Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Posts

Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#1

Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

phillip Medghalchi

Lyle, I always turned between centers and the other day I got lucky that I got a piece of Alligator Juniper (very striking pattern) form my next door negibor's dad form NM. i was excited because I was getting to actually to turn a wet wood then set it aside to dry for later, so as usual I put it between centers and start turning away. I made a tenon for it as usual and so when i went to reverse chuck it and hollow out the top the tenon sheared off three times and I spent another 45 min. three times to make new tenon. and ended up with smaller bowl, and still half of the bowl is not hollowed out so I put it away in shavings for now.

Now, last week I cut up 4 Mesquite burl and pecan bowl blanks which are 15 7/8" dia.. The mesquite blanks are about 5~5.5" high and so they are heavy, and I really didn't want to resort to using face plates on them. however, I need some idea on how to go about turning these heavy blanks. I have to make all of them to Salad bowls for the fiends and families.

Any help will be greatly appreciated. I try to add pic.s tomorrow so yo an see what I mean by them.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#2

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

John Lucas

how big was your tenon? I assume it was a side grain bowl. I've never had a tenon break off. Mine are usually about 3" in diameter but on larger bowls I use 4" or larger since I'm going to return the bottom and reshape the foot I can use any size tenon I want.

On larger heavy bowls I use the tailstock as long as possible when hollowing the bowl. As you go deeper it makes a long tenon in the center which you can easily narrow down and cut off as the bowl gets thin.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#3

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Bill Howatt

I have had 1 external tenon shear off and I was watching a demo at a woodshow and saw one shear off. Both cases were green wood blanks with a very straight grain and may have been ash or similar. The solution is to make a larger tenon and also use the tailstock as John suggests.

Bill

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#4

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

robo hippy

Well, size does matter, probably as much as wood species. I have turned Mountain Mahogany (very hard), and a recess with shoulders that would have worked fine in most softer woods failed. I have worked some very soft woods as well, with the same problem. Mesquite is pretty good for turning, and is in the medium hardness range. That juniper is probably pretty soft. There is some juniper that grows in the high (4000 feet which is high for Oregon), and it is pretty hard.

Now, size does matter. Generally your tenon should be minimum 1/4 the diameter of the bowl, and max at 1/3, so on a 12 inch bowl, you want a tenon 3 to 4 inch diameter. Some times you can get away with less, but if you go smaller, you have to be much more gentle as you cut.

When tightening, you can over do it. Some times you can break it before you start, and some times there can be so much pressure on it that any little catch can cause a failure. Snug is good.

Angles have to match as perfectly as possible. Size of tenon and recess also need to match jaw size as closely as possible. This varies between wet and dry wood. You can go closer to perfect diameter with dry wood because it won'g change shape as it dries.

Another consideration is on lining up your chuck jaws with the wood grain. Again, not a lot of difference if you are using dry wood. Especially if the wood is green, you do not want the jaws centered at 12, 3, 6, and 9 o'clock. Rotate them 45 degrees. If 2 are lined up on end grain (very little compression of wood) and 2 are lined up on side grain (much compression of wood) it can work loose, or at least there are different stresses on the wood. You can even it out if you rotate 45 degrees.

robo hippy

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Lyle Jamieson

It's not starting between centers that failed you, it is what you did between centers. Starting between centers is only the beginning of my methods. It's impossible to capture a four hour, twenty minute DVD here in text. You prepared for a chuck. My process prevents these kind of obstacles from getting in the way.

Some good pointers so far on using chucks better. BUT...... Why use a chuck?? It is not a good way to hold wood. A faceplate and or glue block is much stronger and will never sheer off a tenon. Usually vibration is the issue, not the tenon when using chucks. We can turn easier, faster, safer with the stronger holding methods. I only turn wet wood but it will work for wet or dry. Yes, size matters, bigger turning requires bigger faceplates. I think Dale Nish started the 40 percent rule. 10 inch bowl needs a 4 inch faceplate/glue block.

I know, I know, you have spent hundreds of dollars buying chucks, but they don't work very well. You may need to justify the use of chucks but that will mean you need to live with the limitations.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#6

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Dale Gillaspy

I want to add one more thing that may or may not be of consequence. You said you were turning Alligator Juniper. I have turned that wood several times before and there are some things to watch out for. It is a soft wood, and when it is dry, there are sometimes hidden fractures. It also comes off very splintery at times.

