Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

wood ID

Posts

wood ID

#1

wood ID

john lucas

I picked up some wood today and don't know what it is. There weren't any leaves handy to help. The center looks like Walnut with mostly sap wood however this was a huge tree, about 30" and only the very center of even the big section had this dark area. I've never seen old walnut trees with this small of a heart wood. Anybody have any ideas.

Re: wood ID

#2

Could be Butternut, often called.......

JamieDonaldson

....White Walnut in areas of the country.

Re: wood ID

#3

Re: wood ID

Bill Howatt

The butternut dark wood around here (Ontario) often has very small worm holes in it and if turned green, has a tendency to be a bit fuzzy unless the tools are razor sharp.

Sometimes referred to as poor man's walnut.

Bill

Re: wood ID

#4

Re: wood ID

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

John, the butternut that I have has a very distinct light tan color, and distinct mild smell. Much lighter and softer than walnut. And as Bill said sometimes tends to fuzz when turned. I sawed the logs that mine came from about 10 years ago. I don't remember the heart being dark or bad in that particular log.

I have seen some elm that would meet the description you gave. Also, some sweet gum. In days past when very large sweet gum was harvested the heart wood was sold as red gum and would almost pass for black walnut. Used for furniture during WW II, or so I've read.

Re: wood ID

#5

Re: I have an idea

Sergio

What about a picture or two?

Re: wood ID

#6

Re: wood ID

Craig Daymon

A bit more info would be a big help. How hard is it? If it is VERY hard, could it be, Persimmon? (If so, you are very lucky.) Any chance it is an exotic? Was it a yard tree/plant? Did you find it or acquire it? In other words, was it in the wild or from a supplier of some kind? (Lumber yard, firewood, shipping crate?)

Re: wood ID

#7

Re: wood ID

robo hippy

The walnut smell is pretty distinct. Butternut tends to smell more like vinegar, or at least the one tree I got smelled that way. The black walnut here when under 20 inches or so tends to have small heart wood, and lots of sap wood. Once they get over that size, then there tends to be more heart wood. Because of our wet climate and mild temperatures, they can get over 4 foot diameter on the stump. If it turns your fingers black, then probably walnut. I haven't seen any persimmon that size, but it could happen. It has a bitter scent to it.

robo hippy

Re: wood ID

#8

DUH

john lucas


Re: wood ID

#9

Ash


Re: wood ID

#10

Roger in MO

Re: Ash

Roger in MO

My guess is also ash.

Re: wood ID

#11

Could be a lot of things, but...

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

my first guess is elm

second guess ash

Re: wood ID

#12

Re: Could be a lot of things, but...

john lucas

Don't believe it's elm. Elm has a much more reddish center than this. I really don't think it's ash. The heart wood looks exactly like walnut but I sure haven't seen any walnut trees this age with that little heart wood which is why I am asking.

Re: wood ID

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: DUH

Brad Vietje

Bark doesn't look quite right for Black Walnut. Usually thicker, ridges more pointed, and a coarse/dense fibrous layer up against the cambium.... Landscaping tree? Maybe a non-native variety of Walnut? How's it smell?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: wood ID

#14

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Could be a lot of things, but...

Leo Van Der Loo

What you have there is Black Ash John

Re: wood ID

#15

It is definitely Ash.

john lucas

As soon as I started turning it the grain was quite apparent. The students didn't have any trouble with it and all went home with bowls tonight. Tomorrow they will be turning dry wood so it should be an eye opener although it's maple which of course turns great with sharp tools.

Re: wood ID

#16

Re: It is definitely Ash.

clay foster

They are going to be whining to get that green wood back.