Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Sliding Headstock

Posts

Sliding Headstock

#1

Sliding Headstock

Ron Pemberton

What is the advantage of a sliding headstock some of the lathes are offering?

Re: Sliding Headstock

#2

Re: Sliding Headstock

John Lucas

I don't do it as much as I used to but when turning bowls if you stand at the end you can stand upright instead of leaning over the lathe. Same is true for hollow forms. The other advantage on the powermatic 3520b is you can mount the short bed extension down on the legs. Slide the headstock down and you have 30" swing.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#3

Re: Sliding Headstock

Ralph Lindberg

Even without getting a free standing tool-rest, the ability to slide the headstock almost of the way down the lathe, this allows you to stand at the tail of the lathe. Really nice for hollowing.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#4

Re: Sliding Headstock

John Lucas

Powermatic sells a tool post extension so you don't need a floor rest which is really cool

Re: Sliding Headstock

#5

Re: Sliding Headstock

robo hippy

I posted this one a few months ago I think, but it explains more than I can do here if you want to watch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djX9vRlkcK8

I love the sliding headstock because I can always, no matter what I am turning, can stand straight up, and keep my arms in close to my body. Some, like Mike Mahoney and Dale Bonertz (hope I didn't spell that too wrong Dale) state that a fixed headstock has less vibration for turning and coring than a sliding headstock does. The difference is because the fixed headstock is bolted down. Well, I don't know about that, and need to spend some time on a fixed headstock lathe. I think there are differences in the pressure plate on the headstocks. My Robust AB has a plate the full length of the headstock. Other than that, the higher the headstock is (bigger throw) and the farther away from the headstock you mount the blank (my Beauty sticks out about 2 inches more than my old PM did) the less dampening there is because of longer levers. Cast metal is quieter than the steel tubes, but I don't think it makes any real difference other than different noises. I haven't done it yet, but have thought about filling the tube with sand for dampening reasons....

robo hippy

Re: Sliding Headstock

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

More room for buffing

Chuck Jones - West TN

You can pull the headstock all the way to the end and you have more clearance for buffing.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#7

Re: Sliding Headstock

mjonesrdg

I set-up my dust control system with a fixed-position dust collector hood. Optimal pull of dust occurs at intervals along the length of the collector hood. It's easier to slide the headstock for sanding operations to match best "suck" from the unit, than than to constantly try to adjust the dust collector. Sometime I like "centering-up" on the lathe bed, and sometime I like to work off the end. My PM 3520 A is sweet as is, but I loved the swiveling and sliding of my old NOVA.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#8

Re: Sliding Headstock

Darrell Feltmate

I like my rotating headstock for the same reason. It allows me to point the headstock away from the weighs of the lathe and have better angle and clearance for hollowing.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#9

Re: Sliding Headstock

Mark Wollschlager

There are the many advantages listed above.

But.

It is important to keep the underside of the headstock and ways clean when moving the headstock.

Dust and chips can bind under the headstock and alter the alignment of the spindle.

Not critical, just something to take into account.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#10

Aage Rendalen

Saves your neck and back

Aage Rendalen

I'm not sure if my back and neck could handle a fixed headstock lathe any more. Standing at the end turning is ergonomically so much more comfortable.

But, you need to organize your work when you do so. When I do a series of 10 bowls, I turn the tenon and the outside of all ten before I remove the tailstock and begin turning off the end.

I have an 18" bed extension on my PM3520 with the tool post extension that allows you to turn 30" off the end, but I'm selling it because I don't like the idea of turning the outside of an out-of-round piece without the support of the tailstock. I could, of course, (and should, no doubt) use an 8" faceplate in such a case, but I'm to lazy to do it (and besides, a bowl bigger than 16" turns into furniture, as is, because of its size, unfit for a table.)

Re: Sliding Headstock

#11

Re: Sliding Headstock

Dale Bonertz

Robo you spelled it correctly. :)

For what I do and for the amount of coring I do the sliding head stock just doesn't work well for me. I have said many times for a good percentage of turners the sliding head stock will work fine. I know another professional turner, other than Mike, who also will not core on the sliding head stock lathes in his shop. He uses his Vicmark for coring. So I guess I am not to crazy with my thoughts on this topic. :)

Funny though how many turners I have run into that have sliding head stocks and say they haven't moved theirs in years. They leave them sit in the position they are and lean over the bed like it is a fixed head stock. Makes no sense to me but it is what those folks do with their lathe.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#12

Re: Sliding Headstock

robo hippy

Darrell,

Haven't heard from you in a while. Good to see you still around.

As far as sliding compared to pivoting headstocks, I think the sliding is far easier to move around than the pivoting ones, and it seems that the pivoting ones don't always line back up in line with the tailstock and take some fussing with. They have come a long way though.

robo hippy

Re: Sliding Headstock

#13

A question of those that turn off the end

Dick Coers

If you say you turn bowls by standing on the end, don't you still end up standing off to the side? Maybe not to start the cut, but to get the bowl gouge to the bottom, you have to have a range to swing the handle over. When using a fixed head, a lot of the travel is just through the arms. I'm just thinking that if you say you stand on the end, you really have to step to the side somewhere to get the travel. Am I wrong? Hollowing I can understand completely standing on the end.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#14

Dick, you are correct about bowl .....

