Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Posts

CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#1

CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Warren White

I have a new problem since buying CA glue from Woodcraft. I am using thin and medium "Stick Fast Instant CA Adhesive" which, when I am not using is stored in a refrigerator. I just purchased these a couple of weeks ago, so it shouldn't be a date problem. However, the two pens I have made and finished with these glues have exhibited the same problem: little 'sparkly' effects in the pores of the walnut, while previous pens finished with a different CA glue (specifically labeled 2P10) didn't have this issue. Perhaps it isn't the glue, but for the life of me I can't see that there is any other difference. Same procedure, same wood, etc.

I have attached a photo that I hope will show the effect. Not quite the same as holding it in your hand, but perhaps you will see what I mean. Little white spots in the pores of the Walnut. Doesn't show up in cherry, incidentally.


I would certainly welcome your thoughts. I am going to Woodcraft this Wednesday and would like to have a solution in mind.

Thank you!

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#2

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

phillip Medghalchi

They look like bubbles to me, i am not sure if I know where you live ,but if there was humidity then that was your enemy. then it looks like you didn't sand the walnut that smooth which in turn will trap air bubbles. these are he things I remember from the demos. More experts needed to comment. that stick fast is no the best CA either though, I have had problem with it gelling and getting thicker.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#3

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Bruce Pratt

May be dust in the open pores of the walnut. Do you clean off your turned blank with alcohol or compressed air before putting on the CA finish?

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#4

The "little voice"....

Warren White

You know, the one that keeps you awake thinking of things like this? (It is 5:00 in the morning...)

The nagging voice tells me it might be the change in viscosity that comes about by taking the CA out of the refrigerator right to the project. Is it possible that my 'thin' CA isn't as 'thin' as it should be, and therefore not going into the pores? That might trap the air in the open pores causing the effect. I didn't put the CA into the refrigerator before; I read that it will last longer if it is kept there.

To answer Bruce, I am fairly confident that the blanks are clean before the application of the CA. I don't blow them off (I didn't before either), but they are cleaned very well with a soft rag and acetone.

A simple test tomorrow night will tell, but your thoughts are most appreciated.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#5

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

terry quiram

There are certain species I wet sand with thin CA and Walnut is one of them. After that I proceed, like you with thin and med applications.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#6

Re: The "little voice"....

Bruce Pratt

Warren, you may be on to the solution with the viscosity issue. I use only medium CA (same brand), but don't keep it in the 'frig, as I go through it fairly rapidly. BTW - the same problem may be less visible/not occur in cherry, due to its lighter color and/or smaller pore size than walnut.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#7

Are you using accelerator?

Dick Coers

If so, try it without it. I never use thin, always medium. And if I use accelerator, it's just the very finest mist on the second coat only. I glued too many bushings on when I used thin.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#8

Like Dick, I'm curious if you're .....

JamieDonaldson

...using accelerator, which often causes frosting as the CA sets. And once the CA container has been opened, never put it back in the fridge. The cold humid environment causes the CA to thicken and harden. I often leave opened CA bottles without caps in my shop for months without any problem, so long as humidity levels are not high.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: The "little voice"....

Brad Vietje

You can store it in the fridge only if you warm it up to room temp before you open it. You can also store unopened bottles in the freezer for years, but be sure to warm it up before opening -- as a cold liquid, it will attract condensation out of the air (especially in a humid location), and that water will act to catalyze the curing of the CA, and it could be getting thicker if it absorbed some water from the air.

I have had some in the freezer for over 10 years -- still perfectly good. Once I allow it to reach room temp and open it, I leave it at ambient temp in a little cup near the lathe in the barn, where the temp's rise and fall with the weather. The this stays thin if I use it up soon enough, but it will thicken over time from exposure to air and humidity.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#10

Re: Like Dick, I'm curious if you're .....

phillip Medghalchi

Jaime, "I often leave opened CA bottles without caps in my shop for months without any problem, so long as humidity levels are not high."

that's it. This doesn't apply to S. TX, the darn thing go from very humid to less humid then back up again. I don't know where Warren lives, but if he lives in South then he has that problem. Then all them other guys hit the possibility. CA is a vicious thing that there is no definite answer to it. I think that two thing got Warren in trouble, first was that he worked with Walnut then I can see the open pores, and next is that I think humidity got trapped under neath the CA. I had that happened to me on a bowl that I have to re-sand and refinish it again. I should have known better not to finish it in a very humid day.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#11

To the group:

Warren White

Thank you all for your observations and suggestions. I woke up this morning feeling I probably made a big mistake in putting the CA in the fridge and then using it right away. Some of you commented along similar lines.

Let me comment on each of your input:

Terry, how do you wet sand with CA without it setting up as you wet sand?

Bruce, I cleaned with acetone, but didn't use compressed air. I will try that, but wonder if alcohol is better to use than acetone.

Dick and Jamie, I do use accelerator in a spray can. I may be using too much. I thought the purpose of using the thin CA first (2 coats lightly) was to fill the pores.

