Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Club "responsibilities" question?

Posts

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#26

Re: incorrect...my demos are not teaching

Dale Gillaspy

If you are not teaching when you are demonstrating, is it then really just a form of grandstanding? If you are not trying to impart knowledge, then you are just showing a group how great you are and what you can do.

I for one, think demonstrating is teaching. It may not be one on one, and the measure of the understanding may not come from a test, but rather from the audience being interested enough to try it for themselves.

We may be arguing semantics here, but I don't agree that teaching can't take place without testing. Testing is a measure of knowledge retention, and we can even argue that point further. It is not necessarily a measure of delivery. Many more variables have to be worked into the fray to evaluate the teacher.

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#27

Steven Antonucci

semantics... but not

Steven Antonucci

I separate the two because they are very different. I agree that part of any demo is to impart knowledge, but the primary focus is to finish the demo. If people don't get everything, there isn't time to try to get them past everything for full retention. In teaching, I can adapt to my student and I often do. I might see that what I had planned to do will be too difficult, so I can change it to something more targeted to the student...and if there are multiple students, each individually based upon their specific needs.

Pet peeve of mine: overheard often at symposiums..."I just took a class with famous turner X..." Actually, the person sat in on a demo from famous turner X. In the back of a crowded room. With 100 other people.

So, it is sort of two very different things to me.

I demo for my clubs, but I also teach at both too, mostly because I think it is important to the club's well being. I want the work to improve, and I want people to want to be better turners. You can learn from a demo if you have a good base.

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#28

Brad and all,

GaryG in MD

You're right, of course.

After I wrote quickly wrote that (it was very late), I thought that I should go on and say things like you did, but I was happy with what the others had said.

The keys to making the good things happen that you mention, and preventing the bad things, technically fall within the bounds of E&O. It's up to the Club Officers to make sure that there are sufficient programs available to provide venues for Members to do things that make themselves better and pay it forward.

So, although my reply sounded glib (and maybe was), I meant what you said too.

Sure, MCW had David Ellsworth as our demonstrator last night, and we were extremely happy and privileged, but it doesn't end there. We also have Skills Enhancement, Wounded Warriors pen classes, multiple County Library shows, Demo Days in our Woodcraft storefront, County Ag Fair week, support demos for community activities, etc., and now we're going to be starting the Warrior Eagle-head cane project too -- sharing the service with a carvers club. That's what we call "outreach", but it fits well under "opportunity" too. Hence my terse reply.

What I didn't like about Steve's question, and maybe I read it wrong, was the implication of a need for constructive criticism of show&tell pieces, as opposed to a want. I belive that belongs in the category of people asking for help if and when they really want it and understand the reason for asking -- kind of like asking for CnC on a forum post.

Bottom line -- good question, Steve. You got quite a lively response. ...GG

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#29

Re: I consider the "responsibility" of a club....

Steve Worcester.

I would consider the responsibility of the club is to setup a safe environment for its members during meetings to watch a woodturning demonstration safely. And this is after 15 years of trying to push and pull its members though to get them better educated in turning and trying to get them to be better turners. We can't force them.

I am thoroughly convinced that most of the butts in the seats during a club meeting are wanting to interact with other people and to be entertained. I would put that at 70% and that is being kind. After that, 15% want to see better techniques but likely won't use them, and the remaining 15% want for a demo that would actually teach them something as they have the potential to want for more and are the future mentors of the club. The last 15% I think are what the club is for. They will foster the hobby, but most need to be asked to do so (do I sound a bit jaded?).

I went to a club meeting last night, I am the VP. While setting up the 80 or so chairs, several member just sat down and didn't even help setup, they are in the 70%, and in the lower part of that. Being a member in our club gives them the opportunity to partake in several events a month, discounts at local stores (which I suspect is what they really paid for, a discount card), access to probably 500 videos and books, and really good, seasoned mentors, and they just come once a month to watch a demo. Really we should offer the free membership of demos.

Sorry, this may seem as a tirade, but you should demo to the 15% and thank the others for their money for helping put on the event.

And don't forget to thank the people who put in countless hours, for free, to make it all happen.

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#30

Steven Antonucci

Not focused on critique, Gary

steven antonucci

The question was really open ended. In general, I think most people would agree that joining a club is an opportunity to improve skills, but is anyone measuring those improvements?

I think that some people get better, but I also see a bunch that do not, and in general, it is not for lack of equal opportunity or personal drive. I am not sure what it is, but I know that I have seen it over the handful of years I've been in both clubs. Some folks just aren't getting better? And I am not talking about the people who only turn a little, or you question whether they even own a lathe...

Maybe a "Most Improved Turner" trophy at the end of the year...I dunno?

S

Re: Club "responsibilities" question?

#31

Steven Antonucci

Not jaded at all

steven antonucci

I doubt you'd find a club anywhere that was vastly different than your 70/15/15 mix? We all pay the same $25/year, so I expect everyone to pitch in with moving equipment and clean-up. If I see someone sitting on their duff while others are working, I usually volunteer them to do the thing that I was doing, and then I go find something else to do. As one of the mentors in my club, you say no to me, I say no to you...

We also have the group that only shows up a couple of times per year to see the big name demonstrators. They usually get there early enough to grab the front row seats. I never sit in a seat for a demo, no matter who is there, simply because I'd rather leave the seat for someone who really needs to see it. I usually sit off to the side on the S&T table.

I do everything I can to try to get new people integrated into the working class. If you are in the working class, my shop is open to you. I don't care if you are a new turner or just new to the club, I want to get you on the payroll (pay is lousy, but it is a job!) My goal is to make 70% more like 50%...and then 30%...

Maybe a "non-participating membership" of $100/year is the answer...

Steve