Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>Kevin - the main reason the manufacturers didn't jump in the bandwagon was $$. I'm not sure of the exact royalties that Gass wanted, but I believe they were in the 10% - 15% range (closer to 15%). That's 15% of the sale of every saw fitted with his device that goes back to him. Not 15% of the price of the component - 15% of the price that the manufacturers sell the saws to the retailers for.
Let's put this in perspective. First off, most people that sell patents accept a royalty that's in the low single digit percentage region (2%, 3% etc.). 15% is virtually unheard of. Secondly, as we know, the price of saws has been steadily declining over the years and quite simply, if the manufacturers have to give Gass 15%, there simply no money left in it for them. Your first reaction would be "put the price up", but that's not realistic. This market's been speaking with it's wallet (for majority sales, elite items are not included in this generalization) for long enough that the manufacturers can safely forecast that the trend is going to continue.
Now - had Gass been smarter and tried to sell license to his patent for a reasonable amount - I wonder what the table saw world would look like right now?
You said "If I had something that would benefit the safety of people and I was rejected by really selfish reasons (ie, that would cost too much), then I would take the route too of making it required."
Kevin - I'd be the one standing on the courtroom steps waiting for your arrival. You don't have the right to place your values on my lifestyle and Gass didn't have that right either. Luckily enough the public got wise to Gass before any harm was done and smacked him up-side the head.
I don't think SawStop is going to fail. In fact, I think they're going to succeed and I hope they do. Now that Gass has decided to fight fair, has recognized the error of his early ways and is indeed producing a better mousetrap, the remainder of the market is figuring out how to play catch-up. That Kevin - is free enterprise and that Kevin - is how it's supposed to work.
I'm looking forward to see which of the majors is the first to respond with comparable technology and to see how they do it. You can bet there's a lot going on in the engineering back rooms right now. They know a threat when they see one. This technology (Gass') has the potential to be distributed across band saws and jointers as well. We're a lucky group as we're living through what could be the first technical revolution to hit powered rotating woodworking tools in a very long time.
As for me - my 1955 Boice Crane cabinet saw is just going to have to do me for the foreseeable future. All this talk of saws and technology is completely hypothetical for me - I represent the average consumer and spending money on a SawStop is so far removed from reality that I'm not even considering placing it on the horizon.
Rob