Powermatic 3520B tool rest
Brian
Hi all..... rant on....
Looking for some input / opinions.
I have had a Powermatic 45 for over 25 years....and done a LOT of work on it.
Thinking it time to upgrade to variable speed and larger swing I have begun to look at what's "out there".
Stopped at Woodcraft in Milwaukee to look at the PM 3520B....since I have been leaning heavily in that direction.....and have a WTB ad in the classifieds (not so sure about that now).
Now, of course, there is no perfect machine....and I understand cost cutting...but I gotta say Powermatic's switch from the split nut they used for many years to a single screw end bearing on the tool rest post to tighten the tool rest is just ......well....baffling.
The lathe on the floor in the Milwaukee store has never even seen a moment of use and the tool rest post is covered with divots and dents from the end of the screw that is SUPPOSED to secure it in position for turning!
I say "supposed to" because, even with a VERY firm crank on the screw, it was quite easy to move the tool rest. Not surprising....since the bearing surface of the rounded end of the single screw on the 3520B is miniscule compared to the two (approx.) 5/8" long flat surfaces that bear on the shaft in the old PM45.
The split nut on my old PM45 has seen literally thousands of "tightenings" over the years and there is no hint of a mark on the tool rest post. (and the tool rest does NOT move when tightened)
The production time involved ....comparing the new "system" to the old.....is not that different. Both have a screw with a cross sliding handle. The machining of the banjo on the PM45 is one simple drilled and reamed hole. On the 3520B they have drilled and tapped three holes (presumably to allow the user to place the tightening screw in the front or on either side ?). The split nut on the PM45 can also be inserted from either side as needed for clearance.
As a machinist I can say the necessary work on the banjo of the PM45 is simpler.
So... the split nut.....the unthreaded piece is simply a piece of round stock with a hole thru the center and a flat angle machined perpendicular to the length. The other piece is identical ..... except with the center threaded, of course, to accept the handle screw.
Yeah....I know....the split nuts don't exist on the 3520B.....so less cost.
But......they should.....
Instead of spending production time and material cost on the (apologies to those who think it's wonderful) absurd hinged door on the tailstock they should have spent the resource on something that makes a difference!
I find it puzzling, to say the least, that any professional turner would be involved in the design of the 3520B and agree with the tool rest banjo "system" change....
I would appreciate any thoughts and opinions....
Thanks!
Brian





