#7

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Rich in MN

>I liked the frames where the index was always the top half of the scrren and message thread was readable in the bottom half of the screen. Now after reading a thread I have a looooong down load to get back to the index or have to hit BACK as many times as there are messages in a thread as I usually read them all.

This might be an upgrade but I feel I have lost a good feature.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#8

JL

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

JL

>Like the format - but it does appear to be a little slower (and I have DSL).

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#9

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Larry in NW Ohio

>I really hate change, but I try new things and so far I kind of like this so far. It`s going to take time to get use to it. First thing I couldn`t find was the post response. Boy Ellis was getting a talking to, that he left post response off of just my computer somehow. But one thing I found out that some of you are talking about, having to use the back button, try using the "back to index" at the top or bottom of the message you are reading. Works for me. Larry in Ohio

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#11

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Although I liked the separate message frame, I'm sure I can get used to this. My first thought was the red box around each message is perhaps a little distracting, but some may prefer it.

Response does seem slower, but it's hard to tell if this is different than before since response time often varies considerably at times.

JKJ

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#12

tooooooooooooooo sloooooooooooow

fred in ct

>

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#13

It's broken

David

>Th elook is fine but the response time is horrible. The back arrow may work but that doesn't give you the next message and loading each message takes forever, as does switching from one message board to another. Right now the message boards are close to unusable.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#14

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Larry in Central Florida

>I have DSL but the new format is about as fast as using dialup. Maybe its my system, but I have to hit the back button multiple time to get back to the index. I give it a thumbs down.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#15

Slow even on DSL

Craig

>I agree, even on DSL it is way too slow. The old format loaded and viewed much, much faster. Sorry.

Craig

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#16

I like it!

Roger Myers

>I like it much better. Didn't like the frames settings, so I never used to see the sightings pics.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#17

Hmmmmm..... couple of observations....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>First, it looks like the back door benefits have been eliminated. We now get a banner column down the left side regardless of whether we want it or not.

Second, the main message index no longer fits on the screen. Stuff rolls off to the right. Not a biggie since there's not much out there anyway.

Third, the "open thread in new window" function has been abandoned. You can sill hold down while you click the message and it will open in a new window, but I liked it better when it did it automatically (admittedly after coming in thru the back door).

Fourth, it looks like the display area for message content has been made narrower in the interest of more room for banner ads down the right side. I realize the site needs sponsors to survive, but it makes it less readable to me than the old full page back door display.

I gotta be honest, I'm not sure I like the new format.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#18

Sorry to disagree, but...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>what was wrong with the old format? It worked, it was much faster and for us old-timers, it was comfortable.

Though newer is often better, I think in this case it missed the mark.

Doug

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#19

Seems awfully slow...

John E

>Maybe this is something that will improve, but I'm concerned that for us poor folks on dial up (see my post about satellite internet below), it may be unusable. I'm on my dsl work connection now and it seems WAY slower than usual. But I only have dial up at home - with the banner ads that change pictures, I don't know that I'll EVER be able to browse from home. I'm all for trying something new, and I promise I'll try to keep an open mind for awhile, but on first glance, I like the frames format better. (I frequent a variety of message boards, and I've always liked the "old" woodcentral format better than any.)

My 2 cents, (but I'm really worried about the slowness)

John

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#20

Re: Sorry to disagree, but...

Jeffrey D. Rose

>I agree with Doug...seems slow and I personally liked seeing the message strings and message all at once.

I did through me for a loop when I first saw it.

Jeff in Iowa.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#21

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

Bill White

>I Like it too.

Bill

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#22

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

kenny in indep MO

>I did like the old format, however things change and maybe after a couple of weeks it will be faster, right it seems really slow.

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#23

Or use the Return to Index link at the top

Jack

>

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#24

Works for me! Thanks!

Jesse Cloud

>

Re: ***New Messageboard Format***

#25

Re: Seems awfully slow...

Howard Norman

>I am not having any problems with WC speed. This is my second time today to try the new format. I like it. There will always be those who don't like any changes. Sometimes I am in that crowd, but this change is working fine for me.

Howard