Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Posts

Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#1

Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Brian

Hi all..... rant on....

Looking for some input / opinions.

I have had a Powermatic 45 for over 25 years....and done a LOT of work on it.

Thinking it time to upgrade to variable speed and larger swing I have begun to look at what's "out there".

Stopped at Woodcraft in Milwaukee to look at the PM 3520B....since I have been leaning heavily in that direction.....and have a WTB ad in the classifieds (not so sure about that now).

Now, of course, there is no perfect machine....and I understand cost cutting...but I gotta say Powermatic's switch from the split nut they used for many years to a single screw end bearing on the tool rest post to tighten the tool rest is just ......well....baffling.

The lathe on the floor in the Milwaukee store has never even seen a moment of use and the tool rest post is covered with divots and dents from the end of the screw that is SUPPOSED to secure it in position for turning!

I say "supposed to" because, even with a VERY firm crank on the screw, it was quite easy to move the tool rest. Not surprising....since the bearing surface of the rounded end of the single screw on the 3520B is miniscule compared to the two (approx.) 5/8" long flat surfaces that bear on the shaft in the old PM45.

The split nut on my old PM45 has seen literally thousands of "tightenings" over the years and there is no hint of a mark on the tool rest post. (and the tool rest does NOT move when tightened)

The production time involved ....comparing the new "system" to the old.....is not that different. Both have a screw with a cross sliding handle. The machining of the banjo on the PM45 is one simple drilled and reamed hole. On the 3520B they have drilled and tapped three holes (presumably to allow the user to place the tightening screw in the front or on either side ?). The split nut on the PM45 can also be inserted from either side as needed for clearance.

As a machinist I can say the necessary work on the banjo of the PM45 is simpler.

So... the split nut.....the unthreaded piece is simply a piece of round stock with a hole thru the center and a flat angle machined perpendicular to the length. The other piece is identical ..... except with the center threaded, of course, to accept the handle screw.

Yeah....I know....the split nuts don't exist on the 3520B.....so less cost.

But......they should.....

Instead of spending production time and material cost on the (apologies to those who think it's wonderful) absurd hinged door on the tailstock they should have spent the resource on something that makes a difference!

I find it puzzling, to say the least, that any professional turner would be involved in the design of the 3520B and agree with the tool rest banjo "system" change....

I would appreciate any thoughts and opinions....

Thanks!

Brian

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#2

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

John Lucas

When they were all made in McMinnville, TN they all had your system. When it got transferred overseas they changed it. I haven't noticed dings in my tool posts but then most of my post are aftermarket or handmade using Drill rod for the post. Maybe they are using cheaper metal. Almost every lathe I demo on has the same single screw to lock things down. It works. I do on rare occasions have a tool post slip. Since the powermatic has 2 screws when I'm roughing out bowls where the tool rest takes a pounding I tighten both.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#3

That's why Oneway and Robust are both.....

Dick Coers

...selling banjos for other lathes. You just have to tell them the lathe, or bed gap, and you get a banjo worth using. The Jet 1642 is the same, and now Grizzly is selling bigger lathes with the same poor design. "You get what you pay for" has never been more true.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#4

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest problems- long

mo'wood

Hi Brian,

I am in complete agreement with you regarding the poorly designed tool rest system on the new Powermatic lathes. I have owned two of the older Powermatic 45 lathes in the past- they were very common in the high school and college woodworking shops and can still be found at reasonable prices. The simplicity and dependability of that tool rest locking system was terrific, and the handle could also be reversed for left handed turners without any trouble. I just don’t understand why it was abandoned on the newer machines.

I have taught at a wide variety of schools and clubs for many years, and some of the particular topics I present involve use of on-lathe texturing techniques such as spiraling and chatter-work, which can produce vibration from the cut that is transferred to the tools rest. I have frequently seen the newer Powermatic tool rests suddenly drop when they are subjected to this vibration- an inconvenient, if not dangerous tendency, and one that makes me wonder why the company decided on such a relatively undersized locking handle given the loads and vibration it is subject to.

It seems that one improvement would be to carefully drill out the casting –perhaps best done by a qualified machinist- and use a helicoil to make a new larger thread for a proportionally larger replacement locking handle. Fine, rather than coarse threads, would be a noticeable improvement as well, though may be tough to find.

Another way to solve your problem with the tool rest is to simply replace it with the best available- namely, the Oneway system, which is a far superior design. Their tool rest bases are sold separately from their lathes, and I believe are worth the money. Not only does the lock handle on the tool post employ a contact pad that won’t scar the tool rest post, but the handle itself can be adjusted to stop in any position you choose, and is also hinged to allow for use right or left handed. When it is position on the right, the weight and the ample length of the handle itself makes locking the tool rest firmly a breeze, and always positive.

The best thing about the Oneway tool rest base (banjo) is the system they use to pull it tight to the bed of the lathe- rather than using the common eccentric shaft that can flex under load, they use a clever square shaft system that rotates a short cam sitting in a sliding cradle that bears on grooves in the base casting – exactly where you need it- rather than at the ends of an eccentric shaft. It is my understanding that this is a patented system, and Oneway has had to fight to prevent it from being illegally copied by competitors.

