Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Posts

Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#1

Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

david

I find that I am using my vacuum chucking system less and less. Major problem I have is am able to pull a strong enough vacuum on soft woods like Norfolk and Cook pine, which I turn a lot. Most of these are turned end grain also. On other woods I should be drawing a higher vacuum but I feel the seating of the wood on the vacuum gasket is not good enough. I have two of the smaller Oneway vacuum chucks, outfitted with an after market pink molded plastic "gasket" that I feel is too firm and not moldable/conforming to reversed bowl shapes. Have used the Oneway foam rubber "doughnut discs" that Oneway sells. Does anyone make/sell a soft gasket out of silicone? I don't know what the Shore hardness would be, but cured silicone still has softness to it. I once saw an article in the AAW magazine where someone had details on what he made from silicone, but it seemed to complicated to attempt. I like the idea of using PVC pipe to make various sized vacuum chucks but the gasket to reversed piece (wood) seal is what I think is lacking.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#2

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Chuck Engstrom

Hi David -- The silicone article is from AAW April 2013 and I have a PDF of it which I am sending along to you by email. I've had fairly good success using stick-on foam sheets from Michaels, A C Moore type stores, sometimes using several layers to get a "gasket" thick enough for imperfect shapes to sink into enough for a good seal.

Best of luck with it -- they're great when they work, just used mine a short while ago.

Best -- Chuck

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#3

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Doc Green

My suggestion would be to place a "gasket" cut from a sheet of closed-cell foam between your vacuum chuck and the workpiece. The gasket can be a disk as long as you cut at least a small hole at the center. Make the diameter of the foam disk considerably larger than the diameter of your chuck so that alignment is not a problem.

To use the disk, just sandwich it between the workpiece and the chuck. No adhesive is required. However, if you want a (semi) permanent installation, apply a few short pieces of double-sticky tape between the chuck and the foam.

Almost any foam will work as long as it has a slick finish and you can not blow air through it. It can be as thin as 1/16". I've used pieces of foam salvaged from packing material. If you wish to purchase the foam, a craft foam called "Foamies" from a hobby shop will do nicely. I prefer the thin version.

A piece of foam used in this manner can be used repeatedly, but after a while it will begin to be rather beat up. At that point, replace it with a new piece, and you will be good to go again.

All my vacuum chucks are shop made, and I use the foam gaskets for all of them. A vacuum chuck I use a lot is simply a flat plate (like a big air-tight faceplate) made of plywood or MDF. I just stick a piece of foam between the rim of the bowl and the flat plate.

Good luck. ~Doc

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Dennis in Southern Oregon

A futher useful measure for porous wood is to apply plastic kitchen wrap to the portions of the outside of the piece that are not going to be turned and tape it in place if necessary.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#5

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Michael Gibson

Have you checked out Rubby Chucky, when l use a vacuum system they always work well.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#6

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Barry Irby

I made several chucks. Went to a commercial gasket shop and bought some Neoprene in sheets. Armorflex is a brand name I think. Got some that is 1/8" and some much thicker, maybe 3/8". The 1/8" stuff works great. I thought the thicker stuff wuld be good for irregular or distorted shapes and it works for that, but is too thick and soft and it deforms, making it difficult to mount the pieces accurately and to keep them in exactly the same position. The advantage to buying it this way is they had rolls three feet wide and as long as you wanted.

I mounted it with spray contact adhesive.

I have use packing tape and sanding sealer to seal porous wood enough to get a good vacuum. Be careful spraying the sanding sealer on. I did it with the vacuum running and it slurped it through and created a very fuzzy hairy looking "finish".

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#7

Might help if we know what diameter you turn

Dick Coers

You may not be using enough vacuum area for the diameter wood you are turning. What diameter wood versus diameter of chuck?

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Dick Hines

If you are not getting good vacuum on your pieces you can bring up the tail stock to make sure the piece is running true. Then turn your pump on and run your hand over the piece. When you find "sticky feeling" places that is where the vacuum is drawing air through the piece. Just put masking tape over the "sticky" places and your vacuum will rise.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#9

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Mike Brazeau

I do this with my 8" Oneway vacuum chuck on which the original gasket is worn. Works so well, I never get around to looking for a replacement gasket.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#10

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

john lucas

I haven't read all the other messages yet but one problem I have with gaskets that are too stiff is the bowl warps very slightly and may not make a good seal. I bought a piece of closed cell foam from Walmart called Silly Foam. I cut a square out of it larger than my chuck. Cut a hole in the middle of it. Place it over the chuck and then put the bowl on top. The square corners make it easy to pull it into place. This is just soft enough to take up any warp in the bowls and make a good seal.

I have used the same stuff for my gaskets but it is a little bit thin. You can place a piece over the wood and use clear silicone caulk to hold it in place. When dry you can either just punch a hole in the middle or you can use the toe of your skew to cut away both sides to make a more round gasket.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#11

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

david

Thanks, Michael. I do have Rubber Chucky vacuum seal on two of my smaller Oneway vacuum chucks. I am not happy with the seals I can get with the woods that I use.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#12

Re: Might help if we know what diameter you turn

david

I turn boxes that are about 3" x 3" to large calabashes and platters. Typical calabash is in the 13"-15" dia. range. I have home made PVC vacuum chucks of various sizes for deeper bowls and all but the large Oneway vacuum chuck which I refuse to shell out the big bucks for.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#13

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

david

I am not saying that Rubber Chucky vacuum seals are a defective product. I wish the pvc(?) material were softer and more able to conform to my pieces to make a better seal. At least the closed cell foam gaskets conformed to the pieces. The foam gaskets that Oneway sells for their chucks work reasonably well, but I wish I could draw a better vacuum on the pieces I turn.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#14

Thanks for comments and suggestions!


Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#15

Latex hose

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

Lot's of good advice in above replies. But since no one mentioned this solution so I'll throw it in.

I bought some latex (I think it's latex) surgical hose at Lowes, slit it, placed it over the edge of my larger pvc chucks, cut the ends to fit exactly, used a little silicone to seal the joint---has worked great for 3-4 years. I'm calling it surgical hose because the only other place I recall seeing it used was for drainage hose sticking out the side of my chest. It is extremely soft and pliable.

There is just enough inward pressure on the slit edges to hold it without any adhesive. But I did add just a bit of silicone.

I tried to buy some more of the hose at Lowes recently, but no one at the local Lowes would admit they knew what I was talking about. There are probably other sources.

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#16

Re: Might help if we know what diameter you turn

Bill Howatt

The key parameter is the area under vacuum. Going from a 4" dia chuck to a 6" dia chuck increases the holding force by 9/4=2.25 times. This can be a lot more effective than trying to increase the vacuum.

If you have small objects then the usefulness of vacuum chucking diminishes considerably.

Bill

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#17

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Jorge

David,

My bowls get a walnut oil finish if they hold vacuum, if not they get sanding sealer and then lacquer.

The gasket I use is a packing foam glued to the chuck with rubber cement when it starts getting "tired" but otherwise still in good shape I glue a second layer right on top of the first one, it works great.

Vacuum works best for bigger pieces, my vacuum chuck most used is the 8" oneway.

Vacuum holding small pieces is not nearly as good...

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

#18

Re: Wish List for Vacuum Chucking

Jorge

David here is the foam about 1/8"thick:


It is white not grey like the picture. David Lancaster and the Maine Woodturners, turn me on to using this.