JamieDonaldson

....turning from the side, and bowls are only turned off the end when the swing capacity of the spindle is exceeded. Hollowing is another matter, and the short bed is then a real back saver!

Re: Sliding Headstock

#15

Re: A question of those that turn off the end

robo hippy

I talk about it in my 'Bowl Turning Ergonomics' clip on You Tube. Have you ever seen Stuart Batty and his push cut? It involves extending your arms out away from your body so you don't have to bend or lean over the lathe to get your tools to cut. It does work. When turning the inside, you do pretty much the same, though as the tool rounds out near the transition it is closer to your body. When turning off the end of the lathe, you do still have to move, but movement is with your arms at your side and next to your body. You pivot from one foot to the other, and rotate your shoulders and hips. Same thing for turning the inside of the bowl. You can keep your hands near your body and move and pivot that way while standing up straight. This is pretty much Tai Chi 101. Mike Mahoney uses his pull cut, which is still a long bed lathe concept. For the outside of the bowl, he still extends out a bit, but keeps the gouge closer to his body. They do the insides fairly similarly. I think you may be able to find their 2 Ways to Turn a Bowl on You Tube, but maybe not. It is a good demo. I find standing at the end of the lathe more comfortable.

robo hippy

Re: Sliding Headstock

#16

MT2 alignment tool

Jeff Willaford

My Nova DVR-XP has a swivel head and is a real back saver for me. My shed is small and there is no room to stand at the end of the lathe. Alignment is very simple. I use a double ended MT2 alignment tool. About $20 from several vendors. No fuss, no trouble. It just works.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#17

Re: A question of those that turn off the end

John Lucas

It lets you stand up straight and use your body instead of just your arms to cut the inside of a bowl. Much more precise and a lot more relaxing. You get to "dance" with the bowl. For hollow turning you have the tool right up against your side instead of hanging out in space. Much easier on your shoulder.

If you are the type that mounts a bowl blank to the lathe rather than between centers standing at the end lets you use your body to support the gouge while roughing which is much easier. It also allows you to use more of a push cut while turning the outside because the tailstock or the bed won't be in the way. I only do this on straight grain production style bowls because I prefer to mount them between centers so I can adjust the wood as I go to make the grain balance better.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#18

Aage Rendalen

Dick, with an Ellsworth grind, no problem

Aage Rendalen

Dick, I certainly have to make sure I have an eye on either side of the wall when hollowing a bowl, but I don't have to crane my neck. With my Ellsworth-grind, I can pretty much cut sideways when I reach the bottom of the bowl. I spent a few years using a Jet 3612 with a non-sliding headstock and I could not imagine go back to one that does not allow me to hollow bowls at the end of the ways.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#19

So you don't have to dance around the leg?

Dick Coers

I was envisioning one leg on each side of the lathe corner, or straddling the lathe leg, then having to shuffle around it to finish a cut. Guess I need to borrow some time on a sliding head.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#20

risk vs benefit

Geoff Whaling

I think like all tools & machines there are good designs & bad designs for sliding head stocks. Some of the discussions I hear about fellow turners having issues with alignment & wear on sliding head stocks I think I will stick with my fixed Vicmarcs.

Not wanting to be a kill joy but like everything there is the risk vs benefit equation to consider.

The benefits of a sliding head stock permitting an upright turning stance are very considerable for those with dodgy backs and is very hard to argue against that benefit.

However the placement of the head stock near the ends of the ways encourages turners to not use the added safety of tail stock support where ever possible. I do realize that mostly tail stock support is not required at that stage in the turning process.

The act of having to move the head stock position between turning projects simply becomes bothersome so turners think "I can get away with it" or if it may be required on the current project it is either impossible due to bowl dia, or the set up of other accessories like steadies etc. and simply becomes a nightmare to realign all the components again after a shift.

Re: Sliding Headstock

#21

Re: MT2 alignment tool

Darrell Feltmate

Yeah, I have a big enough shop except that it is filled with all sorts of stuff and I would have to do some fancy maneuvering to stand at the end of the lathe with a moving headstock. I turned a M2 taper on either end of a spindle and use it to realign the head after turning. Works great and I imagine the commercial one is even more accurate. Maybe. But I am cheap 8)

Re: Sliding Headstock

#22

Re: MT2 alignment tool

Tim OHearn

OK, how does the alignment tool work?

Thanks

Re: Sliding Headstock

#23

Re: MT2 alignment tool

Doc Green

Tim, the tool consists of two MT2 tapers back to back, with the small ends of the tapers pointing outwards from a "fat" middle.

To realign the headstock after it has been moved, place one end of the alignment tool in the tailstock. With the headstock not clamped down, bring up the tailstock so that the exposed end of the alignment tool goes into the MT2 taper of the headstock. Push the tailstock and headstock toward each other until the alignment tool is firmly seated. At that point, clamp the headstock down.

Pull the tailstock back, remove the alignment tool, and you're good to go.