Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

screw it!

Posts

Re: screw it!

#26

Tapcons!


Re: screw it!

#27

Re: Stating that a tenon is "far more likely...

Doug Trembath

It appears that we don't share the same perspective, Jamie. I'm not certain how we would go about defining a "universal basis in fact". You are perfectly welcome to doubt what someone else says, no argument there, but you seem to bring a lot of emotion to the discussion, especially when you appear to have never tried the process under discussion, because your initial perception is that it's the wrong way to do it. My question to you would normally be something like "What do you base your conclusion on?"

Then again, I normally wouldn't respond to a post like yours.

After turning many hundreds of bowl blanks in a production mode, I assure you that in my own experience, a tenon will let go under similar circumstances long before a recess, as outlined by Reed, in the original post. If you haven't tried it, how are we supposed to trust your judgment?

I specifically excluded newbie turners from the discussion, because I believe all new turners should have hands-on training for the basics of fixing wood to the lathe, so your comment there also seems to be out of order, don't you think?

Too often folks here condemn processes they are unfamiliar with and label them unsafe with no experience upon which to base the summary judgment. Does that mean when you, personally don't agree with something, it is automatically wrong?

Truly, what's up with that?

Doug Trembath

Re: screw it!

#28

Well Doug, since you question my ......

JamieDonaldson

...apparent understanding of a process, you have failed to understand that I also have many years of turning experience on which to draw, 26 yrs. to be exact, and that's significantly longer than you've been turning! There are often many ways to accomplish a specific task, and consideration of safety relating to both process and material are required. There are very many diverse methods of mounting wood to be turned, and I have experienced all that I've ever encountered that might be practical and safe, and I've studied with some of the best turners of all time. Rude Osolnik was among the first, and he was among the first turners to tackle all manner of "crappy" wood, and his methods and products are among my favorites. You may continue to use your practices and I will continue mine, but be assured that I will not endanger myself or any of my students with questionable mounting methods. Enough! ;)

Re: screw it!

#29

Steven Antonucci

You'll never break one.


Re: screw it!

#30

Steven Antonucci

All of this talk about tenons vs. recesses?

steven antonucci

and nobody has taken a second to talk about the practical applications of both?

Given a choice, I lean towards a properly made tenon personally, simple because I start most pieces between centers, and it would be hard to turn a recess in the bottom with the tailstock there. That said, if I am working with a thin platter blank where I may not have enough material to turn a tenon, I wouldn't hesitate to use a recess.

I will also offer the following. A tenon that is too small to support the rotating mass is much more likely to shear off in the event of a catch. A recess may get a little bit dinged up, but you could probably still remount the piece vs. having to fix it. I used to get all kinds of tenon failures while coring larger blanks until I bought larger jaws for my chuck. Since then, I haven't lost one tenon.

I think that you need to consider the application and make your choices accordingly.

Steve

P.S. there are so many poorly made tenons and recesses out there, it often doesn't matter which you use. I spend 2 hours in my class going over it (at least that's how it seems?) and often watch people tearing things out of the chuck anyway. If your tenon is properly made (or your recess), it should be nearly impossible to take the object you are turning out of the chuck whilst turning it.

Re: screw it!

#31

Re: All of this talk about tenons vs. recesses?

Bart Leetch

So I just gotta ask because because I have turned some over a period of years I still don't have the experience some of the turners here have.

Recess or tenon isn't the aim to make either the tenon or recess the right shape to fit the dove tail jaws so as to fit the dovetail angle & have the most contact with the circumference of the jaw without opening or closing the jaws to much.

It seems to me some people here while they may have a lot of experience in one way or the other of mounting a piece of wood to be turned depending on the type of wood & whether it is wet or dry or the object to be turned & size need to be a lot more tolerant of others with experience way of producing the same produce unless it has been absolutely proven to be unsafe to do it that way. Also maybe those who are not so tolerant need to spend more time trying the other persons method of mounting to discover why the other person can do it safely & they don't seem to be able to. In the end there just has to be a reason & we should all be willing especially the experienced turners to try we might learn something we thought we already knew.

In the end I guess I'm saying I would have a hard time learning from someone that makes dead end statements about methods that others have proven to work safely. Also the fact that these chucks were designed to be & have been used for years this way leads me to wonder....

Re: screw it!

#32

Steven Antonucci

Correct on tenon shape

steven antonucci

Generally speaking, if I have 50 mm jaws on my chuck, I aim to make a 51 mm tenon...give or take. The idea is not to try to make an 80 mm tenon with the jaw slides sticking out, because you only have 8 small points of contact.

Similarly, the recess should be whatever the outer diameter of the fully closed jaws is. Again, no 80 mm recess with 50 mm jaws.

Either one should be appropriate to the mass and operation. While I might be able to return a bowl with a smaller tenon, I want the largest tenon possible when I core the bowl. There is a big difference in what you are asking the wood to do under the stress of coring vs. a recut. Choose wisely.

I agree that there are usually multiple ways of doing things, however, I am always amazed at opinions vs. facts. When people represent opinions as facts, usually that's when we see the difference of opinions :-)

Which one is stronger? My opinion is that the tenon might be because wood doesn't compress real well, but is also cannot expand without failing. Given the choice between compressing something that cannot compress, or expanding something that can expand only via failure... you now know why I might favor a tenon?

Steve