Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Posts

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#26

Oh, I see!

GaryG in MD

Wally,

I get it. I never would have thought of doing it that way.

I understand, and I'll remember it. I've been doing glue blocks with tenons in a chuck, but this is a nice alternative.

My comments were based on a way that, as I said, doesn't work very well -- which is drilling a hole for the screw chuck in the top of a cut-edge bowl blank (in the interior, waste material), mounting it, and then turning a tenon, shaping the outside, and reversing for hollowing. Now you see why I quit doing it! There's no room for adjustment.

I agree about the strength of the glue joint -- IF it's done properly. That's not always a given, of course. :-)

Thanks for your thoughts, Gary

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#27

I really hate to admit it...

GaryG in MD

because now I'm going to go way down in everyone's opinions.

The fact of the matter is that I have three chucks and about 7 sets of jaws and have spent a total of probably less than $200 on the whole mess.

And they work just fine.

I'll let you guess where I got them, but I can already hear the groans out there.

Seriously, I'm picky about my pieces, and these work just fine -- and have for ten years. It's harder to be as frugal these days, but you can still get decent chucks and jaws for reasonable prices.

I have to repeat that I only have a 12" lathe, and I know I would have to spend (a lot) more if I got into larger pieces and larger chucks. But that doesn't mean I have to make only "small" pieces -- I use every bit of the 11-3/4" available to me. My limitation is that I have no place to turn indoors, and no garage, and have to be able to lift my lathe over the sliding glass door track from my family room to my back patio. So my lathe has to be (barely) under 200#. My Jet 1236 fits the bill very well and has never missed a beat in over ten years, with no servicing at all. Of course, I'm just a hobbyist and not doing production turning! ...GG

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#28

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

phillip Medghalchi

I think this was a very sensitive subject I brought up and very well received. all the comments are valid and very helpful. Thanks to everyone's reply.

There are a lot to take away form this discussion.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#29

My question: drive center in wet wood?

Henry W

So I appreciate that design flexibility that between centers turning allows.

My difficulty arises when turning wet wood; the drive center I have (middle point highest, 4 radial ridges, slightly shorter than center)simply strips out (lathe spins but the piece does not). Since this early stage of turning has the most unbalanced pieces (i.e. approximately rounded on BS), I find that I just can't effectively turn between centers.

Am I just due for a new drive center, and if so what style do you recommend?

Or am I missing something in how I am attempting to work here?

I typically use a faceplate screwed onto a rough cut surface (Lyle J notes above that this is not a good plan, but that is what I have done), rough turn the outside and a tenon; then reverse the piece and hold in a chuck to finish the outside and turn the inside. I recognize this process does not allow 'design flexibility', but since I am so ineffective using my drive center. my methods have gravitated to allowing me to finish a piece. (Nova 3000 lathe, 16" swing).

Henry

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#30

Re: My question: drive center in wet wood?

Henry W

additional note -

I just watched Lyle J's wood turning video on YouTube, that he linked in a post lower down

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4xIHTS0yJc&feature=youtu.be

That helps, but maybe only for well balanced / symmetrical pieces.

Henry

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#31

Re: Two ways of dealing with it...

Stuart Johnson

Thanks, that sound you heard was me slapping my forehead and muttering duh. I leave the little nub on when turning a tenon using a faceplate but could not connect it when thinking between centers. Nothing like being a public idiot :\

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#32

Lyle Jamieson

Re: My question: drive center in wet wood?

Lyle Jamieson

OH NO, this process works well with out of round wacky shaped wood. You start on the balance point and rough some off. Knowing all the time this is not the final axis. Move the axis in small increments and round it up between each position. When you use the balance point you can get the lathe speed up and the turning is easy. It is even more important to do this with funny shaped wood. I never use a band saw and always put a square chunk of tree on the lathe to start.

