Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Posts

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#51

Your rights...

John in New Mexico

>Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of employees who are injured due to lack of guards/safety features? Do you think those people who have been injured might prefer to have their digits back at the expense of your rights?

Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of those who end up paying the medical expenses of the un-insured/under-insured? Even if you have adequate financial ablities to pay for your accident, do you think every one who uses a tablesaw is also able to pay for his/her "repairs"? Who pays if they can't?

Do you really think a bunch of cops were going to show up and confiscate your "illegal" tablesaw if Mr. Sawstop's efforts had born fruit? OSHA requires guards on table saws used in the workplace- none of the shops I've worked for had them, and the rule was never enforced, even after one shop had three accidents, two involving tablesaws.

For what its worth, I'm not trying to agrivate you, and I use an old unisaw with no guards that I'm not planning to replace. But like it or not, we do not define our own rights. Right or wrong this is the nature of our civilization.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#52

Choosing This Post but Might Have Chosen Another

Robert Hutchins

>Pointing out seat belts and air bags does nothing to refute my argument. It's like answering, "Abraham Lincoln," to the question, "How much is 2 times 4." It is a logical fallacy long and well known as post hoc ergo propter hoc (so long has it been known that it is best recognized named in Latin). Look it up in Wiki. That seat belts and air bags are fait accompli is inarguable, but their accomplishment doesn't justify making more government rulings because of them. In fact, one could make an argument that seat belts and air bags, by making drivers feel more secure, encourages greater risk taking and thereby endangers the public more. Because patent holders and government accomplished the law in those cases doesn't make it right. In fact, making it criminal NOT to have those devices is egregiously wrong! I drove automobiles on far worse roads for decades before those devices were mandated. So did millions of others. Air bags and seat belts are products I would probably have purchased, if reasoably priced and packaged, without government mandate. A good government would have mandated neither. As for the argument that they have saved lives and therefore government intervention is justified, just remember the old saw, "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions."

Being the cynical old fellow that I am - who has known and dealt with more politicians, lawyers and judges at state and federal levels than most here on the forum - I'll openly declare that the reasons we have both seat belts and airbags are only tangentially because they produce good effects in some circumstances. Government is about power and money. Only sometimes - I might easily say rarely- do the governed benefit from those who exercise the power and use the money.

By joining this thread, my goal was to reinforce the arguments against government being used in the manner that the SS people tried to use it, to their narrow personal advantage. Having someone point out that others have also manipulated either politicians or the marketplace to their advantage does nothing to dilute my point. If you don't believe that the granting of power and ceding the loss of personal freedom - even in miniscule amounts - is wrong - even dangerous - consider this. If you put a live frog in a pan of hot water, he will jump out. But, put him in water at ambient temperature then raise the temperature of that water high enough to cook him and he will die without jumping out. That, friends, is how government and laws operate: condition the governed then manipulate them, their liberties, and their property. Whether done by governments, individuals or by corporate entities, those behaviors are egregiously wrong and should - no must be resisted. That Gass participated in the cabal process bespeaks his (lack of) charaacter and brings ill repute on the product regardless of what salient features the product might have.

To put it simply (and somewhat alliteratively): The problem is the politics and the practice, not the product!

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#53

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Yucholian

>Even with car dealers, it's up to the dealer. If the dealer doesn't want to charge, it's their freedom.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#54

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Yucholian

>Even though I have expressed my unhappiness of their business practices, I LOVE TO HAVE THE SAW!!!. It's a great saw even without the brake.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#55

Re: not at all...

Bill Howatt

>It is silly trying to argue this a black and white issue because most of it is gray.

MS's big boost came because they were hooked up to IBM. Businesses had little incentive or trust to put PCs into their workplace (especially when everything was mainframe oriented) until IBM came out with the PC. If the well-trusted IBM people were behind the machine then it must not be too bad of an idea.

Naturally, the non-computer literate people struggled in varying degrees with DOS. The success of the IBM PC even with DOS actually became a problem for MS - anything they did could not abandon the installed business customer base. This actually was a boon for Apple who was able to introduce an totally new computer without paying the least bit of attention to installed base. BTW, the graphical/mouse interface is the product of Xerox's think-tank, not Apple or MS.

MS realized that graphical was the way to go in no small part to Apple's dominance of the graphics type market.

MS did not have the big share of the word-processing market, that belonged to WordPerfect but WP fumbled the ball by not getting a Windows version out fast enough. Being bought out by a network company, Novell didn't help and either did Corel for that matter. Lotus had the spreadsheet market tied up and dBase was the database product of choice for PCs. MS-Word with its integration to W95 and later made short work of WordPerfect and the bundling of Excel into Office finished Lotus. While WP and Lotus may have been good products I think it is unfair to say they were supplanted strictly on the basis of monopolistic business practices.

