Just got an email on Peachtree sale on modular handle with 3 bushings. On sale for 1/2 off with turn25 code, $50 and for me $8.99 shipping. I ordered one, but have no idea of quality or feel. Looks like a good design and a nice system to align and screw through the bushings. Remember, this is no recommendation, just sharing the sale info.
I didn't realize that anyone was selling this handle in the U.S. A friend of mine picked up a few of these and gave me a couple.
They work very well and are very heavy and cold. The diamond knurling near the collet is somewhat unpleasant to handle for a long period of time. I use the ones I have for my larger roughing gouges and handheld hollowing tools. Definitely overkill for the smaller tools that would require the 1/4" and 3/8" collets. Might be okay for a 3/8" bowl gouge but too heavy for a 3/8" spindle or detail gouge.
The best handle I have ever used is the Serious Toolworks Cam-lock handle which is made from stainless steel, and won't rust. The collets are precision milled, and their own tools and Thompson lathe tools fit nicely in them. It has a neoprene cover for the cold and absorbs some of the vibration and such to ease the process for those who may have issues with arthritis or tendonitis.
I purchased one, along with their Ultimate Gouge.......[SWEEEET!!!] Liked it so much, that I ordered a second one! Tools change lickity-split quick, and they are comfortable to use all day long! I also have Thompson handles which I like, but the Serious cam-lock handle is the best I have ever used! No set screws, just a quick 1/4 turn of the collar and it locks in place rock solid, then reverse when you want to change gouges.........it also makes sharpening easier when you take the gouge out and to the grinder wheel! Here is a link:
I found the Serious handle to be middling at best. Tool changes are slow unless you have separate sleeves on all the tools you are going to use on it (having to reverse the sleeve to use the Serious double ended tool is a pain and somewhat dangerous). The soft foam on the handle is just too soft for feedback from cutting and I'm sure with enough use sweat and dust are going to affect it. Better choices for collet handles are those from Kelton, Woodcut and Johannes Michelsen's. I have all handles mentioned here and I use three of them a lot. The Serious handle has the Mysterious Serious 5/8 tool in it which is fluted the entire length of the tool (double ended). This fluting and the soft cover are the reason this combo is used very little (I like a tool that has a solid tang) This secret steel (my guess M4) with that flute just does not cut like my favorite steel.
Bill, you are certainly a respected turner and I respect your opinion here. I have not used Kelton's handle nor woodcut, but have examined Johannes's handles up close and personal at symposiums.
I have no problem getting feedback from the cut and I have used one for two years, plus I still use my Thompson handles with my name on them, and wooden handled tools that I originally bought before I started using Doug's tools and the Serious gouges and scrapers.
We had a rep from Serious Toolworks at our club in February, and we asked him in prep for the demo to talk about metals in tools......the powder metals, kryogenic treatments, tempering and the processes that go into not only his tools but what is true for all brands. As I am sure you are aware, working as closely with Doug as you do, that Serious holds their steel and treatment process proprietary and will not reveal it.
I can say, that I have both the Thompson Gouges, and Serious gouges and use a CBN wheel [180 grit] to sharpen. I find both to be excellent tools and hold an edge as well as one another, and better than most.
The Serious Ultimate gouge really takes a fine, almost polished edge off the CBN wheel, and really cuts. Their regular M2 steel gouge does a fine job as well as Sorby or others I have used. One thing about the flute being the entire length of the tool is that you can put a different grind on each end or the same grind and just flip it when needed. I have never found changing tools in the handle to be tedious at all.........and the great thing for me and one of the main things that made me decide on the cam-lock from Serious is that Doug's tools fit nicely in them as well.
My shop is underheated, and cold hands just do me in, so the cam-lock handle being covered with the neoprene works so well for me, especially in cold weather, and the one I have had for two years still looks like new. It will collect dust on it, but a quick pass with the air hose takes care of that.
Of all the handles that I have, the cam-lock excels for the reasons mentioned above, and I do like my Thompson handles as well, but in cold weather I cannot use them for long periods, so have most of the time when it is cold, I put the Thompson gouge in the cam-lock handle. I do keep a collet on my Thompson gouge and one on my Serious gouge....and have a couple extras.......this system works great for me.
Dick: Thanks for the info. There are many types of handles available. I have two from Doug Thompson and a Oneway two-ended model. The pricing is very attractive and I just ordered one. I am not that particular about the modular handles I use but I find it mildly irritating that the set screws on all seem to get loose very often.
All of the handles mentioned have either a type of foam or in the case of Hannes' handle a type of rubber. All work well in the cold. The difference in the foam compared to the Serious is that it is more compact or denser which gives me feedback much like a wooden handle. Doug Thompson has made handles with foam which I have many of including double ended ones that have two different sized ends. His foam is very much like the Kelton and Woodcut. When you are buying a handle from Doug and you see that you can get your name lasered on it for free you are not thinking foam. But his foam handles are also some of my favorites. Do I need foam - no, my shop is well heated I just prefer it.
Rick: I did the same thing Bill Blasic did--found a way to have the set screws tighten down on something. Bill used a dowel, and I turned a rounded end with a step-down dowel for putting it on either end. Stole the idea from Andy Cole---he turns a rounded end for all his tool handles that do not have one.