There are several lathes made by other companies that have a pitifully undersized eccentric shaft system on the tool rest base- resulting in the base locking handle stopping at different places depending on how far the base is positioned from the center of the bed. There are some lathes where the undersized eccentric shaft acts like a spring, and I have seen them spontaneously flip the handle into the open position when they get out of adjustment. Not a feature I think you would want in a lathe.

If you absolutely had to, I suspect that you could find touch up paint to match the Oneway tool rest to your existing “Mustard Munster” lathe ……

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#5

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest problems- long

Brian

All true...but to spend $4000 only to have to spend another $300 for a quality tool rest....shameful.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#6

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest problems- long

Brian

Err...meant to say banjo...not tool rest.....

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#7

Many current lathes have a .......

JamieDonaldson

... threaded post "bolt" with a rounded end that contacts the post of the tool rest, often creating a bunch of dimples on the post that exacerbates the locking function, especially if the post is cast iron. A quick and simple "cure" that often improves the operation is to grind the handle bolt end flat, so that a flat surface contacts the post without creating dimples on the rest post. ;)

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#8

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Sergio

I have a Vicmarc vl 300, use it every day abouth 5-6 hours day. Like it lot and I'm thinking to get a second Vicmarc VL 240 when the addition to my shop will be ready. I believe it is in a completely different class compared to the Powermatic. Certainly on the same level of the steel made americans.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#9

Re: That's why Oneway and Robust are both.....

Brian

The Robust uses (and gives credit to) the exact same split nut that Powermatic used on the 45 and 90!

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#10

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

robo hippy

I had an early model 3520A that even had a little fan under the converter. The post that screwed into the banjo for tightening up the tool rest had the tip drilled out and a piece of brass rod inserted into it. It didn't leave any marks. I stripped the handle part of that (why any one would use pot metal for the handle and hard metal for the screw is beyond me), and got a replacement, and they didn't have one that had the brass any more. After my tool rest broke, then sent me another one, but it didn't fit in the banjo because they had changed that too. Well, they sent me another banjo, in several shipments and completely in pieces, and I got it back on the lathe. It had 2 holes for the set screws. Well, I stripped the handle again, and had a friend make me a handle like on your bench vises, a T handle, with the stem being threaded, and the cross/top of the T was a round bar that slid freely back and forth or up and down through the hole so it was always out of the way. Far better. I got a Robust next, and love the split nut. Far better than the set screws. My Robust has the soft pot metal handle on a hard metal screw, and sure enough, I stripped that one out. I do kind of like the handle on the Oneway that is on a lever so you can flip it around. It is a little longer than I would prefer, and I would worry about over tightening. Since I seldom turn on a Oneway, I haven't had a chance to really work it out.

robo hippy

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#11

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Sergio

You can easily change the lock lever, if this is what you brake, and get a heavy duty one for about 20 dollars. The one I have certainly will reist a lot of force and occasionally its grip is so strong even without forcing it that I have difficulty in releasing it!

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#12

What you learn on a Oneway,

Dick Coers

is that you don't have to lean on the handle. Just firmly snug it up. Got mine in 1998, haven't had a worry on the banjo yet. You ought to see their banjo on the large outboard turning accessory! Looks like you can park a truck on top of it!

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#13

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Gerald Klug

Sorry, but your complaint against the modern powermatics is an empty conversation. I have spent a fair amount of time on my 3520 with no problems. I also have MANY friends that turn on the 3520 with great enjoyment and no problems. Comparing the features of the Powermatic to thr Oneway or Robust at nearly twice the price is like expecting a Buick to be equal to a Mercedes. The 3520 is such a popular lathe because it offers the most for the money. Go ahead and buy the "best" lathe. I will by more than satisfied with a very good tool at a reasonable cost. Should I experience tool rest slippage, i can have the banjo machined to improve the clamp for about $100.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#14

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Brian

Gerald......please read my original post.

I compared the new Powermatic to the old Powermatic.....listing valid reasons for returning to a system that worked better....period.

To argue that point is truly an "empty conversation".

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#15

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Brian

And.....how would you have the banjo machined to improve it for $100?

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#16

Bill Blasic

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Bill Blasic

Brian I don't think he was replying to your post as the posts above him were talking about Oneway and Robust. I have been using my 3520b for ten years and have had no problem with tightening the tool post on the banjo. I find no need to reef on it to keep the tool rest from moving and I don't notice any gouges or anything like that on my tool post. I think the Robust is a very well made lathe but I myself like cast iron and the Powermatic fits that bill.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#17

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

Sergio

That is one reason I bougth a Vicmarc. Cast iron and the price is not much higher than the Powermatic but there is no comparison between the two.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#18

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

John Lucas

I just looked and the Vicmarc's run about $2000 higher than the Powermatic. I looked long and hard at lathes when I bought my Powermatic and had turned on a lot of lathes. I think the Powermatic was the best bang for the buck. Are there things that I would change. Certainly. Everybody has little things they would change about almost any lathe you buy. It comes down to personal taste.

