Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

22" long 3/8" spindle

Posts

22" long 3/8" spindle

#1

22" long 3/8" spindle

John Lucas

Thought I would challenge myself this morning. I'm trying to turn a 22" long 3/8" spindle. I was hoping to turn it 1/4" but I could tell pretty quick that wasn't going to happen until my skills get better so I'll shoot for 3/8". I've got the hardest part done now. going to reward myself with a Sausage and Egg McGriddle and then get back to it. I'll pay for that later today when I go for a bike ride. :)

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#2

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

Craig Daymon

Tape the tailstock end to the live center and draw back on it to create tension rather than using the tailstock to create tension through compression. It works much better. I did a 12" goblet with a 1/16" stem that way.

Of course, you can't go crazy with drawing tension this way because it will loosen the live center, but a well seated center can be used to draw sufficient tension.

Just a suggestion. I know this is well within your skill range. Good luck.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#3

Steven Antonucci

I've always thought...

steven antonucci

that it would be way easier to do this if you could somehow put the spindle in tension with a collet in the tailstock pulling instead of compressing...

Might need a drawbar?

S

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#4

Steven Antonucci

you type faster than me 


Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#5

Re: I've always thought...

phillip Medghalchi

Man you guys are way too smart.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#6

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

phillip Medghalchi

Craig, that's amazing to pull a 1/16" on the lathe w/o crushing it? I've got to watch you up close to see how you did it. Very nice hand and eye coordination.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#7

How do you do drawbar

John Lucas

I e thought about it but my tailstock changes size when you crank the handle so I can't run a drawbar through it in the traditional way to pull a morse taper. I suppose I could grind a flat in the morse taper and crank the sets few In that I installed to hold my drill chuck.

I did rig something up years ago using a chuck in the tailstock. I was so proud of myself. It seemed to work as I turned it thinner and thinner. Turned it off to inspect the piece. When I turned it back on the inertia needed to swoon the tailstock chuck ripped my turning in half. I thought about gearing the two together but haven't tried it

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#8

Re: How do you do drawbar

phillip Medghalchi

John, how about turning two washer type rounds (or washers) and then drill it in the center to the size for the draw bar and put a spring in between the end of the tail stock(outside) and the draw bar so it would compensate for the distance different when you tighten it. Then you would have the tension to hold it in place as it tightens. this would also enable you to adjust he tension as you need and hold it in place. Just something to think about.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: I've always thought...

Brad Vietje

Aren't there commercial products to do this? A live center threaded to accept a draw-bar through the tailstock, and a Jacob's or similar chuck or collett that will thread onto the spinning ("live") tail-center ???

I would like to get or make such an arrangement, but I thought there was something like this on the market already -- no?

If not, John will make one, but you gotta watch him -- he might machine it out of a grain of rice! :D

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#10

Steven Antonucci

Huh?

steven antonucci

I'm not sure how your tailstock spindle works, but mine (Nova) is just a hollow bar with a taper in it. It is always the same length, and just moves in and out on the tailstock assembly?

I would simply use a threaded rod into the back of the collet, and a washer and nut out the other end of the tailstock tube to hold it in place. You probably only need to pull 1/8" of tension, and the drawbar just keeps the collet from unseating?

S

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#11

Re: Huh?

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, now you made me think what the heck I suggested above. How can tail stock get smaller in length as you tighten it against the head stock. Thanks, buddy that made me feel, oh well.........., duh..

Unless, John meant to say something else and his finger thought another.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#12

Re: I've always thought...

phillip Medghalchi

Brad, there is I have it. I have Jacob chuck that has thread at the end and when I want to use it on my lathe to clean out my sanding disk form derbies I have to use it on the head stock, so chuck won't fall off, so you can use it at the tail stock also. I think John was not thinking with his finger earlier today when he was typing. We have to wait for his reply to see which one of us really got what he said. Challenge of he day.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#13

Dennis in Southern Oregon

What a coincidence!  Long response.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I gave a demo on this subject a couple of weeks ago at the Southern Oregon Woodturners meeting. As a bored retired engineer, I decided to see if I could apply structural beam deflection theory to spindle turning, and verify it by actual experiment. It turns out that the answer is yes.

I considered five cases: (1) Spindle chucked at one end, the other free. (2) Spindle between centers. (3) spindle chucked at one end, the other against a center. (4) Spindle chucked at both ends. (5) Spindle chucked at both ends with tension applied to the spindle. I determined the relative rigidity of a round spindle of fixed diameter and length for each of these cases. "Rigidity" here means pounds of tool force required to produce and inch of deflection when applied at the worst-case point along the spindle.

Taking Case 2 as a reference, the relative rigidities were

Case 1: 1/16

Case 2: 1

Case 3 2.12

Case 4 4

Case 5 8 (0.4" D x 16" L spindle with 55 lb tension

Case 5 was determined experimentally by comparing its results with Case 4 (no tension).

