Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Posts

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#26

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Sawdustdan

>Can't speak for Marc Adams motivation but

Well with all do respect I'd suggest you do check out the SS inards and manual.

Adjustability is better, trunion is more massive, dust collection is better. Lift and tilt are effortless better, electrical breaker etc...

As far as 'for the money' that is a relative subject that I'd never debate we are all from different perspectives on this.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#27

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Ted Wong

>I wouln't crawl inside any saw cabinet, too dusty. But I will look inside one from time to time to check things out and I'll have to say SS definitely has better innards than PM 66. Bigger trunions, smoother blade tilt, smoother blade raising, bigger arbor bearings and dust shroud around blade. Not to mention two access doors on each side of the saw. I will however give PM the thumbs up on a better finish on the table surface. PM's table is smaller than SS but it is definitely shinier.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#28

For all of you who are upset with Sawstop

wilbur

>For those of you who are opposed to the idea of the SawStop people using anticompetitive behavior to "force" their invention on the market:

If you are reading this on a computer running Windows, please go get a sledgehammer and pound your computer into bits no larger than 3 inches in diameter, immediately.

And for the record, two things need to be made clear in the recounting of events in this thread:

1. Stephen Gass, the inventor of the SawStop braking technology, approached every manufacturer with this device, and was turned down by every one of them. He spent four years (1999-2003) on this effort. This seems like a reasonable effort at promotion to me, not to mention the numerous non stop demonstrations at trade shows.

2. In 2003 Gass approached the Consumer Product Safety Commission. What was asked for was that all tablesaws have a detection system that would stop a saw blade and result in a cut to a user no deeper than 1/8th of an inch. This would not necessarily be the Sawstop device. If the major manufacturers wanted to develop their own, that would be acceptable as well.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#29

Bruce, your recounting of events is inaccurate

wilbur

>For the record, two things need to be made clear in the recounting of events in this thread:

1. Stephen Gass, the inventor of the SawStop braking technology, approached every manufacturer with this device, and was turned down by every one of them. He spent four years (1999-2003) on this effort. This seems like a reasonable effort at promotion to me, not to mention the numerous non stop demonstrations at trade shows.

2. In 2003 Gass approached the Consumer Product Safety Commission. What was asked for was that all tablesaws have a detection system that would stop a saw blade and result in a cut to a user no deeper than 1/8th of an inch. This would not necessarily be the Sawstop device. If the major manufacturers wanted to develop their own, that would be acceptable as well.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#30

Thank you...

John in New Mexico

>Nothing like injecting a little reality into these train wrecks.

Here I was trying to figure how to point out some of the evils of various industry lobbies, and totally overlooked the most obvious one!

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#31

I don't have the inside dope, however…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> 2. In 2003 Gass approached the Consumer Product Safety Commission. What was asked for was that all tablesaws have a detection system that would stop a saw blade and result in a cut to a user no deeper than 1/8th of an inch. This would not necessarily be the Sawstop device. If the major manufacturers wanted to develop their own, that would be acceptable as well.

It is my understanding from following these events from the beginning that the inventor is a patent attorney and that he has filed patents for just about every conceivable iteration of such a device, virtually assuring that, despite the rosy field of choice you paint, it would be extremely difficult (read costly) to implement a device meeting the specifications he sought (and wrote) without infringing on one or more of his patents. It fails the duck test.

That's like me having a patent on oxygen and telling you that you can breathe other stuff if you want—that's acceptable to me. That's no choice at all.

Rod

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#32

I responded to Point 2 above, here's my thought...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…on Point 1:

> 1. Stephen Gass, the inventor of the SawStop braking technology, approached every manufacturer with this device, and was turned down by every one of them. He spent four years (1999-2003) on this effort. This seems like a reasonable effort at promotion to me, not to mention the numerous non stop demonstrations at trade shows.

I don't know what that means. Are you suggesting that reasonable effort at promotion is all that's needed to succeed? Are you saying that numerous…demonstrations are a guarantee of success? I'm no MBA, but I don't think that's ever been assured in the entrepenurial equation. Sure, it's difficult to succeed without those factors, but I'm positive there's something called risk inherent in any venture such as his. With the exception of trying to get the government to force SawStop technology down our throats (there's no other way to describe it), he hasn't accomplished the one thing that allegedly assures large market share, and that's consumer acceptance. His mousetrap may be pretty good, but it should be settled in the marketplace, not by some government agency.

No, no one's guaranteed a thing when one takes soldering iron in hand.

