Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

dust collector duct noise

Posts

dust collector duct noise

#1

dust collector duct noise

John Lucas

When I installed my new 2300 cfm dust collector I was very excited. That thing really sucks, literally . Here's my problem. I used solid duct work for most of the duct. I did put a flexible piece going up to the lathe. It is very noisy. I'm guessing it's from the corregated pipe I used to connect the large intake duct. I'm not sure I can install solid pipe because I do need to adjust it's position to either get it out of the way or bring it closer while sanding.

Any suggestions. It's loud enough to be really annoying after a few hours of work.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: dust collector duct noise

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, are you talking about plastic tubing with spiral wound wire support? I use 5 ft length of this at my lathe and it produces no noise. I wonder if you have debris or a scrap of the tubing inside the tube that flaps in the airflow.

Dennis

Re: dust collector duct noise

#3

Re: dust collector duct noise

John Lucas

Don't have any debris in there. I just checked it a while back because I was having old sandpaper get stuck in a few places reducing the airflow. I cleaned it out and don't do that anymore. I may remove the coiled hose and have just the steel pipe and see if the noise changes. It's a whooshing noise that sounds like air running over the corrugated surface, unless I'm grossly mistaken. This has twice the airflow of my older 1100 cfm unit and that's part of the reason.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#4

Re: dust collector duct noise

Dick Coers

You have 3 options. Increase duct size, decrease air flow, or change the size of the opening or shape of the opening. Do you have 4" duct all the way to the collector? If so, the velocity is probably too high.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#5

Consider a muffler?

Mike Jones

http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/muffler.cfm

Re: dust collector duct noise

#6

Re: smooth wall hose

Steve Criscenzo

John

If after your test you determine that the flex hose is the problem, consider getting the flex hose with a smooth inner surface. It is not quite as flexible but the air flow is much better.

Steve

Re: dust collector duct noise

#7

Re: smooth wall hose

John Lucas

Steve where do you find the smooth wall flex hose?

Re: dust collector duct noise

#8

Re: smooth wall hose

Bill Gasper

Try using some of the flexible aluminum duct used for dryer venting. It is much smoother walled than other flex hoses. I have some at the business end of my DC and it works great (quiet). It also is more rigid than regular flex and stays put.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#9

Re: dust collector duct noise

Barry Irby

A couple of things you might try.

Open another port somewhere else in the shop and see if that helps.

And if the noise is related to the main duct vibrating, you might try isolating the unit form the ducts with a short piece of flex.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#10

Re: smooth wall hose

John Lucas

I haven't tried that but it's probably too flexible. I some regular aluminum pipe collapse on me with the force of the vacuum when I closed a gate. Doubt that's any stronger.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#11

Chuck Jones - West TN

I have same problem

Chuck Jones - West TN

John, I'm going to watch this thread carefully because I have the same problem. I just re-plumbed my entire shop with 4" thin wall pvc and a short flex hose connected to each tool. I have a "big gulp" at my lathe. I still have the 1100 cfm blower and it's still in the attic. It's doing a good job, but the air noise at the lathe is entirely too loud.

Fifty odd years ago I was on a naval base in a barracks near a hanger where they tested jet engines. Very similar.

I'm going to have to put some chicken wire over the big gulp so I don't have to go out in the woods to retrieve my sand paper. 8)

I'm pretty sure my flex hose is the "smooth" kind. Came from PSI.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#12

Re: smooth wall hose

Steve Criscenzo

John

I have had it for years. I will have to dig a bit to find where I got it. It is plastic, smooth on the inside with round "ribs" on the outside. The ribs are not spiral, just round plastic hoops molded into the hose. I will give it a look to try to find the source.

Steve

Re: dust collector duct noise

#13

Re: I have same problem *LINK*

John Lucas

Chuck I did a test this morning. Not very conclusive but it seems like the big gulp dust hood is a pretty big player in this problem. It amplifies the sound. I removed it and the corrugated hose itself seems to be much quieter. Then I went down to the floor where the hard pipe is and removed the rubber hose. It was hard to tell since the environment of the floor was different but it seemed quiter.

So when I have time I may rig up a better way to get the 4" hose close to the work and do away with the big Gulp collector. Then I might try rigging solid pipe up to a point and using the shortest flexible pipe I can and if I'm lucky I'll find some flexible pipe that's smoother inside.

To bad Dr Swim retired from the University. He did tests for the navy on moving air silently for submarines and is probably one of the top engineers in this area of research. Another opportunity passed up years ago that might have saved me this headache.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/DBGULP.html

Re: dust collector duct noise

#14

smooth hose *LINK*

John Lucas

It doesn't say so in the website but in their catalog the Standard duty hose says

"Standard Duty transparent hose is made of medium weight PvC with a smooth innner surface for minimal friction loss and excellent resistance to abrasion.

