Re: Carbide Tipped Tools
Geoff Whaling
Tom,
It doesn't matter if the tool cutting material is carbide, carbon steel, HSS, V10, V15 etc each have their merits in particular applications. My views on this subject are,
1. Tool design & how to present the cutting edge is more important. Material properties, edge holding, wear rates, brittleness etc are considered in tool design & tool applications. Carbide is simply another material available to us.
2. Learn how to use the tools to maximum benefit - and how to sharpen / maintain them to get maximum efficiency. Keen edges are generally more efficient cutting edges in hand woodturning.
3. All tools have pros & cons. Some may be "better", "safer", efficient and more effective in very particular applications or may be very good general use tools. Some tool designs are simply incapable of producing fine detail on a finial or spindle but are exceptional in other recommended applications.
4. Learn to reduce physical stresses on your body while turning, don’t fight the tool or the wood - if carbide roughing out tools permit that then use them (i.e. arm brace systems vs captured boring bars etc). Same goes for mental stress & anguish - if a skew or a bowl gouge doesn't do it for you then learn to use another tool & method so that you can enjoy turning and not fear certain tasks.
5. Some developments & inventions vastly improved safety & efficiency in woodturning (4 jaw chucks, EVS lathes etc). Many new tools & processes met strong initial resistance & turners using them faced ridiculous statements like "you're not a real turner if you use....." How many tools have we got that promised us the world when we purchased them & now we never use them? Some are / were just fads or marketing campaigns to get us to spend money.
6. Learn to minimize risk & how to work safely. Tool design, application and even the materials used in some tools are all factors to be considered. If using scraping tools vs cutting tools “makes you feel safe” then use them. When you gain confidence expand your skill sets.
7. "Pro et contra" - use the tool, tool material, and technique that offers the most benefits and fewest disadvantages for the task at hand.
7. Economics doesn't factor into woodturning - if it did 95% of us would not turn. Spending on wood turning is purely discretionary luxury spending. Enjoy both the tool purchasing & the wood turning.