Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

Posts

Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#1

Brad Vietje

Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

Brad Vietje

The recent discussion about buffing and finishing bowls let me to conclude that some people are trying to make nice things from pretty poor quality or marginal quality wood. Maybe they live where wood is scarce, but I'll bet an intrepid turner could source wood in most places in the USA with a little diligence.

I am very lucky to be surrounded by trees of many varieties, and in great abundance. Just check out Vermont on Google Earth, and you'll get the idea! I understand that some folks are not so lucky, and that turners who don't live out in the boondocks might have a harder time finding good turning stock than those of us who do.

Where to get good wood? Let's start a list here to inspire people to go out there and get some good wood -- it's almost like the stuff grows on trees, fer cryin' out loud!

I'm not including the obvious vendors like sawmills, Woodcraft, Rockler, etc... You already know about them.

1. Logging sites -- ALWAYS ask and be careful! Log landings are dangerous places, and loggers do not want you scampering around a log pile (OK, this is not helpful if you don't live out in the woods a bit :~). If you see someone clearing land for construction, etc... you can always stop by and flag someone down and tell them what you're looking for, or leave them a note with a phone number. I've known loggers to leave behind a few chunks for me to pick up -- or drop them outside a fence or gate, since they definitely don't want you climbing about on piles of logs that could shift and crush you.

2. Firewood dealers -- see if you can buy some "log length" green firewood, or get them to cut it to a length you can handle. I've bought logs for the same price as split and delivered IF they allowed me to pick out the logs. After all, they don't have to cut it, split it, stack it, truck it, etc... so this is a good deal for them.

3. Construction sites -- if someone is building something in or near the woods, chances are a number of trees will bite the dust. If there are any good hardwoods on the lot, you could score some good wood if you show up early and ask.

4. Town/City "stump dumps" OK -- they won't call them "Stump Dumps" in the city, but find out where landscapers and tree surgeons get rid of the trees they cut down. Some sell 'em as firewood, some truck them to a stump grinder to make mulch or shredded wood for landscaping.

5. Tree surgeons: some sell the trees as firewood, but if they know what you want... you never know. See no. 2, above.

6. Town/City Road Crews: Municipal road crews -- or "Highway Departments" in the 'burbs -- need to cut down trees that threaten roads, or remove live trees for new roads, widening roads, bike paths, sidewalks, bridge repair/replacement, etc... Worth finding out who is in charge and asking if you could get some logs from them.

7. Parks & Recreation Departments: Trails through the woods, maintenance work in parks, etc... Can't hurt to ask.

8. Turning Clubs: lots of turners have too much wood, and some will happily give decent blanks to people they know through the local turning club.

9. Wood auctions: Some of the local clubs in my area raise money 1-2 times per year by asking members to bring in excess wood, and selling it at auction to other club members. Good way to raise a few bucks for a good cause, and helps make use of wood that would just rot or go to waste.

There must be many, many more. I'm not a city guy, so I may not be aware of good urban/suburban sources. I have seen some awesome burls on street trees in cities, and if you know the right people..... ?

How do you ask? That's another topic, but many people bring a bowl or box to show, and pledge to make something for the person granting you access to the wood. If you are buying the wood, no need for this.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#2

I made the "Mistake"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of giving a big bowl to the owner of a tree service whose stump dump I had raided and then telling him I was always looking for wood.

Picture a 40' 12-wheel stake-bed lumber truck, complete with loading boom crane, showing up in your driveway and proceeding to unload 25 20' logs of walnut, cherry, oak, hickory, poplar, osage orange, and mulberry!

Great googly moogly! Be careful what you ask for . . . :D

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#3

barry rockwell

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

Barry Rockwell

Great information Brad! I can't believe how many guys I hear say "I can't find any nice wood". Either they are blind or just haven't looked. I get it by the trailer load.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#4

Betty Scarpino

Re: Know What Good Wood Is

Betty Scarpino

First a turner needs to know what good wood is ... many don't. Faced with a dump truck full of logs or rooting through someone's firewood pile, what should be left alone and which logs are worthwhile?

Then, how to process the wood? Mistakes abound. I've made my share.

Is the wood given away at local club venues really a good source? I usually keep the best grade for myself :D

Yes, there is plenty of really great turning wood available in just the places you've listed. Learn how to recognize the good stuff and understand that it's best to toss the crappy wood onto the firewood pile.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#5

Re: Know What Good Wood Is

John Lucas

Ditto what Betty just said. Over and over again I'm asked how to fix a problem on a piece. The problem was the piece itself. We spend hours and hours teaching people how to fill cracks in wood and if they had been more careful in their wood selection the cracks wouldn't exist.

