Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

in defense of Trend line helmut

Posts

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#26

Betty Scarpino

Re: Positive Approaches

Betty Scarpino

First of all, the correct rating number for the safest faceshield is Z87+, not Z87.1. Have you read Andy Chen's article in the April journal about faceshields? Are you aware of AAW's latest book on Safety, released earlier this year?

Second, I can only officially speak for the contents of the AAW's journal, American Woodturner. I edit the journal as an independent contractor. The AAW Board of Directors make policy. Anyone who wants to help the AAW with policy decisions needs to send a note to the entire Board (links found on AAW's website). Be proactive with your concerns.

A bit about my background: I started woodworking more than 35 years ago as an industrial arts major in college. My instructor, Dabney Doty, was a stickler for safety, so I learned to approach woodworking (and then woodturning) with safety as essential. I taught a safety class at the University's woodshop. Anyone buying a membership to the woodshop had to take this safety class first.

As editor, I bring with me an internalized awareness and concern for safety. Not only are there specific articles about safety in the journal, each article is edited with safe practices in mind. Of course you cannot see what I start out with--many articles include unclear instructions or even unsafe practices--but my overriding concern is that the end product be safe information for woodturners. I want the contents of the journal to be interesting, fun, and safe.

With all that said, how much more proactive do you think the journal should be? In what way?

Unofficially .... the AAW's Board of Directors are all volunteers. These folks are being proactive about their care and concern for the organization and for woodturning with their many hours of volunteer time. Are you proactive with your concern about safety, beyond simply posting a note on a woodturning forum? The AAW and its many local chapters is primarily an organization of volunteers. Many local chapters have a safety officer. Does your local chapter have a safety officer? Would you volunteer to be a safety officer? My hat's off to the hundreds of woodturners out there who are voluntarily helping others learn to turn. Safely.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#27

Betty Scarpino

Re: Topic already covered

Betty Scarpino

Steve, since you are not a member of the AAW, you may not be aware that there is a recent article on safety that included a photo of a lathe with a red vertical safety (unsafe) zone stripe painted on the wall behind it. The article was written by John Kelsey.

John also edited AAW's recently published Safety book, a compilation of previously published journal articles on safety.

And, a proactive AAW Forum participant already is currently writing a safety article specifically about the safety zone.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#28

Steven Antonucci

That is great news.

steven antonucci

I don't remember which books I had first when I first started turning, but it seems to me that most of them covered the topic. I don't think people understand exactly how important it is... so keeping it in the limelight is a good way to stress it.

My son's Tae Kwon Do Master always said that the best way to take a punch was to not take a punch. Having people demonstrate with the lathe set at a safe speed, standing in the right spot, and understanding that their safety gear will protect them against (and what it will not protect them against) is the best way to keep people from getting hurt.

It may be preachy and overbearing, but it needs to be periodically reinforced. I do it EVERY time I demonstrate unconsciously, but I think it probably bears some merit to proactively discuss what and where I am standing while the lathe is on, and what the risks are. I will be incorporating it into my next demo.

Thank you.

Steven

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#29

Re: That is great news.

clay foster

"I do it EVERY time I demonstrate unconsciously,"

I would like to see one of those unconscious demos.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#30

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

Don Orr

Steve,

Please take this in the constructive way it is intended.

If you want "someone" to take on this challenge of producing a dedicated, truly safe head & face protection device for woodturning, why don't you be that "someone"? You're an engineer and a woodturner and are the perfect person to develop this device. Design elements would need to include true high speed impact resistance, comfort, light weight and of course the ever-important cost, among other concerns. Design, prototype, Z87 certification, production, marketing, etc. All possible for someone like you. I'm serious here. It's long overdue. And if it really worked it could make a big difference in turning safety. It could even become the industry standard. I have thought about doing just this very thing myself but don't have the knowledge or connections I feel necessary. I think you do. Again, I'm very serious about this. I won't even charge you for my inellectual property for this since it is just too important. You can have the idea and run with it.

Think about it-seriously.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#31

Steven Antonucci

And with one hand behind my back! 


Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#32

Re: And with one hand behind my back!

clay foster

You should wear a face shield when you type.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#33

Steven Antonucci

Yeah...Usually in the LOF when I type LOL


Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#34

Dream On 


Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#35

Steven Antonucci

one hand almost behind my back

steven antonucci

it was holding the camera instead.


Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#36

Alan Zenreich

Re: one hand almost behind my back

Alan Zenreich

Sure, the old "don't try this at home" and 'I need a hand to hold the camera' approach. Exactly what I don't want to see in a video.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#37

Or how about the ol' "hey guys, watch......

JamieDonaldson

....this, and hold my beer!" :D And Steve, do you own a tripod? ;)

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#38

Alan Zenreich

Re: Or how about the ol' "hey guys, watch......

Alan Zenreich

Jamie, after I asked Steve the same question last year, he finally found his tripod... Don't know if he has actually used it yet.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#39

Steven Antonucci

not yet...

Steven Antonucci

But I know where it is... now if I knew where the camera was...

Got some more bowls to rough when the heat leaves us...who knows is they make it to video?

Good non sequitur.

S

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#40

Re: Positive Approaches

mjonesrdg

I will reply to your questions, Betty. I want my responses to be well thought out, and as positive as I can muster. Replies may show up in a separate thread.

Mike Jones, in Redding Ca.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#41

Re: one hand almost behind my back

Stuart Johnson

The only tool I can get a 220 grit cut from is the skew. My question though is:

If the shaving are hitting you in the chest or face shield doesn't that mean you are in the lof?

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#42

Re: one hand almost behind my back

Dale Bonertz

For some tools I would say yes, at least turning the outside. My smock looks like I stand in the line of fire all the time. In reality it looks that way do to all the coring I do where the chips fly out from the face of the blank into face shield and chest. Some of the carbide tools will also fling chips at you even when you're out of the line of fire. I am sure there are other gray areas to the chip flying, standing in the line of fire, test.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#43

Brought To You By . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

those friendly folks at Kill Zone Video Productions in conjunction with The National Network of Emergency Room Physicians.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#44

Steven Antonucci

Not at all

steven antonucci

When I refer to the line of fire, I am talking about the path that the blank would travel if it suddenly became disconnected from the lathe. The path that the chips come from the flute is a different line of fire.

I'll take a second to repost this in a new thread, since it is important to explain the distinction.

Steve

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#45

Re: Not at all

Semantics & glossary

Even though turning has been around for centuries we still struggle in describing concepts - not not that line of fire - the other line of fire.

Sorry Steve but I could not watch the video through & have to agree with AZ. Now I admit we have all done silly things but hand holding the video camera and one handed turning doesn't do too much for your credibility on safety.

Its a bit like the old fall backs "guards removed for clarity" or "I wear PPE all the time in my home shop" ....

You are not alone, no matter which YouTube clip or professionally made DVD even from leading and widely acclaimed “safe” turners there are "errors" in compliance with widely accepted turning safety protocols. People learn from visual examples, those images are lasting and far more powerful in getting a message across, more so than any words or caveats , warnings or whatever we want to call them.

How about re shooting it with a tripod as I believe you have a lot to contribute so why shoot yourself in the foot with the one handed turning & hand holding the camera multi tasking.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#46

Re: Not at all

Geoff Whaling

Oops the Semantic & Glossary post is mine....