Yes, folks, it's that time again -- time to toss out another contentious question for your thoughts and opinions. As usual we'll be distilling replies to their essence and sending them off to Woodworker West magazine, where our bi-monthly column "News & Views" has appeared for the past 15 years.
This time around, I would like to hear your musings on "making do," or getting by with less. Not everyone can afford every conceivable tool and machine, nor do many of us have the luxury of a large shop. So how do we manage to get things done. I'll be interested to hear some of your coping strategies. How have you arrived at the right mix of resources to accompllish what you want to accomplish? (Hint: It might involve outsourcing some things you can't do alone.) Has your formula changed over time? Do you adjust your ambitions to the tools at hand, or do you tool up to meet your ambitions?
We all get by with what we have. Let's hear your stories of how you do it.
Cool survey. At one point in my life not to long ago I thought I was going to have to sell everything and get buy with the smallest shop possible. I had determined that I could keep my bandsaw, my mini lathe, my hand tools, carving tools and my routers and good workbench and I could still do most of what I do today. Not as fast certainly and would have to modify some things but I would still be working.
I also look back at some of the pieces I made 20 years ago and sometimes wonder how I did it with the tools I had. The answer is simple and comes down to the topic you chose, I just got by. I simply took the tools I had and made something.
Since I'm a tool junkie I'm not at a loss for those. In fact, I probably use only three or four turning tools most of the time. My "problem" is space. I'm in one stall of a two car garage. I also share it with the lawn mower, wheel barrow, and large recycle bin. But I make do. Most of the time I just move them outside when I start to work. It's still a small space, but in my case it's probably good since I'm a hoarder and don't have the space to store much.
I'm at the extreme, I have a shop full of tools, been buying for the last 25 years. My kids will have to sell or auction. You can't take it with you. I do the same with my golf clubs, lots of drivers. I'ts a good thing I have Ebay to buy and sell, member since 98, with 1365 attaboys. Ok I have sold some tools to make room for new lathes, sanding machines, etc. But I always manage to hang on to my Shopsmith I got in 1980. I have purchased from all your advertisers here.
recently when I told how I get by with making my own versions of expensive tools! My articulated hollowing tool has less than $75 in it, that infamous optical guide cost less than $20. Previously, I have been very fortunate to be able to buy nearly every tool I wanted. I've been forced to become more creative with storage, as I'm packed to the gills.
For me, the constraints have always been space. When I started, I bought things without concern for where they would go, since we had more space than we knew what to do with. As that space became accounted for, I needed to evolve my shop to suit the needs of what I was doing.
One of the liberating things I did was to move most of my lumber outdoors until I needed it. It gave me back so floor space in my 15X26 garage that I could then afford to put all of my tools on dedicated wheeled stations to be wheeled out whenever I needed them.
Unfortunately, this led to the realization that I have a lot of things that I just don't use all that often eating up valuable floor space. I actually need to take another swag a yet another bench that is purpose built to hold a lunchbox planer, a drill press, a mortiser, and a sand blasting cabinet...yeah, that's an odd combination!
Visual clutter is another enemy...for another day. If you build storage, you will keep things you shouldn't keep. I am working on that...yeah, really hard, right now... LOL
HI Ellis, When I was 18, I started working in a cabinet shop, where they had every conceivable piece of equipment, including stroke sanders. Since I was making minimum wage of $2.25 per hour, there was no way I could afford one of those, so I build my own. Using discarded 6 x 96" belts, tearing them down the center gave me two belts. My stroke sander was a crude three-wheeler using pillow-block bearings and hand-turned drums....but, it worked! I later built two stroke sanders (one for a new boss) that used 300" x 8" belts. (Still have one). I turned on a Craftsman tube lathe for some time; it was all I could afford. I'm still turning on my big General, but would love a Robust
A few years ago I redid my shop. I took 1/2 of a 25x25 garage for my shop. I gave my table saw and a LARGE plainer to a friend that does flat work. I still have access to them.
I have two lathes, one Pm 3520 and a jet mini.
As far as tools I try not the buy any new ones unless the old one is used up. I also don't keep a lot of finishes and sand paper around. I live 5 miles form two big box stores.
I big problem is I can't seem to get rid of cut offs from highly figured wood. I must have 6 plastic tubs full. One day I will find a use fro them,LOL
I seem to tool up to meet my ambitions! I have maxed out my little shop and just sold my big lathe........but I have a bigger one on order at present! I am looking so forward to building a bigger shop........when I move from the house we are in at present........may take a while to see it come to fruition, but I am tired of having to move 15 things just to do another step in a project, and then have to move them back and perhaps even more for the next step.
I need room to process and store turning wood and I will always do flatwork as well.......so I am keeping my tools.......even the radial arm saw, that gets rare use any more, but I have it when I do need it!
I plan to do segmenting at some point when I get the room to do all the glue ups and such.....one has to have space for all that, and at present, that is an issue for me.
I own up to being another tool junkie. Why make a bead with a gouge when you can get a beading tool? Same for those captive rings... I also tool up for the future. When Don Derry first came to the islands. I thought his hollowing rig was amazing and bought one. Thought I would make hollow forms when I got good enough at making bowls. It was nearly ten years later that I made my first hollow form, with that same hollowing rig. Any kind of embellishment can "require" its own set of specialized tools. It was about six months before I finally used the Sorby box making scraper, but am now amazed why I haven't thought about cutting the side and the bottom at the same time. I figure you only live once, so why not get that specialized tool if you can afford it. That is why I put stuff I make up for sale--so I can buy more tools!!!
Not the right question for me as I too like David am an admitted tool junkie. Like not having to change jaws with enough chucks, having multiple lathes to keep different systems on is also a plus. And you can never have enough Thompson Tools!
I'd love to be a tool junkie, but I just can't afford it!
My dad started turning back in the 1940's in Junior-High shop class, and made furniture his whole life, so I was around tools and lathes as long as I can remember. I have a lamp I made with my dad on his Rockwell Delta gap bed lathe in 1967, when I was 7 years old.
After many years away from turning, my first "lathe" was a 1955 ShopSmith, with a very basic set: a gouge, a skew, a diamond point tool, and a parting tool. I had an old McCulloch chain saw, and for creating bowl blanks, a splitting maul, and a hand axe. Sometimes I'd refine the billet with a 1" wood chisel. Drive center, dead cup center and a faceplate -- no chuck.
Eventually, I upgraded to a name-brand lathe with a 1" x 8 tpi spindle, and a Supernova chuck with 4 sets of jaws, and acquired a band saw. About 10 years ago I upgraded to a Powermatic 3520B, and I inherited a larger band saw and a Stronghold chuck after my dad died in 2004.
Aside from investing in a number of modern gouges and hand tools for hollowing, and an 8" grinder, that's pretty much my setup now. I have a mini lathe for demos and farmers markets, and I own an 1880's pattern makers lathe that I have never used, and have not seen in almost 10 years, having set it up in a group shop about 35 miles away. I cut logs with a chain saw, sometimes trim it up on the band saw, and turn almost everything between centers to balance the figure. I still trim spindle and end grain hollow form blanks with an axe and a wood chisel, though! The old ShopSmith is used for flat bevel sharpening on a 12" disk sander, and will probably evolve to a drill press, since I don't have one, and I'll build or buy a 4" belt sander sharpener for my flat bevels.
I turned for 5 years in an unheated garage, then 10 years in a horse barn. Living in Northern Vermont, this severely limits my ability to turn in the Winter. When working on Christmas gifts, I sometimes bring my most-used tools indoors to keep them warm before heading out into the barn, which can help a lot. I need to build a heated shop space next!