REALLY good or CRAZY?
Roger Chandler
someone just sent this link to a video of a guy felling a huge tree.........wait till you see...........you will be amazed!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
REALLY good or CRAZY?
Roger Chandler
someone just sent this link to a video of a guy felling a huge tree.........wait till you see...........you will be amazed!
Re: REALLY good or CRAZY?
Bob Macgregor
I'm sure it wouldn't have turned out that way if it had been me felling the tree. It still would have been a neat video, just not for the same reason!
Bob
Re: REALLY good or CRAZY?
phillip Medghalchi
He must have been Irish with lots of luck.
Re: REALLY good or CRAZY?
Dick Hines
I would have bet $100 that the shed or house would have a tree in the middle.
Re: REALLY good or CRAZY?
robo hippy
I have seen a logger or two who could have done that. Having a plumb bob (spark plug on a string), accurate cuts, and no wind, would make that possible, but not for me. I know better...
robo hippy
I think I would have hit both....
Re: REALLY good or CRAZY?
Dennis in Southern Oregon
How many times do you suppose it took to get a keeper?
That was TAKE #724 ;^)
Been There
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
But no guts for the free-fall; we used ropes to control the stick, and had "several" more feet each way for clearance. Gunning lines are the feller's friend.
Crazy or fake?
Chuck Jones - West TN
I too call fake video.
Several reasons.
I've dropped a lot of trees and I've seen real loggers drop lots more.
Nobody's that good at aiming a falling tree and those that are wouldn't be foolish enough to try it in such a narrow spot.
His final cut was on the wrong side of the tree.
He supposedly started the fall with the wedges before he yanked his saw our of the cut.
The tree was already on it's way down before he grabbed the saw.
It's interesting how he avoided a bind.
After looking at the video a few more times I do notice that he is using a relatively new type of cut (at least to me) whereby the bulk of the wood is plunge cut from the center and small areas are left on each side to hold the tree. Those side areas are then cut slowly and gradually to allow a greater degree of control over whether the tree veers a bit to the left or right. But even with that, the final cut is made from the back (away from the falling area) to avoid pinching the saw as the weight of the tree comes to bear on the other side.
Sorry. I still don't buy it.
For real.
Jennifer Indy.USA
I think it's for real. I saw the raw uncut video of an interview that Scripps Broadcasting (the company I work for) did with this guy. He's been cutting trees for 40 years and seemed to know what he was talking about. (Not that I do). He talked about how well balanced the tree was up top. That that was the only reason he could do what he did. It was perfectly balanced and there was no wind. Plumb bobs and hundreds of trees of experience. This is his profession. He said that he is insured and bonded and that if something did go astray a few inches one way or another he would have taken care of it. He said he didn't make the video for any notoriety, but that he was video tapping it for his grandkids. So he could show them what Grandpa does.
He was a genuinely neat guy.
I believed him.
That might change my mind
Chuck Jones - West TN
Jennifer, if I saw the interview like you describe I would probably change my mind.
But I'm still puzzled how he made that final cut on the "wrong" side and managed to recover his saw.
With all the advancements in photo and video editing much of the things that float around the internet are so doctored up I have become a grouchy, skeptical old man. 
Re: For real.
phillip Medghalchi
Jennifer let him go to the Vancouver, WA and go to those Cal-de-sacs and or Portland for that matter and let's see if he can bring those long tall tree down in the Cal-de-sac without ruining the place. I think this was just pure luck. Once in a million percent. he just got lucky.
Re: For real.
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
There are several guys in my area who can do the same thing with a "stick" (all the limbs and leads are trimmed off first) and the remainder is dropped within 12" either way of a target line. While they also use wedges, they always use a hinge and guy ropes to prevent an unauthorized home remodeling.
I rather doubt he does it that way on a regular basis 