Having been involved in the PC/IT arena when there were various word-processing contenders, even DOS flavors, spreadsheet contenders and everybody had a favorite I don't get upset by there being a monopoly. Try supporting a couple of thousand people who are using different products and then want to exchange documents. Then add on a corporate need that documents be readable well into the future. The reality is that it cannot be efficiently done if at all.

Regardless of the ethics/good idea/bad idea, monopoly issues, I will say that if MS (or somebody else) didn't achieve the strong dominance of the PC industry that it has there would be far less PC usage by the general population than there is now.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#56

seat belts laws are ..

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>against the laws of Darwinism. they protect you. they can stop you from dying. everyone I know that is against seat blets all talk about some accident where the driver gets thrown clear of the car and lives because of it. if that is what people want to believe, let them. it's there right.

Cars should be made with seatbelt. they should not be a law to wear them. we keep letting dumb people live to long. by the rule of natural selection they should be going the way of the dodo bird.

sorry :) I just couldn't resist.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#57

Re: Your rights...

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>John,

You forget one thing, (assuming I have a business) My right to not have those safety products, does not proclude your right to quit the job if you feel your environment is unsafe. It also does not proclude my insurance company from charging the heck out of my if I decide not to have those safety products.

Mark

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#58

And this is the core of the dispute…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> ms's market dominance has nothing to do with a superior product and market demand.

It all depends on how you define market demand. In your next statement, the market demand is by the computer manufacturers (their choice). Superior inevitably falls by the wayside once the licensing deals are brokered.

> It is entirely due to packaging deals with computer manufacturers.

The packaging was a negotiated and agreed upon deal between the several parties. There was no government involvement. If SawStop had been successful in his negotiations with the manufacturers, we wouldn't be having this discussion. But because he didn't have the same success that BG did, he ran to the government for help. Any discussion of M$ as a comparison to SS fails on that singular point. Like it or not, M$ earned their exclusivity—SS tried to strong arm theirs.

And for those who keep who keep trying to make some sort of comparison between M$ and SawStop and who keep wondering why I am using M$ products, it's because it's virtually the only game in town. I choose to use an open architecture machine. That lets out Apple. I choose to select which M$ products to use (put up with). That pretty much means the OS (I haven't ruled out a Linux configuration at some point—another choice). I choose apps which aren't funneling $ into M$ coffers (and don't funnel bit and byte nasties back into my system by the truckload). There's not one element of government influence in any of those choices.

Rod

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#59

Re: seat belts laws are ..

Robert Hutchins

>Hi Joe!

There was a line in my post - which I took out after reflection - about the government protecting those who dwell in the shallow, stagnant end of the gene pool and what that presence does to the overall quality of the pool - but I took it out because I didn't want to give offense. (heh heh heh)

I think the government would much prefer to have only those who live and breed in the shallow, stagnant end of the pool. They are much more easily exploited.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#60

What About Industry Standards?

Robert Hutchins

>Mutually agreed standards by affected parties with compliance by vendors with vendors being shunned by IT selectors would have sorted out the marketplace without government intervention or favor to any vendor. Look at the W3C standards that have resulted in the Internet becoming what it has. Imagine having to support web sites that might be viewed by any number of proprietary browsers.

My career in IT started in 1964. RCA, GE, Sperry Rand and Univac all had mainframes that competed with IBM. IBM dominated the marketplace for several reasons. One was product and support - mainly support. Another was marketing strategies (and exploiting them after they had driven the competition out of the market). Another was risk-taking (they bet the company on System360 and damn near lost). And another was complying with standards for platform portability of application software that were generated by the military - primarily under the leadership of Capt. Grace M. Hopper.

My experience - in several different companies - was that finance departments lacked insight into the technologies (and were too lazy, in many cases, to learn about them) and fell back on the market reputation of the companies supplying products in making their decisions to fund technology expenditures. I saw far too many inferior AT&T desktop units bought on that basis. Microsoft struggled against that mentality until it realized that it was beating Apple because of it. Somehow the appeal of a guy who hoodwinked IBM on the DOS deal was greater than two young weird-looking guys who built their gadget in a garage. I think it was an example of coyotes recognizing their own breed, myself.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#61

Yes, John. I Have the Right

Robert Hutchins

>NOT to pay for another's stupidity. And I believe given a little time to research it, I think I can produce case law and precedence to cite in defense of that right.

