Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Terminology Question?

Posts

Terminology Question?

#1

Terminology Question? 

Mike Potts

After 2 days of hanging around the house in my jammies and out of the cold, I went down to the shop fired up the wood burner and turned,sanded and put 1 coat of finish on this bowl. It's made from Ash that has been laying in my woods since 09/2012. the bowl is 8 1/2" x 2 3/4" walls 1/8". my Question is there must be a name for this shaped bowl. " fluted" "flared" come to my mind, but I dought if I'm right.

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Terminology Question?

#2

Brad Vietje

Ogee ?

Brad Vietje

Here's one:

Many people have made them, my inspiration was Bert Marsh.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Terminology Question?

#3

Re: Terminology Question? 

Phillip Medghalchi

Mike I am not sure if you arfe finished with it and if you can remount it back on your chuck again. look at the pic. bellow and you will see your curve is broken and the second pic. is a sample of what you wanted to achieve in your case or if you want true ogee then print Brad's example and then try to copy it so you can get the feel of the curve. Hope you don't take this the wrong way.




Re: Terminology Question?

#4

I like the shape the way I turned it.

Mike Potts

Actually Phillip the shape is exactly as I wanted it. that little curve in the middle is what I wanted. It may not be what you like but and you certainly have the right to your opinion. As I have the right to mine.

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Terminology Question?

#5

Re: I like the shape the way I turned it.

Curt Stivison

I kinda like the bump.

Re: Terminology Question?

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Terminology Question?

Brad Vietje

P.M. -- I don't think the drawing is what he was after at all. That flared shape was popularized by Richard Raffan in the 80's, and is still fun to make, of course, but I don't see how it relates to the bowl Mike made.

I suspect a gentle "S" curve, sort of laid on its side, or angled, is more like the ogee curved bowls. These are soooo hard to get exactly right, and the one I posted could be improved quite a bit (by curving in more at the bottom). I've made a few attempts that were "close, but no cigar", and a few that were just what I was after, but I've lost most of my photos :( It is fun to make a series of bowls that are slight variations on a theme, and you can really nail the shape you're after, or it can help you decide what shape you really want -- I sometimes don't really know until I make a few that don't quite "do it" for me, and then I try to figure out why/how they fall short.

There are some great shapes in Raffan's Turned Bowl Design, which is getting pretty old, and could use a new edition with better photos.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Terminology Question?

#7

Re: Terminology Question?

Clifton C

Brad, Raffans update of Turned Bowl Design (1987) was updated with

The Art of Turned Bowls (2008). I have the latter, I'd like to get them both

together to see what was thought important in 87 and see what the

changes have been. No joy at the library but still looking...

cc

Re: Terminology Question?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Terminology Question?

Lyle Jamieson

You are blazing new trails here. Not many attempt that shape. It is hard to get it right. You certainly have close to nailed it. On the outside I would call it a double ogee. An ogee is a concave surface next to a convex surface. You have a concave-convex-concave line. The only thing I would do to try to improve it would be to refine the line right under the rim. There is a slight flat spot, unless the camera angle is masking it. Curved lines tend to be more exciting than straight lines. Nice job.

Re: Terminology Question?

#9

Re: Terminology Question?

Mike Potts

Thank you Lyle, you have a very good eye, it did get a little flat where i came out of the second ogee, I was concentrating more on flaring the the rim out. I must give credit where credit is due. without your utube videos and your BOWL BASIC MADE EASY DVD I would not be attempting bowls like this.

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Terminology Question?

#10

Re: Terminology Question?

Mike Potts

Clifton, I found both on Amazon pretty pricey for the older one. here is the link.

http://www.amazon.com/Richard-Raffan/e/B00DQ66A3G/ref=sr_ntt_srch_lnk_3?qid=1416537302&sr=8-

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Terminology Question?

#11

I had a feeling

Phillip Medghalchi

...............that you may take offense by my comment. You are exactly right, it is yours and you do with it as you please.

I thought to give you some idea for your next project. Ogee, is like what Brad did, and some tuners are drawn to it and some not. and the one I drew for you is the one that many professionals do. The whole thing is about Aesthetics, however, at the end of the day what pleases you is what counts.

You have done well for the while you are turning. I thought I just give help so you can see what others can see. And I added that "I hoped you didn't mind".

When I post something I do want a true critique (not atta boy) , so it helps me to improve my vision at the lathe for next project. And, most of the time the angle of camera does not help the viewers to see the truth about the piece created.

In most cases seeing the actual piece and touching it brings whole new meaning to the piece that can not be felt by a picture

Re: Terminology Question?

#12

Re: Terminology Question?

Barry Irby

When I opened the post only the top half of the picture was on the screen. I looked at the vase(?) behind your bowl and thought "that's not ash" and then I scrolled down. At first I could not see the bowl at all.

If the convex shape at the one third point were moved down a bit and then flowed back under the bottom making the bowl what I guess you would call an Ogee, it would have been what I call a serpentine bowl. As you have it now I don't think that fits.

Lyle is right about the flat under the rim.

I think the bowl would look better with a smaller foot. Smaller in diameter that is.

Re: Terminology Question?

#13

Flared double ogee

david

is what I would call the outside. Hard to tell from the photo if the inside reflects the outside shape.

Re: Terminology Question?

#14

If you want to learn good bowl design

John Lucas

Get Richard Raffen's book. It is fantastic. I don't remember if he gives a name to the shapes but he sure has some wonderful examples.

However as was mentioned above we should all feel free to experiment and create our own shapes. Although most of the better shapes have been proven over the years and Richard's book really shows how it's done.

Re: Terminology Question?

#15

Re: If you want to learn good bowl design

Barry L Elder

Aw, come on, John! You know as well as I do that all bowl shapes came from Eve and all her sisters. I think you have studied as many ladies as I have and I mean no disrespect to all our ladies, but they demonstrate all the shapes of all bowls. :D

Re: Terminology Question?

#16

Re: If you want to learn good bowl design

Phillip Medghalchi

Barrrrrrrrrrrrry. be nice now. :)

Re: Terminology Question?

#17

Not with a 10 foot pole wii I touch that 


Re: Terminology Question?

#18

I have a 20' pole for not touching that, twice


Re: Terminology Question?

#19

Raffan - which one though?

Rum

By Raffan, Richard Art of Turned Bowls, The: Designing Spectacular Bowls with a World- Class Turner (2008) Paperback...

By Raffan, Richard Turned-Bowl Design (1987) Paperback

Turning Bowls with Richard Raffan Mar 1, 2002

Re: Terminology Question?

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re:This one............

Jesper, Denmark

By Raffan, Richard Turned-Bowl Design (1987) Paperback

Re: Terminology Question?

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: If you want to learn good bowl design

Jesper, Denmark

Once we have disposed of the juvenile snickers, it is not a silly concept.

They are mostly catenary curves - curves with ever changing radii, which are well known to be pleasing to the eye.