Glue Block question
ken chase
Is it a bad idea to use plywood for a glue block?
Thanks
Ken
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Glue Block question
ken chase
Is it a bad idea to use plywood for a glue block?
Thanks
Ken
Re: Glue Block question
John Dillbeck
Very bad idea:
It might be...
mjonesrdg
It may be a bad idea, but I, and countless numbers of woodturners have been using plywood for a glue block and for many years. Certainly, there will be a point, when the size, moisture content, and weight of the workpiece dictates that some precautions ought to be taken. Also, the term, "plywood" is pretty generic....some plywood will have greater structural integrity than others.
Re: It might be...
Ken chase
Thanks. I've always used a chuck. Recently watched a Utube video in which Lyle Jamieson
Demonstrated how to make a glue block. He indicated glue blocks were far safer than chucks.
He made the blocks slightly concave. That's what precipitated my query.
Thanks all
Ken
Yes........
Re: Glue Block question
Geoff Whaling
Yes & No. Unfortunately plywood is such a generic term that it is safer to say no to using ply as a face plate.
Having said that good quality ply, the marine plys etc, are HQ veneers very well bonded with high quality glues. The glue bond in them will be as strong as any glue we routinely use.
The lower end of the scale the "single use" plys used in packing crates are pretty low quality veneers just bonded with minimal glue and are dangerous in this application. They delaminate very easily.
Re: Glue Block question
ken chase
Thanks all
Re: Glue Block question
robo hippy
After I sheared my second one off, I quit using them. I only use waste blocks for threaded boxes now. Pine is perfect. Having them slightly concave means that there isn't a high spot in the center for the bowl to rock on while you are trying to turn it.
robo hippy
Re: Not too concave
Betty Scarpino
Don't make the glue block too concave, otherwise if you try to turn a small base on something, there might not be enough of a glue joint left to hold the turning onto the glue block. A flat glue joint is ideal.
Be sure to use numerous, large, and appropriately long screws to attach the faceplate to the glue block. Also, ensure that the screws are tightened securely into the glue block (no gaps, screws tight). If, for instance, one screw breaks loose and two hold for an instant, disaster will happen quickly ... ask me how I know that .... wood, screws, and split glue block flew everywhere, fortunately not directly at me (I was wearing a faceshield).
Yes, glue blocks can be much safer than chucks: if the glue joint fails, the turning usually just falls to the floor. But with that said, there are safety considerations with the wood you select for the glue block, the size of the glue block, and the screws you use. I have good results with fir, poplar, pine, and soft maple, 2" thick so I can part through the glue block to remove the turning (make sure you avoid cutting into the screws).
my 2¢
GaryG in MD
I only use glue blocks as a last resort on relatively small (under 10") and/or relatively light pieces of "special" wood when I cannot waste even the 1/4" of wood necessary for a chuck tenon without destroying the design of the piece. (And I don't use recesses.) I hold the tenoned glue block in a chuck. I don't use faceplates, by choice.
The slight concave leaves room for a small amount of glue, so you don't squeeze the joint dry. I use medium CA and have not had any problem with it flying off. I am careful to make light cuts, primarily directed toward the headstock. CA is strong in compression, pretty good in tension, but very weak in shear. Put the CA on one side and spritz the other side with accelerator, and press together firmly for a few seconds. Make sure it's as centered as you need before touching them together. Do not try to move it sideways after the first fraction of a second, or you'll get a failed joint. After ten seconds, give it a firm pull, by hand, to make sure you did a good job before turning the lathe on. Then stay out of the line of fire.
When you're done turning, insert the edge of a sharp bench chisel into the joint and give it a little whack. It will come right off, although you will probably end up with a little bit of wood, from one side or the other, stuck to the glue. Finish turn the bottom in the normal fashion of your choice -- jam chuck, Cole jaws, donut chuck, Kirsten Kone, etc. ...GG
YES, a really bad idea!