Rod

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#33

Re: I don't have the inside dope, however�

wilbur

>Hi Rod,

There's no inside dope here. It's easy to see exactly what was patented. Go to the US Patent Office website (http://www.uspto.gov/patft/index.html) and do a search for Stephen Gass and SD3 (the corporation name under which the patents were filed). There are 19 patents awarded to Gass. If you look at the patents themselves, they pretty much describe the Sawstop mechanism and its components, its application to a number of different power tools, and nothing else.

You can't patent the idea of applying a brake to a spinning a sawblade and dropping it below table height in a few milliseconds. You can patent a device to do so. There is no way that the patents awarded to Gass are the only way of achieving this goal.

Furthermore, this isn't even the goal that was requested of the Consumer Product Safety Commission. The goal was to mandate any means that would stop a sawblade and limit a cut to the user to 1/8th of an inch or less. If Delta could invent a method of braking the blade fast enough to achieve this goal without dropping it below the table, this would also satisfy the request, and would clearly be a mechanism that was different and separate from the Sawstop patents. If Powermatic could invent a method of braking the blade that relied solely on electromagnets (and maybe leave the blade suitable for further use!), again this would also satisfy the request, and would clearly be a mechanism that was different and separate from the Sawstop patents.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#34

Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

Robert Hutchins

>Don Henthorn said it best. He's absolutely right. When we have to have a government to protect us from ourselves, who or what is going to protect us from our government?

RANT MODE ON:

As for Wilbur's point about the Gates Grab, so what? General Motors systematically bought up bus and trolley companies and shut them down - or reduced service to levels so far below acceptabilty that they became useless - in order to foster the growth of automobile sales. There are countless other examples, BUT THEIR EXISTENCE PROVES THE POINT THAT THE PRACTICE IS ABOMINABLE. Does it make the behavior 'right' or even acceptable? H&LL NO! The example does nothing to certify it as a correct practice. I'd like to see Gates skewered, too. Open source proves that he has done little to improve the offering to the public other than to establish dominance and thereby legitmize the purchase of his product in the minds of finance pukes who never produced a product in their lives. I remember all too well how much choice we had for telephones before that little cabal was busted up. If you're going to make an argument, at least make one that has merit.

The SS may well be a good product - maybe even a superior one - but DAMN the government that enriches the patent holder at the expense of my freedom of choice. Hitler had a good idea in the VW, too. I, for one, am damned glad he wasn't able to foist his ideas on us through government. The VW product's value created its market niche - at least until our government protected us from owning them any more!

RANT MODE OFF

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#35

Re: Bruce, your recounting of events is inaccurate

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Wilbur - Steve Gass has enough patents on this whole concept such that if any other manufacturer implements a solution that stops the blade via mechanical means when contact with skin is detected Steve Gass cries "PATENT INFRINGMENT" and starts the lawsuit ball rolling.

That's why no other manufacturer has come up with a better mousetrap. Steve Gass is to the table saw industry what Robertson was to the screw industry when he designed the square head screw. Fantastic idea - miles ahead of anything else, but he got greedy and place stupid pricing on the license of the patented technology. Robertson died penniless BTW and it was only after his design became free domain that it was jumped on by all.

Let's be perfectly clear - Mr. Gass' approach to the Consumer Product Safety Commission was made under the guise of "doing right" by the table saw user community but he knows full well that if any shred of change is effected that would place credence on his device and even hint of it being "mandated" into use on other manufacturers, he makes $$ off every single saw sold in the US from that instant onwards.

This is about Steve Gass (not that there's anything wrong with that) and if he wants to win the battle with a better saw - I have nothing but admiration for the man and without a doubt, it's the way to win the west. But when he plays underhanded games like trying to force the nation into a sole source through the swaying of the rulings of the Consumer Product Safety Commission, I have nothing but disdain for those tactics.

For now, I'm led to believe that he's shelved those tactics (according to SawStop when I last spoke to them). I'm not convinced he won't try again, but I'm glad to see his saws selling well - maybe he can win this battle for the right reasons and using the right methods.

Rob

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#36

Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Did somebody ever hold a patent on automotive lap belts? Or air bags? Aren't they both government mandated now? Is there a difference?

??

KC

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#37

Bruce's truck's braking OT

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>quoting Bruce

I know I can brake better than the ABS system on my truck. Can I do it better all the time? I don't know, but I have more experience than my truck...

Bruce, unless your truck has a broken ABS system or you're stopping on gravel, there is just no way that you can brake better than the truck's ABS system. Next time you're on a really quite paved road get the truck up to about 30 and stand on the brake � when the pedal fights back don't for an instant let up on the pressure, push even harder, try to drive the brake pedal through the fire wall.

post your observations here or in a new OT post

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#38

Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

wilbur

>Hi Rob,

Please note that I'm keeping my comments to the factual issues regarding the development of Sawstop. From some of the comments I have read regarding the Sawstop/Consumer Product Safety Commission issue, one would think that Gass invented this device, and then went straight to the feds to immediately mandate the Sawstop into all table saws. In fact, the original business model was to license the device to the current manufacturers, and by the chronology, Gass started doing this a year before he even applied for his first patent. So I doubt that the Consumer Product Safety Commission issue was part of his master plan from the beginning.