It is possible that a hidden fracture near the tenon was enough with the vibrations and tool forces to cause it to shear off.

Like I said, it may not have been the only cause, or the cause at all, but I have had similar things happen with that particular wood.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#7

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I agree with Lyle....why use a chuck, especially with a large blank. I've been using glue blocks and faceplates or screw centers for years. In my classes I never allowed chucks. I wanted the students to learn to turn without them. The strongest fastening you can get is a faceplate.

Just in case you didn't know, before about 1990 four-jaw scroll chucks didn't exist....we turned a lot of bowls before that.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#8

BC (before chucks) AC (after chucks)


Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#9

with all due respect to Lyle and Wally,

GaryG in MD

I think it's safe to say that most of us use chucks.

I've turned bowls for over ten years using a chuck to hold a tenon.

I've never lost a single one yet.

I have never in my life used a faceplate, nor do I expect to.

Nothing wrong either way -- it's just a matter of personal preference.

I suggest that, as Dale noted, your wood could be flawed, your tenon may be too small for the bowl size, or you may be putting too much stress on the tenon with your turning techniques.

...GG

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: with all due respect to Lyle and Wally,

Lyle Jamieson

I have tested it many times side-by side, chuck vs. faceplate with people that think your way. Do your own test and you will be a believer. It is not the risk of pulling the piece out of the chuck as much as it is a holding power issue. You can turn bigger, faster, easier with a faceplate without vibration. Many folks push past the vibration point, but I never turn with vibration. Vibration is the indicator that you are exceeding the capability of your chucking method.

All this being said, the faceplate or glue block must be properly installed. To screw a faceplate on a chainsaw cut or band saw cut is not a good plan. Even using a "flat" board will be problematic. I start between centers for two reasons. 1) I am in control of the axis. 2) I need to prepare for the faceplate with a shallow cone or concave surface so the faceplate or glue block seats on the rim with no hump in the middle to allow vibration. Just a little 1/16 inch relief is all that is needed. It does not take any longer to prepare a concave surface for a faceplate then it will to prepare a tenon for a chuck.

Why do we all use chucks?? As Wally pointed out, us old timers all used faceplates before chucks were made for the turning world. Remember the first Axminster chuck, it was one of the first good chucks?? What a nice piece of equipment. We used them because the production turners were using them. That was what was passed down from the masters over the years. It was an exiting innovation back then. Now...we all want to turn as big and as fast as we can and the chuck is a limiting factor. It is great for small things but you must understand its limitations and don't go there.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#11

Re: with all due respect to Lyle and Wally,

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Gary, I wasn't knocking the use of a chuck. I own five of them myself and use them a lot. A tenon cut into a glue block works very well. I don't use faceplates much anymore because I don't turn large pieces anymore. I do use a screw chuck a lot though. I have three of Jerry Glasers screwchucks and they're the best. (Manufactured by someone else now)

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#12

Steven Antonucci

The problem with chucks...

steven antonucci

in general is the tenon, not the chuck.

I almost always start between centers, regardless of whether or not I am going to use a chuck or a face plate. The only time I would still use a faceplate is on a big vessel, simply because if you do it right, it gives you the largest area to grip against. If you do it wrong, it is no better than any other wrong implementation of a good solution.

When I observe many long time turners making tenons in their chucks, more often than not, they are made wrong. If you are breaking tenons or having things come out of the chuck, you most likely have made the tenon incorrectly.

First, a 50mm set of jaws should be holding a 51 mm tenon. If you are gripping the entire circumference of the tenon instead of just the corners, it is nearly impossible to take something out of the chuck (unless you have the gouge cutting facing the wrong way...but I digress).

Second, the shape of the tenon needs to be correct and cleanly cut. I use my Thompson detail gouge to cut both the face of the shoulder and the tenon. This gives me a clean corner and a round tenon. If you use a parting tool, toy will get a fuzzy surface on the end grain of the tenon and a fuzzy shoulder. The skew or scrapers are better, but not as good as a detail gouge.

Third, you need to make sure that the jaws are clear of chips and dust, and that the tenon doesn't have any fuzzies stuck to it. If your tenon is accurate, the blank should run almost perfect when you tighten it in the chuck. If there is a little wobble, it is usually a small bit of wood stuck somewhere.

