Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Saw dust as mulch

Posts

Saw dust as mulch

#1

Saw dust as mulch

phillip Medghalchi

This is a qsn. for those of you who are also good in gardening. I gather my saw dust and was trying to put it down around my trees in my yard, I noticed that when you go to water it makes a very hard barrier around the trees. Is this any good for the trees? Secondly, can the saw dust mixture of different woods like walnut, maple, Mesquite, cedar elm, red cedar (aromatic) be any harmful to some trees or shrubs, or even flowers. I am hoping that Rob, can help me with this as he knows about trees and their structural make up.

If the answer is yes then what's the best use for the shavings, should I try to give it to some one who has ranch for cattle and live stocks to lay on? what do you guys do with them?

I forgot to mention that I have two large compost bins one is the type that is like a bucket with a rod in the middle so you can spin it to turn the mix. (costco) and the other one is made by rubber made. I have been putting veggies and the fruit scraps in it clippings and also the wood shavings, but I am not sure that if this mixture would be harmful or too acidic for some flowers or for my pear, flowering plum, live oak and, Japanese black pine tree I got. what say you?

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#2

Re: Saw dust as mulch

Terry Scott

Hi Philip

I used to put the raw shaving around our trees and gardens (we have 1/2 an acre of Garden ) plus another 1/2 of lawn )

This was fine as it gave me a chance to find all the tools that got lost

One day however I noticed our buxus (ive planted 1200 as borders) in patches were dying

It turns out that some timber species are poison to other trees and shrubs.Because of the amount of shavings and the different timbers I use I dont know what one caused all the damage .The neighbor now collects for his chook shed

I would thisng composting first maybe the way to go

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#3

Re: Saw dust as mulch

Barry Irby

Terry is right. There are trees that have defenses against other trees. Walnut has Juglones (sp?) which makes it difficult for other seeds to germinate below them. It is also hazardous to horses so don't give walnut sawdust to anyone wanting to use it for bedding for horses. I don't know of any specific treats for other trees, but there may be some.

My understanding is that composting it first will negate the problems. Mixing green matter in it will accelerate the process. Also, raw sawdust will rob nitrogen out of the soil. The bacteria that decompose it need nitrogen and will aggressively take it from the surroundings, robbing it from the plants. Add some nitrogen fertilizer to your compost pile and wet it thoroughly and watch what happens. It can heat up to well over 140 degrees. I did not believe it until I stuck my hand in a pile that was steaming.

I was making a huge pile of saw dust because I had gotten too lazy to compost it and use it, and my son set it on fire. It burned for weeks. The ashes are an excellent soil amendment.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#4

Don Leydens

Re: Saw dust as mulch

Don Leydens

Terry and Barry got it right, don't use shavings for livestock of gardening.

I have my dust collector set up so it blows all my shavings and sawdust right out the back of my shop and into the woods behind my house. Keeps the weeds out and I never have to sweep anything.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#5

Re: Saw dust as mulch

John Veerkamp

AS long as I don't use pure walnut , I don't have any problems with using turning residue for mulch. As you noted it does compact and makes an impervious water barrier. If you regularly break up the crust, it works just fine.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#6

I am so jealous....

Barry Irby

I can't figure out why anybody wants a dust COLLECTOR. I don't want to collect it. That's the problem, I already have a collection. I want a dust remover or destroyer. If I could I would do exactly what you are doing. Blow the crap right out into the woods and never touch it again. Emptying the bag never comes up at a good time.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#7

Don Leydens

I hear ya

Don Leydens

A buddy and myself just finished hooking this up a few days ago and I couldn't be happier with it. It's hooked up to my disc/belt sander, a movable floor vacuum hose, my lathe for sanding and a floor receptacle for sweeping the chips into. Gates change the flow direction.

I got a 2 horsepower extractor real cheap when a business closed down and instead of collecting it in a bag, I changed it around to just shoot the hose outside the shed I have it in and out into the woods. Blows the stuff 20 feet out and keeps the weeds down, too. Sorry to gloat, but maybe this will give other folks some ideas.

