Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

Posts

Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#1

Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

Keith Newton

Rather than asking what finish is safe for people to eat out of, I would rather hear what finishes hold up best when used for serving food.

I've don't usually get to see most of the bowls that go off to people's homes, to see how they held up after years of use, but I do care about how they hold up. A good finish would need to be pretty good to not be penetrated by all the water usually in a salad, not to mention with vinegar and oil poured over it, then not cleaned up for a couple of hours after a party.

I have gotten calls from clients who had water glass circles show up on table tops. And my sister served blackened salmon on paper plates once, that the steam trapped under the fish left a filet shape under every plate. That was through a sprayed catalyzed varnish.

I'd rather hear a discussion about what finishes some of you know will hold up, and or that you know will look like crud after a little exposure to getting wet, or oils.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#2

Steven Antonucci

A different answer

steven antonucci

I think your question is good, but I propose a different answer to it.

Rather than starting with a "great looking finish" that degrades to something else, I take the approach of a finish that will essentially not change much over time at all. In a great many of my bowls, that means that they get two coats of BLO and they are done.

I do this for two reasons. If something is shiny, not only does it wear (and you may get the chemistry questions...which many people are not qualified to ask or answer), but I've also been told "oh, it's too nice to use..." A salad bowl that never sees a salad is a failure in my book.

The second reason I do this simple finish is that it doesn't show those little stains and marks anywhere near as much as a high finish would. I have a bowl that was originally mineral oil finish, but today is probably 90% finished with microwave popcorn "butter" (or whatever it actually is). For all of the talks about various oils going rancid, I've never seen it or smelled it. Most of the bowls I make get wiped with a paper towel unless there saw something messy in it, then a dot of dish detergent and a little water.

For me, making something that will fail through normal wear and tear just doesn't make sense. If you can see your face the finish, put a spotlight on it...not a salad in it.

Steve

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: A different answer

Lyle Jamieson

I agree Steve, A used wood utensil takes on the character of use. It gets stained, scratched, worn in pleasing ways and patterns. Celebrate a used bowl. Mineral oil or no finish at all works just fine for me. You don't put a finish on your butcher block, at least I don't. I remember years ago the first time I walked into Mike Mahoney's home and there sets this huge cherry bowl with Guacamole in it.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#4

Re: A different answer

mjonesrdg

Steve A. wrote: Rather than starting with a "great looking finish" that degrades to something else, I take the approach of a finish that will essentially not change much over time at all. In a great many of my bowls, that means that they get two coats of BLO and they are done.

Rephrased, his idea is to do a half-a** finish on the bowl when new. That way it will always remain a half-a** finish.

Boiled Linseed oil, used straight, is very soft (almost as soft as walnut oil) and liquids run through it like it is not even there. It is the least water resistant of the oils typically used by us wood turners. A finish like this will leave the surface of the wood vulnerable to staining, water spotting, abrasion and scratching. And those are just aesthetic concerns.

It behooves me to do the very best that I can do to prevent failure of my work. For a utility bowl, the first order of business is to seal the wood against liquid penetration. I'll top-coat my sealer with a finish that is water resistant enough to be used on high-end boat decks and bright-work and hard enough to be used on hardwood floors.

(And, if you don't prefer "shiny", you can always rub the top-coat with steel wool)


img

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#5

Re: My test

Steve Criscenzo

About five years ago I was interested in how finishes would hold up with use. I turned a couple of maple bowls for use in my home. I chose maple because of its light color. I finished one with a single application of Minwax Antique Oil and the other with another Tung oil (I think it was GF Seal a Cell). I have used both bowls often for over five years. They have been used for salads with dressing, tomato sauce based dishes and lots of other "staining" foods. The bowls have developed a patina but have not stained. After use, they get washed and dried but I have done nothing else to enhance the finish. They have become cherished utensils in our kitchen.

I agree that with utility items less finish is better and surface finishes should be avoided. However, I think a penetrating oil finish can provide some protection to avoid staining.

When I sell utility bowls I let folks know how they are finished and they will get a patina with use and age. I convey that as a positive. I have had no complaints.

Steve

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#6

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

Bill Jacksonville, NC

I go with no finish or mineral oil.

Rolling pins, hard Maple wood with no finish people simply wipe down with wrung out damp towel after use. I was given the proper cleaning and care class by a customer that ordered assortment of French and convention rolling pins.

Salad eating & mixing bowls mineral oil, people reapply as needed. I do supply one bottle free. Next bottle is on them. Again customers know how to clean and care for their bowls. If do not do not sell to them.

That kind of stuff is a special order item on other bowls use a film finish.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#7

Re: A different answer

John Lucas

I don't consider things like walnut oil a half ass finish at all. In my experience any finish that builds on the surface will fail eventually. An oil finish can either be rejuvenated with the application of more oil or as Steve said will pick up its own patina.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#8

Steven Antonucci

don't forget the half a$$ sanding job too 

steven antonucci

On a good day, I'll sand to 240 and work on getting most of the tool marks out. The end grain can occasionally show a blotchy spot because I frankly just don't care.

