Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

sanding disc

Posts

sanding disc

#1

Dick Hines

sanding disc

Dick Hines

I just got a shipment of sanding disc from Vince. He sent me a few green disc. Have not had time to thy them yet.

Have any of you guys had a chance to use the green disc. The price is about the same as the blue ones.

Re: sanding disc

#2

Re: sanding disc

phillip Medghalchi

I do not have any luck with the blue ones. He claimed they last longer than his competition which is jokes. klingspor last much longer than his and cuts much better. Good luck with your disks, and do spend more money on them soon.

I attached some pic.s bellow, so you don't think I am making it up so you can judge it for your

the explanation is that the blue ones still have their particles on them but due to what you see is created that is down to it's backing film which in most cases they leave a stain on the wood.

Now, the white one in the picture is a 80 grit Klingspor disk that I used last night to sand inside of a bowl I was working on which had some tear out from the tool marks and it is 3" dia. it holds up very well and the edges are worn due to the cracks in the wood, but what I do is that I cut it down to a 2" disk and I can still use it on a 2" disk holder and the backing of it is tough paper which holds up very well and I don not get the bluish film melted on the wood that I have to sand that out again.

Before any one going and attacking this post you make your own judgment on those disks and I sand on the lathe at about 250 RPM and in most cases I sand by hand (holding the sanding disk in my hand backing it with a back up pad, so I am not pushing it hard on the wood or running it fast to create heat.

additionally, I started spraying soapy (dish water soap-Kitchen) on the pieces lately to eliminate dust and also get a much better finish when I get to 180 grit and Vince's disk so not hold up to wet sanding Vs. Klingsor and they last longer. When the sludge builds up I put the on a velcro'ed backed larger disk and I clean it with neoprene disk cleaning block and I can get a lots of millage out of them this way.

This is solely my experience with them and as I stated in another post I don't think they are worth the money that we the turners spend on them. Also, they are expensive. so, this is my input, you can make a judgment on your own merit.

Re: sanding disc

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: sanding disc

Chuck Jones - West TN

Dick I have some of the green ones that Vince gave me, but I get along so well with hid blue ones I haven't been motivated to try anything else.

Now that you mention it, I think I will get them out and try them.

Re: sanding disc

#4

Re: sanding disc

robo hippy

Phil, I was wondering why our experiences with Vince's Blue discs are so different. Maybe the soapy water is the reason. I typically can get a 3 bowl cored set (14, 11, and 9 inch diameters) done with one set of discs. The 80 grit does flake off a bit, but not really a problem. I have had no issues with 120 and above losing the grit off the plastic film. I have wet sanded with walnut oil, but didn't like that, too messy, and the discs loaded up with sludge. I do soak my bowls in soap water first, then let them dry, and then sand.

robo hippy

Re: sanding disc

#5

Re: sanding disc

Vince Welch

Hi Dick,

The new discs are called GreenFlex and I believe they are excellent! They are filmed backed like the BlueFlex. They are a bit more aggressive then the BlueFlex, seem to load even less and I am getting a longer last from these discs. Additionally, these discs are marked with each grit on nearly each disc! I really think folks are going to like these discs!

Hi Phillip,

I truly am sorry if you have not had much luck with my BlueFlex discs. The claims I make are not intended as a joke! The fact is the BlueFlex discs are a proven discs that have been used by hobbyist and professionals for many years. As I recall you posted back in April I believe that you were not happy with the product and your back up pads had failed. You also made comments at that time to lead me to believe that I had offended you stating something to the effect "he was not interested in customer service after the sale!" Well nothing could be farther from the truth as I speak to countless people coaching and trying to help them in their sanding process. I responded to your post at that time offering you a full apology for any miscommunication or behavior on my part that occurred. I even invited you to call me toll free so you and I could discuss any issues and clear the air. To my knowledge you have not called me! Again I invite you to call me! Toll Free 1-877-284-8969 If you are unsatisfied with my products or not happy with me we can discuss these issues and hopefully clear the air. If you have not had any luck with my sanding discs... SWAT will be here in 3 weeks... please bring your unused discs back to me and I will be more than happy to provide you a refund!

Phillip, I want you to be happy and successful in your sanding efforts! As I often tell folks I am here to provide the very best products and the very best service period! I value each and every customer!

Thanks, Vince

Re: sanding disc

#6

Re: sanding disc

John Lucas

Well I don't wet sand but the Blue discs outlast any other discs I've tried so far. I have not tried the new green ones. I used to be a Klingspor gold fan until I tried the blue discs from Vince. I get much more life out of them and have even made myself a small punch so I can save the middle section for use on my really small homemade discs that I use for sanding carvings.

