Another thread sort of drifted into outdoor dust collection, so I thought I'd start a new thread and include photos that someone asked for. The photos are of a 2 horsepower dust collector that I recently hooked up to throw the chips and dust out the back of my shop and into the woods behind the shed where I keep my dust collector and compressor. Works for me. No more sweeping or emptying the dust bag. It was simple to do, the hose going into the collector bag was re-routed out back into the woods. Keeps the weeds down too! :-)
I only use my dust collection system for collecting dust. Some old curmudgeon told me years ago that a dust collector was not a vacuum, and in his opinion should not be used as one. I see nearly everyone cleaning up by sucking up all the shavings and dust, and even using a shop vac floor attachment for vacuuming the floor, so I guess it doesn't hurt them -- they just tend to clog up more if you have a lot of long curly shavings from green wood.
I have a use for all the shavings, so I rake & shovel them up, and use them for mulch and in a composting toilet system, so I don't use the dust extractor to bag the shavings. I think a lot of people will benefit from following your example.
I am curious about removing the bags, l heard someway say as it was designed with them they shouldn't be run without. I cannot see it doing that much harm, perhaps someone has a better understanding than l.
I know there are other guys who do this and it's been working for them, Mike. I guess it's OK on the machine, one guy, who is a professional turner literally has a pile the size of a house on the side of his shop. Still uses the same collector.
As far as loosing heat or air conditioning, I always had the collector outside in a shed and haven't noticed a difference. It's only on for short periods of time anyway.
Gotta give Bob Moffett props for helping me with it.
I've had my compressor and DC out in the garage for 10 years or so. Can't put mine in the woods so the bag has to be emptied, but it makes good mulch unless I'm working walnut. Makes for a much quieter basement shop and the air loss is minimal even with the 6" piping and 12-1/2" impeller blower.
Mark, when I lived in NJ (born and raised till I moved to NC 17 years ago), I used my woodworking (didn't turn yet) dust and shavings in the garden till I read that it eats up a lot of nitrogen in the soil. Still worked great at keeping the weeds out of other problem areas of the property though.
The sound was my second biggest reason for moving the DC to the shed. There's something about the pitch of that sound that doesn't agree with my ears. Now, how can I move my planner.....
You are correct on N depletion. It's not a problem at my place, however, because I use pure urea (46-0-0) as ice melter on my walks next to the planted areas.
You guys are about to convince me I have been worrying needlessly about sucking the air out of my shop. I may just leave it like it is and put in a cat door like Barry's and see if I can get one of the fat cats from our barn to come live in the shop.
I still have a gut feeling it has more effect on the heating and cooling than you think. I can't spell injunnearing so I don't know all the factors but my shop is 18,340 cubic feet. My blower is rated at 1100 cfm. To me that means it's capable of changing the air every 16.75 minutes. Don's looks even bigger in the photo.
I'm sure it brings out some heated air, Chuck. The question is how much and will you put up with loosing a little. My shop is a 3 car garage and I honestly haven't noticed any difference whether the DC is on or off (for reasonable amounts of time). The shop is insulated well, but it does have 3 garage doors, 5 windows and a side door that has to have leaks in it anyway. I want "some" fresh air leaking in so any fumes don't cause a problem, so the cracks don't bother me either. I purposely didn't over-insulate around the doors and windows so some fresh air would always be coming in. Guess it's a matter of convenience over some extra $$.
Yes, I know Dick. There is more PVC than you can see in the photos. Also, the flex pipe that's outside is temporary till I get PVC for that as well. The Lowe's by me didn't have the right size. This thing already blows the dust 20 feet out, wait till the smooth PVC is attached!
I'm up at the house and don't know what the cfm rating is. It's a 2 hp motor. The inside diameter of the inlet/outlet ports are 5". Weird size, that's why Lowe's didn't have the PVC. It's an old Grizzly.
Its hard to explain, heat and the feeling of warmth/cool/comfort are very complex. In your shop you may have a couple of pounds of air and literally thousands of pounds of other stuff. There is a huge amount of heat energy stored in the stuff and only a little in the air. Lets say its winter and the DC is on for ten minutes and sucks thousands of cubic feet of air through the shop and back out. (I find that the air comes through a "point source" (the cat door) to the machine, and back out. Pretty much a straight line path. Its cool/cold in the path, but the rest of the shop remains pretty undisturbed. As soon as the DC stops The air becomes still and heat form the surroundings warms up the pound or two of air that's left of the part that was flying through.
I come in on a cold day and turn the heat up. I have a tiny electric heater and it takes a while, but it finally knocks the chill off. The reason it takes a while is its blowing out hot air and the "stuff" is cold and it sucks the heat out of the air. Also, back to the complex part, YOU sense the temperature around you in at least two different ways. Your skin radiates infra red heat to surrounding cold surface. The colder the surfaces, the faster the radiation. Air also conducts the heat off exposed skin. A few degrees makes a dramatic difference in both radiation and conduction.
So, if you run a tool for a minute here and five minutes there the effect will be almost nothing. Thirty minutes or an hour would be more noticeable but it might not be as much as you think. I have a friend that runs his DC all day. Always has a gate open somewhere. Heats the shop with a wood stove. works for him.
You do need to have enough make up air to avoid the back drafting. For a while I did not have a flap in the cat door. it was just a hole the size of a sheet of paper. It made a difference in both heat and AC just putting a loose flap in the hole.
I'm thinking about giving it a try. Less cost and effort than my other plan. But I'm not really going to build a cat door because there are too many other critters that would take up residence in my shop; racoons, possums, armadillo, squirrels, and maybe the old fellow down the road.
Like I said earlier, heating and cooling is not one of my limited set of skills so I appreciate all the input here.
Can you still buy that? I used to get at HD but they no longer carry. Not sure if farm supply stores like TSC sell or not. With some fuel oil and detonator you have modern day explosives.
As far as the air inlet goes, you could make a door that even Wiley Coyote could not get through, assuming you don't want your cat to use it. Just make the flap open inward and cover the out side with hardware cloth. or other heavy screen.
The make up air has got to come from somewhere. In order to have "goes outa" you must have "goes inta". If your shop is leaky enough, the air will find its way in. You must be careful not to overwhelm the wood stove. At some point in every fire, wood fires produce CO. That's why a CO detector is a good idea.
Moving the DC outside was a really good thing for me. The crap is GONE as far as the shop is concerned. If I spill some changing the bag, its not in the shop. I don't care what micron bag I have, any thing that escapes the bag if outside, not in the shop. So, the bulky stuff is gone and so are the fines. Its the fines that are dangerous to your lungs. The noise is vastly reduced. And, in my tiny shop I have more room. Moving it outside was one of the best things I have done for my shop. Now if I could just blow it out into the woods and eliminate the bag that would be another great improvement.
You can buy in Ag stores (Agway, etc, and Garden center types) or, if you'd like to pay twice the price, you can get it at Petco etc. as it's sold under several brands such as "SDoft Paw" as ice melter that won't harm your dog's foot pads.