Having looked at the Sawstop patents, it seems to me that there is room for a different device to be invented that would limit table saw damage to skin to 1/8th of an inch. I really doubt that the Sawstop mechanism is the only way of making this happen. And in any case, the patents will become public domain in the 2020's. It's a good thing they weren't copyrighted.

My point about the Gates grab is simply that that there are many people that say that they won't buy a Sawstop because of the Consumer Product Safety Commission issue, but who also use Windows computers without complaint, even though Microsoft has been convicted of antitrust practices. It seems inconsistent to me to take the former position if one had no qualms about buying a Windows product.

It seems that you're an open source fan, which is great. This is really geeky, but I got my mug in PC World magazine several years ago in an article they did about user responses to the security mess that is Windows. I was the guy that figured out how to install Linux on my computer at work rather than deal with the virus issue. They probably picked my story because I'm not a computer/IT guy -- I'm a pediatrician.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#39

Re: Don, I agree with you 100%

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I would not buy a sawstop if it were the last saw made and sold for $.50. I have been using powered tools for over 50 years and still can count to 10 without taking my shoes off. I detest anyone who mandates "safety" to me. I deplore the tactics used by the sawstop makers and hope they fail miserably and all end up bankrupt.I value my freedom much more than my body parts or even my life. Had our forefathers valued "safety" as highly as some do today, the Native Americans would be the only ones in the land known as the US. I have no issue with those who feel a car is not safe without Anti lock brakes, air bags, seat belts, roll bars or whatever makes them feel good. JUST DON'T FORCE ME TO USE IT UNLESS IT DIRECTLY AFFECTS YOUR SAFETY. I will use my Unisaw till it quits - then rebuild it. When I was a young lad, my father said freedom is the right to swing your fists anywhere you want - except when you hit another person. This applies even if you want to hit a concrete wall or tree!

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#40

Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I posted earlier on this subject and have read all of the comments. I still think that the technology was developed out of a need for a safer saw, someone had the knowhow to do it, approached the manufacturers and they took the road that they did not need to offer this to the consumer. This was a big mistake. As far as the developers approaching the government, big deal. If I had something that would benefit the safety of people and I was rejected by really selfish reasons (ie, that would cost too much), then I would take the route too of making it required. Some think SawStop is going to fail. I don't think so. Given that the schools are converting tells me alot. Again, all of the saw manufacturers listened to their lawyers and accountants, and they blew it. I believe in the next 10 to 15 years, the saw manufacturers will adopt it or be pushed out of the saw business.

My hats off to the folks at SawStop.

Kevin

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#41

Some general questions, not specifically for Don

John in New Mexico

>So is the offensiveness limited to Mr. Sawstop's lobbying actions?

Is the government ramming blade guards down your throat?

Do you apply these standards of anti-lobbying to the manufacturers of all the products you consume?

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#42

Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>>My point about the Gates grab is simply that that there are many people that say that they won't buy a Sawstop because of the Consumer Product Safety Commission issue, but who also use Windows computers without complaint, even though Microsoft has been convicted of antitrust practices. It seems inconsistent to me to take the former position if one had no qualms about buying a Windows product.<

Not inconsistent at all. In the Sawstop case the manufacturer tried to force their product on the consumer by government regulations. In the Windows case you buy Windows machine because of the large amount of software available, entirely different situation IMHO.

As I have said before, it will be a cold day in Hell when I buy anything from Sawstop.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#43

Perfect example below...

John in New Mexico

>The thread about openoffice. No one got all bent about open-source vs. microsoft. No one started ranting about the evils of ms's business practices. Why do people apply one standard to one product, and a different one to another? Isn't this all just a wee bit irrational? Perhaps ms doesn't directly lobby our fine elected officials and appointed beaurocrats for their own corporate gain. Why don't people get this hot and bothered about how the big agri-businesses operate? Don't they attempt to influence regulation of their industry to reduce free market competition? The mind boggles.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#44

Re: Perfect example below...

Bill Howatt

>I too find it funny just how much ire the Sawstop issue raises - maybe because this is a WWing forum. It would be blindingly stupid to think that no large business has their team of lobbyists pushing their corporate agendas; it seems the only thing different about the Sawstop story is that a relatively little guy managed to an attempt to sway some regulator's opinion.

I also find it amazing that regardless of the evil's of government that anybody thinks GM (as an example of many others) will do what is best for the public regardless of profit margin. Fiery Pintos, GM pickup side gas tanks, Love canal quickly come to mind.