You would have us believe in your argument - inherently - that it is OK for an entity (the government or some other) to require that the uneducated, foolish or ignorant use of an obviously dangerous object - a table saw - to require the consequence of injury to be paid for by us collectively. I don't believe that for many reasons. I do believe that I am ethically obligated by my own being to provide care for the 'challenged' but that doesn't stretch to providing a rubber room for all of them. There is the natural law of consequence on which Darwinian principles depend.

Is it right for public education to set the standard of competence at that of the lowest child? Does "No child left behind" mean that resources should be spent inordinately to assist the non-achievers at the expense of above average achievers? [These are rhetorical, philosophical questions not meant to broaden the discussion to education nor are they based on anything more than my observation that public education has declined in effectiveness - significantly - in my lifetime. They are questions worthy of discussion and intense debate, but not meant, by me, for this forum.]

We are likely to continue to disagree on these points. I doubt either of us is wholly 'right'.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#62

Even in disagreeing, I can respect your position..

John in New Mexico

>Because of this:

"I doubt either of us is wholly 'right'"

And philosophically, I do tend to agree with you. But though I've only lived half as long, I've found that dealing with practical realities is as important as philosophy.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#63

Quitting not always an option...

John in New Mexico

>The shops I worked for (late '90's) were pretty low wage, $7.50 to $10/hour. Many of the employees were not qualified to do much else, unless they wanted to work for even less. They often had children to support, all had to pay rent or the mortage. Most of the employees did not take vacations, as there was no paid vacation time and they could not afford to miss a week's pay. Sure, tell someone in that position to quit if they don't like it.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#64

Re: What About Industry Standards?

Bill Howatt

>I agree that W3C has made web-site creation a model of simplicity compared to what has gone on previously in the IT world even if it isn't perfect.

I really think it was IBM's service with mainframes and perhaps, offices' Selectric typewriters that got them in the door. Many if not most computing centers thought the PC was a toy fad and would be gone in a short-time. The opposite of course happened.

Unfortunately, the word-processing business didn't have standards and it was the golden era of development and for that reason I don't think they wanted standards since they tried to out-feature each other at a rapid rate. Today the de facto standard is MS-Office. If you can't communicate with it you don't have a place in the business.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#65

I master of the

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>obvious!! also a little pragmatic and sometimes cynical with a dry sense of humor aimed at making myself laugh.

I could rant for days as this world is Topsy turvy. common sense and personal responsibility are the thing becoming extinct.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#66

Re: Bruce's truck's braking OT

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>Or try steering on a slippery road with ABS engaged and then turn it off (if your vehicle allows that, which mine do) and try steering while braking again without ABS.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#67

So? What's the point?

Don Henthorn

>

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#68

Re: Your rights... My thoughts

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>John, while I am sure we would never find agreement on these issues - you have the right to your opinions. My feeling and answers to your questions are expressed below.

Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of employees who are injured due to lack of guards/safety features? Do you think those people who have been injured might prefer to have their digits back at the expense of your rights?

I have worked in factories before OSHA and did work with some dangerous equipment. However that was my choice. I could have left the job an found another. The issue in question was not requiring employers to use safer equipment - it was to "outlaw" existing standard saws and FORCE all producers of this equipment to install a braking mechanism. I really think you can't take all the risk out of life, next step would be to insist all chisels have dull edges and jointers have automatic feeds so no cutter could be exposed. If Osha had control of our personal cars we could not open the hood with the motor running to tune the engine. Should this be done to eliminate the chance of getting into the fan or belts?

Do your rights as an individual trump the rights of those who end up paying the medical expenses of the un-insured/under-insured? Even if you have adequate financial ablities to pay for your accident, do you think every one who uses a tablesaw is also able to pay for his/her "repairs"? Who pays if they can't?

I do think my "rights" allow me the freedom to take chances. I do not feel I am responsible for taking care of "everyone" nor do I want to dictate how they live their lives. I do have adequate insurance, but I pay dearly for it. My father passed on when I was 10 years old. We had little money but did not receive or want any assistance from the government. I worked and paid social security since I was 11 years old. I worked 2 and 3 jobs for many years to raise my family and so I could pay my way, again I have never received one cent in government aid of any kind - even when I was eligible for some with 6 children. I currently drive a van that is 18 years old and do all my own house maintenance so I can afford to pay my insurance. I do have a pretty decent nest egg in my retirement savings (I am now retired) but we scrimped to save that. I have little sympathy for those who drive new cars, work one job and complain they have no insurance.

Do you really think a bunch of cops were going to show up and confiscate your "illegal" tablesaw if Mr. Sawstop's efforts had born fruit? OSHA requires guards on table saws used in the workplace- none of the shops I've worked for had them, and the rule was never enforced, even after one shop had three accidents, two involving tablesaws.