Phillip, I live in California, 40 miles due east of SF. Humidity isn't too high here. As for the open pores, yes the walnut has pores you could drive a truck into. However, my first two pens looked terrific and the only thing I changed was the brand of CA, which I then put in the fridge.

I will try and find time tomorrow and try another piece of walnut with the non-cold CA. I will let you know how it turns out.

Thank you all, and if you have other thoughts, please help this newbie out. My first pens were really spectacular. These last two make me want to buy a disassembly kit....

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#12

Warren,

GaryG in MD

I understand your pain.

I, too, use the Stick Fast pen finishing kit.

I followed their instructions carefully, and my first few pens came out great too.

I was very encouraged and enthusiastic.

After that, they all started cracking into spiderwebs.

I'm using the same woods, same products, and same procedures.

VERY frustrating.

I have watched all the videos.

I have watched Barry Gross do it in person.

I have watched Kurt Hertzog do it in person.

I'm still sanding off cracked CA.

It's driving me NUTS.

I have varied the procedure to use thin only.

I have rubbed back and forth.

I have not rubbed back and forth.

I have put accelerator on first.

I have put accelerator on last.

I have used no accelerator.

I have put the CA on from the top.

I have put the CA on from the bottom.

etc.

Sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.

And it has nothing to do with putting the pen parts together.

This is happening right on the lathe.

I've gotten to the point where I just leave the tubes on the lathe overnight and come back in the morning to see if they have cracked or not before I even bother with the first sanding with Abranet 400.

I still haven't come up with a dependable, foolproof method.

Everyone you talk to or read about has a slightly different method, and lots of people claim that their method works.

OTOH, I have read about an awful lot of people who are having the same cracking problems that I am. And I have NOT seen a good explanation of why.

If I HAD to guess, I'd say it cracks when it gets too thick. But my first ones were just as thick and didn't. And most people put on more coats than I have been lately, for this very reason. I'm now putting on so little that I'm afraid of sanding right through it.

It's a poor man who blames his tools, but I'm starting to question if something has changed in the product, even though it's certainly not obvious what or how that could be.

I did change to a different can of accelerator, but it's the same brand.

When CA works, it's fast and easy and gives the best possible result.

But when it doesn't, which has been far too often for me lately, grrrrrrrrr...

So consider yourself lucky that you only have bubbles! ;-)

If you're like me, when you get the bubble problem solved, then it will start cracking!!! Let's hope not...

...GG

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#13

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Barry L Elder

I just wonder if many of the problems talked about here are the result of not allowing the blank to cool down after turning/sanding. Depending on the type of wood and the weather, sometimes the change in shape and dimension can be dramatic.

And to Warren, I wonder if your questions could have been more easily answered at IAP (International Association of Penturners)? (penturner.org) There are many members there who only turn pens and have been doing so for many years.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#14

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Jon Behnke

From what I see in the picture, you have sanding dust in the pores of the wood, Walnut is very porous and sanding will not fill those pores. Somebody said in an earlier post to "wet sand with CA", what they mean by that is to create a slurry of sanding dust and thin CA to fill the pores. This is easy to do, just sand until you have some dust built up on the paper and drizzle a little CA on top of the blank with the dusty sandpaper below. This will fill the pores quicker than trying to build up enough layers of CA alone.

Blowing the blank off with compressed air after sanding will also help, this also works with light colored woods to keep them from looking muddy.

A CA finish is much like paint on a fancy car, it's built in layers and sanded back to even it out, it is not self leveling, if there are open pores it will take many coats applied and sanded back to fill in. I generally put on at least 12-15 coats, the first few in thin CA (this will soak in somewhat) and the balance in medium CA. I only sand every 3rd or 4th coat and at the end with 600 and all the grits of micro mesh followed by Novus polish.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#15

Gary

Warren White

Oh my gosh, Gary! I must admit that I had to laugh inappropriately when I read your post because you were so eloquent in describing my frustration! Shared pain makes for instant friendship, I hope.

I am going to try two things; first my CA glue is no longer in the fridge. Second, I will try to do better at cleaning free I apply the CA. I will clean with acetone, then blow the blank with compressed air, then vacuum it.

I will let you know.

Sorry, my friend. We have shared misery. Perhaps one of us will find a solution that we can share.

Best wishes,

Warren

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#16

Barry

Warren White

I have, at your suggestion and one other, signed up for the IAP forums, and found someone who was having the exact same problem. I have posted to his thread.

Thank you!

Warren

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#17

Jon

Warren White

Thank you for your help. I really appreciate the clarification regarding wet sanding with CA. I couldn't picture what he was saying.

You said: I only sand every 3rd or 4th coat and at the end with 600 and all the grits of micro mesh followed by Novus polish.

What grit do you sand the interim 3rd or 4th coats with?

Also, am I crazy, or are not all, say, 400 grits the same? I have some stuff I bought at Penn State and they are not at all the same as paper I have on hand of the same grit.

