Club "responsibilities" question?
steven antonucci
Do you think it is the responsibility of an AAW chapter to improve the quality of the work of its members?
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Club "responsibilities" question?
steven antonucci
Do you think it is the responsibility of an AAW chapter to improve the quality of the work of its members?
Steve
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Mark Wollschlager
I think the Chapter should encourage member to do their best work.
It is not a guild with steps and masters, it is a group of like minded folks.
If a member was deemed 'not improving', then what?
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Dick Coers
Responsibility? Absolutely not. Goals? Maybe. It's my opinion that nearly all members will improve with the proper instructional demos and exposure to high skilled artists and their work. There can be many members who just attend for the social aspect and enjoy being around skilled craftsmen. They can not, nor do they care to reach high skill levels with their work. It's purely fun for them.
Not individually, but collectively
steven antonucci
Restating the question:
Rather than a one on one perspective, should the collective work improve over time? I realize that not everyone wants to be "an expert", but should the tide raise all boats anyway?
S
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Alan Zenreich
Let's see what the AAW has to say about it...
http://www.woodturner.org/?page=Mission
Mission:
"The mission of the American Association of Woodturners is to provide education, information, and organization to those interested in turning wood. "
About:
"The American Association of Woodturners (AAW) is an international, nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization, headquartered in Saint Paul, Minnesota, dedicated to advancing the art and craft of woodturning worldwide by providing opportunities for education, information, and organization to those interested in turning wood. ..."
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Dale Gillaspy
Education…opportunity….it says nothing about quality or improving. It's like the quote referencing the Declaration of Independence….."The pursuit of happiness….." it says nothing of guaranteeing it, you have to go out and do that for yourself.
My point is, I think it is the responsibility of the club to provide education. What you do with that education is completely up to you.
As far as the tide raising all the boats, I like the analogy, but as new, inexperienced members join, wouldn't that water it down again? It is a never ending cycle, and I think that is OK.
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Josh bowman
Steve the old saying fits here...you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink. Heck, some of us in our club believe some of the long term members don't even have a lathe! It would be hard to improve their turning skills. 
Simple answer -- NO
GaryG in MD
I agree with those who have already answered and covered the situation well.
Education and opportunity -- that's what it's all about.
After that, it's up to the individuals.
Most of us are hobbyists, and if the Club makes E and O available, that's it.
IMO, any kind of "pressure" to do more would be inappropriate.
But with good E&O, it should happen naturally.
...GG
Re: Simple answer -- NO
Brad Vietje
I concur. But I think it's helpful to look at this from the reverse angle.
I would consider a chapter negligent* if they failed to provide or facilitate the opportunities for the members to learn and grow. I have never heard of a chapter that did this, but maybe they exist out there somewhere.
If a group meets and does the same ole same ole and bores its members without looking to provide opportunities for learning and inspiration, the group should look to change leadership, or else it could wither and disappear.
I also believe that a trap some groups should avoid is to assume that inspiration can only come from the famous, "name-brand" turners. Some groups spend perhaps too much time and effort raising money to pay for touring professionals to come and demo, which is fine, as long as they are not ignoring the local talent or all the other outreach and education they could be doing. I've been inspired by a number of big-gun turners, but a club needs to be more than a fundraiser for paying demonstrators.
Clear as mud, right?
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
* (negligent is a pretty strong word, and I know it has legal definitions that might not be intended or appropriate -- maybe Mark K has a better one?)
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
Our club, Carolina Mountain Woodturners, is a 401C non-profit because we PUSH education. Stop teaching and that would go away. Most months the Saturday meeting demonstrator teaches a Sunday all day class of ten members for about $25 to $40 each. The revenue from a successful endowment makes these prices possible. Attendance in classes is by drawing of interested parties. Classes are always full. Our demonstrators are of the class of national symposiums. We have an enclosed trailer with ten mini lathes and tools for teaching us and the general public at fairs, schools, festivals, etc. We have instant galleries each month with 15 to 25 presenters. If your work doesn't improve, you don't show. The completion gets pretty fierce. We have about 5 professional turners in our club of over 400. We have Arrowmont and JC Campbell schools within a 2 hour drive, so any one that does not learn is just plain lazy.
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Bill Jacksonville, NC
Anyone can improve their turning skills with just a little patience, practice, and persistence. Some turners get more out of the camaraderie of club membership than actual turning. Before your club sets up a bunch of goals and standards consider how much time do your members actually have to turn wood? Also what is their access to wood to turn.
Better goal is keeping members happy and finding new members.
No.
Re: No.
Bill Blasic
I agree with Clay - No!
Bill
Who says the work ever ends?
