Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

finishing blend

Posts

finishing blend

#1

finishing blend

Dave L

I read the Russ Corner and saw his recipe for tung oil, spar varnish, turpentine mixture. Could BLO be used instead of tung oil, or would that have disasterious results? Just curious. I don't have the knowledge to know what the result would be. Thanks in advance for you response.

Re: finishing blend

#2

Re: finishing blend

david

I have used Russ Fairfield's brew for soaking my NIP and Cook Pine pieces for nearly ten years. The other turners in this state who turn pine pieces all have a variation of Russ's recipe. The proportions may be slightly different, but the ingredients are usually the same. BLO can be used in lieu of tung oil. On some woods, tung oil is an advantage because it dries out better than BLO. There are modifiers than can help, such as Japan drier. The trouble with spar varnish is finding a product that is not water-based (oil and water, etc.). I don't know enough about the difference between spar varnish and a polyurethane finish, but have been able to find oil-based poly. Can't say that I have exhausted all possibilities in searching for an oil-based varnish, but have found the poly to work well in the mixture and it does the job. This is my version of Russ' recipe: 2 gals. paint thinner, 1 gal. BLO, 1 qt. oil-based polyurethane. (Min's has a product I found that works). I immerse my pieces and need a lot of liquid, and my last batch was 5 gals. paint thinner (pail avail from Lowes) 2-1/2 gal. BLO, and 3 qts Min's poly. I know the poly was a bit much, but I figure for that quantity (7-1/2+ gals), the extra 2 cups shouldn't matter. What we usually do is add more paint thinner as the mixture level goes down. Eventually this mix will gel and has to be absorbed in sawdust and thrown in the trash.

Re: finishing blend

#3

Re: finishing blend

mjonesrdg

No disastrous results. Blo will work the same, but will not have the same long-term results. Blo will yellow more, and sooner and will become more brittle over the very long haul. For large parts, tung might be cost prohibitive, small parts--- might not be a consideration.

Re: finishing blend

#4

Re: finishing blend

don stephan

At the recommendation of a long time finisher several years ago I started using equal parts mineral spirits, boiled linseed oil and Pratt & Lambert 38 gloss varnish (which I get at a paint store here in Cincinnati). 3 coats on an ash bowl in mid 2012 after which it's been used daily for corn flakes breakfast with no water damage.

Re: finishing blend

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: finishing blend

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I use equal parts regular polyurethane, BLO and odorless mineral spirits. A few points of interest: According to Bob Flexner's book "Understanding Wood Finishing", spar varnish is just varnish to which has been added a bit of drying oil to render the final product softer and less prone to cracking, and the term"Tung Oil" has come to mean a drying oil that can be applied by rubbing, and most likely does not contain any real tung oil. (It might be just BLO at an inflated price.) Therefore, using spar varnish rather than regular varnish in the mixture is redundant, and using "Tung Oil" rather than BLO probably is a waste of money.

I use odorless mineral spirits instead of turpentine because the smell dissipates more quickly. I have also used lacquer thinner instead of mineral spirits when I wanted to finish an item with no smell as quickly as possible. The thinner is there merely to help the mixture penetrate the wood as well as possible. It evaporates quickly and as far as I know has no role in the polymerization of the varnish and the oil.

Re: finishing blend

#6

Re: finishing blend

Dale Bonertz

Is there a real advantage to mixing your own? You are making Danish oil aren't you? Unless used in large quantities is it more cost effective to just buy Danish oil. I have been using Watco danish oil with satisfactory results but I have always wondered what the benefits would be to mix my own?

Thanks,

Dale

Re: finishing blend

#7

Good point..

david

In small quantities, Danish Oil, like Watco (natural) is a good option. In large quantities, making your own mix from separate ingredients saves significantly.

Re: finishing blend

#8

Re: finishing blend

mjonesrdg

Dale,

Over 60 years ago, I apprenticed in my fathers sign shop, and did all of the coating of sign blanks in preparation for his lettering. I worked with paints, stains, and varnishes. Virtually everything that came out of a can was "tweaked" to improve the function of the finish and I was taught the reasoning for each and all additives. Later in life, I painted cars and worked with custom coatings and lacquers...and further down the road, I was foreman of the paint shop in a houseboat factory.

'Blending my own' for wood turnings was something of second nature for me. I doubt, considering the low level of production from my wood shop, that there is any real economy in it. However, with the basic ingredients, I can replicate (to my satisfaction) just about any of the commercial finishes. "Danish" oil, for salad bowls, Tru-Oil, for gun stocks, gloss varnishes for "museum" pieces, etc. Give me some spar varnish, some 100% pure tung oil, some Boiled Linseed oil, some turpentine, paint thinner, and japan, and I can get pretty close. It is easier, IMO, to flatten a finish for semi-gloss after completion, than to get it just right with additives, but with a little corn starch from the kitchen added, you can flatten a high gloss varnish.

Blending your own from scratch, or tweaking a commercial product, allows for making the finish accomplish or perform, according to what attributes the finisher wants....in the way that it is applied, the drying times required, the protection level given, appearance, and it's expected longevity.

I think too, that guys in their shop enjoy making tools and jigs and gizmos, fly fishermen like to catch fish on flies tied at home, bakers brag on their "scratch" baked goods, and turners just like to say that the finish they use is home brew.

I understand that Wipe-On-Poly is polyurethane (varnish) with lots of thinner. I tried my first can of it this last summer and I suspect that there is some oil in it, but I am satisfied that there is nothing to be gained by trying to blend my own over the varnishes that I have been using, lo these many years.

Hope that helps!


img

Re: finishing blend

#9

Re: finishing blend

don stephan

If using small quantities the commercial product can be economical. However, it seems very thin, as if the mineral spirits portion is more than 33% and the solids content correspondingly lower. Even adding Bloxygen to the quart can of varnish, it's not uncommon for me to lose the last 3/4" or so to curing in the can. A quart of varnish lasts me 6-8 months using 1/3 in the oil-varnish blend.

Re: finishing blend

#10

Re: finishing blend

mjonesrdg

I have no idea what this "pic" is nor where it came from. And, I can't open it. (hope it is not naughty!)