Re: I'm rethinking my approach to Carbide tools
Phillip Medghalchi
John, if you go back and watch the commercial or advertising for easy wood tools VS traditional bowl gouges and scrapers; or any other carbide cutter turning tools; you'll notice that the pitch is about how easy it is to use that tool and maneuver around to shape objects. When a beginner sees those ads and the itch of making a bowl or any objects in their ability is overwhelming they would tend to go to what ever is easier for them to make something and join the rest of the group ( as acceptance).
There is a myth about carbide inserts not being able to be resharpened and Cap. Eddie and some other turners show you how to do it by taking it flat and sharpen them on a diamond honing tool.
You mentioned that you use Hunter tools too. So, we can't come back and say yo are any lesser turner.
Also, as time goes on you will see all kind of tools are going to come to the market and someone is going to buy them. AS most of pros have learned turning on the traditional gouges and skews and scrapers. When some one posts a qsn. about carbide cutting or inserts, why should matter how they use those tools to achieve what some other turners do? Shouldn't definition of a turner change as time evolves too, just like any advance technological changes that are occurring in our lives?
I think the objection to those carbide tools are due to some of us having trouble changing our old habits. In reality, we should not be considered true turners as I see the bragging happens here about the PM, JEts, Oneway fancy lathes. Then same argument should be applied to the tools also.
On the other hands, (no disrespect) once this generation of the pro turners pass on, I have a feeling the newer turners who come to our trades are going to pick up newer tools to play to make whatever they have in mind.
I also, believe that some the most beautiful works yo see nowadays are contributed to all these newer tools that are making it easier to achieve newer shapes.
I think whatever tool makes it work you better is the right tool for you.