Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Posts

COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#1

COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Mike Potts

Rescued some Cottonwood & Willow from the firewood pile at the campgrounds. Has anybody worked with these before? I turned a 10"x 4" x 3/16 sidewall, out of the cottonwood, very wet, I had to wipe off my facesheild 4 times to get the outside turned. I single turn and did not get any tear out, which I thought I would. Even after spinning it at 2500 RPM'S it still way to wet to start sanding, guess I'll try that tomorrow. Any advise or tips would be appreciated.

Thanks Mike

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#2

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

steve worcester

Both with move radically when dry. Cottonwood (and Willow) grow very fast so they will have large distances between the annular rings which results in a lot of warping.

Willow, turned once, smelled too much to continue.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#3

Steven Antonucci

the smell is the biggest issue

Steven antonucci

Neither of them ... Both reek.

Steve

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#4

Re: the smell is the biggest issue

Dale Gillaspy

Mike Mahoney has made a pretty good living at turning Cottonwood.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#5

Re: the smell is the biggest issue

Jeff Smith

Perhaps it's just the cottonwood variety that grows here in the Pacific Northwest, but it's pretty miserable stuff to turn - stinks to high heaven usually, tears out easily and has a cel structure so large you can hang your hat on it. After attempting to get something from a large blank, I did a little research. The book on Pacific Northwest Tree varieties says there is little commercial value - the only thing they've found it's good for is horse stalls - it is naturally resistant to horse urine.

I did save a couple of pieces and, when dry the smell was almost tolerable. It is good to practice getting nice clean finish cuts on - if you can get it right on cottonwood you've got it down.

Just my very humble opinion...

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#6

Re: the smell is the biggest issue

Mike Potts

Seems Ohio cottonwood may be a little different that what you've worked with, there was no bad smell. I haven't touched the willow yet so we'll see in a couple of days how it smells.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#7

Steven Antonucci

willow (my only time) was a nightmare

steven antonucci

granted, my willow in my yard was wetter than wet, but it was impossible to cut cleanly. Any tool, any orientation... fuzzy mess.

I'm using it to make a retaining wall for a garden instead. Covered in burls...

S

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#8

Re: willow (my only time) was a nightmare

Bill Boehme

I got some cottonwood last summer and it started cracking before I got it out of my truck. The stink was bad enough just handling the 18" diameter logs that I chickened out of trying to turn it.

The only use that I know about is making kachina dolls.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#9

Chuck Jones - West TN

different kinds of willow

Chuck Jones - West TN

My handbook on trees in Eastern North America lists three varieties of willow, black, white, and weeping.

A few years ago I tried to turn some that I think was black willow, definitely not weeping willow, and it was a bad joke--like others have said.

About a month or two ago one of our favorite weeping willow trees died. The truck is about 12"-14" and I couldn't resist. I rough turned an enclosed bowl sort of thing and have it drying. I checked a few days ago and it's doing great. It had very little fuzzing or tear out like with the other willow, it has not cracked and the warping is minimal.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#10

Re: Cottonwood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is often used for horse stalls. They (the horses) won't "crib" (chew on) it because they don't like the taste.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#11

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Jennifer Indy.USA

I have found both to be stingy, fuzzy and hard to work with especially when it's very wet. Might work better when dried but I was never that patient with it.

Jen

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#12

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Mike Potts

Finished sanding cottonwood bowl, sometimes it nice being a newer turner, I don't know any better than to just get'er done. I'll let it dry for awhile the do a danish oil finish. I have the other half on the lathe now turning a NE bowl. Yard work calls so I won't get a chance to try the Willow till tomorrow.


Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#13

Re: Cottonwood

robert

I got cottonwood burl from Az.turns great and no smell

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#14

Dale, Mahoney turns "Mormon Poplar!"


Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#15

Re: the smell is the biggest issue

Mike Potts

Well I've had a chance to work with both, there wasn't any bad smell from either. There seems to be quite a few varieties that may account for the smell.

Steve two tips: Never spit into the wind and Never turn wood that came from the shade tree over your outhouse.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#16

Re: willow (my only time) was a nightmare

Mike Potts

I cut up the piece of willow this afternoon and was able to get 4 blanks,



It looked like it might be an interesting turn, so I mounted up one.



Not nearly as wet as the cottonwood, but still a pretty wet turn. Got the outside turned, before I even started turning the inside it started cracking.

Really not worth wasting my time on. Even though I don't have multiple girl friends with multiple sisters to give demonstrations to, I do have a Honey-do list longer than both arms

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#17

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

phillip Medghalchi

Is this sopposed to be like a very light yellow and not much character and smells like the cow piss? I first came across this one and every time I tried to turn it it smelled like fresh cow urine and then every time I walked away from it, it would would crack? I see if I still go the other half of it to show you guys, no one could tell me what it was and unfortunately, I got hold of it at the beginning of my turning years and fiddled with it trying to save my work.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#18

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Bill Boehme

How are we supposed to know what cow piss smells like? I thought that it was odorless. :D

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#19

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Barry Irby

I grew up on a dairy farm. I can assure you it is not odorless. Couldn't describe the smell, but it is distinctive and foul.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#20

Allan W

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Allan W

I have turned a couple of pieces of Black Willow. I tried to turn it wet, but it kept spitting all the while I was turning. I let it dry out and then turned a couple of small bowls. End Grain is hard to get smooth. Ended up doing a light finish to stiffen the grain and then lightly returned. This seemed to help with the end grain, but still had quite a bit of sanding.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#21

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Bernie Rose

I keep a chunk of black willow around just for replacement of pieces of knocked off natural edges bark .

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#22

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Barbara Gill

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_turning.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=7545BIY22SIKON7iiww1404902204;spage=1;sanc=118608;sbid=2106;md=read;id=118608#m_118608

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#23

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

bill Crommett

For those who don't know what cow urine smells like should have been with me one day when I got behind a cattle truck on the way to auction. Cows have been known to follow the leader and when one lets go they all let go. I quick headed for the nearest car wash place, but it took a couple of weeks to air out the car's ventilation system.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#24

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

phillip Medghalchi

Bill, were you trying to grab the cotton wood out of their munching jaws. Is the why you were chasing them? :D well, they sure left a memory of it for you.

Thanks, for verbalizing pictorial emotions of smelling the cow PISS. that's what my unknown wood smelled like. I am gonna have to take a pic. of it for you guys.

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

#25

Re: COTTONWOOD & WILLOW

Bill Boehme

My question was meant to ask how the average person whose only relationship to a cow was at the dinner table might know anything about the smell. I do know the smell very well. My parents had cows and so did I. I get reminded of the smell occasionally when following a cattle hauler or passing a feedlot of which there are more than a few here in Texas. There are also cottonwood trees here and to a connoisseur of foul smelling wood, the bouquet is quite distinct from the bovine aroma.