Don

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#8

Chuck Jones - West TN

One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Chuck Jones - West TN

It's going to be back to the bag for me. When I built a new shop a few years ago I took the blower off my dust collector, mounted it in the attic, piped the dust into the woods and thought "What a smart boy am I". Then winter came and I realized it was pulling the smoke from my wood burning stove right down the pipe and into the shop. I later installed an air conditioner, and guess what it does to the efficiency of the A/C.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#9

Don Leydens

Re: One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Don Leydens

Sorry to hear about the smoke and AC, Chuck. I'm lucky as my dust collector was always in the shed outside the shop anyway, so I lose a little heat, but don't use AC at all. I like the idea of opening up the garage doors and windows and kind of feel like I'm turning outside. Kills me when the cold weather comes and I have to close everything up and feel claustrophobic again. 8-(

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#10

Re: I hear ya

phillip Medghalchi

Don, we need a pic. of it,please.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#11

Re: One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Bernie Rose

I blow my saw dust directly outside, but for a different reason. I modified my collector intake to fit a 6 in. PVC pipe, but the force of the suction kept blowing the top bag off the machine into the paint locker ---------- what a mess to clean up ! So, in desperation I altered the outlet to bypass the bag and blow the sawdust directly out onto the path, which makes for soft walking.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#12

Re: One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Barry Irby

Not sure I understand why going back to the bag would help? Unless you put the bags inside the shop. Mine are in an exterior shed and there is some lose of heat and AC, but I only run the dc when I am running a tool so it is intermittent. If the shop is temperature controlled, most fo the heat or "cool" is stored in the stuff other than air (drywall, wood, steel, concrete, whatever) and the air will recover quickly once the DC is turned off.

I have electric heat so back drafting is no problem, but with a wood stove or other fired heating system it could be dangerous. You need to open up a source for "free" air. I ahve a cat door in my shop and It opens when the dc comes on.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#13

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Chuck Jones - West TN

Barry, I plan to have the bags and filter inside the shop and keep the motor either in the attic or an adjunct building. You may have a good point about the minimal effect on the cooling. I'm not knowledgeable of air conditioning. I do open a window a bit when I have to use it now, but it sure seems to pull both the heat and cool out. Maybe my imagination. :)

I sure don't want to give up my wood stove. That's how I get rid of most of my turnings. :D

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#14

Re: One problem with blowing dust into the woods

Barry Irby

Chuck, You are mixing a couple of concepts together.

Because your DC sucks air out of your shop and dumps it outside, it creates negative pressure inside the shop. The same amount of air MUST come back in from somewhere and it will take the path of least resistance. In winter you probably have the shop closed up fairly tight and it would suck the "fumes" back down the flue for the stove. If the stove is burning those fumes would be smoke and sometimes carbon monoxide. The draft on the stove is not very powerful and the DC easily overwhelms it. If you open a window the stove draft MAY be strong enough to function even with the DC running. In summer, when the stove is not burning producing fumes, the DC still sucks air down the flue, but it is probably harmless, but it may smell a bit.

The other thing that is going on is the system is sucking conditioned air out of the shop and it gets replaced with whatever air is outdoors. What makes this a bit tricky is that what you need to do is replace the heat or "cool" in that air. It really does not take a lot of energy to reheat or re-cool that bit of air. As long as you run the DC in short bursts, the energy stored in all the other stuff in the shop will quickly compensate for the loss of the air. This concept works no matter how the heat or AC is produced. Since I have Electric heat (No Dangerous or smelly fumes) I don't have to be concerned with back-drafting.

I turn on my DC and watch the cat door swing open. My experience is that the air flows in through the little door and to what ever tool is operating and out. It gets cold between the door and tool, but the rest of the shop is relatively undisturbed.

If you dump the air back into the shop, there is no need for make up and little fear of back drafting, so you are right about that. I still like my set up as the dust and noise are outdoors.

It might be a good idea for you to get a CO monitor for your shop.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#15

I can't help myself from a mental......

JamieDonaldson

..image, but does the inflow of air rushing in through the cat door also pop the cat inside like a projectile? :D

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#16

Re: Saw dust as mulch

phillip Medghalchi

OK, guys how did we go from my qsn. to air filtration in the shop. I am not trying to burst your bubbles, however, that discussion should have been under air filtration maybe?