Lastly, to make the tenon the right shape, it needs to match the profile of the jaws. It is absolutely critical that there is no space at the outer edge of the jaw and the chuck sits perfectly flush. You also need good contact at the bottom edge of the tenon and the corner of the tenon shoulder intersection. The tenon should not bottom out inside the jaws of the chuck, and I usually leave at least an 1/8"

Should you decide to use a faceplate, you need a ring of wood that sits flush at the outer edge of the faceplate. I usually make the inner surface slightly concave to allow for the screw to pull a little, and also give any wood excavated by the threads somewhere to go. I use Wally's dowel trick to offset the fact that screws don't really hold in end grain.

Steve

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#13

Lyle,

GaryG in MD

I don't dispute anything you're saying, but my personal needs are fully and comfortably met by going first between centers and then into a chuck.

I have a 12" lathe capacity, so I'm not putting monster pieces of wood on it. If I had a larger lathe and turned 30# (or more) pieces of wood, then, most certainly, I would use a faceplate.

But that's not me.

I'm an amateur and not on a clock.

I do not rush my work; I enjoy it.

I don't take overly heavy cuts. I'm not trying to prove anything.

I have no vibration.

I don't need an electric driver, and I waste no time and energy with screws.

While I respect that you are doing what is right for you, and others like you, I think that you have to consider that there are a lot of others like me out here, and I think it's important to balance the commentary. That's the only reason I replied. I disagree with implying to a beginning turner that a faceplate is "the way to go" without discussing the common alternative that so many of us have used for years, and continue to use successfully every day. ...GG

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#14

Wally,

GaryG in MD

I use glue blocks too -- when I have a piece of wood on which I don't have enough room to turn a tenon because I want to save every millimeter of the available stock. It's a great method. Of course, my glue blocks have a tenon that go into a chuck, because I'm not going to make heavy cuts (as I said to Lyle, I don't anyway) on something held with a CA glue joint!

No question that Jerry's screw chucks are the best, and an effective way to go -- with one exception. I used to use screw chucks too, but I found, more often than not, that I would have benefited from being able to adjust the mounting angles subtly after I got a better look at the grain patterns. You can't readily do that once you've started on a screw chuck. That's why I now start everything between a steb center and the live center. (The fact that I use a steb center is a dead giveaway that I don't take overly heavy cuts.)

Please see my reply to Lyle too.

Thanks for your thoughts. ...GG

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#15

completely agree

GaryG in MD

You nailed it.

All of your points are important.

A spindle gouge is definitely the way to go -- making final cuts from the two different perpendicular directions. As a final step, I actually "remove" a tiny bit of the inner corner of the tenon in each direction (leaving a tiny void) to ensure that there is nothing there to deflect the inside corner of the jaws. ...GG

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#16

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

phillip Medghalchi









John, as you can see in the pic. my tenon was made for slightly under he largest possible tenon size for a 50 mm Nova 2 jaws so when and if it drys out of round I would still have enough tenon left to bring it back to round and finish the job. As for the grain orientation it ran in perpendicular with the axis of the bed when i put the log in between centers. This tenon was chosen to be for 50 mm jaws because it did not exceed the 8" Dia. limit. when I go hollowing the bowl I always use the tail stock and yes do make those long tenons until my tools get in the way of hollowing and I hollowed out almost 85% of the bowl that way. Of course, on smaller bowls it doesn't very long before your tool hot the tail stock, and I push it until the handle can not be easily get into the bowl to hollow.

Bill, your point was taken and I already do that, thank you.

Reed, as for size I do realize that matters and I try to keep it proportional so the largest jaws i have is 100 mm Nova jaws. Now, i did have problem with wood species, you are absolutley right on that, for instance with mesquite if you dona't watch it and you have part of the sap wood in the tenon 95% of the time you are asking for the tenon to break, so i am lucky I have experinced that with the woods I have been turning. As for the recess I have not had much of luck with it they all have broken or busted when I tried them or when I go tightening I guess I over tighten them and has not worked for me. Reed I hope as I said before that when I make it back to WA, I can make some time to drive down to your place and watch you first hand turn and learn some of your techniques.

