Re: Your rights... My thoughts
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>John, while I am sure we would never find agreement on these issues - you have the right to your opinions. My feeling and answers to your questions are expressed below.
Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of employees who are injured due to lack of guards/safety features? Do you think those people who have been injured might prefer to have their digits back at the expense of your rights?
I have worked in factories before OSHA and did work with some dangerous equipment. However that was my choice. I could have left the job an found another. The issue in question was not requiring employers to use safer equipment - it was to "outlaw" existing standard saws and FORCE all producers of this equipment to install a braking mechanism. I really think you can't take all the risk out of life, next step would be to insist all chisels have dull edges and jointers have automatic feeds so no cutter could be exposed. If Osha had control of our personal cars we could not open the hood with the motor running to tune the engine. Should this be done to eliminate the chance of getting into the fan or belts?
Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of those who end up paying the medical expenses of the un-insured/under-insured? Even if you have adequate financial ablities to pay for your accident, do you think every one who uses a tablesaw is also able to pay for his/her "repairs"? Who pays if they can't?
I do think my "rights" allow me the freedom to take chances. I do not feel I am responsible for taking care of "everyone" nor do I want to dictate how they live their lives. I do have adequate insurance, but I pay dearly for it. My father passed on when I was 10 years old. We had little money but did not receive or want any assistance from the government. I worked and paid social security since I was 11 years old. I worked 2 and 3 jobs for many years to raise my family and so I could pay my way, again I have never received one cent in government aid of any kind - even when I was eligible for some with 6 children. I currently drive a van that is 18 years old and do all my own house maintenance so I can afford to pay my insurance. I do have a pretty decent nest egg in my retirement savings (I am now retired) but we scrimped to save that. I have little sympathy for those who drive new cars, work one job and complain they have no insurance.
Do you really think a bunch of cops were going to show up and confiscate your "illegal" tablesaw if Mr. Sawstop's efforts had born fruit? OSHA requires guards on table saws used in the workplace- none of the shops I've worked for had them, and the rule was never enforced, even after one shop had three accidents, two involving tablesaws.
No I did not feel this would affect me with my equipment, however if I decide to replace my saw, or my son buys one, it would have a huge impact on cost of the equipment - and possibly with replacement of saw blades, stop mechanism etc.
Did you personally file a complaint with OSHA? If not, why? If so what was their response. In most cases, including my last employer, they find is much cheaper for them to spend the money to avoid accidents than to pay the resulting claims, insurance, lawsuits and fines. The shops you worked for are probably closed now due to this.
For what its worth, I'm not trying to agrivate you, and I use an old unisaw with no guards that I'm not planning to replace. But like it or not, we do not define our own rights. Right or wrong this is the nature of our civilization.
If no one objects like I do, you are correct. If we do object and put out pocketbook and vote where they count - maybe we can "define our rights" or at least not lose all the rights our brave men have fought and died for.