Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Thin Turning Advice

Posts

Thin Turning Advice

#1

Thin Turning Advice

Charlie Drake

I normally don't turn very thin bowls but I'm in the process of turning a thin (less than 1/8 inch) segmented bowl (from very hard to rather soft pieces). Even with a steady rest and very sharp tools, the chatter is quite bad with the accompanying "ripples". Does anyone have any advice for turning such items or should I just expect to have to get out the coarse sandpaper? Thanks for any advice you might extend.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#2

Re: Thin Turning Advice

John Lucas

Is it a bowl and not a hollow vessel. I turned some very thin bowls using the Bowl from a Board method of segmented work. The chatter was terrible. You need to do the obvious which is thin from the rim down a few inches leaving the rest thick and then gradually work your way down. don't go back to the rim it can easily explode because the flexing of the bowl will pull the wood into the tool and you get what amounts to a catch with very bad results.

What I did was to hot glue stabilizers to the outside while I turned the inside. I cut pieces of 1/4" plywood so that the shape roughly matched the shape of the outside of the vessel and the bottom end was roughly the shape of my chuck. So in effect I had a piece of wood that ran down the bowl and up the chuck. I left it about 2" wide (by 1/4" thick of course). Then I hot glued this to the bowl. I put a bead along the bottom and stick this to the bowl and then apply a little more along the edges to make the joint stronger. I made 4 of them. It sounds like a huge fan when you turn the lathe on and is quite scary because of this. However it did fantastic things to stabilize the bowl and I was able to turn them less than 1/8" thick. They were about 12" in diameter and 6" to 8" deep.

You need to finish the outside so the glue will be easier to get off. I just used lacquer. It can be hand sanded afterwords if necessary before applying a final finish but I found that once I cleaned the glue off I only had to touch it up with 600 grit and then apply more finish.

Removing the stabilizers can be challenging because the bowl is so thin. First I peel off what i can with my fingers and maybe a screw driver near the chuck where you don't have to worry about damaging the wood. Then I use a piece of fishing line or thin wire tied to two handles so you can sort of "saw" through the glue between the bowl and stabilizer. Once this is removed peel off all you can with your fingernails and rubbing with your fingers. Then use alcohol to remove the rest. It really wasn't that hard to remove them.

With normal segmented rings you might have a problem with the glue joints being so small. On the Bowl from a board your only glue joint is the ring to ring attachment so it's pretty strong. Still I think the turning will be the same. I didn't use any scrapers other than a very light shear scrape. A good sharp negative rake scraper might do the job but I didn't have one back then.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#3

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Barry L Elder

Sounds like you are turning a disaster in the making. Dissimilar woods don't play nice. Try to just use sanding instead of gouges. Hope you are successful in your turning! :D

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#4

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Dick Coers

Extremely sharp tools, in this case, honing each pass will help. Loosen your grip. I used to get stressed making those delicate cuts and would clench up. Now I take a breath to calm myself, and let the tool just make the cut. It also helps to not rub the bevel too hard. You can also play with rpm. It will change the harmonics of the piece and can get you in a better zone.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#5

Re: Thin Turning Advice

John Lucas

Barry oversanding dissimilar woods will leave a very lumpy surface. I try to get the wood down to final size and hopefully clean enough to start sanding with no courser than 180, preferably 220. If you have an area with tearout use a round cabinet scraper with the lathe off. Work on just that area. When you get the tearout out then go to whatever sandpaper you need. that keeps you from using really course sandpaper

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#6

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Craig Daymon

I have a bowl that was turned by a turner, Mike Kutterbach (I might not have the spelling right), that is about 1/16" thick. (I might even have a bit of a video showing him making one, but can't get to it right now.)

As others have mentioned, sharp tools are essential. If you are seeing chatter, that will likely prove challenging to get past now that it is relatively thin, but not impossible.

If you are turning the inside, I frequently support the outside with my hand to reduce vibration/chatter. Going thin does require working in much the same way as creating a hollowform, reducing the inside to final thickness in steps. The thinner you plan to go, the smaller the steps.

The turner I mentioned would start by shaping the outside, then getting a smooth curve on the inside, matching the outside. He would then create a jam chuck, reverse the bowl, taping the (thicker) lip to the jam chuck. (I forget if he ran a light through the headstock to light the inside, which would be helpful. LED being best for this.) He would then finess the outside with a cabinet scraper to bring it to final thickness. OUTSIDE ONLY for the cabinet scraper, as the scar on my wrist can attest!

You might also keep a spray bottle of distilled water near to wet the surface as you work, especially if using a light to illuminate it.

Hope some of this is helpful.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Lyle Jamieson

Caution using your hand for support with segmented thin work. If or when it comes apart in small fragments it can shred your fingers. Solid wood turning would likely crack with the vibration but segments will come apart with the grain going every-witch-way.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#8

Brad Vietje

Good Advice -- Mike Mode, Anyone?

Brad Vietje

Good advice.

