Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Posts

How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#1

How much suck on vacuum chuck?

gtwilkins

G'day All,

I finally got my vacuum pump and assorted bits put together today, I am using an eight inch Vicmarc cup with a Gast pump.

So how much vacuum do I need to pull?

I am working on a 12x6 maple bowl and a 15x4 donut shaped birch bowl. I had the maple bowl on with about 17" and it appeared to be secure but I wasn't using tools on it, just a quick spin to see how it worked.

So any rough rules on size vs. suck or is it all trial and error til you launch something.

Thanks, Trevor

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#2

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Jim Pugh

My experience has been that around 10" of mercury is mighty nice. More than that and you stand the chance of imploding your bowl. I have also found that because of various reasons - including leaky wood - that I frequently have a vacuum of <5" of mercury. One can work with that if very careful.

To give yourself a bit of confidence, put the bowl on the vacuum chuck. lock the spindle, lathe not turning and see what kind of effort it takes to break the bowl loose from the chuck - if you can.

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#3

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Jason Clark

Hold on the vacuum is dependent on 2 factors. Vacuum being pulled (inches of mercury) and surface area that the vacuum is being applied to. I typically use 3" or 4" diameter PVC pipe couplers for my vacuum drums. The 3" coupler provides roughly 7 square inches of surface area. The 4" diameter coupling provides roughly 12 square inches. A rough estimate of PSI can be obtained by dividing the inches of mercury by 2. For the sake of round numbers we'll use 20" of mercury which gives us 10 psi. This doesn't sound like much but that's 10 pounds per square inch. So the 3" diameter coupler yields 70 pounds of air pressure securing the piece, the 4" coupler gives 120 pounds. A change in vacuum pressure (either by leaks, a weaker/stronger pump, or change in elevation) or a change in diameter of the vacuum drum will drastically alter the resulting total pounds of air pressure securing the piece. I usually shoot for 20" mercury but will sometimes dial down the pressure of the piece is thin. Too much pressure can implode a thin piece.

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#4

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Guy Bratt

I use around 15 inches of vacuum on most projects. One other issue affects holding power is leakage through the wood.

If your concerned bring up the tail stock.

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I believe that Jason pretty well summarizes the situation. I would add that you can easily check whether the vacuum is high enough for the chuck and wood being used. With the lathe stopped, see if a REASONABLE force will slide the wood or pull it away from the chuck. If not, you are okay. I seldom have to use as much as 20 in/hg except for very small objects.

Dennis

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#6

Estimating force, plus My method ...

Doc Green

Trevor, your 8" chuck will have an area of about 50 square inches. To find the approximate force pushing the workpiece toward the headstock, take half the vacuum in inches of mercury and multiply by 50.

For example, suppose you have a vacuum of 12" Hg. Half of that is 6. Then, 6 times 50 is 300 pounds.

This is a Lot, but this force is directed straight toward the headstock. Considerably less force will be acting to prevent a sideways movement of your workpiece across the chuck. (Multiply by the coefficient of friction, which may be 0.5 or lower, depending upon the type of seal your are using.)

This is an inherent weakness of vacuum chucking - sideways movement of the workpiece is prevented only by a frictional force. This is where tailstock support comes into play. The point of the live center will prevent the sideways movement.

Basically, a vacuum chuck is just a glorified jam chuck where you use air pressure instead of the tail center to apply the force pushing the workpiece against the fixture. Based on this idea, here's the method I use.

I mount the workpiece (bowl, plate, platter, or whatever) on the vacuum chuck using the point of the tail center to center the workpiece. Then I turn on the vacuum pump to check the seal. When the vacuum is turned on, it will pull the workpiece tighter against the vacuum chuck seal. So, I then tighten the tailstock to take up the slack, so to speak.

Then I turn the vacuum pump OFF and proceed as with a conventional jam chuck, usually to finish the foot of a bowl or whatever. Only when I turn down to a (not too small) nubbin do I turn the vacuum pump On and then remove the tailstock. Once the tailstock is out of the way, I remove the nubbin and finish the foot of the piece.

Using the tailstock in this manner provides the extra security against sideways movement of the workpiece, and, it saves wear and tear on the vacuum pump. Seldom do I need to run the pump for as long as 5 minutes on a given piece.

FWIW ... ~Doc

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#7

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

John Lucas

I use a 4" vacuum chuck for most bowls under 12" I usually se as much vacuum as I can get. Normally around 20"

Due to leakage. I've only imploded one and that one was too thin and never should have been on a vacuum chuck.

When I do platters I use a. 8" chuck and usually back it off to 15"

M not sure why. My platters are usually too thick to implode. I e tried very hard to pull off the chuck and can't. Never had one come off turning but then I don't apply a lot of force across the turning when cutting.

Whenever in doubt use the tailstock. It's not worth losing the bowl or getting hurt

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#8

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

Bill Howatt

I use about a 4 or 4.5" dia plastic pipe coupler for a drum chuck so the area isn't huge. I like to get over 15" but I can use it down to 10", after that I get a bit concerned. The tailstock as a safety device is always a good idea and you can normally leave it in place until you get to the last few cuts.

As mentioned earlier, the force can be appreciable but it is all directed towards the headstock. The only thing that keeps the workpiece from sliding sideways is the friction between the chuck edge which is likely some type of gasket and workpiece. If you have a bowl that "curves around" the drum chuck then the curvature will help too. Fortunately most applications of a vacuum chuck are to clean up the bottoms so the cuts are very light.

Imploding is a concern but for smaller bowls (say, under 12" dia) and a drum chuck under 6" the implosion risk is small unless you really go for thin. Large platters whose size and shape allows them to be used with large dia drum chucks are usually the implosion victims. Regardless, you system should have a valve to bleed air into it to reduce the vacuum if necessary.

It is nice to have a gauge located where you can easily see it from your turning position.

If you are getting too much leakage through your wood apply a coat of finish to the interior.

Bill

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#9

Thanks everyone

gtwilkins

Thank you for the help, finished both bowls today, don't know why I haven't hooked the system up before, it made life so much easier.

I pulled about 15 inches on the 8 inch cup today and I couldn't budge either bowl, could easily get 25 + with the bleeder closed but only tried it for a second or two.

Now to try some offset turning.

Trevor

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#10

Re: Thanks everyone

Pete in Holland MI

My chuck is about 5" diameter. My pump will pull up to 26" Hg, under the right circumstances. I too only use it for light bottom turning.

Couple hints:

- check your system by sucking on a piece of plastic for ultimately vacuum achievable.

- if you suspect porous wood, while vacuum is on, wipe the bowl with sanding saw dust to clog the holes.

- if while finish turning the bowl feels sticky, that's a vacuum leak sucking on your skin. Dust or sand your bowl to clog the pores.

- mount your vacuum gauge where you can easily glance at it while turning to keep track of your vacuum situation. I found an easy to see 6" gauge at a salvage store.

Have fun !

Pete

Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#11

Never thought of the dust trick!


Re: How much suck on vacuum chuck?

#12

What Doc said !