Thanks again!

Warren

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#18

re grits

GaryG in MD

Warren, There are, indeed, many different grit standards. The two most common that we see here are "US" and "European". The latter are usually designated with the letter "P". Even within a standard, the grit distributions vary with the brand and quality of the paper. A few Googles will bring up a lot of info for you. ...GG

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#19

agreed!


Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

Keith Tompkins

HI Warren, I question using CA as a finish at all....It's brittle, and cannot move with the wood as it naturally expands and contracts. Plus, who knows the health risks? I'm not a pen maker, but I'd try guitar lacquer thinned and applied in many coats with a cloth, or sprayed with either rattle can or airbrush, sanded between coats. The only thing I use CA for are demonstrations, where time is of the essence.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#21

Hey Keith,

GaryG in MD

CA finishes do work very well, and have excellent properties.

The main bonus is speed. You can literally finish a pen from raw wood to the final product, with whatever shine you desire, in ten minutes. I'm afraid your method involves days. DAMHIK!

There's not a lot of expansion and contraction because you generally have only a wafer-thin bit of wood left between the finish and the brass tube (neither of which is permeable).

It's pretty much the standard pen finish.

But it can be a dickens to figure out the right way for each individual.

There are clearly some subtle things happening.

What works for one person doesn't necessarily work for the next.

I suspect that the Devil is in the details and that the key is something that is so taken for granted that it isn't mentioned -- such as a cleaning step.

Making sure the first coat isn't put on until the barrels are at ambient temperature is a good idea, but it seems to me that this happens normally during the step where the sanding dust is cleaned off with an evaporative solvent such as alcohol or acetone. Who knows? That may actually make them too cold! The solvent itself may be the problem!

I have yet to see anyone publish a definitive answer to the cracking problem that is a fairly common hazard. If anyone has, please tell me!! ...GG

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#22

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

jerry bennett

Brad,

This can happen with any finish. If the wood is not in equilibrium and is expelling heat or moisture, bubbles occur every time. The viscosity of the finish should be such that capillary action does not cause bridging. A simple solution is to fill the pores with something.

I use lacquer finishes mostly and simply hand rub it into the pores to fill them up. You can use other things: shellac, pore filler etc.

Wood that is in transition will do this no matter what the finish is. A possible exception is A finish that is so thin, it displaces the moisture.

Jerry

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#23

Re: Jon

Jon Behnke

Warren - After much trial and error I only use Norton 3X sand paper that I buy in 9 x 11 sheets, 120, 220, 320, 400 & 600 (600 is wet/dry, isn't available as 3x). I collate 1 of each grit and cut the into 1" x 5.5" strips and rubber band the stack. You just take out one set when turning a pen, they will always be in order then.

I use 400 or 600 in between CA coats, just sand enough to take out the ridges from the applicator used to apply the CA (I use Viva paper towel, the "select a size"). If you over sand you will take off the CA that you've applied. Always remember to sand cross ways to take out the heavier sanding scratches.

Another option that you may try is a product from General Finishes called Wood Turners Finish. It's a water based urethane that dries quickly and after building several coats has a shine and durability very similar to CA finish. You will find videos and discussions in the IAP forum. I've used this and it works well, I still use a CA finish just because that's what I used for years and am comfortable with that.

As to the durability of a CA finish, I've been carrying a pen I made 3-4 years ago that still looks like it did when I made it.

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#24

yellowing

GaryG in MD

I forgot to mention in my reply to Keith that another reason for using CA as a finish is that it does not yellow the work and keeps it exactly the color it is supposed to be. As I understand it, GF WTF has a yellowing agent in the formula to make the result look more like an oil finish and not blue like some of the other water-based products. Some woods will look OK yellowed, but I can't stand it on lighter woods. That's one of the reasons I continue to fight with CA. I WILL win!!

...GG

Re: CA finish pens...We have a problem Houston!

#25

Jon

Warren White

I have carefully considered your advice, and went down to my local Woodcraft and bought more (I already had a few pieces) boxes of Norton 3X in the grits you suggested. I agree that their paper is excellent, and I will do as you suggest and make up some packets for sanding. I should have enough paper to last for a looong time!

I wanted to report that I also tried a modification of my procedure and it seems to improve the outcome. After turning and sanding my very open-pore walnut, I vacuum the area around the lathe, I clean the blank with acetone (I will try denatured alcohol when I get some). I then vacuum the blank with my shop vac, holding my hand around and under the blank (with the vacuum hose on top of the blank) to improve the suction around the blank. I considered blowing the blank off with my compressor, but since I don't have a filter on the output, I didn't want to introduce any oil or contaminants, so I didn't do that.

My first two coats of thin CA are applied without accelerant, hopefully allowing it to fill in the pores before it hardens. Then off to the rest of my regular procedure.

So far, this has yielded good results. I will keep my fingers crossed.

Thanks for your (and all other's) help.

What fun!

Warren