Now I know it's hard. I went through that myself and spent far too much time trying to save pieces that should have been tossed.

First of course you gotta keep your eyes open for wood. It's everywhere. Then you need a good chainsaw because usually the wood that has already been cut into firewood blanks or that length is starting to crack especially if it sits too long. If you have a chainsaw and can get to the wood before they cut it too small you've saved yourself a lot of work. You can cut away the cracked ends and then cut it down to a size easy to load into your vehicle and then deal with it better when you get home.

All of my early turning was segmented work because I didn't understand how to find larger wood that didn't have cracks. It was a great learning experience because I have that knowledge stored away when I need to make a segmented piece.

That brings me to another point. When you get a 10" section of a half long and it has some minor cracks. Don't insist on making it 10". Cut the cracks away and redesign the piece. It will be far better without the cracks and consequent patches. smaller yes, but definitely better.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#6

Steven Antonucci

Once you have good wood, how do you keep it good?

steven antonucci

Thanks for giving away all of my wood hoarding secrets, Brad!

Once you have the wood, what do you do to make sure it stays good? The answer is generally nothing. If I get wood in log form, I try to keep the ends covered to minimize checking from heat and wind. Anchorseal, butting up other logs, piles of shavings, old latex paint... whatever you can.

We're also overlooking a simple fact.

What is the good wood good for? I used to knock off limbs as fast as I could cut them and have the kids drag them away so I could get to the "good stuff". Now that I am also carving spoons and ladles, those limbs are pretty useful too! Would I save a limb from white oak for a ladle? Probably not (ring porous... soup in the pores!)

This is a crazy hobby. Not only do you need to find sources of wood, but you need to learn the trees, the working properties of both wood and the individual trees, how to work with different parts of the trees, how to control moisture loss... it never ends.

That's why I love it.

Steve

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#7

Re: Once you have good wood, how do you keep it go

dick gerard

I thought white oak was used to make water tight vessels because the tyloses are plugged off. red oak,, yes, I can understand not using that for a spoon or ladle. You can actually blow air through red oak end grain. But I've never known that to happen with white oak.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#8

Re: Once you have good wood, how do you keep it go

Craig Daymon

I remember going to a lumber yard and talking to one of the yard workers about wood. I forget how we got to the subject, but he pointed out in the yard to a large trunk with a rotted core. He said, "See that, that's red oak. It's crap." After which, he pointed to a solid trunk and said that it was white oak.

I think the ray flecks in red are suppose to be a bit stronger than in white, but for wood quality/durability, white oak wins hands down.

I imagine a good bath of Anchorseal would assist in preserving any free wood you get as long as you cut and coat it soon enough. (Though something like red oak may be prone to rot from the inside all on its own.) If you get a load like Mark described, you better order a few 50 gallon drums.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#9

Steven Antonucci

Wait! What!  Smaller is better! ;-)

steven antonucci

A cracked piece of wood usually gets a splitting maul. Ain't nobody got time fo'dat!

S

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#10

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

phillip Medghalchi

Barry, you can always be nice and send soem our ways we pay for a large flat rate box, if you are willing.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#11

Re: Know What Good Wood Is

phillip Medghalchi

Betty, couldn't say it any better, I think you hit the nail on the head. I think that's the main problem with some of us.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#12

Re: Once you have good wood, how do you keep it go

phillip Medghalchi

Well, Steven, you think you can enlighten us with your experience in what you have learned and share some of your secrets? I promise not to tell any one. It may be very beneficial to some of us to learn and recognize the good quality wood. Perhaps if time allows you making a new thread to share with us what you know. it would be great if you can help.

John has a point and I am sure each and every one of us including me has spent some times fixing what should have been walked away, but I think what contributes to it is the feeling of that you spent sometimes shaping it and you do not want to throw it away. I am not sure which is the right answer, but I think that may be the main reason, or the lack of knowledge, thereof.

I am glad some of you more experience turners touching up on subjects that were overlooked for a long time now.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#13

Steven Antonucci

Secrets (Shhh... don't tell anyone!)

steven antonucci

All wood is good from something, but not all wood is good for everything.

As an example, we've all seen people posting pictures of bowls with cracks in them. What can you do with this wood? You could cut it smaller to get past the cracks. You could split it along the crack to make spindle material. You could get another piece of wood.

To me, a beginner (not derogatory) is someone who starts at 11"x5" with cracks and makes a bowl with cracks that is 10.9x 4.9". In a lot of cases, it comes down to they don't know where to get wood, so they've paid for it... and there is no possible way that they're going to turn it down smaller!

