Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

teaching teachers

Posts

teaching teachers

#1

teaching teachers

Skip Beardsley

I went to a club meeting last night. We are turning pens for a charity project. Some newbies turning with more experienced folks helping. I realized that some of the newbies were sure to be confused because they were getting somewhat different instruction depending who of the more experience turners happened to stop at their lathe at the moment.

So this question....... have any of the clubs had any experience with putting together workshops on how to teach the use of various tools so the newcomers all got the same instruction? Lots of folks can cut with a gouge or a skew, but what is the proper way to present the tool to the wood to get the best results. I would think it would be best to have some sort of standardize instruction and hope to get our club to investigate this issue. Don't want to reinvent the wheel so wonder if others have thought of this.

Skip

Re: teaching teachers

#2

Steven Antonucci

You think it is hard teaching newbies?

steven antonucci

Try teaching experts ;)

I wouldn't volunteer for that job :D

S

Re: teaching teachers

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: You think it is hard teaching newbies?

Chuck Jones - West TN

I have the same thought as Steve on this.

But moreover, one of the things I like about woodturning (and some other arts/crafts/hobbies) is the freedom to do it my way. Discipline and structure definitely has it's place, but please, not here.

It seems that a large number of woodturners are self taught and usually go for a while before becoming involved with clubs etc. Hard to break old habits that work.

We should always make it clear that there are various ways to doing the same thing and not all agree on the best way.

Re: teaching teachers

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: teaching teachers

Ric Taylor

We do have a method for controlling this problem in our club.

Every year we have a weekend retreat in a large building with about 70 to 80 lathes spinning. The area is broken up into about eight areas and we have classes going on where we teach each other various processes and techniques. Nearly everyone in the club does something well, and they teach a wide variety of turning topics.

One area is reserved to teach newbies. There are about a dozen lathes, each with a newbie, and there are two to three instructors for the group. In earlier years we had a problem with "drive by instructors". People walking past the group would stop and tell a newbie to hold the skew differently (or whatever) from what the instructor told them. This caused confusion and complaints from the newbies. Now we have a rule that no drive by instructors are allowed. People are not allowed to disturb the group, people walking by are not allowed to stop and make comments to the newbies.

The problem has been solved. Newbie confusion has been greatly reduced and complaints have stopped.

Ric

Re: teaching teachers

#5

Re: teaching teachers

Barry L Elder

I have never seen a robot doing woodturning and I don't expect to. As Chuck said, we all have our problems, left handed, right handed, or ambidextrous. I would much prefer to see the clubs requiring senior members to use safe practices in their own shops and when teaching others.

Re: teaching teachers

#6

Safety first

Geoff Whaling

Why is it that most of the successful wood turning instructors at least here in Oz come from a shop or manual arts teaching background?

Very few wood turners who instruct in clubs actually have any formal training on "how to train" so there is quite a range in skills both as turners & as instructors/trainers. In Australia trade colleges run "train the trainer" programs to get tradesmen certified as instructors. Such courses will assist anyone wishing to instruct. They assist trainers by giving them the basics to improve delivery of training, & to recognize and assist students with extra needs.

One matter that really scares me in some clubs is the general "acceptance" of unsafe practices, or more so the lack of will to stop them. From my experience the clubs with a strong focus do not have significant problems with safety or training as there is a core membership that set exemplary behaviour as competent & safe turners. The clubs that let new or inexperienced members drift about between whoever may offer advice seem to be the ones that have more issues.

We should never kid ourselves that wood turning is "safe" or that because we have done it "this way for years & got away with it." There often is either a more efficient or safer manner in which to turn but we may not realize it or have been exposed to it. We can all learn more about how to improve what we do.

Unfortunately the hazards & potential risks are often played down to the extent that new turners without a "hands on" tools background do not realize just how unsafe some practices can be, or how quickly a couple of "minor" matters can compound into a disaster. We have lost several turners in recent years to severe head injuries.

The example above about eliminating "drive by instructors" while training newbie’s is one great method to reduce confusion in the delivery of training. I am more inclined to go with matching a mentor to newbie / intermediate turners after basic training to reduce confusion and to "standardize" technique. Have a look at South Auckland Woodturners Guild in NZ - they have weekly demo nights, & a formalized partnership with Aoraki Technical College for a formal training program.

It seems I favour rigid training but that is definitely not the case. I would like to see much more focus on the basics of tool control; hazard awareness; safety controls or how to minimize hazards & potential risks; as ongoing learning either formalized in courses or informal but more so from exemplary behaviour from our leading turners day to day to reduce the more “unsafe” or the potentially high risk practices/behaviour.

Re: teaching teachers

#7

Re: teaching teachers

don stephan

At some point I would think it would be very helpful to expose the students to alternative approaches, so that they can try to find the ones that work best for them, before working to develop muscle memory and technique. Wouldn't think options should be presented in the first 30 minutes, but somewhere. My two cents.