Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Inhaling metal dust particles...

Posts

Inhaling metal dust particles...

#1

Inhaling metal dust particles...

robo hippy

Well, I made an interesting discovery today. I have had CBN wheels for a long time now. I was getting one of the Moffat lamps down from a shelf about 30 inches above my grinder. I opened the box to check on it (1/4 round dog ears that tuck into slots, but not taped) and discovered metal dust collected on a ring around the magnetic base. I do have the inside shield on my Baldor grinder, but not the outside one. This surprised me. I didn't think it was fine enough and too heavy to float around like that. I commented about this on another forum, and Ralph Lindberg, a Washington turner said that when he was in the Navy, lung protection was mandatory for all metal grinding and working.

Some thing to ponder...

robo hippy

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#2

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

phillip Medghalchi

Reed, I am hoping that you could taste the metal taste in back of your throat if you do not wear mask. that's how you know the metal powder is in the air. Or, look around the grinding wheel and you should see that dust form the grinding particles on the wheels and black powder around or mixed with it.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

Alan Zenreich

... And this surprises anyone?

I have an interesting dust collector setup (including a water trap) under my belt grinder platform.

I wear my respirator when grinding, or whenever the lathe is spinning. I don't want ANY of this stuff in my lungs.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#4

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

robo hippy

Phil,

I have never tasted or really smelled the metal dust. I have plenty of it under the grinder. I can smell and taste most of the woods I turn, and that is almost always very wet wood, so I never wear a dust mask. Hard for me to think about metal dust floating that high in the air...

"That is totally and in all ways inconceivable!" But, now I have to rethink that one...

robo hippy

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

Alan Zenreich

It's also not just wood dust... It's spores, fungi, etc that's flung from the wood into the air. It beats me why folks don't take this more seriously.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#6

New hazards

Geoff Whaling

Reed,

There are always trade offs and potential new hazards that we may not have considered when we change processes. I did my research but I guess I am more cautious than most turners. I came to the conclusion that wet stone slow grinders present fewer hazards & are therefore the safest option. They are not for every one however as they are far to slow for bowl turners in production environments.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#7

Re: New hazards

John Lucas

Glen Lucas is definitely what I would call a production turner. He advertises that he uses the Tormek. You would have to keep the wheel soaked all day to use it like that but if it is soaked then all you would have to do is turn the machine on just like any other grinder. Your just touching up the edge so shouldn't take any longer.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#8

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

John Lucas

Well do you wear a respirator when your riding the BMW. What about all that Asbestos from brake linings in cars. I hear that all the time when people talk about bicycling. Basically the whole world is dangerous so I take it with a grain of salt and try to take some precautions but I simply don't go overboard.

There are fungus and spores in the air all the time. Heck look at your car in the morning. Bet it's green from all the pollen in the air. Did you wear protection from it? What about all the gnats and no see ums we breath. Heck as a bicyclist and motorcyclist I've eaten my share of bugs. Good protein.

We do need to take precautions but lets not scare the begeebees out of everyone. They make is sound like you need a Hazmat suit to turn a pen. I've been an active woodworker and metal worker for 35 years. Not to mention working on copiers and breathing all that stuff. Photo chemicals, I've often spent 10 or 12 hours in the darkroom breathing that stuff for the last 30 or 40 years and how much silver nitrate have I handled. Still here and kicking.

Kind of reminds me of my Uncle. They told him smoking would kill him, and sure enough at the age of 87 he died. Now I'm not advocating smoking is not dangerous, we all know it is. I'm just saying we all need to look at what we do and take precautions but lets not go overboard.

Well sorry about getting on the band wagon I know I'll take a lot of flak. Guess old age and opinions are catching up with me. Be cautious and be reasonable. You don't need to buy a $500 dust mask and $800 dust collection system to go along with the $300 lathe you just scrounged to buy. You should look at these options and if your going to be a serious turner start taking precautions but they make it sound like your going to die tomorrow if you don't do this.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#9

Re: Dust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We've known about the danger of grinder dust for years. Alum-Ox, SiC, produced their own hazards along with the metal dust they produced. CBNs got rid of the mineral particulates but the metal dust will always be there. This should not surprise anyone nor be an excuse for not having a DC hooked to the grinder.

With my lathe and turning located in the basement, I upgraded my DC, installed ambient air cleaners, and did everything I could to control dust. I still got complaints about the level of dust in the house. I moved the "turning studio" to the garage and use box fans to blow it all outside.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#10

Re: New hazards

Mark Wollschlager

When I saw Glen Lucas last week at UWS he said he is using CBN wheels.

I have no doubt that he uses a tormek too.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#11

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

Don Evans

Robo, what you have not taken into your calculation formula is the factor of the wind created by the spinning grinding wheels. The metal dust as you call if is being BLOWN around, Not simple floating.

I posted pictures on here once of my old dust collector (with bags removed) connected to my grinder and blowing the metal particals outdoors via a vent through the wall. This was metal from simply tool sharping for wood turning. I don't do a lot of turning anymore so not a lot of sharpening but you can still see the brown streaks on the vinyl siding on my shop where the vent throws out the dust, the brown streaks are metal that has not washed off and therefore rusted.

I do more carving now instead of turning and I sharpen all those tools with a hard felt wheels with mineral oil and chromium oxide on it. The oxide traps the metal particles and the table stays clean of metal dust. After searching for the best way for 40 year to get tools sharp I have learned that this is the best and even better than a Tormec stone.