Re: Glue Block question
John lucas
Depends on the size of the work and the quality of the plywood. I frequently owe scraps of plywood to turn my mirrors but they don't have any weight. What I do is just go to Lowes a d buy a 3 1/2 inch piece of poplar. Cut it up into squares and inhave a whole stack of good glue blocks. If for some reason I need a thicker block I simply glue 2 together. I face them off when I remove the wood so they will be ready for the next project. I get quite a few uses out of each one before it needs to be tossed
Re: my 3 Cents
Brad Vietje
If you're going to use a glue block, why use CA at all? CA is not only weak in resisting shear forces, it's terribly weak and brittle when exposed to shock -- like a catch or any sudden bang.
You might find that you don't even need the chisel to get it off -- just give it a whack, and it will likely break free -- and that's not a selling point!
For strength and safety, slow down and use a good PVA glue, and use CA for hairline cracks.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: It might be...
steve worcester
Slightly concave would indicate he is using a glue that would allow a method of attachment that would allow glue to affix it better than screwing into the wood. In that case the glue does do a better job. But go back to plywood. If it is a dense ply, maybe it would hold better, if the glue filling the gap was stronger than the wood. Yellow glue might. Personally I use poplar for vessels up to 8"or do. But I actually prefer to screw into the block itself. It depends on what you are doing.
Re: Glue Block question
Wally Dickerman
I doubt that anyone here has used glue blocks more than I have. Started way back in the early 80's. Got tired of dealing with the holes that were left after using a faceplate. (For you late comers, the 4-jaw chuck wasn't around before about 1990) We used mostly faceplates or screw chucks. Still do.
I do most of my finishing on the lathe while the piece is still on the glue block so I treat the joint like any good glue joint. Both surfaces true and flat and no concave surface. For those of you who have doubts about CA I've used it on many hundreds of pieces and can't remember ever having a failure. If there is a failure it's almost always because not enough glue was used. I always want glue squeeze-out.
I use alder because it doesn't warp so it always has a flat surface, it's soft and doesn't split easily. I have good source for 1 inch thick alder.
If I'm turn an end grain piece I usually use a chuck with a tenon on the piece. If I do use a glue block on end grain I cut a 1 inch tenon to insert into the glue block. Makes a good glue joint.
And God said to wally...
Darrin Hill
Thou shalt invent a method of turning trees into shavings....
"I doubt that anyone here has used glue blocks more than I have."
Seriously... and I am really seriously serious, but i am seriously poking fun at you...
but mathematically... I doubt ANYONE, and i seriously mean ANYONE, has ever used a lathe as LONG as you have... seriously...
so what do people use as their favorite parting tool on glue blocks? I dont trust parting tools... bent one badly one time and then i almost bashed my finger in half... caught something weird and it dragged my finger under the tool along with the tool, and the flat bottom mashed a gash... not cut.. mashed..
if i do anything i part a small percent then i use a japanese saw to cut off the rest... labor and time intensive, but... saves my fingers...
Re: And God said to wally...
Don Evans
I cannot imagine how you got you finger under a tool unless it wasn't on the tool rest, but be that as it may. My first guess would be that you cut into the wood and tried to go too far in without widening the groove being cut.
When using a parting tool you have to cut into it about 1/4" inch then back out and move over (left or right) slightly and make the groove wider than the tool you are using. You must then continue to do this all the way to the bottom.
If my guess is correct then you didn't really catch on something, the wood getting hot closed up the groove and actually grabbed the tool which could raise it off the rest. If that is what happened then you also, in addition to not widening the groove, were not holding the tool good enough.
What do you think? By the way, that is exactly why a diamond shaped parting tool is shaped the way it is, that being the cutting point is wider than the sides above and below that point but you should still widen the groove when using one of that type.
I use nothing but the 1/16" one's now and also made the groove 1 and 1/2 the width of the tool.
I also started back when Wally did but other work took a lot of my time so he has turned much more than me but not much longer. I actually turned my first thing on a metal lathe sometime in the late 1950's.
