Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Posts

Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#1

Steven Antonucci

Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

steven antonucci

So, you've decided to take a woodturning class at a craft school? How can you make the most of the experience?

Just woke up from my coma induced by the three day frenzy of my class at Peters Valley, and I'd offer the following advice to any student as a way to get the most out of the class.

First, read the description. If you are unclear of what it means, call the school and ask them to put you in contact with the instructor. If you sign up for a class that is beyond your skill, the instructor can only spend so much time with you depending upon how many other students there are and how they are doing.

Depending upon what the shop layout looks like, try to get there early enough to get a lathe towards the front. The instructors really want to get to the back of the shop, but it is inevitable that someone closer will grab them as they head towards the rear. Unlike high school, where you could duck into the rear and sleep, you probably don't want to miss what the instructor is teaching.

Now that you're sitting at the head of the class, be considerate of your classmates. Recognize that they also have paid the same money you did to be there, and they also deserve the instructor's time and attention. Take you fair share.

Be open and listen. Do not nod and agree if you do not understand something, because as an instructor, if you tell me you got it, I am moving to the next person who has a completely different question and need. I have to assume that you meant what you said.

Part of being open is to try something that may not be comfortable to you. As an instructor, I get students with all kinds of bad habits. My first goal is to make sure that you are safe. If I see you reaching to flick away a piece of wood from the bandsaw blade that is still moving, I am probably going to yell at you to immediately stop you, and once the danger is past, I will take the time to explain why you don't do that. It is not personal, but I simply cannot have people hurt in my class.

On the other side of being open, there are techniques that have little to do with safety but are more effective ways of working. Too many students come into the shop focused on the piece of wood in front of them and the project they are working on instead of the techniques to complete the project. As an instructor, I show them how to complete an operation, and then I watch them for a second assisting, and then I watch them for another second on their own. Within two minutes of walking away, more than half of the students will go back to doing it the way that they are "comfortable", and in many cases, this causes major problems with their project. As an instructor, I have a "three strikes" rule- after the third time I show someone something, if they insist on doing it their way, I have to abandon you to spend time with the people trying to do it right.

Lastly, if you have materials like wood or steel for tool making to be used during the class, do not be the locust. The locust is the person who goes to the pile before the beginning of the day and picks out the largest pieces for themselves and squirrels them under his/HER lathe. As an instructor, I try to measure the steel closely and cut them all to 15", but I do notice you comparing all of the bars to take the one that is 15.2". I do notice you taking the blank that is 1/4" thicker than the three that you pushed aside to reach it. I do notice if you need to run to the bathroom when it is time to sweep up at the end of the day. Don't be the locust.

Lastly, do not commute. Stay on campus. After dinner shop work is great, but after an 8 hour day, a lot of people (like your instructor) are probably too tired to turn another 2-3 hours. However, the opportunity to do less physical things, meet other people in other disciplines, and share ideas is the true hidden gem of the whole experience.

I highly recommend that anyone looking to get into turning takes a class with these principles in mind. The craft school experience is an excellent way to build skills and immerse yourself in the environment. Be safe. Be open to learning. Be respectful of your classmates. Make shavings fly.

Steven

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#2

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Pick out a lathe that is close to the proper height as possible.

Always wear face protection

If you know how, always arrive with SHARP tools

Bring paper and pencil/pen to take notes

Digital pictures are great for refreshing foggy memories

Wear closed toe shoes

Take a water bottle for camel stops

Take a skin moisturizer. Shavings for 12 hours can be very drying for your hands

Bring the tools listed for the class

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#3

Agree with all the above.

Don Orr

I had to stop teaching classes for our local woodworking club due to many of the issues you describe. I wanted my class to be advertised as intermediate and I would get people who had never used a lathe before. I would show and explain a step and then have them try it with me watching and helping only to have them revert to their way. I always told them my class was about the process, not a finished project and there would be no sanding or finishing only to have them break out their sand paper and poly. Once in a while I would get that one person who actually "got" it and that was a pleasure. I have been told I am a decent teacher but sometimes I wonder if it is me that is the problem. I have been asked to resume teaching but am hesitant. I did do a short evening class on sharpening turning gouges and it seemed to go fairly well but 3 hrs is really not enough.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#4

Re: maybe...

Henry W

Don - Never having taken a class in WW I can speak to the topic, though the advice seems quite sound.

is it possible that those who insist on sanding and finishing a project are people who are taking a class in part to gain access to a lathe? If that is the case, then I can see why they would want to complete the project (in addition to learning the excellent material you are presenting and demonstrating).