Re: sanding disc

#7

Brad Vietje

Thanks for the great support, Vince!

Brad Vietje

I have been using home-made discs I cut out of Wurth 6" round pads I got from an auto-body shop years ago (they're probably 152mm, not 6", since they come from Germany).

When I look for new discs and sources, I'll definitely try some of these blue & green discs.

Phillip -- looks like you may be catching an edge on a crack and crumpling the discs somewhat. Are they failing at the flex point where the disc bends? You may need to change the angle between the disc and the wood a little so the edge doesn't catch (?) Good luck -- seems like Vince is more than willing to help.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: sanding disc

#8

Re: sanding disc

Michael Gibson

I haven't tried the Greens ones yet, l believe Vince's blue are the best out there. Michael

Re: sanding disc

#9

Re: sanding disc

Marvin J Ewing

I have used the blue disc for years and years and they are without a doubt the best sanding discs that I've ever used. Vince will gives excellent customer service.

Re: sanding disc

#10

Re: sanding disc

Dale Bonertz

Vince helped me years ago with sanding issues. Every since that 1/2 hour long conversation and applying the methods he suggested has cured my sanding issues. I still use the blue also. Now if I could only get him to come to the Rocky Mountain Woodturning Symposium!!!

John, What did you make your punch out of?

Re: sanding disc

#11

Re: sanding disc

John Lucas

Dale I just used some Drill rod that I had laying around. Center drilled it on my metal lathe for the size that I needed (about 1/2 I think) and turned the outside to a cone shaped point and sharpened it with diamond hones. I need to make one for 1". I bought a commercial leather punch that is 1" at the flea market but I'm saving that one for my leather work. I drilled a hole at an angle through the side so I could use a dowel to push the discs out.

Re: sanding disc

#12

Steven Antonucci

I use the easy button

steven antonucci

I also save the middles after the outside is shot.

I make my own holders, so I don't know exactly how big they are, but let's say 2.5" and 1.5"?

Once the outer edge is spent, I simple stick the disc to the smaller pad and trim around it with scissors. precision is completely up to you, but it doesn't need to be perfect. I have a cheap pair of beater scissors in the shop just for cutting sandpaper.

As the discs get worn, they get tossed in a pile. I process them in bunches. Probably can do 20 in 2-3 minutes...

No, I am not making the mini ones like John... but if you cannot find punches, scissors are close enough...

S

Re: sanding disc

#13

Re: sanding disc

david walsh

I have used 1000's of Vince's blue discs over the past several years and have found them the best of any I have tried. My discussions of sanding with him have always improved my sanding technique. The discs in the picture appear vastly overused to my eye and are as beat up as I have ever seen. I have never had the disc stain or melt onto the woods surface and I use a lot of manzanita which is a difficult a wood to sand because of all the voids. I do about 1000 bowls a year sanding each to 2000 grit. The discs I use never reach the condition of those in the picture. I drill sand on the lathe at 300-500 rpm stopping to hand sand problem areas. I don't use a disc for more than 60-80 seconds before disposal. This really saves me time and money as sanding goes so much quicker with many fewer problems with surface imperfections. I would much rather make more bowls and less time sanding. I would give Vince and his sanding discs both 5 stars.

Re: sanding disc

#14

Re: sanding disc

robo hippy

I never have punched out the centers of my 3 inch discs. When sanding the outside of the bowl, I have more of the center of the disc on the wood, and when sanding the inside, I use more of the edge, so when done, the disc is pretty much toasted. I have found that the blue discs can feel dull as in when you rub your finger across them, they feel slicker than the fresh discs. Funny thing is that they still cut really well, and I have to judge sharpness by how much dust is coming off.

The only other disc I found that cuts as well as the blue ones from Vince are the Dry Ice ones from Norton. I did 2 sets of bowls from the same tree. Durability was about the same, with almost no difference in how long they cut. The main difference was in the price, with the Norton discs being about 2 1/2 times the cost at that time, maybe 4 or 5 years back.

robo hippy

Re: sanding disc

#15

Dick Hines

Re: I use the easy button

Dick Hines

I have not a chance to use the green disc yet. Doing a lot of rough turning.

I do not wet sand anything. I don't know of any disc or sand paper that is intended to be used on dry wood that will stand up to wet sanding. I don't wet sand but if I did I would more than likely use wet/dry paper that is made for wet sanding.