""Another consideration is on lining up your chuck jaws with the wood grain. Again, not a lot of difference if you are using dry wood. Especially if the wood is green, you do not want the jaws centered at 12, 3, 6, and 9 o'clock. Rotate them 45 degrees. If 2 are lined up on end grain (very little compression of wood) and 2 are lined up on side grain (much compression of wood) it can work loose, or at least there are different stresses on the wood. You can even it out if you rotate 45 degrees."

Reed, I am not sure if I follow you on this paragraph, I wish I could see a drawing of what you are telling me.

Lyle, you wrote:

" A faceplate and or glue block is much stronger and will never sheer off a tenon. Usually vibration is the issue, not the tenon when using chucks. We can turn easier, faster, safer with the stronger holding methods. I only turn wet wood but it will work for wet or dry. Yes, size matters, bigger turning requires bigger faceplates. I think Dale Nish started the 40 percent rule. 10 inch bowl needs a 4 inch faceplate/glue block.

If you do start between centers then at what point you use a glue block or a face plate. I thought you said that you use between centers so you can control the grain orientation. OK, after you do that then you have to make a true surface for the face plate to screw it onto, don't you? then can this not happen at that point?

Dale, thanks for the heads up i think you may be very well right on the wood species and this is my first time playing with this wood anyways. so, I have to watch out when I do the other half of this log for the natural edge and the othe half for the end grain to showcase the real grain. As for the hidden fracture i don't think it was there because the wood was very wet and sappy, then again I am not too sure about it.

Wally, I respect what you said, and Lyle, when I started in this trade the president of our club suggested that I should own a chuck, and I respected his opinion so, I bought one, so we are passed trying to justify why I bought it. I have not had any formal training nor can I afford it at this time, i have been blessed by the tips i got form true professionals like yourselves that helped me along. I am for ever grateful for it.

Wally, I wasn't into wood turning back then, I was doing some wood working and in the college, but since the money is already spent, I am trying to get my money's worth of my tools. I looked into buying face plates and at the prices they sell them for I could not own that many, however, I bought 6 of nuts that accommodate the spindle size and threads on my lathe and I have to get int their and make some face plates. I don't have metal lathe to true up the face of the nuts and glue them in a wooden face plates, so when I went to try it out I had problem with vibrations and finally figured out that the nuts I bought are not true for the purpose i wanted them to work for. so, that is my next project to make face plates for those 15 7/8" bowl blanks, even at that I have to figure out how to them between centers for the grain orientation w/o accident.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#17

Re: with all due respect to Lyle and Wally,

phillip Medghalchi

Gary, I appreciate your thought on this I guess we all have to evolve as the new technology comes along. I did what I was told and bought the chucks and well, the money is already spent and I wanted to make the best of my investments, i am sure you realize that the jaws I have in my disposal are still limited to their final sizes and I was trying to find other alternatives for larger blanks, I am sure you ahve spent lots of money on those jaws for your chucks. I have to watch my budjget and make work of what I already have.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#18

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

phillip Medghalchi

I am not sure what happened to the pic.s, but here are re-posts.

OK, the bowl you see is the other half of this piece of log. In this pic. you see the half that I am going to turn a natural edge from.

As you can see I couldn't get around hollowing it to the thickness I wanted due to the tenon breaking.

This is how it was oriented on the lathe between the centers, ( disregard the torn grain, that I'll fix it later.

I think incorporating some of the sap wood was the issue, what do you think?

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#19

Re: The problem with chucks...

Stuart Johnson

Should you decide to use a faceplate, you need a ring of wood that sits flush at the outer edge of the faceplate. I usually make the inner surface slightly concave to allow for the screw to pull a little, and also give any wood excavated by the threads somewhere to go.

Often the simple things seems to confuse me. If starting between centers and then switching to a faceplate or glue block how do you flatten the center and turn it for the slight concave? Do you sand / carve off the nub from the tailstock? My second question is once it is ready and the faceplate is attached or glue block glued on how true will it run?

Using a counter sink on the face screw holes will give a place for fibers pulled up by the screws.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#20

Re: The problem with chucks...

John Lucas

Stuart Most of my faceplates have a hole in the center that is about 3/4" so I simply turn the tenon down to fit that size or smaller. When necessary I just cut it off, usually with a hand chisel and mallet since it's concave at that area so shape isn't critical

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#21

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

John Lucas

You don't need a faceplate for each bowl. I file a notch in the outer edge of my faceplates. Then after turning the bowl If it's going to be twice turned I simply put a mark on the wood where the notch is. Then when I take the faceplate off and put it back on later I can match the exact location since the screw holes will line up.