Is there a video of Michael Mode out there anywhere? He's pretty darned impressive in his thin laminated bowls, which he's been making since the late 70's early 80's. I saw him turn one of these and reverse turn the bottom in his shop about 10 years ago. He uses a 1/4" bowl gouge with a very steep, nearly vertical face on the "left" (with flute upwards) and a different geometry on the right (for vertical shear scraping, if I remember correctly). Very impressive work!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#9

Re: Thin Turning Advice

John Lucas

Not just segmented work. I've used my hand for many years to support the outside while turning the inside of thin work. Last year one blew out and cut a pretty nasty gash in my thumb. That is part of why I developed the outer support system.

sharp tools with no pressure on the bevel are really necessary. Mike Hosaluk turns extremely thin bowls to show people how it's done. He has about the lightest touch on a gouge I've ever seen.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#11

John, have you tried reheating hot melt

david

glue to remove pieces stuck together? Have to reheat carefully, but can be done on very thin pieces.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#12

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Craig Daymon

Sorry, I missed the segmented part. Mike Kutterbach was turning bowls from a solid piece of wood.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#13

Thin wall dry turning

Geoff Whaling

Keep in mind that most thin wall turners use wet wood. Segmented work is built up from well seasoned air dried or even kiln dried timbers. Kiln drying changes the properties of some timbers effectively case hardening or changing the "temper" of the timbers. Dry timbers do not flex well and are nowhere near as forgiving as wet/green timbers – hence the severe vibration and harmonics.

Size matters! I have a lot of respect for turners who successfully turn large thin walled dry segmented works. Larger thin wall turnings require some form of stabilisation. Have a look at Malcolm Tibbett’s DVD’s and turners like Michael Mode etc.

I turn thin wall (0.8 – 1.2mm) goblet cups and small bowls from linear laminations, so many of my cuts on goblets are effectively end grain hollowing which increases harmonics. Try to turn the complete piece using only the one mounting with no reverse mounting except for very light refining cuts on the base only to remove nubs.

Use very sharp tools & very light cuts, only kissing the bevel. Turn a significant section of the outside profile first but leave very substantial support in the base. Then turn the inside, progressing down in steps. It pays to be meticulous with measuring wall thickness as once you move on it is neigh on impossible to go back and finesse a cut. Then refine the outside once the inside is complete.

Aim to turn and shear scrape a section to near finished thickness before stepping down, and to use minimal sanding as any lateral pressure from rubbing the bevel of the tool or sanding increases risk substantially on dry thin turnings. One other thing I have noticed is how rubbery a bowl becomes when nitro cellulose sanding sealer is applied. Be very careful when hand applying sanding sealers or using any thinners/solvents as the glue joints are miniscule..

NEVER stabilise the outside of a segmented bowl with your hand while turning as it is high risk with potentially nasty hand injuries. Shattered segmented pieces tend to perform like blunt circular saw blades.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#14

Brad Vietje

Stabilize With Cloth ???

Brad Vietje

I wonder if some sort of external stabilization device that used a piece of cloth against the wood (as opposed to wheels, for example) would be helpful ? Wouldn't mar the wood, and might just add a little extra polish to each area being worked (?) I'm imagining a folded length of terry cloth or hand towel held at upper and lower ends, and held against the wood with very slight tension... hmmm, may have to try that someday.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#15

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Stabilize With Cloth ???

Lyle Jamieson

I would not use my hands. You see it all the time and I do it myself rarely...but its wet wood. If you try it and something goes wrong you will have a BIG story to tell about the injuries.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: Stabilize With Cloth ???

Brad Vietje

Indeed! I meant some sort of contraption like a bowl steady with a cloth belt or pad instead of wheels -- certain;y not hand-held. In fact, I wonder if a painting pad applied with hardly any force at all would help with the ringing vibrations ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#17

Rubber bands

John Lucas

I tried putting several large rubber bands around a thin piece once and was amazed how much it reduced the chatter and vibrations. Not sure why it works but it does. I had forgotten about that until you mentioned the cloth.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re: Rubber bands

Alan Zenreich

There is also a technique where the segmented bowl outside is turned, then the entire piece is cast in wax. The outside is then turned to a cylinder and work can proceed on the inside. After all the turning is done, the wax is melted off.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#19

Re: Thin Turning Advice

Charlie Drake

I truly appreciate everyone taking the time to respond to my post. Another reason I always pull up this website every morning to see what the experts are saying. Happy Holidays and Merry Christmas to all!

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#20

definitions of an expert

John Lucas

Break the word down Ex is Unknown and Spert is a drip under pressure so An Expert is an Unknown drip under pressure.

the other definition I like is Expert is anyone more than 10 miles away from home or anyone on the internet

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#21

Re: Rubber bands

john Veerkamp

I use vinyl electrical tape to dampen vibrations. I think that the stretchability, like the rubber bands, stiffens the wood enough.

Re: Thin Turning Advice

#22

I concur with my learned colleague.  :-)