I have great luck with the blue disc. Have been using them for years. We will see if I change. Even if I don't I stay with the blue ones they will come from Vince.

Re: sanding disc

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: sanding disc

Mike Stafford

I have never seen discs so dilapidated. Something is very wrong with the way you are sanding Philip.

I use water and/or wax as a lubricant and have never seen a disc look like the one pictured.

Re: sanding disc

#17

Re: sanding disc

Josh bowman

+++ on Vinces blue disks. I've tried wet sanding with oil. Not certain it's a good mix with closed back paper. Maybe better with mesh. Vincent will certainly help you out. Give him a call. I've talked with him twice, once on the phone when I was just starting out. Once again at a symposium. Wealth of knowledge on a boring part of the process. I know no one that has spent more time with this task. Good luck.

Re: sanding disc

#18

Re: sanding disc

Barry L Elder

My 2 cents: The gentleman with the gripe has by now grasped the fact that he is abusing the product he complains about. There are probably 50,000 woodturners out there with the same problem. I use discs sold by someone else, not Vince. We were starting the local woodturning club at the same time that Vince was getting started and I was tasked with getting some discs to be given out to club members, which we did, and I don't know who liked what. The discs from Vince that I tried were too aggressive for my style of sanding. So I will use the Mirka as long as they are available or until I totally quit. Until then, please understand that I like to sand in every grit that I can get, and then wet sand with MicroMesh and mineral spirits.

Philip, you really need to join a club and learn by watching, or, take a class at one of the schools and you will really be surprised. And you will be amazed at the finish you can attain on your works of art!

Re: sanding disc

#19

Re: I use the easy button

David Walser

Dick - Whether your sandpaper will stand up to wet sanding depends a lot on what you use as a lubricant. I regularly use walnut oil in my sanding. I've found no need for wet/dry paper when doing so. I've used lots of different sandpapers with walnut oil and never had a problem.

Re: sanding disc

#20

Same Here only....

Wally Dickerman

I use tung oil.

Re: sanding disc

#21

Chuck Jones - West TN

I agree, the disks work well with oil

Chuck Jones - West TN

I haven't done a lot of wet sanding, but a couple days ago I had a 13" x 5" sweet gum bowl that I couldn't get a good finish off the gouge so I used the 3" blue disk with walnut oil and sanded it aggressively through all the grits and it came out amazingly well. Yesterday I cleaned some of those disks on the "eraser" and used them on something else. Not even one slight problem.

Re: sanding disc

#22

Re: sanding disc

phillip Medghalchi

Gentlemen, I have read every one of your replies and I very much appreciate each and every ones help. I do respect dick's post and do not intend to hijack his subject. To ones who suggested me to join a club, I am member of two, San Antonio, and Hill country turners which Jaime Donaldson is going to hold class and demo for us in a very near future. I am aware that I may need improvement in sanding techniques, however, I have learned what I stated above form some of the master turners in my area. To those who said I am abusing the sanding disks, unfortunately, I am not. I have been blessed by exchanging wood with some of my friends form other areas of the world that affords me to experiment with woods that are not local to me, and as such I don't think I have to jump on here and ask evrey time I get a new wood as how to sand it. I should be able to use what's in my arsenal to tackle what I am working on. We have discussed, many tools here that many of turners do not use them and or not comfortable suing them. when it comes to sanding I get a better price and better life from Norton, and Klingspor products. I have had better luck with them and they held up better for my money for my style of sanding. I am not claiming that I am the best sander out there, however, so far this is what I know until someone can show me otherwise. I am open to suggestions and all ears to hear them.

dick appreciate it very much for letting other turners to advise me on your main post.

Re: sanding disc

#23

Re: sanding disc

phillip Medghalchi

David, you must have been very lucky or likable person for him to that for you. If he took time to discuss the sanding process with you he must have been in a good mood that day, it sure didn't happen to me as you experienced.

Re: sanding disc

#24

Bill Blasic

Re: sanding disc

Bill Blasic

I have Vince's blue disks and Steve Worcester's brown disks in bins on the wall. Same grits in each bin just blue and brown. When we have a hands on they are there for use by everyone. I have noticed over the years that those who repeatedly do the hands on reach for the brown disks. Just an observation.

Bill

Re: sanding disc

#25

Re: sanding disc

Peter Lamb

I too use Vince discs for more than five years. The quality and of course price are the best.

Vince has been wonderful teaching me a great deal about abrasives. Great products at great prices!