Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Posts

Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#1

Saw Stops at Marc Adams

David W

>Marc is replacing all of his table saws with SawStops this year. It makes real sense to me, given the instuctional setting where there is a wide range of woodworking experience among users. It will be interesting to see if this is the start of a trend.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#2

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Neal in San Jose

>Yep, a local school/time rental shop (Sawdust in Satnta Clara) has already made the change. They like the saws so much they became a distributor.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#3

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If Saw Stop becomes the de facto standard via market based buying decisions, forcing competitors to adopt the technology to stay in the business, that's OK. If competitors have to adopt the technology because of government mandate, that's not OK.

Clint

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#4

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If Saw Stop becomes the de facto standard via market based buying decisions, forcing competitors to adopt the technology to stay in the business, that's OK. If competitors have to adopt the technology because of government mandate, that's not OK.

So if I understand you well, if Saw Stop helps save lives and reduce injuries via market based approach, then that's fine, but if the government mandates the use of Saw Stop to help save lives and reduce injuries, then that's wrong?

Why stop there? Let's get rid of all mandated and expensive safety features in vehicles, no more seat belts, collapsible steering columns (my mother nearly got decapitated by the non collapsible type BTW), safety glass, etc.

Building codes, who needs them? Food safety? Come on, we can trust food companies to take our best interest... And so on...

I better stop there...

DC

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#5

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Bill Howatt

>As much as I hate the gov't finger in the works and telling us what to do, I certainly can't argue with your examples. Unfortunately, the safety record features when left to the people whose main motivation is to make the most bucks, is poor. The other unfortunate thing is the purchasing public generally ranks safety features low on the list of priorities until something goes wrong.

Bill

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#6

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Yucholian

>What he is saying is that Sawstop has not conducted their business as cleanly as a lot of us would like to see. I tend to agree with him. Also, they are FORCING all dealers to charge customers shipping cost of the saw even if it's in stock and you're picking it up in person. They are dictating how the industry should behave and it's not sitting well with some of us.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#7

Well said Bill

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#8

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Robert Henderson

>Absolutely! None of those things are a legitimate job of a government of a free society.

Just because something is a good idea doesn't justify forcing people to do it at gun point (naked force or the threat of force is the only thing Governments have to make people do anything).

The ready acceptance of what are basically fascist political ideals just because it "will save lives" is garbage and is destroying this country.

I'll trust my own judgement over the government's any day.

What about the mandates of Barbara "Baby Killer" Dole? they had to do a quick rethink of that idea "to protect the children"

By the way, the car industry was developing both air bags and air belts. Air belts was the better technology and had more potential to protect the person using the equipment. Before the "market" could sort out which people would be willing to pay for, the industry got the word that Big Brother was going to mandate air bags so they dropped all research into air belts. "We're from the government. We're here to help you". Humbug!

Rant ends here.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#9

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I'll take your word on Saw Stop's antics, I knew of a few but not all of them. It's too bad that the company's attitude triggers emotions with people (they asked for it, I guess) and cloud the perception of the product itself.

DC

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#10

I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lot.

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#11

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Denis,

Once again we butt heads on the issues of freedom, but we can, in a friendly manner, agree to disagree.

If you want real completed saftey we can lock you in a room, and only feed you the safe food that government has approved, but it is not much of a life.

By the way, Anderson Arts Ranch has Saw Stop saws, and if I could afford one, I would have one. They are superbly built. If I had a business where others used the tools I provided, I would have one, the added cost would be justified the in liability costs, the first accident it avoided.

Like others have said, it has been Saw Stops antics that have soured people on them.

Mark

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#12

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Ted Wong

>Isn't that the same tactic that auto companies use? Despite picking up a car at the dealership I still have to pay destination (shipping) fees. I think Sawstop hasn't included shipping in their price because of the various charges to different parts of the country and a flat rate shipping charge wouldn't be the most equitable for someone living next to the Sawstop warehouse.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#13

Re: I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lo

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I have followed SawStop since I heard about their technology. They tried to get the manufacturers to use their technology and they ALL passed on it. If the market forces them to use it (and I hope the SawStop people charge an ungodly amount for it) by demand, so what.

Instead of letting the big boys thumbing their noses, they manufactured their own saw. Now, if they build a better product and the masses want it, I personally would not feel sorry for the other manufacturers for the loss of customers. One day, someone is going to sue a manufacturer for not using the technology and developing a retrofit or as an option for a new saw. The the way I see it, the manufacturers do not think anything would come of it, and I guess they made a big mistake.

When I replace my old saw someday, I hope to have the funds to purchase a SawStop.

Kevin

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#14

Re: I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lo

Ray Newman

>From what I read & have been told by others who have seen the �innards� of the SawStop TS, the technology/design can not be retrofitted to existing saws. You either keep your old saw or buy a new a SawStop.

Myself, while I�m intrigued by the technology, I would not by such a saw. It is way too high for me to use & from what a Woodcraft salesman told me, the cabinet is one-piece, so the saw can�t be lowered.