Don
Re: Glue Block question
Don Evans
Wally for others to know, you mentioned CA glue. I have done that also but should mention it should be thick or at least medium CA. I agree 100 percent on the squeeze out. I also add some drilled 1/8" holes in the block. I prefer yellow glue though clue over night.
Pls say if you agree on the viscosity?
They should also be small pieces.
Don
Re: CA Glue Thickness
Betty Scarpino
Of course I'm much younger than either you or Wally ; .) .... but I've been using glue blocks since the early 1980s. I switched from using yellow glue (yes, let it cure overnight) to CA glue in the mid 1990. I use medium-thick CA, but thick would work also. DO NOT use thin CA glue and expect the joint to hold.
I use a diamond-shaped parting tool to part through the 2" glue block--not all the way, but until there is a small tenon. For a small turning and small tenon, the joint will snap apart. For larger turnings, I have a larger tenon and then use a mallet and chisel to carefully break the joint, with the assembly off the lathe.
Next, comes reverse-turning--and there are several easy, safe methods to accomplish that.
Re: And God said to wally...
Alan Sweet
I frequently use paper between the wood parts in some of my glue blocks. and a good chisel and one or two good blows will separate them at glue/paper line.
Re: And God said to wally...
robo hippy
Probably the best parting tool, and the least used is the one from the McNaughton coring system. The cutter is wider than the blade so it doesn't bind.
robo hippy
Isn't that more to do with speed???
Geoff Whaling
.... "Yes, glue blocks can be much safer than chucks: if the glue joint fails, the turning usually just falls to the floor."
A failure or a seperation of the blank from the face plate / chuck / glue block will cause the blank, or bits of it, to go in the direction it sees fit, irrespective of what work holding method is being used. Speed has more influence over where the blank ends up and is most likely the cause, or a very significant factor, in many "work holding failures". To fast & it becomes potentially lethal; nice & steady generally means lower risk & lower consequences. We have to look at the wider picture - will it be safe & successful as a system - blank + glue + waste block + lathe attachment + speed + turning method + skill. Or chuck etc.
Glue blocks with hot melt glue work very well - just ask Australian turner Vaughan Richmond. I don't think he uses much else than face plates & glue blocks for his rather large and weighty bowl / platters..
Re: Glue Block question
ken chase
Wally, Thanks. Very helpful. Since reading this and the other posts I've used a glue block twice,
see the advantages and enjoyed the process. One question remains. I considered a great advantage
using the glue block over the chuck was enabling my removing the plate to work on another project
at the same time. I did this and when I re-mounted the glue block the piece was so out-of -round
I had to separate the form from the block and remount on another. Also I was unable to split
to piece from the block using a chisel and hammer. I'm thinking it best to complete the outside and
hollowing before removing from the lathe.
Ken
I frequently use glue blocks, and.....
JamieDonaldson
...especially for the thin square pieces I often turn. When starting the project between centers, I simply CA glue(medium or thick) a square waste block on the bottom and turn it round, with a tenon to fit a chuck when reversed. For final shaping of the base I support the work on a jam chuck, bottom to tailstock, and can turn away all but a stub of the tenon, easily removed off the lathe, no parting tool needed. Someone recently mentioned using hot melt glue for attaching waste blocks, and I had never considered that possibility! The thicker glue would facilitate having an uneven surface on the blank bottom where the waste block is attached, best not attempted with CA glue. I'll have to try out the old hot melt glue gun and see if it still works! 
Re: Glue Block question
Jorge
Ken,
I use glue blocks a lot, specially when making platters with rather thin stock that cannot make a tenon, I use a face plate with a block, glue the blank with yellow glue and let it set overnight; I used to use medium CA, plenty on both sides and spray one side with accelerator before joining, but had a rather big piece come unglued, after a day, the glue was hard on the glue line but still wet on the inside, so now I use Gorilla or the regular yellow glue, Tite Bond II or III.
I now turn to completion, both sides all in one go, before parting, I start the parting with a parting toll and as soon as I have established it, stop the lathe, reverse mount and start the vacuum, then part with a japanese saw.
I hate when things go out of shape, so now I make them in one go.