Don

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#12

Informed decisions

Geoff Whaling

John, I agree calm logic is the way to go. We sure cannot remove all risk or protect ourselves and family from all hazards - simply not practical or financially feasible. With some hazards such as wood dust there may be ambient environmental hazards that present an equal or higher risk.

If we are aware of the hazards we can make informed decisions about which hazard presents the highest risk to us and we can make an informed decision about whether we should attempt to protect ourselves from them. Or we can take pot luck.

I agree metal dust is a hazard; there are known illnesses attributed to exposure; but is our exposure sufficient to present a credible risk? What is a safe level of exposure? The "unsafe" exposure threshold for some turners may be quite low.

Personally, I would be more concerned about sending sparks into a DC that is used for both wood and metal dust extraction. That is a proven hazard with proven potential catastrophic outcomes.

Wet grinding removes both hazards.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#13

Steven Antonucci

Better never sit in a demo then...

steven antonucci

Folks watching woodturning with no safety gear, walking around trade show floors breathing who knows what?

There is a practical limit to all safety gear where you have to just accept the risk and get on with things. If I am sanding out a bunch of salad bowls, I will put on a mask. If I am finishing them, I will wear nitrile gloves too. If I am turning something small like a top, I may forego all of them because the risk of catastrophic injury is very low.

Always and never are very tough to use in a shop environment. I would personally never dust collect on a grinder wheel unless the system was specifically built for grinding metal because I think the risk of fire is worse than the metal powder everywhere. If I am doing a lot of grinding, I will put on a mask, but it's the wheel dust I am afraid of...not the metal.

Wonder if the flat woodworkers wear a mask on the tablesaw? Jointers? Planers?

S

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#14

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

robo hippy

Well, interesting comments.

I know there is a spray area for the metal area, just like the water from my wet bowls. The metal got inside of a closed cardboard box. That took some maneuvering.

One would have to be really careful about using any type of dust collector on a grinder. One spark sucked into it and you have an instant fire storm. There are special ones for metal grinding, but I would guess since they are pretty much fire proof, they would be very expensive. Maybe I need a hood like on my lathe when I sand. Far enough away so any spark will go out, but enclosed enough to get the dust. The metal on the bench just goes in with the shavings. I can see the commercial now, 'Is your garden soil anemic? Just add my iron rich mulch"...

robo hippy

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#15

Re: Better never sit in a demo then...

Dick Coers

Not to make light of the subject, but I've smelled plenty in the air at symposiums. Especially after lunch. Get enough old fat guys together, feed them a greasy burger and fries, well you get the idea............

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#16

Grinder DC - plan

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You connect the DC with a water vacuum chamber in between the grinder and the system that runs the airstream through a few gallons of water before going on through the dry-dust ducting. True, you could get some damage to the hoses from the grinder to the bucket, but that's where any hot sparks will stop. Easy to make with a 5-gal lidded bucket, some 2" hose and a PVC pipe and fittings. Once in a while you change the rusty water. The hookup will work on a stationary DC or a good shopvac.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#17

Just get an MRI

Bill Howatt

and it will suck all the metal particles out of you. Actually from what I understand small metal particles possibly in eyes can be a serious issue for having an MRI.

Bill

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#18

What about a magnet?

Barry Irby

If CBN wheels spray only metal dust what about sending the air from it through a bunch of magnets?

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#19

Re: Better never sit in a demo then...

Tony - Memphis

I more of a "flat" woodworker I guess. There is rarely a time that I don't wear a mask in my shop. I use dust collection and an overhead air cleaner but I don't want my lungs pre-filtering the air! Yes, I wear safety glasses and ear plugs a lot too. I have a respirator to wear when finishing. I can't afford to lose anymore brain cells.

I also wear a mask when cutting the grass, swapping brake pads, etc. etc. Glasses too.

I for sure wear one when grinding. I used to work for a performance parts company and we ground camshafts. You wouldn't believe what became airborne in that shop. And it was wet grinding! I can't help but believe that all of the grinders will eventually have respiratory issues. They all smoked too.

Tony

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#20

Re: Just get an MRI

Guy Bratt

This is turning out to be a serious subject. Buttttt [:p Can you see a patient with lung problems caused by metel inhalation getting sucked up against the MRI machine by the chest. Screaming, legs and arms flailing.... Could make a good safety poster.

Ok sorry I'll leave now. :{

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#21

Steven Antonucci

I was thinking X-Men, myself

steven antonucci

There is a scene where Magneto is in an all plastic prison to keep him from getting away, so he has one of his minions feed an iron rich solution to prison guard, and then he used the iron in the guards body to break out...

S

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#22

just saw the latest X men- Great movie


Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#23

Excellent - an engineered control

Geoff Whaling

Mark, your solution is an excellent example of an engineering control used to substantially reduce perhaps even totally eliminate the fire/explosion hazard when the same DC unit is used for both metal and wood dust collection. Having a dedicated hose from the grinder to the water trap eliminates any potential for fine dust to linger in the hose.

The only possible risk may be environmental wood dust being drawn in at the same time. That seems a very minimal risk given your knowledge and implementation of dust collection controls.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#24

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

Jim Breeden

I don't have the water bath, but do have the shop vac plugged in down wind of the grinder wheels when in use.

Re: Inhaling metal dust particles...

#25

Re: Tattoos with metalic ink

Stuart Johnson

can cause some problems according to an article in today's paper. I wonder what the next patient would make of half a dragon stuck to the wall of the machine.