Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Posts

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#26

Steven Antonucci

part of the cultural change process

steven antonucci

150% with you Mike.

I've seen people termed "safe" vs. "unsafe" because they had goggles on and a plate wailing along at 3000RPM. I've seen folks pushing the "face shield" chip deflectors as being "safety conscious". I've seen people say PAPR is "the best available"... but they all beg the question: Do any of them actually fix the mortality issues of a high energy impact? The data suggests no. I don't argue with data.

I also agree with Steve about having a safety culture, and I will wear my dust mask when I am sanding but I don't expect that it adds much value in the protection against large energy objects. We need to stop presenting PPE out of its intended use as it is a disservice to the community.

It would be very interesting to hear from the Powermatic owners as to the exact reasons that they remove the cages, which were designed with that intent (stopping high energy objects). What could be done to leave that in place in a way that woodturners wouldn't remove them?

Instead of thinking about better ways to absorb the energy with our heads, why not think of better ways to arrest the energy at the lathe? LatheStop, anyone?

S

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#27

Re: part of the cultural change process

mjonesrdg

Steve A wrote:

".......It would be very interesting to hear from the Powermatic owners as to the exact reasons that they remove the cages, which were designed with that intent (stopping high energy objects). What could be done to leave that in place in a way that woodturners wouldn't remove them?......"

Steve, I run a PM3520...I'll install the cage tomorrow (for the first time!) to see what I can learn.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#28

Re: What CAPA measures do you take...

Doug Wolf

Steve A,

You wrote, "Show me one PM with a guard not sitting on the floor behind it... refer back to point #1 (education) I would hazard a guess that PM owners never replace their cages in risky situations...".

Well you guessed Wrong.

I've turned for over 40 years, the last 5 on a 3520B and one of the reasons I bought it was for the cage that gives me some protection when turning. I admit I don't use it 100% of the time, but whenever I'm turning questionable wood it goes back on the lathe.

Please don't lump all of us 3520B owners with the "macho" ones that have removed their cages and never put them back on.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#29

Steven Antonucci

Good for you!

steven antonucci

I'd be interested in knowing how "inconvenient" the cage really is? Can you describe some of the issues it creates when it is in place? (I assume there are issues, or you'd probably just leave it in place?)

Perhaps there is a way to design a cage that doesn't have these issues?

Steve

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#30

When not used.

Doug Wolf

Steve,

It's not really that inconvenient or in the way as they designed it to swing up 90 degrees and lock with a spring loaded pin.

I use a box fan and filter when sanding and like it to be close the item I'm sanding so instead of redesigning my box fan I sometimes remove the cage completely.

I have to swing it up out the way of my head when I need to get down close to the work such as this goblet. I figure there's not much protection offered in this case anyway.