If I did not have access, that would be my inclination in the class, and clearly if they bring sandpaper and poly they are prepared to finish the object.

Just another possible perspective or point of view.

Henry

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Mike Stafford

One solution to the locust problem that I have used is to prepare a box or bag of materials for each student. Whatever bag they pick contains the materials they will use.

Sometimes that is not possible when the instructor has 10 or more blanks per student but it does solve problems such as those you describe.

I always used after dinner time for the students to turn on their own. Most of them want to turn in the evenings. I also would find out before class if they had any special talents and if they did and were willing I let them do a short demo in the evenings. As far as turning in the evening myself, I did not unless it was to help a student make a specific cut. I never introduce new material in the evenings.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#6

Steven Antonucci

counterpoint...

steven antonucci

If someone is coming to make use of a lathe because they don't own one, should they really sign up for a class that costs as much as a lathe? It is a full shop....should they also expect to be allowed to use the bandsaw or the table saw?

Aside from being a distraction to the instructor, the school might assume some liability for people working outside the boundary of the curriculum.

As an example, I had a student who had some kind of incident during my workshop. I didn't see it, so I have no idea how it happened. His forearm looked like a bear had clawed it, and there was literally blood all over the headstock of the Oneway he was using. I have my guesses as to what he did wrong, but when I asked him how he got hurt, he said "he didn't even know he was bleeding?" Not sure I believed him. I do believe that he was working within the scope of the class, though.

As an instructor, I want my students to enjoy the class, but I really, really, really want them to doing the things we're all doing. No side trips, no open studio time...

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#7

Steven Antonucci

Sage advice

steven antonucci

I usually bring more that I think I will need, and try to get people to understand that the after hours stuff is not more content or open studio, but only an opportunity to work within the confines of the class. It is funny how someone will gravitate to the largest block to claim it, even though everyone has the same sized lathe and we draw the same 11.5" circle on all of the blocks? I may even accidentally bandsaw their blanks a 1/4" shorter than the rest of them. just to make a point :D.

I will have to think about "kitting" next time.

S

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#8

Re: Sage advice

Doug Reynolds

Is the class advertised as a "skills" class or, a project class? I don't like registering for what is described as a project class only to go home with a box of "parts".

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#9

Possible but not likely

Geoff Whaling

Steven some are on medications that thin the blood so its quite possible the student could be bleeding well & not notice. But the bear claw look - they must have known & been too embarrassed to fess up!

I like your advice. I have assisted with classes and have watched gifted instructors like Neil Scobie take on groups that cover the whole spread in one go. With complete novices to turners probably near his peer level in technical skill, the instructor really earns their fee to keep everyone safe.

I would add advice for schools or clubs engaging instructors for classes - don't mix levels of competence just to fill a class. No one wins. It is grossly unfair & very demanding on the instructor plus participants do not get the full benefit of the class.

Have an assistant who is a competent & safe turner to assist and guide per the instructors directions & techniques. They take a lot of load off the instructor by doing the mundane tasks & a extra pair of eyes helps keeps everyone safe. The instructor can then offer a far better experience and concentrate on developing the skills of each participant.

Make sure all of the instructors requested materials & tools are available before the class starts!

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#10

Steven Antonucci

My course descriptions are always accurate

steven antonucci

We had a three day class. The prerequisites were that people had some basic understanding of how to turn a bowl (and face grain work in general) and were looking to extend it in two ways: Coring to preserve bowls, and hollow turning their first vessel.

My expectation is that you can say banjo, tail stock, drive center... etc, and everyone is good. Not so much. Lots of basic lathe issues throughout the weekend, including unlocked banjos and tail stocks. Also, a couple of people who just kept putting their bowl gouges at 12 o'clock and stabbing the wings into the bowl... no matter how many times it was explained. It is frustrating.

My classes are always skills classes, as I would personally never take a class to make something. I try to teach what would personally attract me, and always describe the work we will be doing as a "complete at home later". I do believe that some people just reach what they want to hear, and expect that the instructors will bend for them, but that puts a huge burden on the instructor... and I have decided that I will never do that. Personal preference, but it is for the welfare of the majority.

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#11

Steven Antonucci

You might be right

steven antonucci

The following day, I noticed he had more blood on him, which he also didn't know how it had happened... but he did have a bad 12 o'clock flute habit... and I am certain that it was a result flying wood.

The other person who bled knew exactly why she had cut herself, and she announced "You told us to knock off the knife edge on the rim of the bowl, and now I believe you..."

nicks and cuts... no deaths.

