Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Posts

Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#1

Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Steve Criscenzo

I have been reading the many recent threads on safety but have been too busy to reply. I finally have a few minutes so here goes. Sorry if this sermon like and too long but I live these issues every day.

First the disclaimer….I am a safety guy. With 35 years experience in engineering, I have spent much of the last ten years managing large field exploration programs and I am often assigned to be the project site safety officer. In business, our focus on safety is primarily on maintaining the well being of our workers but there are financial implications as well. A single incident resulting in even a minor injury or lost time can shut down a large project for extended periods or worse yet get you removed from the project.

One of the lessons I have learned is that thinking and acting safely is a learned skill. The difference in safety attitude between folks that have been on multiple projects with me compared to newcomers is very evident. It is not a question of experience - it is all about accepting safety culture. We have more problems with crusty veterans who are set in their ways (“I have been doing it this way for 30 years and never had a problem!”) than we do with some less experienced folks. We begin every day with a safety brief and reward ideas and suggestions. After time, most people adopt and endorse the safety culture. Those who do not do not last long on the project.

A few key points from my work life that carry over to turning safely.

1. We must accept the assumption that every injury is preventable. If not, why would we knowingly put ourselves in harms way.

2. In industry, we evaluate each and every activity, identify the steps required, the hazards associated with the actions, and the ways to mitigate that hazards. I do this so often during my work day that it has become second nature in my shop. There is rarely an action I do that I do not think about this process.

3. Use the two minute rule – take two minutes before an activity to evaluate the task at hand, the work environment, hazards and PPE. Do it again if things change.

4. Trust your gut. I am often called upon to assist in an investigation of an incident. Almost without fail, when I interview those involved, they say they were uncomfortable with the task prior to the incident but still elected to proceed. If in doubt, stop and re-evaluate!

5. Evaluate all “Near Misses” as if there were injuries. A near miss that is evaluated can prevent a major injury in the future. A severe catch or an item dismounting from a chuck while turning are good opportunities to stop and evaluate even if there were no major consequences. What can be done to prevent it next time? “Accidents Happen” is not an acceptable conclusion. In industry we do a root cause analysis. Ask yourself why at least five times to get to a root cause. The answer may surprise you.

6. Use the correct PPE. Some of the statements I have read in this forum against face shields are the same ones I hear about PPE every day on the job. A hard hat is not designed to prevent injury from a 100 pound weight falling from height but that is not a reason not to wear one. There may not be PPE on the market to completely protect us from a heavy blank coming apart at speed but there is equipment that will minimize injury, dissipate energy and protect us well from less severe events. To reject face shields because they give a false sense of security or that they cannot protect from the most sever event, or they are hot or I am standing out of the line of fire or they are bulky or ….. is , in my view, dangerous rationalization.

7. I absolutely, 100% agree with the discussion of understanding the “Line of Fire”. It should be part of the hazard evaluation mentioned above. I have learned from this discussion and have altered my methods. I do not believe however that it mitigates the need for proper PPE. A blank that comes free from a chuck or a platter that comes apart at speed can easily be deflected by a tool, a tool rest, or other obstructions and travel in an unanticipated direction.

8. Finally, I think it is important to recognize and mitigate other hazards associated with turning. In my opinion, wood dust, can be just a s deadly as a dismounted platter. The effects of dust are subtle and therefore easily overlooked but can be cumulative and devastating. There are also potential hand injuries, fumes, fires and a host of others but that is for another day.

My personal bottom line – Shortly after I started turning, I evaluated hazards and PPE. I elected to purchase a 3M Airstream based on a conversation with Bill Grumbine (he was wearing one while doing demos in the vendor area at a symposium). I my view, the Airstream provides adequate head, face and lung protection for the turning I was doing. It also cost more than my first lathe. While it was painful to have to spend that kind of money, I made it a priority and have not regretted it for a moment.

