screw it!
Darrin Hill
really need to stop using cheap screws... anyone use screws for faceplates that are better than the cheap lowes ones?

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
screw it!
Darrin Hill
really need to stop using cheap screws... anyone use screws for faceplates that are better than the cheap lowes ones?

Re: screw it!
Darrin Hill
2 broken screws and the hole on the left is another screw i dug out by drilling around the screw.. but i broke the drill bit and it's still in that hole..
sigh.
Re: screw it!
John lucas
Don't use woodworking screws Use screws made for metel working.
Pilot Holes ! ! !
Doc Green
Darrin, you gotta drill pilot holes - that is, drill a hole where the screw is to go and then put the screw in the hole.
Of course, the pilot hole must be a tad smaller than the diameter of the screw thread. The preferred diameter of the pilot hole is the same as the solid part of the screw.
This may seem like a lot of trouble, but not nearly as much as trying to dig a broken screw out of the wood after it breaks.
It appears also that for the size of the blank you should use larger screws, say a number 8 sheet metal screw, or as large a screw as will fit through the holes in the faceplate.
Let me say it one more time: You gotta drill pilot holes!
Re: Pilot Holes ! ! !
John Stegall
I'm with JL on this one, metal screws. I also use GRK screws a lot. They drill their own pilot holes, or so the mfr. claims. Drywall screws break too often for me to use in woodwork, of course your mileage may be better.
Re: screw it!
Roger Chandler
Those look like drywall screws in the pics...............never use drywall screws, because they are hardened and brittle...........only use metal screws and pilot holes are the right way to go. I use some screws that are 1.5" and some that are 2" in length......no. 12, if I remember correctly.......they have plenty of strength for a faceplate.
Re: screw it!
John Jordan
SPAX Screws-12x1-1/4. Available from Highland Woodworking and other places. Knife edge threads, a box will last forever.
John
Re: screw it!
Cyril Griesbach
Ditto on the SPAX screws. I've had two boxes in two sizes for years.
Re: screw it!
Donna Parrillo
If you decide to go with the SPAX screws, try your local Home Depot. The stores in my area sell them.
Re: face plate too small
Sergio
As already said never use brittle drywall crews and make pilot holes.
I add that from the picture it looks you were using a very small face plate (is it a true face plate or what? never seen one like that)
Larger faceplate have larger holes for bigger screws or you can drill a larger hole in the faceplate. Larger screws have much more holding power and can be a little shorter thus doing less damage to the wood.
Re: screw it!
Barry Irby
Good advice above. I use the blue screws that are meant to dive into concrete. For the life of me I can't think of the name, but Lowe's has them. As mentioned, they are somewhat expensive, but a few last a long time.
Re: screw it!
robo hippy
When I do use a face plate, I use galvanized decking screws. If the wood is very green, you seldom need to drill pilot holes. With some of the harder woods, you may need to do this. One other problem is people don't seem to know that setting your drill to max torque is a problem. You can, and do overtorque and break the screws. You want it set high enough to drive them, but not hard enough to break them. Of course, this can vary with different woods. If your drill has an impact setting, that works very well also. I do go around and tighten they all up again after I tighten them down the first time.
If you have a drill press, and a good sharp forstner bit, you can drill out the center spot and expand a chuck into that. With the tailstock attached to the back, you are safe, and never have to mess with screws and/or face plates again.
robo hippy
Re: screw it!
Bill Howatt
Probably Tap-Con.
I use sheet metal screws with Robertson/square drive. Screws are hard, have good thread depth and the square drive heads last forever.
As far as faceplate size mentioned above goes, it depends on the size of the blank. I use my 3" faceplate for probably up to 12" dia blanks (if I use a faceplate). It came with 3 holes but after watching a Lyle Jamieson demo I increased it to 6 holes. IIRC, he seemed to like a lot of screws when doing his hollow-forms. I think he said he didn't like square drive because he often had to remove them manually from the bit after removal. I considered it an indication of much better they are than Phillips.
Bill
I'll have to try the drill/chuck trick!
Re: screw it!
Dale Miner
Another good choice; The screws made to fasten cement board underpayment down to a subfloor. They come in 1-1/4“ and 1-5/8“ lengths, are #10 in diameter, are hardened but not brittle, and use a square drive.
Most Big Box stores carry them.
As aggressive as Robo is with his....
JamieDonaldson
...scrapers, I would never trust a recess/expansion chuck for mounting wood!
Compression grip on a sound tenon is much stronger, and safer!
Re: As aggressive as Robo is with his....
robo hippy
The 'which is better, tenon or recess' rises up again. What it comes down to is having either one 'properly' made. They both have very secure gripping power. As far as compression goes, again, this is the same. It makes no difference if the jaws are pushing out, and the wood is pushing in (recess) or the jaws are pushing in, and the wood is pushing out. Either one needs to match the chuck jaws for size and angle. By size, I mean you need a big enough tenon for the diameter bowl you are turning, and for a recess, you need a big enough shoulder outside the recess for the diameter of bowl you are turning. Other than that, the dove tail jaws do have a mechanical edge over straight jaws. The only time I will not use a recess is on end grain, which will split the wood like an axe or wedge. I learned by trial and error how to make a recess secure enough to turn and core bowls up to 16 inch diameter with my big Vicmark with jaws about 2 5/8 inch diameter. After I solved the problems of too shallow, too small of a shoulder, and overtightening, I heard a couple of turners state why the recess was not as good as a tenon. Every reason they stated was just a problem that I had already solved. Both work just fine.