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#12

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, Don,

I read your post, although that I have not taken any classes as such you described, but being married to and educator and observing some problems with classes, I can offer few tips that may help to eliminate those problems.

1- You are dealing with older adults that may be on medications ( whatever their health conditions dictates), and also, they may be too proud to consider themselves as an expert which in some cases they may very well be. Some of them would consider themselves intermediate and some may have a big head thinking that they know what you mean by intermediate level and consider themselves as such when they do not have any idea what you mean. some may assume that because they have done wood working for a long time and think that because of that they are considered intermediate.

2- When you are young and I mean in your teen and maybe under you are more flexible to learn and also apt to learn. Now, you are working with adults that are set in their own ways and have acquired certain method to learn and gain new knowledge.

3- Teaching is not an easy job when it comes to adults. ( I wanted to go back and teach what I have learned in my profession, because of my injury which prevents me to do what i used to do, but now I have to take about 30 hrs (not sure) of continuing education courses for teaching to adults). Therefore, as you can see teaching adults is an art in itself.

4- Before you start the class, in order to keep it pretty much uniform, you need to check their supplies you requested them to bring along. If they have something that will distract them from your goal then politely ask them to take it back to their car and make sure they understand they can not use it during your class. they should adhere to your rules for their maximum benefit and yo need to be firm on that. If you are distributing the blanks and you think they will go for the big one then take out the blanks randomly and give it to them so you overcome that problem. If you gonna show a technique to someone, then ask if the others have problem with it again and call them to that person's lathe and then have them watch the person you are to correct, then this way you make sure that they will not repeat that mistake and you can go on to someone else and correct a new problem that may arise.

5- Just because you adhere to certain rules and discipline in your shop so not expect that they come form the same back ground, so take time or allow time to lay the rules up front before you start the actual lessons.

i know it may sound pretty basics, but we as adults have weird attitudes about learning and sometimes we need to be brought back to focus again.

That was my $.02. I hope it helps.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#13

Re: Possible but not likely

phillip Medghalchi

Jeff, you wrote:

" I would add advice for schools or clubs engaging instructors for classes - don't mix levels of competence just to fill a class. No one wins. It is grossly unfair & very demanding on the instructor plus participants do not get the full benefit of the class."

Unless you have a way of testing that which is not practical, you will now know the levels and some may be too smart to fake it so they will not show that they know a lot. Then, you are dealing with different levels of learning, some student may learn it with the first attempt of the lesson, and some may take few goes until they really get the idea.

You know if the guy learned it the wrong way in the first place for you to teach him the right way is gonna be tough. since his muscle memory would want to take the easy way out.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#14

Re: You might be right

phillip Medghalchi

Steve, the words that come out of your mouth may sound and mean different to other people. :b

If you say knock off the corners, they may hear knock off the God knows. ;)

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#15

Re: Possible but not likely

John Lucas

Geoff. Wish that could be done- fill classes with experienced people. Unfortunately to pay the instructors they need to fill the classes if they can. Almost every class I teach for a school has had one or two students without a lathe.

Purely workshop

Schools like arrowmont and John c Campbell also get people who use it for a vacation. The spouse signs up for a class a d the. They look at the school and just pick something. Often it's woodturning.

We've also had trouble limiting classes to Intermdiate or advanced. The classes either don't fill or you get a few students who overestimate their skills.

All in all Steve's advice is good but its a lot like asking people to read the FAQ's to a forum. Some will some wont a d some of us don't even k ow where to find them :-)

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#16

Re: My course descriptions are always accurate

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, you are ready to teach in college level, with all them smarty a........ young adults that they think they know everything. then go home and try to relax at end of the day.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#17

Steven Antonucci

This!

Steven antonucci

Schools do need to fill the classes, and that's fine. I adjust as much as possible. I planned on having a bunch of bowls piled up from coring the first day, but after our opening intro talk...I realized we needed to just cut a regular bowl on day one, and I demoed coring. We held off student coring until day #3.

One guy of the three that tried to core got through it with a core. The other two ended up donutting because they didn't slide the knife, but ended up trying to rotate it...and it moved the gate...

S

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#18

In My Classes........

Wally Dickerman

Over the years most of my classes have been beginner bowl classes. The students want to go home with one or two finished bowls. Unfinished work often never gets finished. Learning to turn a bowl isn't just about wood grain and tool technique, it's also about proper sanding methods and about applying finishes. My classes always start with a session on tool sharpening. Then we have a short session on form and design. Folks have asked why I talk about form to beginners....my answer is why not? It's a major part of learning to turn a bowl. I want them to be proud of the bowls a year later. After all that we start turning. I've always limited my beginners class to five students so that I can give them the attention they need.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#19

Steven Antonucci

miscategorizing oneself

Steven antonucci

Read my reply to John's point about filling classes.