Others may make different choices. The important thing is that your choices be based on a sound and reasonable evaluation of what you are doing, the hazards associated with it, and the limitations of the PPE to mitigate the risk. Learn good technique but know that technique alone cannot protect you from the unexpected. PPE is essential. There is no single right answer but if we all embrace a safety culture, set good examples, and do thoughtful evaluations of our processes, we can make a difference.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#2

Betty Scarpino

Excellent and well worth reading.


Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#3

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Barbara Gill

Very good post Steve. Thank you.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#4

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Peter Rand

"PPE"?

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#5

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Steve Criscenzo

Sorry - Personal Protective Equipment. Faceshields, eyeguards, respirators ...

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#6

Alan Zenreich

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Alan Zenreich

Steve, thanks for a well thought out post. It echoes many of the points I have been making over the years.

By the way, we are often almost immutably influenced by those we learn from in our early years. Fortunately, I and Lauren were also influenced by Bill Grumbine... and we now have a nice collection of AirStream and BreatheEasy respirators. Our priorities are very different than many turners we know.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#7

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Steve Kniffen

Steve,

Excellent post. I've been in the safety business for 30 years now. Everything you wrote was spot on. Whether we realize it or not, everything we do has some degree of risk, whether it's a decision to wear or not wear a face mask or (for married guys) a decision on what to wear out of the house. We all continually analyze the known risks, guess at the unknown risks, and decide courses of action based on our cost/ benefit assessment of the risk involved.

Steve

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#8

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

sergio

I entirely agree.

There are a couple things I would like to add and that can greatly contribute to sfety.

First, do not underestimate the fatigue factor. Many accidents happen when the worker is tired.

In addition I belive that pushing the limits is always a risk: turn at a reasonable speed for the wood you are turning and use sharp tools, the sharpest you can get the better.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#9

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Steve,

Well written and I agree with everything you wrote. The same points that I have been trying to get across but couldn't find the proper wording or sentence structure. Fantastic.

Dale

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#10

Steven Antonucci

What CAPA measures do you take...

Steven Antonucci

When you determine something to be insufficient to protect a worker, i.e., something that the worker is exposed to a hazard. Do you redesign a procedure to remove the worker? Do you redesign the equipment to remove the risk?

Clearly, the elephant in the room is high energy impacts, and I am 100% agreeing with every word you said. However, a dust mask and an Airstream are not the same thing. No safety gear will protect a worker if it is not used, or if it is used improperly.

Back to my question: what do you do when you determine the equipment cannot protect the worker?

Steve

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#11

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

DavidWalser

Steve,

I wish there was a like button. I would click it if there were.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#12

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

mjonesrdg

"Like"

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#13

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Philip Duffy

With over 30 years of flying helicopters -the most dangerous things in the world- - in the Navy, and all that entails, I think your assessment is PERFECT! Well Done, sir. Philip

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#14

Re: What CAPA measures do you take...

Steve Criscenzo

Steve

I would approach evaluating wood lathe operations in an industrial environment the same way as any other task. Identify the hazzards and put controls in to minimize the hazzards. Controls could come in many forms

- Training personnel on risks and mitigation

- Daily briefings- suggestions from operators on making it safer, two minute rule

- Mechanical controls, possibly put controls in place to limit speed.

- Guards - possibly some configuration of the Powermatic cage to be used in situations that presented to greatest risk and there were no other options to complete the work.

- PPE - My view, something along the lines of the Airstream to start with

- Continued Management oversight- Safety oversight and audits

I would not allow staff to work in an environment that I felt was not safe when the proper controls were implemented.

Steve

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#15

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Steve *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I've archived your post as a WoodCentral article so it will be available for easy reference in the future.

Ellis Walentine, Host


Establishing a Safety Culture

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#16

Re: What CAPA measures do you take...

Stuart Johnson

Back to my question: what do you do when you determine the equipment cannot protect the worker?

Outsource...

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#17

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Geoff Whaling

Excellent post.