No I did not feel this would affect me with my equipment, however if I decide to replace my saw, or my son buys one, it would have a huge impact on cost of the equipment - and possibly with replacement of saw blades, stop mechanism etc.

Did you personally file a complaint with OSHA? If not, why? If so what was their response. In most cases, including my last employer, they find is much cheaper for them to spend the money to avoid accidents than to pay the resulting claims, insurance, lawsuits and fines. The shops you worked for are probably closed now due to this.

For what its worth, I'm not trying to agrivate you, and I use an old unisaw with no guards that I'm not planning to replace. But like it or not, we do not define our own rights. Right or wrong this is the nature of our civilization.

If no one objects like I do, you are correct. If we do object and put out pocketbook and vote where they count - maybe we can "define our rights" or at least not lose all the rights our brave men have fought and died for.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#69

Different viewpoint

DB

>All of the government regulations for safer products are not to remove your freedoms but to force the manufacturers to provide you with the safest product possible. You still have the right to use the product in as a reckless manner as you wish. You can even remove the safety devices if you want.

If the manufacturers provided the safest products in the first place then there would not be any need for the CPSC. But the manufacturers fight against almost all safety devices saying that no one would buy the product because the cost would be too high. They said that with seatbelts, airbags, dual braking systems, blade stops on mowers, blade gaurds on table saws. I could go on but I do believe you get the point.

True there are a few companies that do want to provide safer products, Sawstop and Tucker motor cars come to mind but not much else.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#70

Re: Key word FORCE

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I don't know of any manufacturer who will not provide a product that people want when they can make a profit. IF the public wants seat belts, air bags etc., - and they can be provided for a price that they accept - manufactures will provide the product. Why not, it raises their profit margin and sets their product apart from those that don't provide what people want. I do not need - nor want the government telling me what is good for me. The only reason Indiana has laws requiring seat belt use is that the government was going to require the installation of air bags in all vehicles a few years ago unless a certain number of states passed a mandatory seat belt use law. The auto manufactures put pressure on states by implying they would not invest in businesses in those states without the mandatory seat belt law. Why should I be forced to use seat belts that protect no one but me??? The erosion of personal freedoms is insidious and people seem to think we need "government" to tell us what is best for us. I DO NOT either need or want this type of leadership / dictatorship.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#71

Re: Your rights... My thoughts

John in New Mexico

>" I have little sympathy for those who drive new cars, work one job and complain they have no insurance."

I'll agree with you on that one, but I don't know anyone like that. Everyone I know with no insurance drives crappy old beaters. Perhaps I'm not running in the sophisticated circles.

" Did you personally file a complaint with OSHA? If not, why? If so what was their response. In most cases, including my last employer, they find is much cheaper for them to spend the money to avoid accidents than to pay the resulting claims, insurance, lawsuits and fines. The shops you worked for are probably closed now due to this."

No, I did not file a complaint. Why is a tough one, but its mostly because the owner was and remains a friend more than just a former employer. We butted heads over many things when I worked for him, and if I still worked there I'd be telling him its cheaper to replace two saws than pay those high insurance premiums. I still don't think I'd turn him in. His shop remains in business incidentally, as does one of the other two. The one that closed I would speculate is due more to foolish business practices than high insurance costs, but that is just speculation.

" If no one objects like I do, you are correct. If we do object and put out pocketbook and vote where they count - maybe we can "define our rights" or at least not lose all the rights our brave men have fought and died for."

I will still maintain that our society grants you the individual rights you hold dear, and has the option of limiting them in the interests of the society as a whole. Whether they do so justly is a matter of case by case scrutiny, but the principle remains the same. Look at the places where civil society has broken down- people do not define their own rights there, as it is civil society that actually enforces those rights, whether the means be actual force, threat of imprisonment or fines, or just shame. I supose they could define them however they liked, but it would be pointless when some warlord's gang came along and killed them.

If it were any other way, what is to stop me from defining myself the right not to pay my taxes if I don't like what is done with the money? What is to stop me from exacting "revenge" on someone who steals from me? If I grant myself that right, does it extend to someone who runs a light and damages my car? Like it or not, we all play by our society's rules, and we don't always get to make them.

In some cases I certainly agree with you, that society has overstepped the mark. One example is GFCI outlets. Or fences around pools -grew up next to a lake- no one drowned there- we were all too afraid of what mom would say ;). The list goes on and on.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#72

One question

DB

>What safety device has the majority of manufacturers installed in there product without the intervention of the government?

I know of none. The auto companies did not even offer seatbelts until the government stepped in. Most manufacturers will say that it would raise the cost to much and no one will buy the product. When the government told the manufacturers to put the safety devices in people kept buying the product.