I may try to order a 10 foot section and see.


http://woodworker.com/25-x-10-clear-pvc-renfrcd-hose-mssu-124-718.asp?search=124733&searchmode=2

Re: dust collector duct noise

#15

Re: smooth hose

Ron Bauer

One thing that is a significant contributor to noise in moving a lot of air is the transition from the room to the pick up duct. Any sharp edge will create turbulence and consequently noise. The "perfect" pick up would be shaped like a trumpet bell with a gradual transition and no sharp edges. If that can be attained you will get a much more efficient and quiet system. Unfortunately I don't know where such a thing can be found. Ron.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#16

Re: smooth hose

Mike Brazeau

Could be turned from a segmented setup. On the way to the Louisville symposium my wife and I stopped into the Air Force Museum in Dayton. Wright Bothers had two wind tunnels that were made up from laminated wood and turned in a trumpet shape.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#17

I think you are right about the Big Gulp

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

John,

When I got to the shop this morning I discovered that I did not have the PSI flex hose on this connection like I thought. The PSI hose is "different" meaning it looks like it is smoother on the inside. I was in a hurry to do some turning and I didn't follow good testing procedure, i.e., changed two things at once. Following your lead I took my Big Gulp off and put the PSI flex hose on without the Big Gulp. Huge improvement. But I couldn't come up with a quick way to fasten the hose at the lathe. The way I tried it, it didn't pick up much. I put the Big Gulp back on and the noise is about half as bad as before I started messing with it.

My test is definitely not scientific but I think you are on to something about the Big Gulp. It's a shame too because it really helps with the pickup. I'm going to play with it some more later. Have to turn some ornaments first.

Thanks for your help.

Chuck

Re: dust collector duct noise

#18

Re: dust collector duct noise

robo hippy

Well, I don't have a big gulp type hood, only my barrel section that I put on when turning bowls. There is, supposedly, as much noise generated by air flow as there is by the motor and impeller blades. The sound is just a woosh, and not much more, and I have a 3 hp Oneida system. Most of the time, my radio is louder than the dust collector. If some one is near by, I can talk with a raised voice, but not a shout. I am curious about noise levels. I have noticed when turning the insides of bowls, and I am standing directly in front of it, the noise is amplified.

robo hippy

Re: dust collector duct noise

#19

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: I think you are right about the Big Gulp

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Chuck, I have a 5 ft piece of flex hose with a band clamp on it about a foot from the free end and a strong rare earth magnet epoxied to the clamp. I can position the end of the hose just about anywhere I want by moving the magnet to an appropriate point on the steel lathe bed. WFM.

Dennis

Re: dust collector duct noise

#20

Re: I think you are right about the Big Gulp

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

Dennis,

Good idea. I have one setting up right now.

Thanks,

Re: dust collector duct noise

#21

Re: dust collector duct noise

Jeff Smith

A few years ago, Fine Woodworking did tests on dust collectors and their apparatus included a hose termination shaped like a trumpet bell that was said to maximize the measured suction of the systems. If I remember correctly, it was said to reduce the turbulence of the air going into the hose/system. Seems like that would reduce noise, too.

Now where would a turner come across a round, trumpet-bell shaped item?...seems like I should have kept a few of the funnels I turned during my McNaughton Learning Curve.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#22

what happened to the Powermatic collector

John Lucas

A few years ago Powermatic had a dust collector hood that was very aerodynamic. It had a center brace that looked like a wing and the rest of the hood sort of resembled a futuristic air duct. I wanted one but when I first saw them decided I couldn't afford it. Later when I had saved some money I could not find them in the catalog.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#23

Re: what happened to the Powermatic collector

john Veerkamp

What about getting a big plastic funnel and cutting it off and fitting to the 4" hose?

Re: dust collector duct noise

#24

Dennis thanks for the tip.

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

I finally got a hose and magnet married up like you suggested and I'm liking it better than the big gulp. Had trouble getting a magnet epoxied to the clamp so I bought one inclosed in a metal cup like you sometimes see with a clip. It has a hole in the center so I fastened it to a clamp with a small bolt. Only size magnet they had like that is rated 95 pounds. The only problem is I have to call my wife to help me get it off the lathe. :)

Thanks again.

Re: dust collector duct noise

#25

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Dennis thanks for the tip.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

You are welcome Chuck. In my brief description I omitted some details. My magnet is epoxied to a somewhat larger flat steel washer which, in turn, is wired to the band clamp through four holes drilled at the edges of the washer. I too had trouble getting a good bond between the flexible band and the magnet.