The one thing about hand wood turning that makes it quite different in modern safety culture is the fact that we deliberately and voluntarily choose to not use engineering controls that remove us from the hazard or intervene in the path between the hazard and us. We focus our attention on medium and lower order controls instead. That is why there will always be significant risk in hand woodturning. We choose to turn by hand and to stand in close proximity to potential high risk hazards. We ignore the basic tenets of modern hazard management so we must always remain vigilant.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#18

Steven Antonucci

Re: What CAPA measures do you take...

steven antonucci

Steve C. wrote:

I would approach evaluating wood lathe operations in an industrial environment the same way as any other task. Identify the hazzards and put controls in to minimize the hazzards. Controls could come in many forms

- Training personnel on risks and mitigation

Education is the start of any change management program. You cannot force people to change. You can educate them to understand why they need to change, and then they will change on their own.

- Daily briefings- suggestions from operators on making it safer, two minute rule

It's me in my garage... do I brief myself?LOL We're seeing this become part of the AAW club culture (i.e. safety sessions)

- Mechanical controls, possibly put controls in place to limit speed.

In a computer driven world, it's amazing that some lathe manufacturer hasn't taken the SawStop approach to drive their product into the market? If someone built a lathe with a brain, industrial shops would have to "upgrade" to avoid the potential liability from negligently having outdated equipment. Eventually, this would drive the price down. Of course, this only gets rid of the error where the speed wasn't check, but doesn't stop fault wood problems.

- Guards - possibly some configuration of the Powermatic cage to be used in situations that presented to greatest risk and there were no other options to complete the work.

Show me one PM with a guard not sitting on the floor behind it... refer back to point #1 (education) I would hazard a guess that PM owners never replace their cages in risky situations...

- PPE - My view, something along the lines of the Airstream to start with

Something is better than nothing, and the cage in place is probably the best option for arresting high energy impacts (because it is not connected to your head... and we don't have to explain how a pressure wave travels through your brain)... and I agree that this is the intended use of the Airstream

- Continued Management oversight- Safety oversight and audits

I am the management. I have a staff of me. I am responsible for myself.

I would not allow staff to work in an environment that I felt was not safe when the proper controls were implemented.

Now...extrapolate that statement to the home shop where you have ultimate responsibility for your staff of one. It's easier said and done in an industrial environment where liability for other people drives behavior. I think most people desire to be safe, but do not have a team of actuaries standing behind them discussing the risk of injury and the payouts to the families after an accident.

So how do we translate your (and my) thinking to a target audience? Seems like the first place might be Powermatic owners...since they have the necessary safety equipment laying on the floor behind their lathes?

Steve

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#19

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

robo hippy

The engineer's biggest problem: You can never invent some thing that is idiot proof. As soon as you do, someone invents a better idiot.

I guess this is like 'common sense' not being very common. Try to educate as much as possible, and hope at least some of it sinks in. A good thread.

robo hippy

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#20

Re: What CAPA measures do you take...

Steve Criscenzo

Steve A

As I stated in my posts, the key for me is to have folks adopt the safety culture used in industry and bring it into their shops namely, take the time to evaluate the task at hand, identify hazzards, and take appropriate steps to mitigate the risks. Training can easily be accomplished through open and thoughtful dialogues (such as this forum) and by having training at events. Some of this training should be done by safety professionals becasue it is a process that must be understood. An objective viewpoint is often benificial.

You mention, "managment oversight" being just you in your shop. This is 100% correct. We need to teach safety culture to everyone so that when one is alone in their shop, they know to use the 2 minute drill, to understand risks and ways to mitigate them. We each have a personal responsibility to learn and live this becasue a shop related injury can effect more than just me. It can effect my ability to support and care for my family or worse.

In my comapny, whenever 5 or more people gather, we are required to start the meeting with a safety minute. What started as a strange pain in the *$!@ is now second nature and it often sparks a thoughtful and interesting discussion.

At my project site, people will routinely come up to me and let me know they are about to start a minor repair of a piece of equipment and then hand me a form we use for Task Safety Analysis. I did not have to ask for it, they just do it becasue it is part of the culture and when they all sign the form, they are verifying they are part of the process.