I am interested to hear about Air filtration, however, this became two different subjects to discuss here.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#17

Don Leydens

Re: Saw dust as mulch

Don Leydens

Hi Phillip! Sounds like you're getting upset that the thread has drifted away from your original question so I'll start another thread and include the photos of my system that were asked for. I thought we pretty much covered your original question. The saw dust is not good for mulch or animal bedding.

Don

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#18

Brad Vietje

Technically a dust EXTRACTOR


Re: Saw dust as mulch

#19

Disagree . . Partly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've used cherry, ask, maple, sycamore, dogwood, and birch for plant's bed mulch with absolutely no negative effect. Notice I left out Walnut. Walnut will kill plants as well as horses.

But, if your looking to have it feed your plants wood dust takes a long time to break down (even in composting bins) so its not really useful as a fertilizer. Wood shop dust is, I think, too fine to be used for animal bedding; just as bad for their lungs as it is for ours.

If you do spread it around your trees, be sure to keep the bole of the tree clear to prevent bark rot and other vascular diseases; think "donut" rather than "pile".

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#20

Re: I can't help myself from a mental......

Barry Irby

My son has a Chihuahua named Wilson Picket who is pretty sure HE owns the cat. The dog is somewhat over weight at seven pounds. The cat is obese at eighteen pounds. The NASA Wind Tunnel would not pop this cat anywhere. The door swinging in does baffle him and he sits and waits for it to return to normal to go out. He's fine with it coming in except that he goes through the shop at what passes for Warp Speed for him.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#21

Chuck Jones - West TN

Funniest thing I've read all day.

Chuck Jones - West TN

I guess you have to be a pet lover to appreciate that.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#22

Re: Saw dust as mulch

phillip Medghalchi

Hi, Don,

Like I said it in my previous post "I am not trying to burst your bubbles, however, that discussion should have been under air filtration maybe?"

I did not mean to not have that conversation, simply because that when some one wants to do a search on the subject it'll be all mixed up and they have to read through all of the first qsn. before they can get to what they are looking for.

Secondly, I was the one who asked for pic.s because I had hard time trying to envision how the process works, plus I was hoping that some one who lives in the suburb with other people in the housing area which the houses are built close to each other due to land limitation' would offer a solution to this dilemma, since I have it and can't figure out what or how to battle it. I do have the HF dust collector I think is the 1.5 hp and have not put it together, because I have a profound hearing loss so I have to use hearing aids and the sound of the vacuum cleaner/dust collection running on that pitch is not the most pleasant thing to listen to. Also, when I asked my hearing Dr. he just came out and said "why are you wearing your hearing aids when turning?" I thought that was a dumb qsn. he asked, then I realized that he probably been never around a lathe and watching or realizing that to the turner it's important to hear the sound of the wood coming to the cutting edge of the gouge. that's how I replied to my Dr. to make him understand about that.

Now, back to the dust issue, i like to know what's the alternative, or how to use my dust collection while I am turning w/O worrying about too much high Decibels of sounds is sent to my hearing aids and not eing able to detect the actual cutting edge of the cutter with the wood which at any moment can tell me if something is about to go wrong.

if we were in another forum this discussion would've been asked by the moderator to be moved to another thread, in order to keep the thread from being derailed.

so, the answer to your qsn. is no I was not upset. I was going to ask the above discussion under the dust collection.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#23

Chuck Jones - West TN

My apologies

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm the one that led it off track. Wasn't thinking.

Re: Saw dust as mulch

#24

Re: To Answer Your Original Question

William Duffield

Not all walnut is harmful all the time. If you google "walnut toxicity plant list" you will find lists of plants and animals harmed and those that are not affected by walnut, from several state universities.

The first one that I found useful is from OSU:

http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/1000/1148.html

Note that black walnut and butternut are toxic to some plants, while English (Carpathian) walnut is not. That's probably why it is necessary to graft English walnut onto a disease resistant rootstock in order to grow it (claro walnut) in California. Also, note that there is less of the toxin in the wood than in the roots. Among the susceptible plants are all members of the nightshade family (tomatoes, potatoes, peppers, tobacco, etc.)

Somewhere, I have read (it's probably somewhere on the list of sites that Google will give you) that if you compost it for two years, it is safe to use as a mulch. That, of course, depends on active decomposition, and not just sitting in a dry pile in an arid climate.