Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

opinion of locust as carving mallet

Posts

opinion of locust as carving mallet

#1

opinion of locust as carving mallet

mreagan

I wanted the group’s opinion on suitability of locust for wood carving mallets. Is it durable? What do people use in lieu of lignum vitae or beech, neither of which are readily available, maybe walnut, oak?

I turned the attached and it’s still pretty wet at 25%. So if locust is an unsuitable material I’ll use it as a “beater” mallet around the shop and make a new one now. Thanks all,

Matt


Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#2

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

john Veerkamp

Locust is not as heavy as lignum but will work just fine if you be sure to use slow growth wood i.e. closely spaced rings. I use Osage Orange for mallets. Hard and heavy, plus nice to turn.

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#3

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

jeff Willaford

I agree with John. I have two locust mallets I turned several years ago and they are holding up fine. They do lack a little in weight for their size.

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#4

Janka scale-locust

David Staeheli

For things like your mallet, I often use the Janka scale as a rough rule of thumb for estimating durability. Black Locust comes in at 1700, Honey Locust at 1580, Lignum Vitae at 4500, Red Oak at 1290, White Oak at 1360, Hard Maple at 1450, Big Leaf Maple at 850 and Osage Orange at 2320. So your numbers, which aren't everything, are right up there. Sure, something like Osage Orange would be better, but can you find a big enough piece?

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#5

Re: Janka scale-locust

john Veerkamp

Big OO is not a problem where I live. I have old fence row trees up to 20" diameter.

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#6

Steven Antonucci

mine is black locust...fine 3 years in


Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#7

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

John Lucas

Black locust is great About the best is dogwood root burl. It's not too heavy pretty hard and the curly grain makes it really tough. I have one I made many years ago from

A piece of dogwood that had a bark inclusion That prt came off but the rest is holding well. I have one I made out of plywood stacked up. I added some brass rod to the inside to add weight. It's holding up surprisingly well

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#8

Re: Janka scale-locust

Phillip Medghalchi

David, would you kindly post that link for Janka scale. I tried to Google it and as I looked they have different numbers for those woods.

Bell Forst figured and exotic wood. lists is as follow:

4000 Lignum Vitae (Argentine)

4400 Lignum Vitae (Genuine)

So if I do not have access to those woods then, Mesquite at 2345 should be good?

wher do you get the correct weight for the mallet for carving?

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#9

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

Jim Pugh

The locust should work just fine. Another choice might be apple wood.

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#10

Thanks all!


Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#11

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I have a beetle (for froes) of black locust. I also have made carving mallets of hard maple, dogwood, purpleheart, bloodwood, bitter orange (Poncirus trifoliata), white oak, cocobolo and others, but my favorite is hophornbeam. You can also use hornbeam. I would not use honey locust (but the Janka hardness numbers already told you that). I also have some lignum vitae stock that I will probably turn another mallet from, some day.

For accurate hardness numbers, both side grain and end grain, and other pertinent dta, like tendency to split when struck across the grain (you'll find big numbers in that column for ash and hickory, which also make good mallets), reference the USDA Forest Products Lab, Center for Wood Anatomy Research. If locally available, mulberry, live oak and elm also are suitable.

Sometimes, even without being able to identify it as to species, you can find excellent mallet stock in pallets, especially those that originate overseas. OTOH, a lot of pallet wood is totally unsuitable, so you will need to experiment. If you can't dent it with a fingernail, and you can raise a nice curl with a well tuned card scraper, it is worth investigating further.

Re: opinion of locust as carving mallet

#12

Re: Janka scale-locust*LINKS*

David Staeheli

Philip, there is no one site of course. Sometimes I have to google up the individual wood. Here are a couple of sites that have a lot.

http://ejmas.com/tin/2009tin/tinart_goldstein_0904.html

http://www.sizes.com/units/janka.htm

http://www.bellforestproducts.com/info/janka-hardness/

I like the Goldstein chart as it also has the density and the rupture strength. Just a couple of other numbers to throw in the mix.