Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

The future of instructional video

Posts

The future of instructional video

#1

The future of instructional video

robo hippy

I was meeting with my film guy, still attempting to get my bowl turning video together, and was asked what form did I want to sell it in. Now, I am way behind the times, but it seems that the video disc is becoming obsolete. The future seems to be heading to down loads/analog rather than the hard disc. It seems options would be for down load or some thing like Netflix where you have the option to rent or buy. It would save me having to get the disc made, packaging, and carrying an inventory.

Feed back please.....

robo hippy

Re: The future of instructional video

#2

Steven Antonucci

Yes

steven antonucci

It also overcomes another issue: copyright protection. Using it on a DVD was cost prohibitive, but using the various distribution platforms like Google Play and iTunes can offer built in Digital Rights Management. You can control the lease on how long someone "owns" something (i.e. rent), and also make it transferrable (i.e. sell like a physical DVD). If you shoot with HD equipment, you are essentially producing a "Blue-Ray" quality product.

As you've pointed out, no inventory or distribution issues. You can technically move all of that logistical stuff to the "stores" who take a cut of the download costs, but provide you a consumer base of 7B people...

Do it, and don't look backwards...

Steve

Re: The future of instructional video

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: The future of instructional video

Alan Zenreich

Digital online distribution is clearly the way to go. Every time I travel by air, I download movies to my ipad. Lauren regularly buys classes from Craftsy.com, and I buy cooking tutorials from Chefs.com.

Lauren and I are considering creating some full length, paid content.

Then again, I donate short tutorials/tips to the AAW FUNdamentals program. So a mix of free and paid content is a good portfolio.

Re: The future of instructional video

#4

Re: The future of instructional video

clay foster

I think it's important to consider the demographics of your market, and how they prefer to purchase and watch videos.

Re: The future of instructional video

#5

Re: The future of instructional video

Chuck Engstrom

Bear in mind that not all of us are in urban centers with unlimited Internet at streaming download speeds -- I have a 5 gig plan from Verizon and though it's 4G, it's one-bar speed most of the time out here in the woods, not at all blazing fast.

I still buy music CDs and video DVDs and sort of prefer them, perhaps mostly from habit, and would prefer to get your stuff that way, bought from the comfort of my desk chair and delivered by UPS/USPS. Otherwise I have to pack up the laptop and take it into town to get to a free, unlimited high-speed link at the library.

Re: The future of instructional video

#6

Re: The future of instructional video

Stuart Johnson

I like to have the option of download for one price or download with a following dvd for a second price. I'm not sure but I think the dvd's are probably produced based on requests rather than a large inventory being on hand.

Re: The future of instructional video

#7

Alan Sweet

Re: The future of instructional video

Alan Sweet

Assume there is some reason a person would want a video on a DVD. With the present software, a copy of any video can be made on most desk tops and many laptops. So someone can download and copy to DVD without any excessive overhead. Making a downloadable version will be able to be distributed to larger market than DVDs. DVDs will not go away, but their demand is not going to grow.

Look a what Kindle has done to literature. Eliminated the need for hard copy.

Aside, eventually all videos and written work will become electronic. The upside, the majority of people will have access.

The downside, any one controlling the central storage will have control over what will be distributed.

But that will never happen (sic). Like you can trust government control of information. Like the IRS, NSA, CIA, ...

Re: The future of instructional video

#8

Re: The future of instructional video

walta

How will the move to on line distribution work for club libraries?

I think DVD will be popular with woodturners for a few more years.

But then again I did not notice VHS was going before it was gone.

I have had bad luck with home computer burned DVD playing reliability on DVD players. I have gotten several authentic sets Russ’s finishing secrets all unplayable on 3 different players on different brands of disks.

Walta

Re: The future of instructional video

#9

Chuck Jones - West TN

ditto Chuck Engstrom's comment

Chuck Jones - West TN

We live in the boonies by choice and love lots of things about it but one big negative is no DSL, no Cable, and on the fringe of Verizon's 4G network with metered service.

My wife and I gained a few pounds eating at McDonald's while we did the required upgrade on those stupid new iPhones we bought a few months ago.

Re: The future of instructional video

#10

Bill Blasic

Re: ditto Chuck Engstrom's comment

Bill Blasic

I prefer DVDs and even if I had to download a video I would put it on a DVD. I wouldn't worry about copy protection as there are no protections that can't be beat. As far as that goes how hard would it be to pass around on a thumb drive. Make your movie, burn your own, make your own cover, put it in a plastic case and ship it out. You can still sell it over the net for those that want it that way. I haven't been to a club yet that has electronic versions of turning DVDs in their library. Make it, I'll buy it!