Powermatic table saws aren't as good as they were when they were made in McMinnville either. But then the price would have been many times higher. What we must consider is that everything is money driven. We ask for less expensive items and that's what we get. If we all had enough money to buy Robust's the Taiwanese tools wouldn't exist.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#19

No one said by a Oneway or Robust lathe

Dick Coers

we were just talking about upgrading the banjo. I suggest you read the posts before passing judgement on the validity of the conversation.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#20

A fascinating thread!!!

Ron Bauer

What started as a question about the banjo/post on a Powermatic lathe morphed to a near challenge to a fist fight. Boy can things go off topic. I wonder if we would act like this if we were looking each other in the eye???

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#21

Re: A fascinating thread!!!

Bill Howatt

We may possibly do it looking each other in the eye but the comments may not be considered so argumentative. The tone of written things like posts and emails have the effect of being totally interpreted by the reader - there are no other clues to the feelings of the sender such as body language and voice.

When I encountered an escalating "discussion" between co-workers at different physical locations I used to tell the person where I was to stop the email and "to get on the phone". Even that improvement usually had the issue de-fused with both parties better understanding the other's perspective.

Bill

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#22

A quote from Gene Wengert at Woodweb

Dick Coers

He stated, "At my age, you either preach or reminisce...HOPE I WAS NOT TOO PREACHY." A well made quote that I really appreciated. Also, in that same vein, Key and Peele did a wonderful skit on text message confusion. I would give the link, but it is uncensored on YouTube, and I didn't want to get that conversation started!

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#23

Re: No one said by a Oneway or Robust lathe

Gerald Klug

This conversation started with a "rant" about Powermatic having lower quality than the old model 45 in the construction of the banjo. I didn't say rant, Brian did.

No mention was made upon the improvements of the 3520, only about how the banjo was inferior to Oneway and Robust, Sorry if some think I was starting a fist fight, I am normally a placid person. If we change the object to automotive items, Brian could have said the 1952 Pontiac was a great riding car and the Subaru of today should incorporate better ride. Left out is that that Pontiac was very well known for going 100,000 miles without major engine work uet a Subaru can and often runs into the multiple 100 grand miles with no major work.

Griping about the design of one feature of a reasonably priced popular lathe is an empty rant. If Brian and others that voiced the greatness or $7,000 lathe banjo's over a reasonably priced Powermatic one, then they can go ahead and buy that fine Canadian or American equipment.

My comments were intended to bring some logic into Brian's rant but you Brian seem to be offended in my comments. You could replace your reeves drive with a new motor and variable speed controller so your classic Powermatic could serve you more like a modern lathe. That would meld the older is better with some modern technology.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#24

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

david delo

I think the comment "best bang for the buck" fits the justification I used when selecting the 3520B a couple years ago. That same justification might be different for a different person and that's okay with me. I see the benefit of the old tool rest tightening and wish they still did it that way. Also wish I could get the rpm's a little lower for sanding, wish they did offer a factory tailstock tilt or swing away and maybe even a thin strip of stainless steel for the ways would be nice.....but they don't and even if they did, it wouldn't be 3.5K on sale. Seemed to me to be the best entry level big dog lathe available and gave me room in the budget for all the other little goodies (coring, hollowing, vacuum, chucks, centers etc. etc. etc.) that come with this vortex. Would love to have a professional level Robust, Serious or Vicmarc, those are wonderful machine, just weren't in the budget for a weekend hacker/wacker like myself. Only one I wouldn't get is the Oneway. I'd be scared to get that machine dirty. That brilliant white color certainly is a head turner, at least for me.

Re: Powermatic 3520B tool rest

#25

I have Robust taste and Grizzly budget

John Lucas

If you put all of my wants and desires into one lathe it would be the Robust. I have demoed on lots of lathes and Vicmarc and Oneway are well up there in terms of quality but I like the features and design of the Robust. Unfortunately I've bought cars cheaper than a Robust. Heck I've bought cars cheaper than the midrange Grizzly so I guess that isn't saying much about my car budget is it. :)

The first Powermatic 3520's that came out after the shift to overseas product had a hollow screw with a brass insert for the tool post lock. These broke really easy and was a really dumb design. After that they went to the solid screw but as noted above will ding some tool posts that are made of softer cast steel. Of course the older powermatics also had a 1 1/8" tool post which was a really odd size so the newer 1" tool post was a little improvement.

My powermatic 3520A was $2000 and and going up $500 bucks the next month. Of course they now sell for almost $4K. The changed a few things that improved the 3520B. One of them was the pin that locks the quill feed from spinning. It used to be on the bottom of the tailstock and is a tapered pin and fell out frequently. They switched one mounted on the back of the tailstock so it can't fall out and can be easily removed if necessary. They also put indexing on the B and not on my A. They added holes in the legs to mount the short bed extension in a lower position to give you 30" of swing. So they are listening to us but apparently we haven't given them a hard enough time about the tool post lock.