I picked my words carefully :-)
steven antonucci
So, if a club as a whole is not raising all boats with the collective tide, is that a failure of their AAW charter to "educate"? Or to "advance the art or woodturning"? (Thanks Alan!)
I am aware that there are social aspects of the clubs that are important, but that's actually not in the charter 
Steve
No.
much more valuable the second time, thanks!
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Keith Tompkins
Hey Steve, One has to ask....why would a new member join a woodturning organization? Chances are they're relatively new to the hobby, and want to improve. After all, the advice we often see here at WC to turners who are having problems is: Find, and join, a local turning club. I know by observing the work that's being produced and displayed at my local "totally turning" symposium there has been a dramatic improvement on the pieces submitted over the years due to participation in the local clubs. Personally, if I was seeking purely entertainment, I could think of better ways than watch someone make a small piece of wood out of a large one. 
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Dennis Bilevich
Well said Keith
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
John lucas
I belong to three clubs a d sometimes go to two other club meetings. There are members who never turn. There are members whose turnings are always bad forms ( but they are having fun so I'm happy for them). And there are members whose work improves dramatically We can teach good form but its up to the individual to actually do it. I believe it's the clubs responsibility to help everyone enjoy the hobby at whatever level they want to stay at
Re: Club "responsibilities" question?
Bill Blasic
I am the President of my home club and have been so for 9 years and I belong to 4 others. Every one of these clubs have all the tools for anyone who wants to learn or get better to do so, vast libraries, monthly demos, mentors and my club thanks to a deceased member has a fund that you can get the proceeds to go to a woodturning function to learn. The AAW has given us grants that aid the learning process and are doing new things to forward the art of turning. Stated all the tools are there but also stated above "you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink". And there are plenty of members in all these clubs who find making a small piece of wood out of a bigger piece is their entertainment. I don't understand it but it is true. With that all said that is why I agree with Clay No, No and No!
Bill
I never said "enforce"?
steven antonucci
You outlined a half dozen ways that the system works to improve members abilities, and ostensibly, their work...but you don't think that it is the club's responsibility to provide it? LOL
I don't really have any ulterior motives for asking the question. It came out of looking at Terry Scott's post, and thinking, "Wow, there are a lot of really good turners in New Zealand?" I wondered if there was one super club where everyone got together and played, or if the even was like a symposium that attracted people from vast stretches of land.
I know that my skills have vastly improved by joining a club, but not necessarily from one on one instruction. Learning through osmosis I suppose? I also know that both of the clubs that I belong to have some informal means of mentoring newer turners outside of the usual demo programs, and generally it helps, but does not produce the "Terry Scott/New Zealand Phenomenon".
One of my club presidents asked a very good question at the beginning of a meeting one night the month after having a very well know demonstrator coming in to present: "Did anyone go home after last month's demo and try what he showed us?" About 2-3 hands went up... which prompted him to ask "Why are we bringing in these very expensive guys if nobody if learning anything that they can use?"
I thought it was a good question.
BTW- I agree with you, Bill. Some folks look at the demos as a performance art piece. I am ok with it. Not every demo is for everyone.
I do think it is a responsibility for a club to raise their memberships standards, for the record, but I also recognize that not everyone cares, and not everyone is capable of the highest standards... so you have to work with the people that want it and can thrive. Clubs that do this well not only produce better work, they probably also produce better clubs.
Keith also asked a really good question: Why would any new member join a club? More often than not, it is to learn... so if it isn't the clubs responsibility to "teach" them how to get better... why would someone join a club? In a high school, if a teacher is teaching calculus and all the students are failing, is it the student's fault or the teacher's fault?
In my opinion, it is the single most important thing a club offers (education), and the single best way to measure how well you are delivering it is performance improvement of the members.
Steve
Re: I never said "enforce"?
Alan Zenreich
Steve,
I am curious...
Aren't you the one who insists that demonstrations aren't teaching?
incorrect...my demos are not teaching
Steven Antonucci
All demos offer knowledge. Offering knowledge is not teaching, because it does not measure the absorption of that knowledge. You are not teaching if you are not measuring results. That's why schools test. It measures both the student and the teacher.
I teach very differently than I turn. I demo differently than I teach or turn. All three things have different goals. When I turn, I care about the end product. When I teach, I care about retention and absorption. When I demo, I care about keeping everyone awake and imparting enough knowledge to make someone want to try something new or look at something differently.
Some demonstrators may feel differently about what they are doing. Showing isn't teaching in my book.
S
I consider the "responsibility" of a club....
JamieDonaldson
... is to offer the "opportunity" and "incentive" to enhance their personal skills to those members that are receptive. 