Bill

Re: The future of instructional video

#11

Re: The future of instructional video *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Chuck, this is a little O.T. but have you checked into a Verison mini cell tower? I have ATT and was only getting one or two bars. With their mini tower I now get the full number of bars. I purchased the tower but later found out some folks got it free after complaining about the low signal strength. If you complain steady enough they might do the same for you.


mini tower

Re: The future of instructional video

#12

Chuck Jones - West TN

Mini Tower is 3G only

Chuck Jones - West TN

Stuart, I agree it's a little O.T., but still relevant to Robo's question, at least for those who do not live in the big cities. I have thought about the mini tower for my metal shop building for phone reception, but it will not get the 4G LTE speeds that are desirable (necessary?) for large downloads like videos.

Re: The future of instructional video

#13

Steven Antonucci

A lot of misconception about technology?

steven antonucci

First, I don't think the market for the woodturning videos is going to go streaming or on-demand right now, simply because of the bandwidth issues some of you have outlined. If you have cable, Directv, DSL, or any high speed ISP, it could go that way... but I don't think there would be any market driver to have someone host the content (video). 5 rentals per year... yeah, no thanks.

On the DVD vs. Downloadable front, it is absolutely going to end up going that way whether the woodturning market wants it on VHS/DVD/Blue-ray or whatever, simply because the cost will be lower. If I am the "maker of DVD's", my profits will go up per DVD because I no longer have to burn them, ship them, and carry inventory. I have an infinite supply of "downloads", and I can ship them ANYWHERE for the exact same cost ($0). I can also choose to use the inherent copy protection capability available via the content publishers, meaning that clubs can no longer "buy one for the library...wink wink".

Downloading does not require high speed internet to watch the DVD. If you have an internet connection, the download is competing with the amount of time it takes for someone to burn a copy, stick it in a mailing envelope, and have the USPS deliver it to your door. Even the worst dial-up (I pity anyone still dialing, 70% of Americans have Broadband, 3% dial-up, 85% connected to the internet) connections will still be able to download the content faster than USPS can deliver it. Once it is downloaded to your PC/iPad whatever, it is yours to watch without being connected to the internet.

The first effects of this are already being felt. Minivans, which used to have premium packages with DVD players and mini TV's are starting to drop those options. Why? Because everyone have a cell/iPad connected to the internet and can watch whatever they want, in their own seat, individually whenever they want...and not the Lion King for the 27th time because it is the only DVD in the car.

I realize that a lot of woodturners are older, but if technology could make your life easier, why would anyone resist it? I've actually given some thought to short, paid content in the iTunes model. Instead of 60 minutes of DVD, high production cost, how many people would pay $.99 for a 10 minute video that could be purchased through their phone or iPad?

Steve

Re: The future of instructional video

#14

Steven Antonucci

3G is fast enough for large downloads

steven antonucci

3G is basically the same speed as a DSL connection. 4G is more like cable speeds. 3G download will beat the post office every day.

Re: The future of instructional video

#15

Alan Zenreich

Re: A lot of misconception about technology?

Alan Zenreich

Steve,

I'm going to assume that fewer and fewer of us cannot access and stream YouTube videos. That's the kind of bandwidth required... and the rich media providers generally automatically adjust bitrate to that which the client can process. So if one has a slow connection, a lower resolution image is sent.

My point is that claiming bandwidth as a limiting factor is at best a short term issue for most people. I don't think it's necessary to base distribution strategies on the corner cases. Go where the "money" is... the folks that are connected.

Re: The future of instructional video

#16

Chuck Jones - West TN

3G and 4G are not precise technical specs

Chuck Jones - West TN

There is no gain in debating 3G vs 4G speeds because of the wide variety of implementations under those "marketing" labels. My service switches back and forth daily depending on weather or "whatever" and I can assure you there is a vast difference in the speed at my house.

The relevant fact is both are metered services (as are the satellite services) and priced by monthly volume usage. This will undoubtedly affect most "rural" consumers willingness to use the internet for downloading large videos.

However, I agree those living in rural areas that cannot get internet services based upon conventional telephone or cable are small in number and may not influence the outcome of the video distribution debate.

Re: The future of instructional video

#17

Steven Antonucci

The Venn diagram of Internet and Woodturners

steven antonucci

The $64 question is "how long do you cater to the few?" I know that there are still people who cannot read the NJW newsletter via e-mail, so they get a hard copy mailed to their houses (a practice I would have personally killed if I ever took that job...)

The latest statistic said 85% of America uses the internet. 70% had broadband, and that another 10% had broadband via their cell providers. Somewhere in the US, there is a guy waiting for all the new releases on VHS...

I personally think that the entire woodturning DVD market would grow 10X if people shifted their content strategy. Would you be able to sell a bowl turning video to more people if it was $.99? How about "non-turners"? Would they buy it as "entertainment"? I wonder what the all-time best selling woodturning DVD is, and how many copies of it were sold? Is it in the hundreds or thousands?