In an industrial/school setting the value of the SawStop is indeed significant, if only for the savings on insurance & workers comp.

But I have a feeling that after the average woodworker trips the saw once (maybe twice) & replaces the blade & brake cartridge, my hunch is that a more than a few will leave the system �turned off�.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#15

Re: I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lo

sawdustdan

>You can't really turn it off. It has a bypass proceedure when you start the saw. But when it is turned off it goes back to normal mode so it requires doing the bypass proceedure everytime the saw is turned on/off .... real pain to do everytime.

Didn't quite understand the thing about the lowering and the cabinet being 1 piece that aspect is not really much different than my previous PM saw

Dan

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#16

Re: I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lo

Ray Newman

>SawDustDan: RE the "bypass", I have been lead to believe that it was/is relatively easy to disconnect/override/shut it off.

When I purchased my Unisaw, I removed the lower part of the cabinet assembly, which bolted onto the main part of the cabinet. By removing it, I lowered the saw height from 34 � - 35� to 30.�

If you look @ a picture of a Unisaw, the part that I am referring to looks like a black band around the bottom part of the cabinet.

From what I was told & observed of the SawStop, the cabinet assembly is one piece. A 34� + high saw is too high for me to use.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#17

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>While I'm philosophically inclined to agree with most of what you say, Robert, please remember that the Sawstop inventors wanted to get the government to change the rules so that we would have no choice but to adopt their product. The primary Sawstop designer is a lawyer, with direct ties to the patent process. That's dang near self-explanatory. If he were truly interested in market forces, he would have introduced the product and let the market decide. But that's not the process it took.

Bruce, a left-over 60's libertarian at heart.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#18

Re: I suppose someone had to start it, thanks a lo

Sawdustdan

>Ray

OK gotch ya on the cabinet

To bypass I'd have to turn a monentary key switch for a second or 2 then while still engaging the switch turn the paddle switch on then after another couple seconds it goes into bypass mode (brake disabled) and the motor starts, after the saw is turned off it goes back to normal mode.

So you gotta repeat that proceedure each time the saw is turned on/off don't thnk I'd have the patience to do that every time unless cutting wet wood.

Havent seen anyother method in my owners manual

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#19

Another intersting thing I learned

Sawdustdan

>Is to go to bypass the brake has to be installed and properly set.

The other day I installed my Frued box joint blades(8" blades) and didn't want to install the dado brake.

Well I couldn't start the saw and when I read the manual a little closer it explicitly states the proper brake must be installed and setup or the bypass mode can't be used.

It senses if the brake is set within the proper distance from the blade.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#20

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Sawdustdan

>True .. and he is also a PHD in physics and an avid woodworker

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#21

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Sawdustdan

>I believe Lee Valley is replacing all their saw with SS.

I also didn't really care for some aspects of what they initially tried to do regarding regulation. But after I 'crawled' around inside one of these saws then purchasing one,replacing a 3yr old PM66 it becomes apparent they have designed a really IMHO superior saw in additin to the braking system

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#22

No objections to the saw or to others using it

Don Henthorn

>But I strongly object to the government telling me I have to have one. I just couldn't afford it and thus I would have to quit using a table saw just because some do-gooders want to make me safe. I have been using table saws for seventy years and have never had a serious accident . I have respect for but no fear of a table saw. It is a tool. You are supposed to learn how to use a tool before you do work with it. If I have an accident I will take care of the expense my self without the public paying my way. I am poor but I pay my way. Every time the government takes on the responsibility to protect people from themselves it takes away a little more of their freedom and destroys the necessity of them thinking about protecting themselves. I Love freedom and would much rather loose a couple of fingers than one iota of my freedom. The fact that there are so many people who don't understand this is testimony as to why every great civilization in the past has gone down.

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#23

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I've "crawled around" the innards of a PM66, but not a Saw Stop. I'll stipulate their braking system is better, but no one makes better innards than the PM for the money.

Marc Adams, Anderson Ranch, high school wood shops and industrial shops, et al, don't replace their PM66's because the innards are better. They replace them because the liability insurance payments are cheaper. That's a pretty good reason. That doesn't make the saw better. It makes it cheaper to live with in the long run.

I know I can brake better than the ABS system on my truck. Can I do it better all the time? I don't know, but I have more experience than my truck...

Bruce

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#24

Re: No objections to the saw or to others using it

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have the same objections to the gov't telling me to do stuff, too, Don. But in this case, it was a matter of the SawStop guy using the gov't to make me use his thingie. I like that even less. I want the choice. My next choice isn't going to be a SawStop, even though I've been using the saw for 20 years less than you...

Bruce

Re: Saw Stops at Marc Adams

#25

Well said Don

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I agree with everything you said Don. Fortunately this time the Feds didn't bite on this proposal to make the technology mandatory. I am. like you, retired with limited resources and could not afford to buy an expensive saw like that.

Howard