More experience turners have developed sources for free wood as well as the proficiency to be able to take a block of wood and get to basic form in a few minutes. I know a guy who said it took him 4 hours to make a 10" bowl. I would be sanding it in 15 minutes, so I don't have the same amount of time into the wood as he does. It doesn't bother me to "lose" a bowl (most times :) )

Brad's list is pretty extensive, and I don't even need that many sources to keep my shop in shavings. The only wood I purchase is kiln dried hard maple for some production items I turn. I only buy it because I cannot find clean hard maple in a log, or I would saw it and air dry it myself. I turn down half of the logs I am offered.

No matter where you live, there is local wood that is suitable for some purpose on the lathe. You'd be amazed at how fast you go from "can't find" to "no thanks".

S

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#14

Re: Secrets (Shhh... don't tell anyone!)

phillip Medghalchi

I confess that in my case was that I was attracted to the grain pattern, and I am growing to learn that think of it this way that it was going to end up as becoming ashes and disappear all together, so just learn form it and be glad yo gave it another life to exist again and be enjoyed, but I think I had to pay my dues to get here. No matter how pretty a piece of wood may be it would have been all gone, and no one even would have cared about it. In my case, I have gotten some wood all the way form Australia, and I know it wouldn't even grow anywhere, I mean literally anywhere in USA, so I am still waiting to build up my nerves to try to make my friend proud of what he took time to send me. However, I a thinking well, the worse case scenario is that I may even blow it up on the lathe. However, wife says I need to finish the 30+ pieces that are sitting in the box and waiting for the final finish and do something about them before I design something new. I think she got a point. but, then again, I guess wwe all have to start somewhere, huh?

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#15

Betty Scarpino

Cracks / grain pattern

Betty Scarpino

A novice woodturner often cannot distinguish between a hairline crack and wood-grain pattern (which is understandable). If you think a bowl blank might have a crack in the endgrain, one way to determine if it is, indeed, a crack, would be to cut off a 1/8" slice of the endgrain, then break it. It will usually break on the crack before breaking anywhere else. If you're still not sure, bandsaw off another thin slice, marking where you think the crack might be, then break the piece.

One truism: Endgrain cracks usually run deeper than you think.

Another truism: Endgrain cracks open up with the heat of sanding and are pretty much impossible to disguise.

But, if what you are doing is practicing turning, who cares if the wood has endgrain cracking/checking?

Or, who cares? Maybe endgrain cracking/checking is not the big deal we turners make it out to be .....

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

Brad Vietje

Glad I got something started here.

Another source could be firewood itself. Since cord wood is usually split already, we may not get much say in how it has been split -- or how it then split, but even older, dried firewood can yield really terrific spindle blanks. I have seen some stunning Curly Sugar Maple delivered as firewood. Makes great pepper mills, small projects, and dozens of pens from a single good stick of firewood.

One potential issue is that wood for burning is not handles the same as wood for turning, but if there is good, solid wood between the cracks, it will probably be very stable, since the stress is already been released from splitting and the cracks that are already there. Always look for more cracks -- ALWAYS! It's also good to be really careful when sawing up odd-shaped chunks of wood on a bandsaw or other tool -- make sure it will sit solidly, and not rotate into the blade; shim underneath, or use a V-block when needed.

I agree with Betty about end grain checks on practice wood, but only where safety is not compromised. We can get hurt while turning for practice or for profit.

Now get out there and get some wood!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT -- way out in the woods....

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#17

Re: Cracks / grain pattern

phillip Medghalchi

Betty, I wonder about this statement though, you wrote:

"Or, who cares? Maybe endgrain cracking/checking is not the big deal we turners make it out to be ....."

now you got me thinking that do we as wood turners make a big deal out of it? After all we are working with a medium that is very unique and I noticed that even when you get kiln dried wood there still possibility of checks and cracks and all other stuff that can happen if you are getting in in rough sawed lumber then you have to plane and joint the board to get the optimum wood you need for your projects, then you are dealing with the price different. In our case we are trying to create something creative out of a piece of log that otherwise would have been destroyed for good and we give it another chance in life, so wouldn't be unique to have some natural look of the actual thing in the work, or am I not perfectionist enough. My thoughts are that if you go to the store to buy china for daily use then you do not get that fancy with the work since you know that it's going to take beatings, however, if you buy china for showcasing and art then yes you will get picky about the workmanship, so would it be fair to say the purpose of the item we make on the lathe would determine the final quality of the wood it's being worked on. Like, If you are paying few $K fir te price of an art work then you would get picky about what you are buying and if you are buying a bowl for daily use that it wood get picked up and scratched by the kids and all the good stuff then little natural roughness or cracks filled to give it a little character is acceptable? I may be all wrong, again.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#18

Steven Antonucci

Eventually, you run out of shelf space

steven antonucci

I have thrown out a ton of early stuff that I made. Some of it was so bad, there wasn't anything to be done with it. I hope you get there someday.