And neither does anyone else...who is considering buying it for use.

There is a level of sanity that needs to be considered in the work. It's going to hold guacamole. It's not going to be in the Smithsonian. Making a bowl that is sanded to 12000 micromesh finish with 8 coats of lacquer can only get ruined. Mine acquires character.

I refinished my table top once. After 10 years of use, it showed a lot of wear. When you have kids who rub forks and plates on the top for no good reason, or forget to not write on it with a magic marker...well, stuff happens. It's only perfect once.

A great number of the bowls I sell through the gallery aren't signed. They aren't dated. Or numbered. They're bowls. Damn good bowls if I do say so myself. The buyers know that I made them,but they didn't buy them because I made them. They bought them to live with them.

And I'm OK with that.

For a really half-assed finish, I do this:


Some of these are not sanded at all, and painted inside and out with milk paint and then burnished with 0000 steel wool... which highlights the tool marks! Gasp! ;)

And I've been using BLO on my spoons, which get stuck in a pot of tomato sauce all of the time, and have no stains and still wash up with a little soap and water with the kitchen scrubber, so it's a much better finish for serving items than you think?

To each his own...

Steve

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#9

A recent test run by a club member...

Lloyd in Mississauga

One of the guys in our club was looking to try out Waterlox on his salad bowls rather than his normal General Salad Bowl Finish.

He cover half the outside of the bowl with each product, a couple of coats and said once they were done you could not tell which half was which as both had a bit of shine. He them left the bowl out on the patio table for few months this summer.

When he brought the bowl into the club, the Waterlox side was dull, though the wood did not look dried or checked, while the salad bowl finish side still had a bit of a shine on it.

For change of character in the finish, the Waterlox lost, but both finishes seems to have provided some protection to the wood, even through the abuse of rain and UV.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#10

Full-on respect for you....

mjonesrdg

....and because I have seen some of your other work over the years, I know that you are capable of producing fine finishes. These bowls are less than your best, and it is cool that you can be enough of a "free spirit" to feel just fine about what they are and how they are finished.

(I don't do high build lacquer on utility bowls either.) But, I do lay up 6-8 coats of waterlox or similar and I have 15 year constant service bowls done that way that look like new to this day. My son's walnut bowl (15 years in his possession) gets "renewed" every year or so....(spray coat of Johnson's furniture polish buffed with a soft towel). He tells me that the baby sitter ran it through the dishwasher once too!

No harm done.

That's how I roll. and that's how I teach.

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#11

Steven Antonucci

philosophical difference

Steven antonucci

I just don't see any value in 8 coats of finish?

Aside from the added cost, the added time...how do you recover them? I don't even do this on my friends and family bowls. It would easily double the effort of making a bowl, with no marked improvement in the finished product. My bowls aren't staining either, with at most 2/coats of BLO and 220 grit sanding...

To each his own.

S

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#12

Re: philosophical difference

mjonesrdg

My philosophy is simple: turn the best form that I can, seal the wood with the best practices and product that i can, finish with the best practices and best product that i can, and take as long as it takes. What is your philosophy?

Please don't think that there is no appreciable difference. Two coats of BLO does not even seal the bowl, let alone protect the surface, and any kind and sort of food stuff can, and will be, absorbed into the wood. This can invite bacterial growth.....so your product is food safe, but your bowl is not.

http://blog.woodturnerscatalog.com/2013/04/what-is-oil/

I include here an excerpt from Bob Flexner's article which is available on CSUSA's web site. If you read this, you will find that this finishing expert does not agree with your "philosophy".

I don't know what you mean by "how do I recover" my bowls? As I mentioned in this thread, my bowls can be brightened up by an occasional spray application of a furniture wax/polish, but where they go after they are sold, and how they are cared for i can never know.


img

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#13

Chuck Jones - West TN

Excellent article! Leaves out a lot of the BS.

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Framing the "Food Safe" question differently.

#14

Steven Antonucci

recover...the cost of your time

Steven antonucci

Turning a bowl is probably the fastest part of turning a bowl. Sanding and finishing is probably the most time consuming. Just because you sand it finer and/or add more layers of finish doesn't necessarily mean it has become a better bowl?

To the average person, they probably can't see past 400 grit sanding. I also expect that my disdain for shiny wood stops me at a couple of coats, as after that the oil no longer soaks into the wood. If the wood is saturated with oil, it won't absorb moisture.

If I had all the extra finish time in a bowl, I would need to double my prices...and I would own 1000 unsold bowls.

Any thoughts about bacteria are misguided. Wood is antimicrobial in nature. Google it. It is more hygenic than plastic.

I am not suggesting that you shouldn't finish however you want, but I am suggesting that form and function get limiting returns from finishing.

S