Yes, you need a good drive center with two things. The drive pin must be proud sticking out beyond the drive teeth. The best drive is one that has an adjustable pin and set screw to hold in place. The drive teeth must be long/tall enough to dig into the wood, not bottom out, and not slip with the hogging off forces. Use my method from YouTube or my DVD to get the drive teeth deep into the wood, or take a chisel and hammer to make an 'X' kerf so the teeth will be deeply seated.

I disagree with your process. Not only yours...but many, many turners use a similar sequence, even some very well known turners. When you reverse the piece after finishing the bottom shape of the bowl it will never run true. Then it is necessary to do the bottom again. I choose not to do that twice. I want both the inside and outside of the bowl done on the same axis. I only rough out the shape between centers. Again you know why I don't use chucks, they are limiting. I want to open up possibilities not limit them.

There are many ways to turn. There is not a right or wrong usually, but different for different reasons. Some foundation elements of the turning process lead to problems and there is usually a fix to the problem. The domino effect of the fix can lead you down a very unproductive road. I choose to prevent the problem rather then deal with the limitations of the fix.

I am proof an old dog can learn new tricks. New bowl gouge, new carbide cutter on my boring bars, when I find a better way of turning I take advantage of it and change my methods. I am just trying to help, take it or leave it. I only use wet wood, so I choose not to do lidded boxes. I can double turn but I choose not to. I choose to live with the limitations of using wet wood. You can choose to live with the limitations of using a chuck.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#33

Re: Thanks Lyle

Henry W

Lyle - thanks. Your YouTube video was helpful, as was your response just now.

Please don't mistake my description of what I have done so far as a process that I was happy with. That was (note past tense) a process that evolved because I had not successful turning between centers. Your posts and videos have shown me another way.

Old dogs (who are not necessarily experienced turners) can in fact learn new tricks! I have some fresh wet wood and will certainly try the method you have demonstrated and described.

Thanks

Henry

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#34

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Thanks Lyle

Lyle Jamieson

I am betting you will like it. Let everyone know what you think once you give it a test run.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#35

Re: Thanks Lyle

Dwight Rutherford

I always start between centers, primarily turn wet rough blanks. I have various diameter drives so I use an appropriate sized spade drill or Forstner bit to drill into the blank about 1/2" so the drive center is in solid wood. Before mounting to the headstock, take a dead blow hammer and seat the drive into the blank ( have never split a blank ). If there is bark at the drive side of the blank I drill through and then go 1/2" into solid wood.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#36

Re: Thanks Lyle

Phil Powell

Henry,

I turn mostly wet wood it's so much easier to work with. I had trouble with normal hold devises. I went to OneWay and bought the " Big Bite Chuck Spur".

Most of my troubles were solved. Take a look.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#37

Phil has a good solution for.........

JamieDonaldson

... a cross point 4 wing drive spur. There are several 2 wing drive spurs available, and when aligned with the grain and properly seated in sound wood they drive very well, without slipping and becoming a dull drill. ;)

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#38

Dick Hines

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Dick Hines

When I turn wet wood and am going to use a chuck I will flood the tenon with thin CA. Don't get in a big rush to but it in the chuck. Make cure the CA is dry.

This will not keep the tenons on all big bowls but if you use the tail stock engaged to the bowl it will save most of the tenons.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#39

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

phillip Medghalchi

Dick, what happened to me was that in the process of hollowing I engaged the tail stock until the tail stock go tin the way and then I removed it. When the tenon broke it was the third time already. The only recourse I have now is to put it on cole jaws and make a new tenon and then I will put CA on it for sure. By now some of the moister have to be out, especially that we had few very dry days that sucked the moister out of everything and even though we got little rain it was so windy because of the cold front that it dried up everything so quick and some area around us didn't even get a drop of it. So, I may be lucky this time I just went ahead and put Anchor seal on the other logs and the other half of the log this bowl came from to slow down the moisture escape. We'll see and I'll try to post pic.s of the other halves and see how it comes out.