I get that schools need people to pay to run classes, but my description suggested intermediate to purposely discourage someone who didn't own a lathe from signing up as a learn to turn class. I think the students bear some of the responsibility for picking a class that isn't French level 2 if they've never taken French level 1?

As far as how adults learn, I would suggest that some do not. Yogi Berra said "You can't teach him something he doesn't already know!". My comment about being open is critical. Instead of doing something 10x the way that ends badly because you've develop the bad habit, fight to try to do it the way that I showed you. I just can't show you how to do it your way better...

I do understand medications and such, but I am not your doctor or responsible for them. If you have limits, you know them and can either tell me or self manage. Possibly, if the limits won't permit you to participate, take a different class.

S

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#20

Re: miscategorizing oneself

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, I totally agree, however, everything you said can not be controlled by you. You are not gonna get the truth out of people who signed up and as long as you didn't advertise the class, then you do not have any control of who will sign up. what I can offer you is that sit down and writ what you like about the class and what you don't like about it and then try to modify the things you can control and lessen your expectation so you won't feel frustrated. There are parameters that you can not change, but is you that can change how you react to them so, you can enjoy it as well. On the to other hands, look at the reality of it, how long did it take you to learn and master what yo know, there is no way in the world you are going to expect that form a three day class. You know how many times you made mistakes until you mastered certain cut, so that's your answer. I hope you don't think i am taking their side, I am not. I can see your frustration, however, the oter guys didn't even care what happened after the class.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#21

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

Dick Coers

I know exactly what you are saying Steven. I taught a lot of classes at Woodcraft, from basic router to bowl turning. The turning classes were limited to 4 and that was too many. I really became frustrated. We had Cindy Drozda stay at our home when she came to Peoria to demo. I asked her about her teaching and how she handles the frustrations. She told me that her main goal in conducting classes is to instill excitement in the student. To light the fire so that it inspires them to continue to turn when they get home. It was very insightful to me. Not enough to inspire me to teach woodturning again though! LOL

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#22

Steven Antonucci

Form is always a day 1 topic

steven antonucci

Keith Tompkins and I discussed teaching form at Totally Turning, and we're all in violent agreement that you can never start teaching form too early. I had more than half of the students produce very good forms for their experience, with only minor bumps here and there, so at least there was that?

I also always manage to talk about where and how I learned, and to your credit, even though you and I have never met, I credit you with being the person who got me straight on the base of hollow forms (so, now you know why your ears were burning this weekend on Sunday...)

steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#23

Steven Antonucci

Frustration is a good word...

steven antonucci

I know that I am generally happy with the class and the results, but I am always frustrated that I couldn't do more...

I probably set my personal goals too high, which is also part of the problem. If I was going to take a class in pottery (I've never thrown a pot or a bowl), I wouldn't feel "right" taking an intermediate class just because I have turned a bunch of bowls and vessels? I am confident that I probably could pick up faster than the average person, but I also know that you have to pay your dues at the wheel.

If I teach this class again, I probably won't change much. I talked to the true intermediate turners in the class afterwards looking for feedback, and I really pressed them hard to tell me something they didn't like... and they couldn't. They thought it was spot on. I know if I had asked the beginners that question, I would have gotten some feedback, but I think it would have been misdirected because they were in the wrong class?

Exhausting, but I love it... and I probably over-think it, but I am still trying and not mailing it in...

Steve

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#24

George Taylor

Workshops

George Taylor

I believe I have been to almost all the major schools (Rockport, Maine to Anderson Ranch to Marc Adams to Arrowmont to Provo to John C Campbell) over the last 10 years. I have learned a lot and have been frustrated just a little. Biggest frustration was the complete newbie and class size. I was in a class of over 15 turners with an instructor and very qualified assistant. Several newbies were in the class, I received little instruction and basically turned what I wanted, good vacation, not much instruction. Suggestions:

1. If you are thinking about going to a class, talk it up in you area or club and see if you can get several to go as well. First, it limits the newbies and secondly you have friends to associate with during the down time.

2. Focus on what interests you; I really like bowl turning, so I sought out classes by Mike Mahoney & Glenn Lucas.

3. Speak up and contribute; the high point of that awfully large class was teaching a newbie to turn a wine stopper. I could see the "light bulb" flash in his mind (very cool thing). That might have reeled him in to the woodturning vortex.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: Advice for Student in Woodturning Classes

#25

Steven Antonucci

This, too!