Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Posts

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve,

A motorcycle analogy: A biker wrote in to a magazine about his experience while attending an advanced motorcycle course (roadracing course). He explained how he had been riding for 17 years, and had great expectations of mopping up the track with the newer, less experienced riders. It didn't turn out quite the way he expected; he was the slowest rider on the track, embarrassed by every other rider, all who had far less time in the saddle. He sadly drew this conclusion: "I didn't really have 17 years experience; in reality, I had one year's experience repeated 17 times." He was no better off than when he started. Well, a lot of turners are the same.....they may have attended classes with many big-name turners over the course of several years, and consider themselves pretty competent turners, yet are comparable to the biker I mentioned. Too many times I've had students with 5-8 years of experience that still had difficulty grinding a tool, had no idea of form, and were frankly still producing "beginner" work. So, I always expect people to show up that aren't quite up to par. It helps to check out student's tools....you will learn a LOT about an individual's skill level right off the bat. I start my classes with each turner introducing themselves, showing their work if available, and expressing their goals for the session. Some turners are content to work on just one piece, sanded and finished. If that makes them happy, that's fine. Safety is paramount...no jewelry, no long sleeves. I show people how I do things, how I would overcome a problem. I encourage them to at least try; take what you like, and use it. If not, I don't take it personally.The accumulated knowledge from attending each class will eventually pay off. My philosophy is you can become a better turner NOW..not in five years, not next year. The piece you are turning right now, and each subsequent piece, should be the best you are capable of.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#27

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

phillip Medghalchi

Keith, I think, Steve sets his expectations too high, then he gets disappointed at the end, plus, If we do not have a definite description of an intermediate turner, then the term becomes subjective, hence the attendees.

The other thing is that not everyone has good eyes for forms and no matter what they enjoy in life they may not have the ability to mimic that form to their hand to recreate it. So, you can not expect that from everyone. the ability of transferring what's on your mind to your hands to create the thought is an art that not every one posses that. Otherwise every one should be a turner.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#28

Brad Vietje

Keith, You Just Hit The Gouge On The Head

Brad Vietje

I think Steve's list is a good one, and some helpful comments have come in, as always.

I like the idea of an introduction with an example of their work, perhaps asking them to describe what they like most and least about it, along with what they are hoping to learn at this class. That can get at their starting points as far as form and design.

You could also ask them to show their favorite tool, and why they like it -- a sneaky sort of way of getting at what they really know, and seeing how they sharpen their tools.

You can tell a lot about a turner by looking closely at their tools -- that's why I keep mine out of sight :D

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#29

Re: Keith, You Just Hit The Gouge On The Head

John Lucas

I'm not sure showing work would tell the skills. With light cuts and patience you can make almost anything using the tools as scrapers. I did for years no knowing any better. I look at some of my early work and wonder how I did it. I certainly don't have the skills I have today.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#30

Steven Antonucci

17x1=1

steven antonucci

Always see that. I try to prepare for it.

I use a "sneaky" way of showing what 17 years of good experience looks like, as I know that I am more like 10X1+10 (10 years of 1 year+10 years of improving)

Before we start any turning, we talk about what we're going to do first, and then I show it. The demo usually lasts ten minutes, and because I am highly competent at the lathe, I can actually watch the students and I don't need to be laser focused on the lathe. I usually look for two types of faces: the amazed and the bored.

The amazed person has never been on bevel and seen how effortless good technique truly is. The bored person hasn't either, but they think they have. I now know how to approach both of them. Can you guess which ones are harder to work with?

I will also contend that an even better indicator of how "experienced" someone is can be determined from 25 feet away. Look at how they are standing. If they are straight up and down and grimacing, they are still in year one. I have not figured out how to teach people to relax their body, their grip, and slow down.

I will often adjust their stances and tool presentation, and then just ask them to stand still in a cut without moving. I am holding their tool where it needs to be, right before a cut, and I can feel them getting ready to surge forward when I let go. I wait, explaining to them that I do not want them to move at all, and inevitably, they stab the gouge into the wood the instant I let go of the back of the handle. In some cases, hard enough to stall a 1 HP Oneway 1224.

As always, I do appreciate all the chatter and input. Gives me some things to work on for myself for the next time.

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#31

Thanks Everyone!

Don Orr

The input, thoughts, feedback, and ideas are all very helpful and constructive. This is actually very timely as I have just been asked to teach a beginner class for our local woodworking/woodturning club. A very experienced turner-and one of my mentors-has been doing it for many years and is giving it up. While it is an honor to be asked, I have some serious hesitation due to many of the issues being discussed in this thread. I also have high expectations of myself and therefore have similar expectations for the student. Most of my expectations of adults taking a class is to pay attention, discard previous notions, do what you are told, how you are told, when you are told and no more. Might sound kind of rigid, but you are taking a class to learn not show off. I also try to show my enthusiasm and passion for turning to help get them excited to keep learning. I am usually eager to pass on what so many others have so generously given to me and I have worked very hard to get to where I am, not that I am anything special, just reasonably competant.

Sorry to make this so long winded, but I have a decision to make and you all are certainly helping.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#32

Steven Antonucci

Showing off...

steven antonucci

Interesting observation...

Yes, I do believe that trying to impress the other students and the instructor is sometimes out there (I know I was guilty of it in the one class I took).

The funny thing is, if you think you need to run to the front of the class, you probably aren't going to impress anyone.

I had an issue with someone "running ahead" of the class to finish first, except he only thought he knew what came next. He cut away something he needed, and ended up standing around while everyone else finished what they were doing.

If you can't follow directions, well, you probably won't get much out of a class...

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#33

Design opportunity ... ?

Geoff Whaling

They are a true wood turner then :-)

Honestly some folks can work to direction, follow plans & work to close tolerances, some don't even comprehend what a plan is, and make it up on the run. So good luck on the "follow directions" Don.

I watched Pat Johnston run a class recently on making a "tazza" using a combination of spindle & face plate skills. The class was a great mix of turners newbies, to an experienced "30 year pro" & 50-50 M&F. Everything mentioned here appeared in the 1.5 hours I watched from the sidelines. From the emphatic & indignant "well nobody ever showed me that before" (60-70yo F) to those quietly going about their work. The two best pieces were from the "30 year pro" (M) and one quiet achiever (early 20yo F) with about two years experience & it would be a toss up to pick the better. The next best was from another quiet achiever (70+yo F). No guesses for the worst "well nobody...".

My issue was with the overambitious turner after the class. The "turner" who has done a basic class & then wants to take on the biggest ugliest bit of timber that would scare the heck out of most experienced turners, to make a very large bowl or HF.