I have pieces with no cracks in them that just aren't right too. When I run out of space, they go next...

S

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#19

Steven Antonucci

Everyday use pieces still shouldn't be cracked

steven antonucci

imagine you went somewhere to buy everyday china and all of the plates and bowls had been dropped and then reglued and filled with CA and glitter? Would you want that?

Even if you thought that it was attractive, long term, would you expect that repair to hold up to every day use? Or split or have bits fall out?

Is it a big deal? Absolutely not, but I won't do it.

S

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#20

Cracks,,,, Checks and Shake

Keith Newton

I find it a little tiring to read cracks used on a forum about turning.

A novice may not know the difference in a radial check, and a ring shake. The ring shake can take your head off, or at least put a big knot on it if ignored.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#21

Re: Cracks,,,, Checks and Shake

John Jordan

There are a couple of articles on my website that may be helpful and illustrate some of the many good points that others have already shared. Click articles at the top of the page.

IMO, a relative beginner should never use wood that is cracked-it may not be safe. Steve talked about the new turner that tries to make a big bowl out of cracked/crappy/rotten wood. If you turn a bowl from cracked wood, and you end up with a cracked bowl. It takes skill and thought to use marginal material well.

John

for some reason the link won't attach so here is the URL: www.johnjordanwoodturning.com

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#22

Re: Cracks,,,, Checks and Shake

phillip Medghalchi

Keith, you may like to coin new term for it, what would you like to call it? It would follow the previous thread about the turning terminology.

I think no one was ever novice? They all had to start some where. You may have had more time spent in it to learn what you have learned, then again term novice is subjective in itself, what determines a novice, 1 month, 1 yr, 2 yr ten yr? It all depends on how much time was spent to pursue certain interest. How much dedications went into it. We are just discussing what Brad was kind enough to share with some of the ones who do not have the privilege of having all kind of trees growing around them, because of the geographical problems or even not being able to afford a $150 burl when the big guys sell them. It's like discussing other aspects of the turnings. I think in making any thing the best material identification is as important as the creation of it. wouldn't you agree?

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#23

Steven Antonucci

Defining: Cracks, Checks and Shake

steven antonucci

A ring/wind shake occurs when the tree separates between growth rings. These trees probably don't need any time on your lathe.

A check usually occurs radially from the center of the log to the edge, and is cause by stresses from drying too quickly. Moisture comes out of end grain faster than side grain, and so something needs to give. If you leave a log longer than it is wider, you can usually cut length off the log to get past the checking and into solid wood.

A crack is something that occurs man made. You might get a catch with a scraper that splits the bowl or knocks a chunk out of it.

In all three cases, the wood should be firewood.

S

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#24

Re: Defining: Cracks, Checks and Shake

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, appreciate the definition of those terms, I knew about them, I wasn't too sure if keith was referring to cracks as a result of discussion we have that he is getting tired of hearing about them. They are what they are whatever you want to call them and all the above will apply including the sanding heat. So, I thought he might want to give it a new term for our trade so, it would sound pleasing.

Re: Obtaining Good Wood for Turning

#25

Betty Scarpino

Re: Cracks / grain pattern / who cares?

Betty Scarpino

Philip,

In response to your question about this statement: "Or, who cares? Maybe endgrain cracking/checking is not the big deal we turners make it out to be ....."

First of all, I'm talking about minor "blemishes," not about anything that would be structurally unsafe to turn.

I'd have to ask: What is your intention with making the bowl or vessel? If it's to sell and you think that's your best work, then fine--maybe someone will buy it and be perfectly happy with its look and use. If it's to use for food, perhaps the minor cracks and checks could be problematic for having food get into the cavities. Or, if for popcorn or keys or as a doorstop who cares -- the bowl works for its intended use.

The accepted standard in the sales arena, however, is not to have cracks or checking in the endgrain. Those cracks and checks are the result of the curing process and can be avoided with careful wood selection and preparation. And, it takes time, attention, and effort to build the knowledge and skills to have a full understanding of wood and its properties so that harvesting can be accomplished flawlessly.