Re: Between Center qsn. for Lyle jamisen
phillip Medghalchi




John, as you can see in the pic. my tenon was made for slightly under he largest possible tenon size for a 50 mm Nova 2 jaws so when and if it drys out of round I would still have enough tenon left to bring it back to round and finish the job. As for the grain orientation it ran in perpendicular with the axis of the bed when i put the log in between centers. This tenon was chosen to be for 50 mm jaws because it did not exceed the 8" Dia. limit. when I go hollowing the bowl I always use the tail stock and yes do make those long tenons until my tools get in the way of hollowing and I hollowed out almost 85% of the bowl that way. Of course, on smaller bowls it doesn't very long before your tool hot the tail stock, and I push it until the handle can not be easily get into the bowl to hollow.
Bill, your point was taken and I already do that, thank you.
Reed, as for size I do realize that matters and I try to keep it proportional so the largest jaws i have is 100 mm Nova jaws. Now, i did have problem with wood species, you are absolutley right on that, for instance with mesquite if you dona't watch it and you have part of the sap wood in the tenon 95% of the time you are asking for the tenon to break, so i am lucky I have experinced that with the woods I have been turning. As for the recess I have not had much of luck with it they all have broken or busted when I tried them or when I go tightening I guess I over tighten them and has not worked for me. Reed I hope as I said before that when I make it back to WA, I can make some time to drive down to your place and watch you first hand turn and learn some of your techniques.
""Another consideration is on lining up your chuck jaws with the wood grain. Again, not a lot of difference if you are using dry wood. Especially if the wood is green, you do not want the jaws centered at 12, 3, 6, and 9 o'clock. Rotate them 45 degrees. If 2 are lined up on end grain (very little compression of wood) and 2 are lined up on side grain (much compression of wood) it can work loose, or at least there are different stresses on the wood. You can even it out if you rotate 45 degrees."
Reed, I am not sure if I follow you on this paragraph, I wish I could see a drawing of what you are telling me.
Lyle, you wrote:
" A faceplate and or glue block is much stronger and will never sheer off a tenon. Usually vibration is the issue, not the tenon when using chucks. We can turn easier, faster, safer with the stronger holding methods. I only turn wet wood but it will work for wet or dry. Yes, size matters, bigger turning requires bigger faceplates. I think Dale Nish started the 40 percent rule. 10 inch bowl needs a 4 inch faceplate/glue block.
If you do start between centers then at what point you use a glue block or a face plate. I thought you said that you use between centers so you can control the grain orientation. OK, after you do that then you have to make a true surface for the face plate to screw it onto, don't you? then can this not happen at that point?
Dale, thanks for the heads up i think you may be very well right on the wood species and this is my first time playing with this wood anyways. so, I have to watch out when I do the other half of this log for the natural edge and the othe half for the end grain to showcase the real grain. As for the hidden fracture i don't think it was there because the wood was very wet and sappy, then again I am not too sure about it.
Wally, I respect what you said, and Lyle, when I started in this trade the president of our club suggested that I should own a chuck, and I respected his opinion so, I bought one, so we are passed trying to justify why I bought it. I have not had any formal training nor can I afford it at this time, i have been blessed by the tips i got form true professionals like yourselves that helped me along. I am for ever grateful for it.
Wally, I wasn't into wood turning back then, I was doing some wood working and in the college, but since the money is already spent, I am trying to get my money's worth of my tools. I looked into buying face plates and at the prices they sell them for I could not own that many, however, I bought 6 of nuts that accommodate the spindle size and threads on my lathe and I have to get int their and make some face plates. I don't have metal lathe to true up the face of the nuts and glue them in a wooden face plates, so when I went to try it out I had problem with vibrations and finally figured out that the nuts I bought are not true for the purpose i wanted them to work for. so, that is my next project to make face plates for those 15 7/8" bowl blanks, even at that I have to figure out how to them between centers for the grain orientation w/o accident.