If it is just you in your shop or your are responsible for 50 people, the process is the same and once you are comfortable with the culture it truly becomes second nature. Do I still make mistakes? You bet I do. Hopefully they are all minor and I learn from them. I cut my hand a few weeks ago when the allen wrench slipped while changing a carbide cutter on a tool (it was a minor cut but could have been much worse). I took two minutes, evaluated what happend and now hold the tool in a vise when changing the tip.

I know I am preaching again but this is not rocket science. This is a process that needs to be learned and accepted. The worst thing we can do is over complicate it or rationalize our way out of it. If we identify and understand risks, then in our own shops, we can personally decide a path forward that meets our individual needs. If we demonstrate, we should include discussion on the process as part of our demonstartion and always set a good example. Intended or not, folks will tend to mimic what they see in a demo.

I am off my soapbox.

Steve C

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#21

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

Donna Banfield

Excellent post, Steve. I purchased an Airstream helmet shortly after Joan Kelly's accident and untimely death. I wear it all the time I am turning, regardless of the type or size of blank.

If someone manufactures a helmet/respiratory system that is better than the Airstream, I will buy it, regardless of the cost, because it's that important to me.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#22

Don't come off your soapbox,

Dale Bonertz

This needs to be heard. Especially the part that just because one implemented safety procedures such as speed and standing out of the line of fire that they still should wear their PPE (face shield). It is a false sense of security to believe that I turn slow and stand out of the line of fire (which I do) so I don't need a face shield or other safety gear. I use a great dust collector and air filtration system so I don't need to wear a dust mask - I don't think so. I could go on and on but I won't get started again. :)

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#23

Alan Zenreich

Re: Don't come off your soapbox,

Alan Zenreich

Dale took the words right out of my mouth...

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#24

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

mjonesrdg

If you would say that there has been argument for and against the use of “face shields” in the wood turner’s shop, you may have missed the point. And, it is a very salient point. First, the term “face shield” is bantered about as though all such devises are created equal….and they are not. Painting these with such a broad brush is tantamount to embracing “incorrect PPE”.

Secondly, failure on our part to distinguish between “correct” use and incorrect use does nothing to advance a culture of safety within the woodturning community.

A “Head Mounted Plastic Chip Deflector for Eye Protection” (“face shield”) is not, in legal, trade, nor industrial terminology, designed nor tested to do anything more than protect the wearer’s eyes from a projectile weighing less than ¼ oz. and traveling at a speed that approximates the speed of a baseball thrown by a major league pitcher. The headgear that supports the plastic or that covers brow, forehead, head, neck or chin, may, or may not, carry the same rating as does the lens. Probably not….and any portion of that head gear that covers the head ought not be called a helmet. A helmet, by definition is protection for the head.

If we are to be true to the cause of promoting a culture of turning safety, we will realize that our audience incorporates the neophyte, the seasoned veteran, and all those somewhere in between. If we are genuine in our interests of safe turning practices, we will focus our discussions on the mistaken beliefs ( about face shields) that lead to poor practices ….that often result in injuries. If we are mindful about what we preach and teach regarding safe turning, we will quit giving carte blanche kudos to face shields and in that, quit inferring or implying that there is a measure of safety beyond the standards established for eye protection.

The discussion is not “pro face shield” or “con face shield”,. and if I say that I might be better off without one, I am saying that I might be better off if I take the two minute pause and consider the alternatives to placing my faith in a “Head Mounted Plastic Chip Deflector for Eye Protection”. My face shield will be used appropriate to the conditions I am creating. I will not trust it to offer any other protection. I would not wish to mislead anyone else into false beliefs regarding the correct application of it, and I would urge others to err on the side of safety….quit generalizing recommendations for generalized use of face shields.

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

#25

Re: Establishing a Safety Culture (Long)

steve criscenzo

The understanding and selection of proper PPE is part of the process. I tried to avoid the "faceshield" debate in my post because it distracts from the point I was trying to make. No doubt there is a need for better equipment.

Steve