For a drilled recess to start the bowl, this is more secure than any drive center if for no other reason, because it is bigger. The main thing it does is drive/spin the wood. If it is a bit undersized, you have to have tailstock support, or it will vibrate off. Been there, and done that, probably more than once. I would not turn and core a 20 inch bowl with my big Vicmark, but with the big 4 inch jaws on it, no problem, especially with the tailstock support.
Any time I am too aggressive with my scrapers, the lathe stalls. This is one reason why I am liking the 1 inch wide by 3/8 inch thick scrapers. I can still stall the lathe (3 hp Robust American Beauty), but it is more difficult to get too much steel into the wood at one time.
robo hippy
#10 Hex Head Sheet Metal Screw
don stephan
Here in Cincinnati every hardware store carries them individually and by the box in various lengths, in the "Hillman" section. I find a hex head lasts longer than phillips, and I haven't had to drill pilot hole for green wood, but always for dry wood. When I get a new box I note on the inside of the lid the drill size for the root. Can't remember ever snapping off one of these screws, but I do keep the drill torque setting just enough to fully drive the screw and no more. For large blanks I will then hand tighten each one just for extra caution.
Actually, I'm with Reed on this one...
Doug Trembath
When you spend all day every day on the lathe, you find ways to effectively, and safely, get around problems with fixing wood that others probably would not discover.
A tenon is far more likely to fail than a recess. In fact I have used both extensively, and have never had a recess fail. Lots of tenons have split, though. In turning platters, plates, and wall hangings a recess is much safer than a tenon, properly implemented, and it can be left on the bottom as a design element on some work, very nicely.
Mostly it has to do with the amount of pressure you apply, in both cases, using dovetailed jaws, such as the Vicmarcs. If you are really ham-fisted, you will increase the opportunity for failure markedly. You can split a tenon simply by crushing with the dovetail until you wedge the fibers apart, causing a split, just as you can split a piece mounted with a recess by applying too much force.
Properly mounted, with the tailstock backing the blank up, it's nearly infallible. Heck, many of us have simply pushed the blank against the jaw faces, tightened up the tailstock, and roughed it out in that fashion. Do I recommend it to a newbie? Heck no, but as I pointed out, when you have spent the hours at the lathe that some of us have, you begin to understand what is possible and what shouldn't be done.
That being said, look at some of the Rube Goldberg fixings Terry does to achieve some of his shapes. That's when I cringe, but he's perfectly comfortable with it, and quite successful, as well.
Reed's comment on turning end grain in this type of scenario is spot on, however. That's a tenon only proposition, as he says.
Doug Trembath
Re: #10 Hex Head Sheet Metal Screw
walta
Hardened screws are a poor choice for face plates.
The harder steel is the less tuff it is every application is a balance of the opposing properties.
For face plates you want a screw that will bend before it breaks.
I test my screws by putting it in 1/2 in a vise and 1/2 out strike it with a hammer if it breaks without bending you have the wrong screws. (Please ware eye protection)
Hardened screws offer few advantages in face plates and are dangerous as they can and will snap without warning.
Concrete and deck screws are tougher than dry screws but still too hard for face plates.
Walta
Stating that a tenon is "far more likely...
JamieDonaldson
...to fail than a recess" is a statement based on your personal conjecture, with no universal basis in fact. The wide variety of turning materials and characteristics make such a claim baseless, and potentially dangerous. You are correct that we experienced turners formulate techniques to suit our individual working practices, but I would certainly not project any such individual practice as a universal fact, and certainly not recommended for novice turners. 
Re: #10 Hex Head Sheet Metal Screw
Sergio
If one is afraid to brake the screws as I said just use metal screws #12 or #14 and four of them will easily hold a 20 x 8 inch bowl no problem. Use as other have said the ex bolts driven with the write torque settings and a 3/4 inch penetration is usually sufficient in sound wood. In many cases and with the tail stock I've used 1/2 inch penetration with no problems. Just think that in point to point turning the point penetration is 3/16 at the mostand with the grain. You can do all the outside of a bowl with the tailstock. The problem might come only with tiny screws on tiny faceplates used on bigger blanks.
Re: Actually, I'm with Reed on this one...
Bill Howatt
For my regular chucking I always use an external tenon and seem to think it is better. I can crank down the Oneway jaws which makes that part of the equation less likely to be the where it came loose place.
An internal tenon is fine but at the bowl shaping/finishing stage the amount of wood that the expanding jaws are pressing against can get or be limited. I see this as the weakness of the internal tenon method.
For the mounting of a new blank things are different:
Drilling a big hole in the face of a new blank and expanding the jaws into it where there is lots of wood around it and the tailstock is keeping the blank against the chuck/jaws I don't see it as dangerous. If the jaws loosen against the wood the tailstock is still keeping the wood over the jaws, the drive force is presumably lost and nothing should fly off the lathe. If there was no tailstock I would see this completely different.
Bill
Green wood tenons can be very weak
Aage Rendalen
I agree with Reed's point that it's all about jaw size relative to blank. I've never tried to hold a bowl in expansion mode, but I've had enough experience sheering off green tenons because of undersized jaws. Recently I lost four tenons in a row because I was too lazy to switch to the no. 5 Stronghold jaws. (Comes close to the classic definition of insanity: trying again and again a failed procedure, hoping for a different outcome.) I lost these tenons because it was Virginia cedar, which I hadn't turned in years, and hence had forgotten how brittle it is. With the bigger jaws, no problem (14" bowls).
GRK