Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Carbide Tipped Tools

Posts

Carbide Tipped Tools

#1

Carbide Tipped Tools

Tom

Given the proliferation of carbide tipped tools for wood turning applications, it would be good to hear professional turners respond to this statement: Using carbide tipped tools, such as Easy Wood Tools, Rockler and others in the marketplace, is not really wood turning as such because use of traditional wood turnng chisels requires many more skills and techniques even though an item can be completely turned and finished using just carbide tipped tools. I'm sure there are other ways to raise this issue but let's start with this one!

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#2

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

john Veerkamp

Just to confuse the issue, carbide tool can be presented to the wood more like "traditional" techniques. And traditional tools can be used in similar manner to the carbide tipped tools.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#3

The only 2 carbide tipped tools......

JamieDonaldson

...I consider worth owning are the Hunter #5 straight and swan neck versions, and they are slicers, not scrapers. I'm not interested in paying big prices for dull carbide scraping tools that create more sanding, even if they do have pretty handles! ;) This topic will create some heat!

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#4

Re: The only 2 carbide tipped tools......

Bill White

I have (and use) a square rougher, a square radius, and a round. All are on 3/8" shafts, and I turned the handles.

While they may not be part of the turning purist's list of go-to tools, I find them to be good and useful tools.

I also use standard tooling.

Bill

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#5

Re: The only 2 carbide tipped tools......

Barry L Elder

Those who buy and use carbide tools, other than nano-carbide, are like the old people who are told they have won the "lottery" as soon as they pay the $15,00 in taxes! Or like the redneck nascar fans who sit there smoking cigarettes and drinking beeyer and tell you they are just watching the race whether there is a bloody wreck or not!

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#6

Re: The only 2 carbide tipped tools......

Curt Stivison

We could be still using sharpened files instead HSS tools. Not much difference between using carbide or using high tech steel tools in my opinion. It's all in what you like. It would be a boring world if we were all the same. Just my opinion.

Curt

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#7

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Hunter tools cut, not scrape. My wife hollowed fifty 2" diameter red maple handbell Christmas ornaments before she had to rotate the cutter for the first time. This was with a #1 cutter, the smallest of the lot! The Hunter cutters put the other carbides to shame. My wife , who is afraid of grinders and their sparks, has eliminated about 85% of her grinder time with Hunter tools. Try one, you'll be happy.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#8

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

David Walser

...it would be good to hear professional turners respond to this statement: Using carbide tipped tools ... is not really wood turning as such because use of traditional wood turnng [sic] chisels requires many more skills and techniques even though an item can be completely turned and finished using just carbide tipped tools.

I doubt the professional turners, as a group, would have a unanimous opinion on the question. (Or most any other question.) Like most people, the question is whether the tool shaping the wood was guided by hand or was part of an automated process -- if the question of how it was made comes up at all.

I don't consider using carbide tipped tools to be "cheating". (I'm also not a professional turner.) I don't enjoy using carbide tipped tools nearly as much as I do more conventional tools. Since I turn mainly for my own enjoyment, I seldom use my carbide tipped tools (the one exception being hollowing). YMMV.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#9

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Jerry Klug

I am not a pro. I do teach middle and high school students to turn. I will not introduce carbide tools to my students as I want them to learn turning, not scraping. I only use Hunter (including Rocket) tools for some hollowing. I gave away an EasyWood rougher. Just didn't like it.

Carbide tools can shorten the learning curve for most new turners but learning tool control and sharpening your tools is a skill that is better learned first.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#10

Re: The only 2 carbide tipped tools......

Bill White

I do not reply to the abject refusal that another device might allow some to create.

My use of said carbide cutters still proclaims the possibility of success for those who do not gain any success with other tooling.

Dang! That scribing made my head hurt.

Bill

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#11

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

robo hippy

Well, I have retired from doing lots of shows, but still am kind of professional. Mostly I turn bowls. If you have watched any of my video clips, I use scrapers a lot for my bowl turning as they are the most efficient tool for roughing I have found. Some will disagree, but in my opinion, most who disagree never really learned to use a scraper for maximum effect. I do all of my bowl shear scraping with scrapers as well. Again, they work better for me than gouges do. I do use gouges for finish cuts, and use the shear scrape to remove the burnishing and any little tool marks that I would rather cut out than sand out. I do have a couple of the Eliminator type tools, which are angled to cut at a 45 degree shear angle. I use them some times on the inside of boxes in the transition area. Still, most often, I will use a more standard scraper at a shear angle, or even negative rake scrapers. Other than that, not at all. What little hollowing I do, I use the Kelton hollowing tools. There is not one single thing the carbide tipped tools can do that I can't do with standard scrapers and cutting tools. I think the main reason a lot of turners like them is because of the smaller cutting surfaces, they are easier to control than standard scrapers. They can be touched up a few times without too much trouble, but from what I understand, they never are quite as good as new. I don't own any of the standard scraper type carbide tools, and won't buy them. They have no advantages over my other scrapers.