I drill more holes in my faceplates. 4 isn't enough. I also counter sink the wood side of the holes so it won't pull the fibers down when I put the screws in and hold the wood off the faceplate.

One consideration when you make the nut style faceplates is quite often the nut won't sit all the way back against the face of the spindle so it won't necessarily sit square. I use my homemade ones mostly for vacuum chucks.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#22

Steven Antonucci

Two ways of dealing with it...

steven antonucci

You nailed #1. I will grind it off with a burr or chisel it away. It is in the waste area, so how it comes out doesn't matter...just that it is not there.

Second answer is that sometimes I can turn it small enough that it will pass into the morse taper in the headstock. Same applies to the tenon on the chuck if you start between centers. It is ok the have a little nib in the middle, as long as it doesn't bottom out the jaws.

I am not trying to get the block to run true when I use the face plate. It is only a roughing exercise. Once it is mounted, I do my final truing.

Steve

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#23

Lyle Jamieson

Great thread going

Lyle Jamieson

My process starts between centers. I start roughing and give myself information about the wood grain, color, faults or features. Slowly sneak up on the shape moving the centers as I go to find the best use of the wood. Once I know the axis I want is final, then I turn the bottom near the tailstock area concave and prepare for the faceplate or glue block. The tail stock waste tenon is chiseled off later, so there is no obstruction in the middle to allow vibration.

The idea here is to transfer the power and stability of the lathe all the way out to the wood without vibration issues limiting your turning. So the first transition point is the shoulder of the faceplate mating with the headstock spindle shoulder. This must be a machined perfect mating joint. A nut with a washer welded on it will not work very well. It will likely bind up and be hard to remove or worse be a weak point for vibration. The more joints or transfer points the weaker the transfer of power. The next transfer is from the faceplate to the waste block. The waste wood should be dry hard wood like maple. We need another concave joint here too. Put the waste block between centers and prepare it so the faceplate seats around the outer rim. Pilot drill the screw holes in the waste wood to prevent the screws from splitting the dry wood. The next transfer is between the waste block and the turning blank. Both surfaces must be a shallow concave. The CA glue line is around the outer rim only.

This is sketchy at best with no illustrations and a partial text description. See my Bowl DVD for the why's and how's of the whole process. I have had feedback from this process that said it had "changed my life".

Another issue is grain orientation of the cuts. You mention you have not taken any classes. The torn out grain in your photos is a telltale sign you are working a lot harder then necessary. Go to an experienced turner in your club and get some help. There are much easier methods and tool control that will make your time at the lathe more enjoyable. You don't have to work that hard anymore.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#24

Lyle Jamieson

PS

Lyle Jamieson

I don't want the tailstock in the way when I rough out the inside of the bowl. Think about the chain of events.

*The chuck is a weakness

*I get vibration when I turn (or worse, I fear the wood coming off the lathe)

*To stop the vibration I put the tailstock up.

*To turn the inside the tailstock is in the way

*I need to use unconventional or inefficient tool methods to get the inside turned because the tailstock is in my way.

Do you see how the domino effect of using a chuck changes everything?? Are we having fun yet?? My process tries to prevent the obstacle or limitation rather then trying to fix it. The fix often has unintended consequences and results in more limitations down the road.

Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen

#25

Re: Wally,

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Gary, I don't quite know what you mean when you give your reason for not using screw chucks. When I use a screw chuck it's used with the glue block just the same as when I cut a tenon for a chuck. Depending on the blank I often start out turning between centers before turning a flat and attaching the glue block.

You mention the strength of a CA glue joint. If it's done right it's stronger than the wood in the glue block. In my classes if a student gets a big catch and knocks the piece off the lathe usually the glue block splits and the glue joint holds. (Yeah, it happens once in a while)

The reason I don't allow chucks in my class isn't because I don't want then to learn about chucks, it's because I want them to learn the use of a glue block and faceplate or screw center. I do show then how to use a chuck.

If I'm turning certain types of turnings such as doing a beaded vessel with the beads going all the way to the bottom a chuck really is in the way when doing the last few beads. A screw chuck and a glue block gives me lots of room to work.