S

Re: The future of instructional video

#18

Re: The future of instructional video

robo hippy

Well, thanks for the feedback. Lots I don't know about down loads, and I am a bit of a fossil technologically. I had also considered just You Tube with a commercial. I have the 'your video will start in 30, 29,... seconds' and almost always click off. Well, except for Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga singing 'That's Why the Lady is a Tramp'. Who knew she could really sing, but that is another story. With the 'you can skip to your video in 5,4, seconds', I have clicked on the icon about 20 times before it switches. The pop up ones that show at the bottom and don't interfere with the video, I usually just click them off.

Mostly I want to share and instruct. I do also want to cover my costs, and am trying to figure out how to do that. Lots to figure out yet.

robo hippy

Re: The future of instructional video

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: The Venn diagram of Internet and Woodturners

Alan Zenreich

The 99 cent approach might work for some authors... especially if they don't have the skills or interest in turning out professional level content.

The "competition" would be from providers that supply well produced content.

For example, take a look at the video about a course on this page:

http://www.craftsy.com/class/metalsmithing-at-home/131?_ct=sbqii-jxucu-byij-ycw&_ctp=2&_egg=sekhiu_wqbbuho_20131031&_ege=131

It's a $29 course in Metalsmithing... 11 HD tutorial sessions.

The only reason I mention this is that it's a good look into what other "craft" or enthusiast providers are already doing. So it should be part of the frame of reference for anyone considering providing content.

Re: The future of instructional video

#20

Steven Antonucci

price/value question

steven antonucci

So, as this topic lingers in my head, I wonder "what topics would sell?"

I'd bet that the "project video" series would far outsell the "how to/101" stuff. If there's one thing I have learned, people want to walk out of the shop with something in their hands and they are willing to pay for it.

Zenreich's 12 part course on making a pendant coming soon.

Lesson #1: Drilling a hole ;)

...

Steve

Re: The future of instructional video

#21

Alan Zenreich

Re: price/value question

Alan Zenreich

Lesson #1: Boring, not drilling

Re: The future of instructional video

#22

Steven Antonucci

Metered, yes, but ...

steven antonucci

When I got my plan with my smartphone, it came with 1 GB per month. The sales kid said that "the special was a 2X" at the time, and that buying an additional GB was $9.99... so I did. 4GB.

In the days that followed Hurricane Sandy, my only connection to the internet was my cell phone. I travel a fair amount, which means it is off the Wi-Fi a few times per month, etc...

During my worst month, I used 1.09 GB.

The key is that using the native device has automatic compression built in. I know that if I turned it into a hot-spot, the 20 devices in the house would suck up that 4 GB in a night. However, within the context of delivering video to tablet via a download, you'd be fine. I think a DVD is 2GB, and it's not like you'd download 3 a day?

There is a Quality of Service issue with rural areas. I bounce between crappy 3G and even crappier 4G LTE all through town, as I don't think they've configured the towers well in our area. It is roughly the equivalent of dial-up.

S

Re: The future of instructional video

#23

Re: The future of instructional video


Re: The future of instructional video

#24

Re: The future of instructional video

robo hippy

phillip Medghalchi

Robo, one of your own neighbors in OR, is just putting on these youtube vidoes

and constantly copying other turners ideas and redoing it. At end it sounds

that he is begging that "don't forget to subscribe to my channel". Few mos. ago

I wondered why is he so persistent in asking people to subscribe and finally

figured that the more people subscribe to his channel the more tool we give

him to go to the suppliers to ask for free tools and supplies for him and

recently all he does is advertising for the other guys and his contents are not

really fresh any more. if this is the route you want to go then expect it for

people to unsubscribe. However, if you are really doing it then put a short

video describing some of the highlights of your video and then if someone

wants to buy it they can go to your website and download it. If you notice

most of the turners can get on this forum because they have the connection to

do so, so downloading should not be a problem for them. Plus if they want to

have a physical copy of it then they can burn a copy of your video for their

own library. On the other hands, you have to consider that there are enough

videos on any subjects in woodturnings out there or even on the you tube, so do

you want to go through all the time you have to take to produce one? (not that

I am trying to discourage you form doing it) unless you make your content

really something special that other have not made it yet. And, remember every

one knows something about some subject, but not every one has the ability to

convey and teach the message for a large audience. Being a good teacher is an

art in itself. Good luck with your endeavor. :)

Philip,

I am not sure why the link on my e-mail had the above, and here it says NM..

It is interesting the things people do. Some times I get samples to try out, mostly from Vince for feedback on abrasives. I will always try some thing to see how it works and give a review. I always try to temper it with 'in my opinion'. I just love seeing some struggling with some thing and being able go give that one hint, and then seeing the light of understanding come on. That is my main purpose in trying to teach/mentor. If people follow me and subscribe, I want it to be because I am teaching them some thing.

Still doing better at getting famous than I am at getting rich, but I am having a lot of fun. I want to be like my dad. He is 91, still goes into work just about every day, and as he said on our yearly fishing trip a few years back, "I wake up every day excited", and he isn't saying that because he is still on this side of the sod. He really has more fun than most people I have ever met.

robo hippy

Re: The future of instructional video

#25

Re: The future of instructional video

phillip Medgalchi

llll