robo hippy

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#12

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Dick Coers

Turning is turning, no matter what tool you use. Do you want a smoother cut than a carbide scraper can give you? Do less sanding? Then there are better tools and techniques than using an EWT. Even better carbide tools. I think your term carbide tipped tool is incorrect. These are carbide insert tools. Tipped would refer to carbide brazed onto steel. I feel that I can getter a better and smoother curve with a gouge compared to a little carbide scraper as well.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#13

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Jeff Willaford

I'm not a professional turner but one well know turner usually leads with something like "I'll use any tool, technique or process available to get to the desired results."

I use gouges, scrapers and Hunter-style carbide where it works best for me. I'm in favor of whatever safely gets people interested in turning as I don't know any turners who haven't grown and expanded their skills.

I also tend to look at the traditional tool vs carbide like the scraper vs gouge, cast iron vs steel and Ford vs Chevy discussions. ... safety first and whatever works best for you for a particular piece in process.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Keith Tompkins

My take....many people take up turning during retirement, and the carbide tools make it easy to create work quickly with a short learning curve. I think if one decides to get serious about turning, they should learn how to sharpen and use standard tools..nothing worse than waiting for new carbide inserts to arrive. Turning as a hobby or pastime should be fun...if carbide tools are fun, well go for it.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#15

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Wayne Kuhn

Not a fan but I do have a easy rougher I use to rough off bark. I bought it after I found replacement inserts for $2.00 rather than $13.00, But where would we be without laser guided captured hollowing systems, 4 jawed scroll chucks, sharpening jigs, fluted gouges. These arguments will continue forever without end.

New and improved is not always. I agree lots of changes going on but tool makers gotta sell tools.

Everybody is now buying tool handles with interchangeable gouges. Just another gimmick as far as I am concerned.

If you want to use the latest and greatest go for it, just don't force it on me.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#16

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Jack Savona

Automatic transmission or manual? Both get you there; one with more control of the vehicle.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#17

I'm rethinking my approach to Carbide tools

John Lucas

Well first of all I don't think any professionals are going to change. Why, because the bowl gouge works so well and is so versatile and that's what they know now to use. That's what I use for most projects. It can be sharpened instantly, you can change it's shape to function better for you and they are less expensive than the carbide tools.

I have learned to use some of the Hunter tools very affectively in the right situation. They aren't my go to tools for everything. I like using the big Hercules in a weighted Thompson handle for roughing really out of round bowls. It reduces the fatigue in my shoulder. I love the #5 or #4 for cleaning up the bottom and sides of boxes and I'm starting to use the Hercules or Osprey for roughing out and shaping the inside of boxes. They are efficient and quick. I like using the straight and one of the curved ones for hollowing Christmas ornaments. YOu just don't have to stop and sharpen them so I can hollow more spheres quickly that way. I also use the Osprey for cutting grain that wants tearout and as a final pass to reduce sanding .

I've taught several all day classes lately and usually there are at least 2 to 4 people out of 10 that simply can't grasp the concept of guiding the bevel to control the shape of the cut. Anytime you turn your back they go right back to scraping or they start the cut but then won't swing the handle to control the shape or where the cut is going. I took 2 students this weekend and reground their scraper and put a burr on it and let them use that. They were perfectly happy and the project was really taking shape and they were smiling. I realized how much easier and satisfying that was for them.

I started thinking about that on the way home and thought. I wonder if I had taught that same class and started everyone with a scraper, be it a flat topped style cutter or the Hunter Hercules cupped cutter. I think they would have all progressed much faster. After that I could show them the advantages of the bevel rubbing shear cut so they could practice if they wanted. What I think would happen is they would go home and be comfortable using the scraper and actually turn some projects for gifts or pleasure and enjoy turning. Later on when they are having trouble sanding out the tearout or trying to cut a nice crisp corner and they ask another turner how to solve that problem, they will be more receptive to using the gouge or skew.

