I would dampen the piece with mineral spirits before changing the collar. You might like that height based on color. I usually prefer the apex of the body curve a little higher. I usually aim for a 5/8, 3/8 proportion. Looking forward to seeing it with the finish! Great craftsmanship!
Roger, In general, I like it, and I agree with the comment about wetting the collar before you change it. You just might like it. The only thing I would say about the form is that the widest spot is sitting a little too low. If you think about the rule of thirds, the widest spot should be a little higher for focus. Right now, it is just a little above center. There also seems to be a flat spot just about 2/3 of the way up, but that could be just the camera.
Not bad for a first effort, but what the others have said regarding the shape is spot on, Roger. Think of shoulders rather than the waist. To help you achieve the uninterrupted curve you are seeking, buy some long glue sticks (hot melt glue), and hold one end at the top of the curve, then bend it along the curve. Look for places the stick doesn't touch the vessel. Makes it really easy to identify high spots like the one almost at the center of the form.
The top may be a bit heavy, but that's only my opinion. Wipe it with MS so you can see the real color, and decide for yourself.
Like I said, though, nice wood, and respectable first effort.
Thanks for the responses. The collar looks heavier in the photos than in life. I'll darken it as suggested and may even use a marking pen to blacken it. I need to find a better way to chuck the second side of this shape. I probably will make another. (and maybe make it without the tear-out
I realized that the belt line was too low and there was a flat spot but had difficulty seeing it when it was on the lathe. Looking at it now, both problems could have been reduced by cutting a new curve starting the top of the crack and flowing to the current diameter of the base, before it was hollowed.
Thanks for the tip on using a glue stick to check the profile. I have a flexible metal 6" steel rule that I "walk down the profile" with the rule on edge looking
Sorry, I'm chiming in a little late here. Overall, a nice hollow form and I think it will really look great when polished up. Mulberry Burl?
Making a series is probably the very best way to really nail the form you are looking for. I like the comments you have collected so far, and by now you may have already made some adjustments (?)
Two thoughts:
1. can you refine the profile at all by re-mounting between centers? You wouldn't be able to move the "waist' if you're at 1/4" already, but you may be able to eliminate or reduce the flat zone.
2. If you like the height of the collar, another option is to turn it to a hollow shape that reverses the curve flowing up from below -- essentially making the whole collar a cove shape, with a more pointed rim. This can lighten the visual effect a lot, and pull the eye upwards by continuing the line of the curve up and out the top of the vessel. Sorry -- I don't have a current photo on my hard drive to show what I mean.
Another idea...leave the collar off. This reduces the overall height and makes a little more exciting form. It may even reduce the perception of the flat spot. Us turners get hung up on small mouth openings but it may work well without the collar.
Thanks Brad for the response. Yes it is a mulberry burl. Due to health limitations I have not reworked it yet but I hope to remount it between centers to see what improvements can be made. Temp was -2 this morning but forecast for Saturday is 70. Missouri weather!
I hope to make another collar or two to evaluate including your suggestion.
It may be a week or two before I can post the "after" pics.