Having said all that, I don't think Sawstop type technology should be mandated and I do think it will ultimately come to the marketplace for both safety and financial/legal reasons. I also see people defeating it so they don't have the expense of replacing the cartridges in case they fire, accidently or otherwise. Of course, some of these people will have trouble activating it after an accident due to loss of digits since they probably don't use guards either but that is another issue.

Bill

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#45

Anderson Ranch has them

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>My wife was there last summer and one of the students, who was in a rush, didn't notice a small nail or staple that was in his board and when he ran it through the saw it triggered the safety. The student had to pay the new cartridge cost.

My wife liked the saws with her only complaint being that the print on the fence rail scale was wearing away making the numbers difficult to see.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#46

Re: Tried Hard, but Just Can't Hold Back

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Kevin - the main reason the manufacturers didn't jump in the bandwagon was $$. I'm not sure of the exact royalties that Gass wanted, but I believe they were in the 10% - 15% range (closer to 15%). That's 15% of the sale of every saw fitted with his device that goes back to him. Not 15% of the price of the component - 15% of the price that the manufacturers sell the saws to the retailers for.

Let's put this in perspective. First off, most people that sell patents accept a royalty that's in the low single digit percentage region (2%, 3% etc.). 15% is virtually unheard of. Secondly, as we know, the price of saws has been steadily declining over the years and quite simply, if the manufacturers have to give Gass 15%, there simply no money left in it for them. Your first reaction would be "put the price up", but that's not realistic. This market's been speaking with it's wallet (for majority sales, elite items are not included in this generalization) for long enough that the manufacturers can safely forecast that the trend is going to continue.

Now - had Gass been smarter and tried to sell license to his patent for a reasonable amount - I wonder what the table saw world would look like right now?

You said "If I had something that would benefit the safety of people and I was rejected by really selfish reasons (ie, that would cost too much), then I would take the route too of making it required."

Kevin - I'd be the one standing on the courtroom steps waiting for your arrival. You don't have the right to place your values on my lifestyle and Gass didn't have that right either. Luckily enough the public got wise to Gass before any harm was done and smacked him up-side the head.

I don't think SawStop is going to fail. In fact, I think they're going to succeed and I hope they do. Now that Gass has decided to fight fair, has recognized the error of his early ways and is indeed producing a better mousetrap, the remainder of the market is figuring out how to play catch-up. That Kevin - is free enterprise and that Kevin - is how it's supposed to work.

I'm looking forward to see which of the majors is the first to respond with comparable technology and to see how they do it. You can bet there's a lot going on in the engineering back rooms right now. They know a threat when they see one. This technology (Gass') has the potential to be distributed across band saws and jointers as well. We're a lucky group as we're living through what could be the first technical revolution to hit powered rotating woodworking tools in a very long time.

As for me - my 1955 Boice Crane cabinet saw is just going to have to do me for the foreseeable future. All this talk of saws and technology is completely hypothetical for me - I represent the average consumer and spending money on a SawStop is so far removed from reality that I'm not even considering placing it on the horizon.

Rob

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#47

Re: Perfect example below...

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>John - it's apples and oranges.

MS got to where they are by developing and marketing a technology that not only worked, it was what the public wanted and was so far ahead of what anyone else had at the time that the buying public jumped on the bandwagon. As such other company's struggled and failed leaving MS to stand at the top. They're a monopoly, but they earned that position.

I could be wrong, but I don;t believe that anyone from MS ever stood in front of the product safety commission and requested that their product be mandated into all computers.

Now- if you want a parallel, let SawStop market their technology through standard consumer means. Let them buy out their competition, let him enable other companies to exist through producing value-add add-ons and supporting technology to theirs. Let them continue to produce technology that revolutionizes the woodworking market and after SawStop owns (and kills) Delta, Jet, Grizzly, General, Rigid and after ALL those brand names have dissapeared - THEN you'll have a parallel.

Rob

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#48

not at all...

John in New Mexico

>ms's market dominance has nothing to do with a superior product and market demand. It is entirely due to packaging deals with computer manufacturers. Granted they have not lobbied whichever government safety body sawstop did, but you can be sure that they try to influence regulation that is relevant to their industry. Any business subject to regulation that has the ability to attempt to sway the regulating body for their own gain would be foolishly naive not to attempt it.

John

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#49

Thanks

Neal in San Jose

>I'm sure I would have had the same problem the first time I use my dado blade. You probably just saved me a bunch of aggravation while I tried to figure out what I was doing wrong!

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#50

Re: Don, I agree with you 100%

Don in Central Illinois

>My mom used to tell me, my rights ends at the beginning of the other persons rights.