In each class I teach there are usually 4 or 5 turners who have been turning for a year or more. They still have trouble controlling the cut and most don't sharpen very well. They get buy and bring in some nice projects but you can tell from watching them that it was probably a struggle.

So it's easy to understand why the Carbide scrapers are becoming popular. People who don't have the time to learn or aren't near clubs or classes can grab that tool and make a project with almost no learning curve at all. Hopefully we can then get them into clubs to learn more about the use of the bevel rubbing tools.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#18

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Bill Howatt

Your analogy is a good one but for many people the automatic transmission will give them far more control of the vehicle. Like the traditional gouges in turning, the manual transmission only gives more control if you know how to use it and far less if you don't.

Bill

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#20

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Jeff Willaford

I drove a stick until a few years ago when my left knee decided it didn't like a clutch any more. I take it as a sign of upgrade needed rather than wear and tear due to age. :\

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#21

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Dale Gillaspy

Following your logic, those who use electricity to power their lathes are not true turners because traditional lathes did not use electricity.

By the same logic, those who use gouges are not true turners because the first turning tools were scrapers, not gouges. Carbide tools are essentially scrapers.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#22

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

Tom

I really appreciate everyone's thoughts on the issue. At the end of the day, I guess tool selection is an individual choice which boils down to "whatever works best for the person using the tool to get the job done". I must note that I have found that carbide tipped tools do let someone just starting to turn to receive early gratification in producing a turning more quickly thus inspiring them to learn more about turning using conventional tools to produce more complex turnings. Finally, I have found that carbide tipped tools are very useful in helping someone with physical limitations experience the joys of wood turning.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#23

Re: I'm rethinking my approach to Carbide tools

Phillip Medghalchi

John, if you go back and watch the commercial or advertising for easy wood tools VS traditional bowl gouges and scrapers; or any other carbide cutter turning tools; you'll notice that the pitch is about how easy it is to use that tool and maneuver around to shape objects. When a beginner sees those ads and the itch of making a bowl or any objects in their ability is overwhelming they would tend to go to what ever is easier for them to make something and join the rest of the group ( as acceptance).

There is a myth about carbide inserts not being able to be resharpened and Cap. Eddie and some other turners show you how to do it by taking it flat and sharpen them on a diamond honing tool.

You mentioned that you use Hunter tools too. So, we can't come back and say yo are any lesser turner.

Also, as time goes on you will see all kind of tools are going to come to the market and someone is going to buy them. AS most of pros have learned turning on the traditional gouges and skews and scrapers. When some one posts a qsn. about carbide cutting or inserts, why should matter how they use those tools to achieve what some other turners do? Shouldn't definition of a turner change as time evolves too, just like any advance technological changes that are occurring in our lives?

I think the objection to those carbide tools are due to some of us having trouble changing our old habits. In reality, we should not be considered true turners as I see the bragging happens here about the PM, JEts, Oneway fancy lathes. Then same argument should be applied to the tools also.

On the other hands, (no disrespect) once this generation of the pro turners pass on, I have a feeling the newer turners who come to our trades are going to pick up newer tools to play to make whatever they have in mind.

I also, believe that some the most beautiful works yo see nowadays are contributed to all these newer tools that are making it easier to achieve newer shapes.

I think whatever tool makes it work you better is the right tool for you.

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#24

Alan Zenreich

Re: I'm rethinking my approach to Carbide tools

Alan Zenreich

Carbide tools are just tools.

If you present them to the work in scraper orientation, they will scrape.

If you present them in cutting orientation they will cut.

This applies to any tool. I see skew chisels used effectively in both orientations, and everything in between.

Here is a video that shows Steve Sherman using a round, flat carbide tool in a finial demo. This is not your basic 'keep the tool flat on the tool rest" beginner technique but shows what a tool can do in the hands of someone who understands the possibilities.

The carbide tool is used starting about 1:50 into the video.

http://youtu.be/n_PHDBLi-tA

Re: Carbide Tipped Tools

#25

Bill Blasic

Re: I'm rethinking my approach to Carbide tools

Bill Blasic

All I will say about this is that if you compare apples to oranges you might look at it this way. An Easy Rougher unhandled is about $99 and a Thompson 5/8 V is $85 unhandled. I'll bet by the time you have used all of the flute of the Thompson gouge you will probably have at least 3 times the amount of money invested in the Easy Rougher and the bowl gouge is a lot more versatile. Maybe those terms should be given to new turners.