In order run Cases 4 and 5 I made a collet with threads to screw onto a Oneway live center. Case 5 also required a method for applying tension while allowing free rotation of the spindle. This consisted of a rod running from the socket of the removable center point, through the live center body, through a bearing support, through a thrust bearing, through another bearing support, through a spring and finally a washer and wing nut. Fully compressed, the spring had a measured force of 55 pounds.




Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#14

I turned a nine foot long dowel......

Barry Irby

on my Nova DVR with about a two foot bed. Just for fun. Made a small stick nine feet long. I used a block plane to knock the corners off so the stick would pass through the headstock spindle, through a chuck with the jaws removed, and then through the tailstock. It went through the tailstock to keep it from whipping. Tightened the chuck on it to drive it. Set up a couple of eye bolts both left and right to keep it from whipping. It could have been as long as whatever piece of wood you had handy. Turned it down to about 3/8", but it could have been smaller if I were careful about supporting it to reduce whip.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

Keith Tompkins

HI John, A couple of thoughts....If you turn the center first, it becomes the weakest point, and will cause the whole thing to whip around, especially when you try to work from the tailstock towards the center. I find if I start at the tailstock and work towards the headstock, I have better luck....I use the chuck as well! You could always use a steadyrest...Now, here's how to do a skinny spindle almost as long as you want: Rip your material so it will slide through your headstock, then extend a short amount past the chuck, and turn it to finish diameter. Loosen the chuck, advance the spindle a bit more, turn to finish diameter. Repeat , using the tailstock for light support. Since you are always turning near the chuck, there is lots of support. String steady or small steady rests can be used to support long lengths. Just don't tell anybody about this! :D

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: I turned a nine foot long dowel......

Keith Tompkins

Hi Barry....I missed your post! We have almost the same idea!

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#17

Re: What a coincidence!  Long response.

phillip Medghalchi

Dennis, thank you for this technical reply, I was thinking along the same way. of course, not this technical. You nailed it scientifically.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#18

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

phillip Medghalchi

Keith, you just did. now, I know it too.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#19

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Keith, let me turn your argument around. In most of the cases I addressed, the most sensitive point is at or near the center. If you remove material from the ends first, your will only make things worse at the critical point, which is the limiting factor on how small you can turn. The optimum approach if you know in advance how small you can turn, is to start at the critical point and turn down to this diameter and then continue to turn to this diameter alternately in small steps toward each end. If you don't know in advance, then the best strategy is to turn down at the critical point as far as you can while maintaining a satisfactory surface and then move alternately in small steps toward the ends. Done this way, the hardest turning challenge is always at the critical point; it always gets easier as you move towards the ends.

Dennis

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#20

Re: How do you do drawbar

Bill Boehme

There is an easy solution to the problem of the tailstock changing length. Put a compression spring of the right size around the drawbar and then use a flat washer and wing nut to set the right amount of tension (which should be very little). From no tension to the right amount will be a very small adjustment so there should not be any need to readjust the tension. You can calibrate your spring so that you will know how much tension is being applied by measuring the amount of compression (bet you didn't know that you could create tension with a compression spring).

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#21

Well, Duh ... here's how .....

Bill Boehme

Steve,

Measure the distance from the end of the quill to the handwheel when the quill is cranked all the way in. Now do the same thing when it is cranked all the way out.

By now it ought to be obvious what John is talking about.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#22

Re: What a coincidence!  Long response.

Bill Boehme

I just posted essentially the same type of drawbar arrangement a few minutes ago before seeing that you had posted the same thing several hours earlier. Must be that we engineers are on the same wavelength.

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#23

Steven Antonucci

It might be a Nova thing

steven antonucci

My quill is hollow from front to rear. The threaded part of the quill sticks out the back of the handwheel. If the protruding part of the quill goes out 1", the threaded part goes in 1".

I am not thinking that you use the drawbar against the handwheel. I am suggesting that you use the end of the quill, which will always be the same length in a Nova. When I looked at the picture of the Powermatic, I can see why that wasn't always the case.

If you own a Nova, do what I said. If not, you are on your own.

S

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#24

Steven Antonucci

Did it "feel" better?

steven antonucci

I know from statics classes that a rigid fixed point is changes where a beam deflects (also an engineer), so it seems obvious that the collet on the end would also help. However, was it noticeable turning? Did you end up with a better, smoother turning?

Also, was the introduction of the tensile load something that you noticed a difference? Was it markedly better than just having the collet there?

I saw the data, but I am wondering about the soft aspects...

S

Re: 22" long 3/8" spindle

#25

Re: Did it "feel" better?

Bill Boehme

If there is compression in the "trembleur" then that causes bowing which contributes to whipping. Some tension would be better, but I suspect that too much might make it "sing" like a guitar string. Like a musical instrument, tuning might be necessary, but it this case we would want it to be out of tune.