Well as some of you may remember I bought some plastic tubes to decant the finish into to save it. Well the good news is they didn't deteriorate or fall apart from the finish. The bad news is the finish cured inside the tube. The finish left in the can is also starting to go bad now. So obviously I don't use this finish often enough to use it up before it goes bad.
I had the same problem with Waterlox. I still use lacquer during the warmer days of the year but in the winter I just can't spray it. Small items like Christmas ornaments and wine stoppers I can wipe on the lacquer and get a good finish but on larger items it won't work.
Have you tried those accordian containers Lee Valley sells? They sell them specifically for storing finish. You compress them in size to remove the air before putting on the lid. It's listed on the site, but marked as "temporarily unavailble". Don't know when that will be, but you can always give them a call.
Around the same time that you shared this experiment, I showed what I thought would be the answer....large syringes with neoprene plungers. This effort also turned out to be a failure.
Craig I tried those many years ago with Waterlox. Same results. Apparently you can only store the stuff for so long or plastic lets air get into it. Not sure what is the culprit for sure.
I used to use containers similar to this for photo chemicals as well. They all work to a degree and will extend the life for a while but sooner or later the chemicals go bad anyway.
Timely post, John. Last night I opened a pint can of homemade satin WOP that I treated with Bloxygen at least two years ago. Though there was some gelling on the bottom, the WOP was completely usable. Contrasting that to the untreated can that became COMPLETELY set over the same time period, I believe that the evidence is compelling. Bloxygen SEEMS expensive until one compares it to the cost of a completely ruined can of finish.
My experience has been the same as you state with Bloxygen. The secret to it's cost is to understand that it is heavier than air, so you don't need to remove all the air left in the container. A thin layer of the ARGON gas is all that is needed. So a little dab will do ya!
It is also best to store these finishes that need this treatment in glass container not plastic.
Tung Oil in any finish will crust over and therefore become bad in no time. I have 2 glass 1/2 pint jars on a shelf in shop as a test that I put 1 one second blast of bloxygen into. I actually used 2 short blast that come close to one second each. You cannot see it, so you have to use imagination and angle it so it stops in the jar but forces air out so the argon can take its place.
The 2 jar with tung oil finish are still good, one jar without bloxygen went bad in just hours.
Also, it's easier if you have no air movement in the area when doing this.
Yesterday, I was using Minwax Satin WOP from a can I can't remember when I bought, but likely at least 5 years ago. Made in USA, 946 ml with black plastic snap opening. Have used half of can and it is still perfect. I use rarely as a finish. Is stored in a wall cabinet right under my infrared heater in garage shop. In winter when not working in shop, garage is at about 50F.
I forgot I had written the date of purchase on the can. It's about 1/3 left and starting to thicken. I guess in reality a year and half isn't bad for an $11 dollar can of finish.
Here is another solution. I have used Stop Loss Bags with great success for Minwax Antique Oil (MAO). I haven't tried them with wipe on poly but can't imagine that these bags won't work wonderfully. These are thick mylar bags with a screw top. I bought mine on the internet. The design allows you to squeeze the air out of the bag. I pour out the amount of finish that I need and then squeeze out the air and recap it. MAO has lasted without any change for over six months. Once it is emptied it can be easily cleaned and reused. I am a happy consumer and have no relationship with the company.
I have also used Bloxygen (actually wine preservative that is the same argon gas) and it works OK with containers that have small snap on caps. Large open cans apparently don't seal well enough and the finish always skins over for me.
I received a couple of StopLossBags for our club to test. Unfortunately we aren't blessed with a lot of highly qualified "Testers" so we haven't accumulated much knowledge about them yet. They look to me like they would work. A little pain to use, but seem to make sense.
(No affiliation with this product or company.)
PS: Sorry, I just realized this may be the same product David Gilbert is speaking of.